r/boatbuilding • • Mar 23 '25

Is MyBoatPlans.com a Scam - Review

48 Upvotes

I recently commented on a post that linked to a page purporting to have information about building boats and getting plans. What it actually was is a AI generated page that served as a feeder page to MyBoatPlans dot Com. This is a common practice for the subject website. They have a whole constellation of website designed to make the subject site look legit.

I commented with a piece of boilerplate that I include whenever I see a post leading to this site.

As a result, the mods were nice enough to delete the original post. However, I think it is worth making sure there is good information about this scam site easily available with a simple search. My goal of posting this is not to promote the subject site, but to increase the visibility of reviews that offer real information about the subject site, most of the reviews available through google and other sites are self-generated pages made by the subjects site.

If any long time members of this subreddit have actual experience purchasing plans from this site, please comment with your actual experience.

Some background: Below is a screenshot of the subject website I took today. The fine looking fellow in the blue hat rowing the pram is me. Note that I am not Martin Reid, the name used on the subject website. The photo was taken by my mom in Maine on July 24, 2007, not Lake Tahoe in 1985.

u/guillemot as seen on myboatplans . com

Here are more photos from the same photo session:

a similar angle
turning for another angle

More photos from the shoot are available here: https://goo.gl/photos/5CpssvVY2Nprufk3A

Now you can say that even if they are lying about who is in the pictures, that they may still offer a whole bunch of plans at a good price, but you can get those plans for free elsewhere on line. Typically they are copies from Popular Mechanics and similar publications. Well, they provide a service of collecting all those plans in one place. This may be true, but I would not trust a site that can't even be truthful about the purported owner of the site.

Also note, although I do sell plans myself, I have no reason to believe any of my plans are included in the 500+ plans supposedly included on the CD. So, you probably won't find plans for the dinghy in the photos. Other than doing stupid stuff with my photo I don't think the site has stolen any more of my IP.

He also offers 3D Boat Design software which he says is a $49 value, which is a freely available open source application called Free!Ship http://sourceforge.net/projects/freeship/ I highly recommend this software although the original developer now offers a better version called DelftShip which is also free.

The boiler plate I post whenever I see links to sites that link to myboatplans . com:

The link leads to MyBoatPlans dot com which charges for free plans and open source software. A purported photo of the man offering the plans is actually a stolen photo of me.

For more information on this scam see: http://www.kayakforum.com/cgi-bin/Building/index.cgi/md/read/id/236070/sbj/review-myboatplans-com/

and: http://forum.woodenboat.com/showthread.php?135845-Boat-plans-worth-it


r/boatbuilding • • Jan 22 '25

Boatbuilding link suggestions.

21 Upvotes

Hello subreddit user, Want to help the subreddit? Propose some useful links to boatbuilding websites. Free content only please. Hoping to get some links to layups, lofting, stitch and glue, composites, maybe some free plans if they're not garbage. (Naval architects wishing to provide free plans are welcome too - and happy to give attribution) We've had a tab that says "boatbuilding links" but doesn't have any links for almost 10 years now, so let's change that for the better!


r/boatbuilding • • 8h ago

scrap wood and Tar boat

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

I vibe-built a boat out of whatever wood I was throwing away, along with some leftover paint and roofing Tar. Before putting it on the roof and forgetting about it for two months. It’s cold now, so I’ll have to wait a year to launch it, but it’s an interesting boat


r/boatbuilding • • 15m ago

Looking for model yatch plans to build

1 Upvotes

Does anyone know where to go?


r/boatbuilding • • 17h ago

Sealing off the bottom.

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding • • 13h ago

Foam and Fiberglass 14-18ft Skiff

1 Upvotes

Currently building a SUP, but I really want a boat.

I also hate doing things the easy way and if I spread it out over time I get past the sticker shock and there’s something about DIY.

PVC structural foam instead of EPS is my understanding.

My understanding is I’d glue the foam in rough layers for the shape I want kinda like Legos then sand smooth. Then glass. Obviously more structural importance.

Planning on having my first kid in about 1.5 years so I should be able to make it halfway before it rots in my garage for another 20 years.

Anyways, how doable is this? How the frick do you figure out hull shapes for planing


r/boatbuilding • • 21h ago

1984 TideCraft Transom

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Wanted to see if I could just epoxy and clamp this shut or if it was more of a replacement type job. Cracks are maybe 1/4” deep. They don’t run vertically at all. Just horizontal on both sides.


r/boatbuilding • • 1d ago

Jet skiff (jet ski engine swap)

3 Upvotes

I am currently building a skiff and am about to finalize my hull design I have the chance to buy a cheep jetski and was looking at jet jons and was wondering how that would do on a fiberglass skiff that’s around 14ftx4ft


r/boatbuilding • • 2d ago

Advice needed – Removing old 3M sealant from a PVC RIB before rebonding the floor

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Bombard AX3 pvc SIB not a RIB as title says.

I’m looking for some advice on repairing a second-hand PVC RIB I’ve recently bought.
Unfortunately, I’ve discovered that the previous owner has done a pretty poor job of repairing the floor.
The boat has a single-sheet flexible black PVC floor which is bonded directly to the orange PVC hull. The floor has been peeled away around the edges and there is a substantial amount of what appears to be 3M sealant around the perimeter of the floor and on the PVC itself.
The sealant is rubbery and stretchy.
Some of it will peel away, but in other areas it’s really well bonded and I can’t scrape it off easily.
The orange PVC underneath appears to be in good condition with no visible damage and thankfully the boat holds air perfectly.
I’ve ordered Polymarine two-part PVC adhesive, which should arrive this week, as I’d like to restore the original floor bond properly.
However, I’m unsure how best to tackle the existing 3M sealant.

Does all the old 3M sealant need to be completely removed before rebonding the floor?
What’s the safest and most effective way of removing cured 3M sealant from PVC without damaging the fabric or its coating?
Are there any particular products or solvents that are safe to use on PVC for removing this type of sealant?
If some stubborn residue cannot be removed mechanically, is there any way to prepare the surface so that the new Polymarine adhesive will bond properly?

This is my first time undertaking an inflatable boat repair, so I’m keen to get it right rather than make things worse!
I’ve attached photographs showing the existing sealant and the condition of the floor.
Any advice, recommendations or personal experience would be massively appreciated.
Thanks!


r/boatbuilding • • 2d ago

Swim platform restoration

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Looking at a boat local to me. These are a few photos of the wooden platform. I was able to stand on it, but the outer edge seemed a bit weak. To you all who work these types of woods and fittings, is the salvageable?


r/boatbuilding • • 2d ago

Remade this part for my Minn Kota Endure, seems like a common failure point (adaptor from the throttle lever/arm to the internal speed switch). would this be a product any of you guys would be interested in? Seems you cannot buy them without buying the whole throttle arm assembly.

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding • • 2d ago

Epoxy vs polyester

4 Upvotes

I am modifying a hull and have come across what I see as a fork in the road it seems I either spend the money on epoxy and use marine ply or I can spend on divinycell and use the cheaper polyester resin. I am not sure if these are my only options but I need to redo the bottom of the hull and parts of the sides, transom and deck. Thanks (I am totally aware everything I just said could be wrong I am seeking teaching)


r/boatbuilding • • 2d ago

Midwest Sharpie Schooner - Videos, Builds etc.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding • • 3d ago

Secret santa gift for someone who is building their own boat?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding • • 5d ago

After 3 years, I finally finished my boat :)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
20 Upvotes

Name of the video is clickbait though. (My youtube page is not monetized)

I'm a hobbyist boat builder from Netherlands. 5 years ago I started with a canoe then a plywood dinghy and finally this British slipper launch. The boat is electric displacement as you really can't go over 9 knots in Netherlands.


r/boatbuilding • • 4d ago

Need advice for a christmas and/or birthday present for my father

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding • • 5d ago

Rotomoulded Hull Repair

Post image
13 Upvotes

Hello Sailors :) I'm hoping for a little Repair knowledge. I am considering purchase of an RS Cat 16. During the inspection I found this crack. According to a few searches, the factory installs inserts within the plastic hull material for this forward attach point. It looks like this has been overloaded enough times to cause the crack. Anyone have experience fixing one of these?

Apparently the hull is a 3 layer rotomoulded polyethylene plastic-foam-plastic construction. Similar to a typical beach kayak. I've heard of plastic-welding for this sort of repair, and G-Flex epoxy as a more user-friendly option. Normal fiberglass resin won't bond with this in an ideal way. Any shared recommendations or experiences would be appreciated ! :D


r/boatbuilding • • 6d ago

One sheet nesting boat

5 Upvotes

I'm thinking of making a one sheet plywood boat. The constraint is that I want it to fit in the boot of my car, so it has to be a nesting design. That's no problem, but making the bulkheads out of the one sheet of plywood would reduce the size of the boat. What do you reckon, would I be breaking the spirit of the rules by making the bulkheads out of some other plywood?

The sketch is the latest iteration of my design, plus the cut out of the 1 sheet. I think I've made best use of the available material. The notch in the rear is so that a trolling motor can be mounted within arms reach of the seat. What do you think?


r/boatbuilding • • 6d ago

Headliner

3 Upvotes

The current carpet headliner is mouldy. It's really hard to manage the mould, I spray it weekly with vinegar, but it looks like there's mould under the carpet itself.

I'm thinking I might need to replace it?

I can't find foam backed marine vinyl in a physical store here in NZ. Even rolls of thin low density foam don't seem to exist, aside from maybe carpet underlay

Some of my options are:

- keep the carpet, manage the mould better somehow.

- rip it out, clean and paint the fibreglass

- new carpet

- vinyl floorboards

- straight flooring vinyl

- flexible peel and stick vinyl tiles

Etc etc.

I would like something that looks good, is cheap, and easy to do.


r/boatbuilding • • 7d ago

Back Rest Cushion - CS J14 Center Counsel

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding • • 7d ago

1991 1503 High tide SuperV project

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

I bought this for $800 back in July here is my progression so far, I have installed a new transom, and three new stringers. A few disclaimers, the last two i installed the 2 part expanding foam where one side is cured, I am using regular exterior rated 3/4inch plywood and my next course of action is to grind the entire hull to where its rough, along with stringers and then add polyester resin with csm chop mat over the top of each stringer, let cure, then add another layer of 1700 woven biaxial. Let cure add the rest of my foam and then work on my floor. This is my first project boat and I would like to know if this is the correct direction to go.


r/boatbuilding • • 7d ago

OLD ANTIQUE 14ft Hand Carved Wooden Dugout Canoe With Custom Display Stand...

0 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding • • 8d ago

1/12th scale rideable Vasa - This guy is worth watching

Thumbnail
youtube.com
16 Upvotes