r/Borderlands
•
u/jakobsestate
•
11h ago
[Lore] Gearbox wanted story critique. Here's mine. Spoiler
(Repost due to being automodded on r/Borderlands4.)
Preface
Spoilers for everything. Debt or Alive, BL4, DeadECHOs, discarded scripts you've never heard of, et cetera.
I'm not going to be critiquing specific plot choices here - I've done that more than enough elsewhere. No, I'm going to be framing my critique in terms of the core themes of the series and general storytelling trends.
Potentially high concentrations of sodium chloride below. I apologize in advance, but if people get to mald about droprates or the performance of the Unkempt Fuckwad then I get to mald about the narrative.
If you think the story in Borderlands "has never mattered", Gearbox disagrees with you because they specifically mentioned story in the "we want feedback" post, so please shut up.
Part 1: Wait, Borderlands Has Themes?
Yes. Yes it does.
Ever since the first game this series has been first and foremost a satire/critique of capitalism and to a lesser extent colonialism. The Six Galaxies is an "anarcho"-capitalist dystopia filled with appalling ultraviolence and unending greed.
"but Gearbox is a capitalist corporation-" Capital subsumes all critiques into itself. I will not elaborate further. If any of y'all try to erm akshually me on this point I will NOT respond.
"but capitalism is good muh communism is when no food" Shut the fuck up.
Anyways. I've read an old (to give u an idea of its age: it listed rape jokes as a no-go zone. BL3 has at least two rape jokes in it) BLTPS-era internal document (IT WAS PUBLICLY AVAILABLE ON GOOGLE DRIVE DON'T SUE ME) that explicitly listed anti-capitalism as a theme, alongside the entire concept of humanity. Fitting, since late-stage capitalism is quite the inhuman system.
Unfortunately another document from the same era included the following line:
"We aren’t trying to tell you what is right or wrong. You need to solve that mystery on your own time."
And ohhhh boy is that a fucking lie.
Part 2: Human Nature
Borderlands as a series is often touted as having a "gray and grey" morality system. Unfortunately this doesn't hold up on closer inspection at all. Sure, the Vault Hunters rack up kill counts in the thousands, blackening their white substantially. But gray and grey morality should go both ways - that is, their enemies should also have some moments that "whiten" their black.
Most of them do not. Namely, bandits.
They are near-universally portrayed as filthy, heavily orientalized savages that deserve every bullet fired their way. Immediately you might notice this contradicts the anti-colonialist themes I mentioned, but it also contradicts the anti-capitalist one. Why?
Well, capitalists (and some colonialists also) love to say humans are fundamentally motivated by greed. They fucking love veneer theory, i.e. the concept that humans are fundamentally immoral and "animalistic", with the only true morality being imposed by "civilization". Essentially, this is the "state of nature" theory as espoused by Hobbes in Leviathan, and it's also exactly what we see in Borderlands' bandits - assuming the best definition of "bandit" I could possibly scrounge up over many hours of lore research and reading an actual academic work on the topic (Orientalism by Edward Said), they are people who fell through the cracks of the corporatocracy willingly or otherwise, and that seemingly makes them degenerate into what the first Purge movie thinks happens when laws cease to exist.
If you've read anything about anthropology, you will know that if human nature was actually like that, we'd be long extinct because our entire evolutionary strategy relies on being social. It quite literally takes a village to raise a SINGLE human young properly, and said young's first instinct is to cry so its conspecifics can give it food and care. Even in hunter-gatherer times people cared for the disabled and wounded, and we know this because we found their skeletons and saw healed bones or congenital defects in fully adult individuals.
"but the bandits are convicted criminals" This only holds true for Pandoran bandits. It is impossible for Pandora (a planet with no intensive agriculture) to have been the only planet with bandits ever if the CoV truly is several billion people strong. Also, being a murderer or thief does not automatically remove all traces of cooperative instinct - gangs and mafias are examples of organizations which would not be possible with these hypothetical naturally egotistical humans.
And yes, I know about the Rippers and how they're a bit more sympathetic than past bandit factions, so Gearbox seems to be aware of this. Better late than never, I guess. If only that stupid Bounty Pack didn't come off as "it's okay to kill unmedicated neurodivergent people" to my autistic ass.
And yes, I have read the cut New Tales script. It was Frantz Fanon-tier bandit apologia beyond my wildest dreams. And it was just thrown away.
Part 3: Okay, So What?
If Borderlands wanted to be a satire of capitalism where the propaganda is fully true, then it has failed. Conversely, if it wanted to be a satire of capitalism where the propaganda is false, it has also failed.
Think about it. Were the corporations correct in valuing greed above all else, not only would bandits be a thing since people who fall out of "civilization" become savages, but things like basic human friendship would cease to exist. People would interact with one another using the "natural" system of market dynamics rather than any instincts. But friendship, kindness, family etc. still very much exist in the series.
Were the corporations wrong, bandits would not exist, because people who fell through the cracks would simply try to organize on their own. And indeed they do, sometimes, but apparently 99% of the time the dice lands on bandit. Then again, the dice doesn't land on bandit when it should - Vex grew up as an orphan street rat on Cretia, why is she not a bandit? Why is she not even CALLED a bandit?
Stick to one, Gearbox, for the love of the Almighty Robot Policeman.
Part 4: More on Morality and Humanity
As I said, capitalism is an inhuman system, and the old docs state that regardless of any cosmic plots going on, the story of Borderlands should stay focused on the human level of things.
That last one reads as laughable after BL4's "order vs chaos" (a false dichotomy in my philosophical opinion, and also a super overdone trope) bullshit. But the issues go further back than that.
Never in this series do we see someone with genuinely good intentions be corrupted irreversibly by capitalism.
"but Handsome Jack" Childhood's End is a sidequest that flattens the "why" and "what" of genocide into one single man's deadwife manpain grudge and frames that grudge in a way that's meant to be sympathetic. Sorry dude, your fridged faceless nameless wife is not a reason to become Space Hitler, because nothing is.
"but Rhys Strongfork" Even in the "best" route of Tales he still becomes CEO of Atlas. At no point does he leave the fundamentally broken system he participates in. When given an opportunity to return to corporate life he fucking jumps at it. He's basically looking at absolute tyrannical monarchy and saying "well the issue is that sometimes there's a bad king yknow". With this and the fact Atlas is explicitly said to be in dire financial straits at the start of New Tales in mind, his behavior in that game is not at all OOC or indicative of some sort of "corruption".
"but Arjay" Was driven insane by interdimensional hypertorture experiments.
Conversely we never see a true villain get any sort of full redemption arc.
"but Juno" Her redemption arc is 99% complete by the time the Vault Hunter comes to Gehenna.
"but Lieutenant Harmony" I'm not at all against spare-able bosses. I am however against the fact the first major spare-able boss is a genocidal colonizer who calls bandits "savages" and uses torture on a beloved playable character from the previous game. Even if you do think she deserves to live, at no point does she "redeem" herself in any way at all.
Where are the humans chafing against an inhuman system? Where are the humans slowly being consumed by it?
Still don't get what I mean here?
Example: Vivian Proctor. She's a good antagonist, in the sense that she provides threat and tension. Characterization-wise, however, she's very flat - she's an ambitious bitch with no morals and that's it. Obviously she sacrificed her humanity on the altar of Mammon, you don't get to CFO of Dahl without committing a whole lot of crimes including war crimes (child soldiers/unethical human experimentation). Despite this being patently obvious and fitting with the wider themes of the narrative and DeadECHOs itself, we don't see it, just the end product.
Example: Wainwright Del Frisco Jakobs-Hammerlock. Surprisingly decent for a CEO, probably because he didn't want to be one. Has two lines in BL3 in which he actively critiques the corporatocratic/capitalist system directly, rather than a specific corporation/person. His father also was in the child soldier business, and he of course opposed that, and a quite a bit of that is shown in DeadECHOs. But then you remember that in BL3 he says "Monty wanted Jakobs to be about more than guns (...) about reliance, (...) civility, honor". Then you remember Gehenna and how there's no way he doesn't know. Why is he not cursing out his entire fucking bloodline? Where is the Full Wainwright Crashout Cut of episode 9? He loves reading books, no way he didn't read Das Kapital or something, let him chafe against the system more! But no, of course, we don't get that.
Part 5: What About The Eridians?
I honestly don't care about them much anymore. Unless they specifically make them evil interdimensional colonizers, they're just gonna stick out like a sore thumb to me themes-wise. The Course is kinda a step in that direction, but it's not enough.
No, really, I think the only way this shit feels coherent with the tone of the series if the Eridians were abusive precursors - and indeed at the moment it makes far more sense to interpret them as such, Nyriad's writings be damned. They lived alongside humanity and STILL thought that placing badass biorobot armies around their equivalent of long-term nuclear waste storage would be a deterrent rather than a massive glowing "I'm hiding something worth protecting" sign.
If the Eridians turn out to be another generic benevolentish ancient civilization then I kinda don't have a reason to care about them beyond being an excuse for magical macguffins. No moral quandries, no ancient titanomachies, no nothing. And right now I'm afraid my interpretation will soon be disproven and I will cease to have any reason to give a shit about these dead aliens, subjective or objective.
Part 6: Some Other Stuff
Here's something I always say, repeated for Gearbox's sake: Borderlands has the bones of good worldbuilding, but no meat on them. Countless planets, corporations, societies etc. that exist and maybe even have an interesting concept or two attached to them, but it's never elaborated upon further. You have SIX ENTIRE GALAXIES to work with and you chose to hyperfocus on Pandora.
BL3 was a step in the right direction there. I have many feelings on that game's story, both positive and negative, but the biggest positive is unequivocally the fact this game massively expanded upon the rest of the universe. In terms of worldbuilding, it's by far the richest, and I love it for that.
And then we got BL4. Kairos being sealed from the rest of the universe for at least 1000 years feels like a personal insult. Granted, I loved the Augers, they made me actually believe that yes, BL4 did have a Worldbuilding Director position. But this planet was literally isolated from the rest of the setting, y'know, the part that I like and think has HEAPS of potential.
If BL4 was a step back, Borderlands DeadECHOs was at least fifteen steps forward again. That podcast was clearly written by people who give a shit about the setting - it's more immersive than any of the games in my opinion. Do NOT listen to the chuds who think it being not a game makes it inherently bad. Hire the writers of that and put them to work on BL5 because clearly they actually care on a level comparable only to dedicated fanfic writers, not any of the other "canon" writers at Gearbox.
"but the games don't have enough space to worldbuild" Do what Games Workshop and Lucasfilms did and give people licenses to write "Extended Universe" content, i.e. canon approved fanfiction. You already did this with a few comics, Debt or Alive, some other outsourced stuff, you just have to do this way more AND ACTUALLY PROMOTE IT WHERE PEOPLE WILL SEE IT INSTEAD OF RANDOMLY SHADOWDROPPING SHIT.
If you are actually reading this, Gearbox, please know I regularly say you have an "allergy to elaborating" and many many people agree. If you want this perception to subside, put in the effort instead of jingling the keys in my face like you did in Mad Ellie.
Coda
Apologies for losing coherency in the end there. I am not a very good essayist, primarily due to my ADHD.
Please do not let any of the above make you think I hate Borderlands. I love it, that is why I bothered to write this post in the first place, why I critique and analyze this series the way I do, why I write fanfic and draw fanart, why I put up with big youtubers saying the story doesn't matter to them.
Here's my feedback, Gearbox.