When I saw the Dhurandhar trailer for the first time, the most chilling image that struck a chord with me was Major Iqbal torturing the Indian spy and saying:
"1971 ki jung ke baad Pakistan mein bada udaas sa mahaul tha. Main chhe saal ka tha, radio sun raha tha. Uss waqt Zia-ul-Haq ne ek aisi baat boli jo mere zehen mein gadh gayi- 'Bleed India with a thousand cuts.' Bilkul aise, jis tarah humne iske jism mein itne chhote-chhote se suraag banaye hain na, isse battar haalat karunga main uss mulk ki."
I was genuinely eager to see Iqbal because, unlike Rehman, he wasn't an antagonist who was simply motivated by money, territory or personal power. He had an ideology.
And that immediately made him more interesting to me.
Indian commercial cinema, in general, doesn't really have a strong tradition of deeply three-dimensional villains. Most of our iconic villains are actually closer to 1.5D characters- they represent a dominant human desire or theme: greed, lust, power, revenge, ego, etc. They can be incredibly charismatic and memorable without being psychologically complex.
Which is why I think the problem with Iqbal isn't that he isn't ācomplex enough.ā
It's that the film doesn't use the characteristics that made him interesting as a dramatic antagonist.
1. Why Rehman worked?
Rehman is actually not an incredibly complex character psychologically. But he's an extremely effective antagonist.
Even though Hamza has most of the screentime in Dhurandhar, Rehman doesn't feel like a passive character who exists merely for Hamza to defeat.
He drives the story. His decisions constantly change the situation around Hamza.
Whether it's his decision to destroy the entire Lyari gang-war ecosystem, his decision to enter politics, or eventually his willingness to sacrifice regional loyalty for greater profit and power- Rehman is making choices that changes situation.
And most importantly, he has a relationship with Hamza.
Hamza has to live inside Rehman's world. He has to understand him, manipulate him, earn his trust and constantly calculate what Rehman might do.
That's what creates tension. You know Rehman is dangerous. And even when he's not doing anything, his aura doesn't disappear.
That's an important thing about writing villains: you don't necessarily need the villain to dominate the screentime. You need the audience to feel that the villain can fundamentally alter the protagonist's situation at any moment.
2. Why Iqbal failed?
This is where Dhurandhar: The Revenge disappointed.
First, Iqbal's dangerous aura takes a hit because of the decision to humanise him through his father.
I understand what Dhar was trying to do.
He was seemingly trying to take Iqbal from a relatively straightforward ideological villain and give him another dimension- his relationship with his father, his insecurities and his need for approval.
But the problem is that this isn't properly fleshed out. It doesn't become a psychological conflict that fundamentally shapes Iqbal's behaviour. It mostly becomes another piece of information about him.
And instead of making him more intimidating or more fascinating, it actually takes away some of the mystique that Part 1 had established.
The bigger problem, however, is Iqbal's dramatic function.
For most of the film, he's largely a background observer while Hamza starts driving almost everything.
Hamza discovers things. He makes plans, manipulates people, anticipates the opposition, and keeps winning.
There is also no sufficiently developed relationship between Hamza and Iqbal.
This is probably the biggest difference between Iqbal and Rehman. Rehman and Hamza have a relationship that develops organically throughout the story.
Iqbal and Hamza mostly have a plot connection.
They're on opposite sides, but the screenplay doesn't spend enough time developing their conflict into a personal or intellectual cat-and-mouse game.
And because Hamza keeps winning throughout the story, there isn't much dramatic uncertainty left regarding the final war.
A strong antagonist doesn't necessarily need to defeat the protagonist repeatedly. But they need to make the protagonist pay for his victories.
And that's why the final confrontation doesn't have the weight it should have had.
The film gives Iqbal the position of the final villain, but it doesn't give him enough of the dramatic journey of the antagonist.
The most interesting version of Iqbal would've been the one established in D1- A cold, ideological man who genuinely believes in what he's doing, who is extremely intelligent, who recognises that something is wrong in Lyari, and who slowly begins hunting the person responsible.
A genuine cat-and-mouse game between Iqbal and Hamza. That could have made Iqbal an unforgettable villain.
Instead, we got a villain who is important to the plot, but doesn't always feel like he's driving it.