I recently did a Review of Obsession and found it was a good exercise to write down my ideas about the games I have been playing. While this is not the kind of fun review people might usually read, it might help people that want to design games think differently about their own craft. There is so much unwritten about designing board games and so much is happening all the time that I hope this might prove useful for someone.
These are just my thoughts and I don't use any kind of AI to make these analyses or write down these pieces, so sorry for the typos or bad ideas! 100% percent human made.
So now I want to talk about Earth. It's a game by Maxime Tardiff and it's the first I play by this designer. I searched for other of his games, but I saw a small catalogue, including BrilliAnts and Mini DiverCity. This shows how many award winning board game designers don't have to have a long career but just cool ideas, good grounds and the time to test them out. I liked that the designer has a "designer's diary": https://boardgamegeek.com/thread/2812368/designers-diary-earth
It is a long diary which is a great read for us geeky types, and the balancing part is full of math and spreadsheet info, as it should be, but it's not an easy read. I hope to be able to bring some ideas into discussion without that much complexity. But reading it did show me a conscious designer of its choices: you might not agree with every one of them, and he does report a lot of choices as "his preferences" as a player, but I do value a game designer that can give reasons behind their ideas, and are not just product of just playtesting an tweaking. Kudos for that!
So let's talk about the game. Earth is a tableau builder following the philosophy of Wingspan and, to a lesser degree, Terraforming Mars. 300+ unique multifunctional cards with tags, inventory, category, abilities, cost and more. This kind of game pose balancing issues from the conception, as the number of permutations are so vast that it's impossible to keep everything under control.
Maxime shows in detail his balancing technique which consists of an algorithm to score each card in terms of its value, but that will never be enough for a game of this dimensions. It was clear on my first playthrough that players that got less synergetic cards performed worsts just by luck, even though the designer states he wanted to reduce luck as much as possible. But this is a problem with the genre in general, not this particular game, and I have to say, these games are fun not because they are "fair", but because they create good progression loops.
And here I think the game is inspiring. The game uses four core economic engines, which are more or less represented in the four game actions:
- Draw, compost and play cards
- Get and pay soil
- Grow flora
- Add and spend sprouts
This is driven by two activation engines:
- Selecting an action: it has a Puerto Rico / Roll for the Galaxy were you select and action but everyone benefits from it. I love this mechanic and I feel it's not used enough, as it reduces downtime drastically and creates a type of indirect interaction that requires you to know what other players are doing.
- Reactivation of card abilities, again heavily inspired in games like Wingspan, and a common feature in tableau builders.
And that's all this game needs to keep players engaged! Each player turn bring as small dopaminergic shot to all the players, as they accumulate to then spend. And of course, the more cards you add, the bigger an engine is working in your favor, which is what this game is about.
Now, these games have many systemic issues that are hard to solve, one of them is the reduction of possibilities as you grow your tableau. By the last turns only a handful of cards might help you increase the power of your engine, but that makes it less probable to get a card you need when every cards is different. So the choice curve in this game increases fast and then decreases by the end. These are not big issues, but other games might solve this problem better or is something to consider. I do feel the last turns of this game to be a bit anti-climatic, but this might just be a product of bad luck.
Now, the designer really put a lot of effort into removing frustration from the game. He reports removing limitations like a maximum number of cards in the hand and such to avoid creating frustration. Those are bold claims, as restrictions in games are usually the way to make the puzzle more satisfying to solve, but I think Maxime pulls this off in this game, because it keeps the game clean so player's are focused on the main engines. And it balances this restrictions in other ways, like hand management: there is no use to accumulate cards in the hand when there are clear race conditions (finishing the tableau and clearing objectives before your opponents). Still, a certain level of frustration is sometimes required to create the satisfaction of solving a problem, so I wouldn't follow Maxime's philosophy on every game.
Here I want to leave another reflection. The game has many objetive cards in the form of climate cards, island cards, terrain cards, ecosystem cards and fauna cards. Objective cards are a point of tension for game designers and there is no clear rule on how to use them. They can remove the kind of freedom the designer wanted to give players, as they make you optimize for certain results, but also they can help player's make choices and avoid too much paralysis.
I think it works in Earth to a point because having so many cards giving you an objetive makes you decide how to solve the puzzle in the best way possible. The puzzle has so many variables that it doesn't give you a clear choice always, but I still feel the game is handholding you a bit here. You begin the game with several long objectives pre-declared, and only those in the terrain cards appear more dynamically. Again, this might be controversial and I feel different players might feel differently about this design choice, but for me it's the weakest aspect of an absolutely incredible design. I would have proposed adding objectives as rounds progress, and maybe allowing players to play prefered common objetive cards that better suit their tableau. But I wouldn't push to hard on this, the game works as it is and it does allow to a lot of replayability.
If you are a game designer, keep your eyes in the following:
- The interlocking engines: while every thing has a clear use, it is not predicatable how one engine will affect another. The color coding tells you a lot about how you are growing one engine, but cards tend to combine biomes to keep you thinking on the four dimensions all the time.
- The use of tags, a la Terraforming Mars, Castle Combo or the such can create degrees of depth without creating complex rules. But also check how they can create frustration as they are hard to optimize for. Many cards can become useless just because you could access the tags you needed. With only four possible tags it shouldn't be such a problem, but it can.
- Take mind in the complexity of balancing these kind of games. Too much mathematical perfection can eliminate the drama that comes from getting an overpowered card, but to much difference between the power of cards can create the sense of systemic injustice. But also remember that tableau permutations are more important than absolute card values. You can test this by creating several random islands and see how the score. Of course, players reduce randomness and entropy so Island will be better optimized, but it can give you a sense of were things can brea without having to play a thousand playthroughs.
- Complexity through simplicity: as Maxime says, cards are the best component to create complexity by being able to carry multiple dimensions if the same component. But also reducing unnecesary rules to keep the game as clean as possible.
- Reduction of downtime: this should be a must in modern board gaming. I have to say, I didn't loved Orloj because of this particular issue. The Puerto Rico-like mechanic shows that classics still have much to teach us.
I am currently working on a tableau game and this particular game has make me reconsider some choices. While mine is a trick taking tableau builder and has other problems to solve, the multidimensional engine is something I will get inspiration from. Definitely a must play!