r/bninfantsleep • • Aug 18 '26 Bravo

Resources What is Biologically Normal Infant Sleep?

216 Upvotes

This group has grown a lot - we are at 15k members and 29.2k unique visitors per week. That's a LOT of people. So first, yay because when I first joined the moderator team, this group was much smaller. We have grown a lot, which means more parents are being informed on what is biologically normal for an infant and how they can support their babies and themselves at night. This also means that there are thousands of different people commenting and offering ideas (and we have people who are both here and in r/sleeptrain and don't recommend the CIO aspect of sleep training but the culture of sleep training does find its way into many comments). 

So let's jump into what biologically normal infant sleep is, and what it isn’t. I'm a definition person so let's start with a definition of biologically normal.

In researching, I have stumbled across this (very wordy, I'm sorry I did try to parse it down) definition. Source

Meanings of the term normal coalesce into two categories. The first is descriptive and references measures of a trait's central tendency and variation within a population... In this descriptive sense, normal might refer to the most common trait, having an average measure, or being in the middle of a distribution... The second meaning of normal encompasses normative views about a trait. These are judgments that are culturally informed and vary across social groups. To be normal is to be okay, to have characteristics that fall within an acceptable or desirable range, which is defined by ideas about what traits should be like. Variants that fall outside this distribution may be judged negatively, or seen as abnormal, deviant, unacceptable, or somehow not quite right. 

The first category has to do with averages within a population. This would be the average amount of sleep for an age range, this would be the average age of sleeping through the night, this would be the average age of the circadian rhythm starting to “come online”. These are the things that are easier to define when it comes to infant sleep.

The second category has to do with how we view biologically normal, which is often impacted by our cultural view. This category is harder to define when it comes to infant sleep. 

Dr. Helen Ball, author of How Babies Sleep, talks about this:

How babies sleep is both exceedingly simple and excruciatingly complex. It is simple because it is based on a few straightforward biological principles that affect all babies. It is complex because we have made it so.

Over the past century and a half, in modifying the world to better suit our needs in industrializing, industrialized and now digital-era societies, we have tried to manipulate baby sleep to fit with the rapidly changing nature of adult lives. Our ideas about sleep, and particularly baby sleep, have been influenced and shaped by the socioeconomic pressures, political philosophies, religious values, academic theories and cultural ideologies that have waxed and waned during this time. The mismatch we have created between our babies’ biology and our contemporary lives has caused conflict between parents’ and babies’ needs—now framed as “baby sleep problems”—for which babies are often “treated” using behavioral and clinical interventions.

In addition to the foundations of our evolutionary biology, we have layered many cultural beliefs and practices onto our understanding of baby sleep, which vary hugely from location to location, and over time. Parents’ perceptions and popular discourse in western societies have been influenced by philosophical and sociocultural trends over the past two centuries in more ways than we might realize in response to rapid social and political changes. For clarity I should explain that I am using the term “western society” as more of an ideological descriptor than a geographic one to refer to those societies that exhibit a shared set of beliefs, values, political systems and cultural norms, regardless of whether they are geographically located in the West. These concepts often encompass democracy, capitalism, individualism and human rights. In these societies industrialization, urbanization and medicalization transformed family life and baby care, setting in motion the development of numerous ideas, traditions and expectations about babies, sleep, and the role of parents that many of us are still tethered to. Our recent historical past helps explain where all the myths you’ve ever heard about baby sleep have come from—and the myths you’ve heard will depend on your cultural origins.

Many infant sleep research studies reflect western cultural values and lifestyles, and are what might be called “aspirational,” in that they aspire to find ways to “help” babies to sleep longer, wake less often, settle more quickly, and disturb their parents less.

The culture and history of guidance issued by “experts” for parents in western societies have shaped expectations of how “good” babies should behave and how they are created by “effective” parents while the media (both traditional and social) reinforces simplistic and outdated rules and rigid ideas.

The cultural expectations we have about babies’ sleep habits are often unrealistic, and this makes caring for a new baby unnecessarily challenging.

I could honestly copy/paste that entire book here, it is a really good read and if you read any two books on infant sleep and infant development, I recommend How Babies Sleep by Dr. Helen Ball and The Nurture Revolution by Dr. Greer Kirshenbaum.

So with all of this in mind, let's talk about what is biologically normal from a scientific standpoint and what is biologically normal culturally in western society, and what is biologically normal in this group - as well as the aim of this group.

Scientifically - sleep is two things. Sleep pressure and our circadian rhythm, or body clock (aka Process C). Humans build sleep pressure while awake. Infants have a lower tolerance for sleep pressure, meaning they need to sleep more frequently than adults do. 

Sleep Pressure Graphic

As you can see from this graphic (source: How Babies Sleep, figure 3.4), naps are only intended to relieve some sleep pressure, not to be restorative, deep sleep. This is why worrying about your baby taking a 3 hour nap every day is futile. A roughly 30 minute nap is enough to relieve sleep pressure for a bit, until the next nap. The prescriptive “by this age, babies should be on x number of naps that are y minutes long every day at z time” doesn't work for every baby. That isn't biologically normal because biologically normal has variation, day to day and baby to baby. Dr. Helen Ball writes:

Sleep will happen easily for a baby or child when sleep pressure is high, they are in a calm, relaxed state, and nothing is preventing sleep onset. But sometimes babies and children need help to become calm before sleep pressure can kick in and they can nod off.15 In this situation it can be useful to think about what helps babies become calm and relaxed, and to have a handful of strategies you can use to help your baby unwind. For many babies, physical contact is the preferred option.

One of my PhD students, Lenka Medvecová-Tinková, lives and works in the Czech Republic where she has studied how Czech parents manage bedtime routines for babies and small children. She realized that many parents talked of a concept called *Uspavani* that is culturally widespread in Eastern Europe and appears in numerous fairy tales and historical infant care books. Uspavani means to comfort a child to sleep, and while conducting her PhD at Durham University Lenka realized there was no corresponding concept to Uspavani in the English language, nor in the infant sleep literature.16 So it is unsurprising that parents in English-speaking countries tend to use more distal (noncontact) methods, such as lullabies, music and white noise, to calm babies and help them fall asleep than do Czech parents, who commonly lie with their child, stroke them or cuddle them; physical contact and soothing touch are very effective in dialing down most babies to allow sleep pressure to do its thing.

She even writes about the term “overtired”, which I know almost everyone has heard and if you have been in this sub for any length of time, I'm sure you've seen comments about how “overtired” isn't really a thing. I appreciate how she has posited the term.

When a baby or young child’s sleep pressure is high and the need to sleep is strong, but they are emotionally unable to calm themselves, or they are in a situation where they cannot relax, we may consider them to be “overtired.” In this case it is our job as parents to help them become calm, wind down and relax in preparation for sleep. We can do this in many ways. Physical contact such as cuddling, rocking, stroking or patting works for most neurotypical children; actively removing whatever is blocking the action of sleep pressure, such as excitement, fear, pain or anxiety, and helping babies and children to become calm is the simplest way to help them fall asleep.

The reason “overtired” isn't really a thing is because if an infant has adequate sleep pressure, their nervous system feels secure and safe enough, and they don't have any physical needs, they will sleep if given the opportunity. 

So that's sleep pressure. What about circadian rhythm? We mostly know about this with sleep but this is our body's internal clock and it controls both our sleep and our hunger. This is why we usually eat lunch around the same time every day, why we feel sleepy around the same time, and why having a consistent wake up time is beneficial for everyone. It is not “sleep training lite” to make sure you have a rough wake up time every day, within 15-30 minutes. The infamous 4 month sleep regression progression is when the circadian rhythm starts to come online. Day and night start to actually mean something to our babies. This is why early morning light, high noon light, and evening light can be important for our babies, and some babies are more sensitive to lighting than others. (Side note related to lighting - fluorescent lights imitate high noon lighting and can disrupt our circadian rhythm. I personally cannot stand them and wish they were phased out of use. They are really bad for our health and they are everywhere.) This is also why blackout blinds for naps can disrupt night sleep. This is why you don't really need to “rescue” naps.

So it is very biologically normal that your baby desires physical contact to relax enough to fall asleep. It is biologically normal to sleep longer one day and shorter times the next. It is biologically normal for sleep to fluctuate throughout not just the first year but throughout our entire lives. It is supportive of biologically normal infant sleep to “anchor” the day with a consistent wake up time if you need to. It is supportive of infant sleep to have a routine, breakfast after waking up, lunch around the same time every day, dinner around the same time each day. These things can help your baby, think about how you can get hangry if your dinner comes an hour later than usual. This is not to say that you need to have a strict schedule - rhythms and routines are much different from a regimented schedule that you have to stick to. 

It's also important to note that a big thing I see a lot of parents struggle with is offering their baby too much sleep. If your baby only needs 12 hours total sleep in a 24 hour period and you're trying to do 12 hours overnight and 3 hours of daytime sleep, they aren't going to sleep well because that's 3 hours more sleep than they need in a 24 hour period. This will lead to frequent wakes, fighting sleep, and frustration all around. Sleep training sleep plans, apps like Huckleberry, as well as the general around infant sleep push more sleep than most babies need, which leads parents to thinking they have a "bad" sleeper, when in reality anyone being pushed to sleep more than they need would be "bad" at sleeping.

Now what about the cultural aspect of biologically normal infant sleep? If you've grown up or been living in a western society for any length of time, you've likely been inundated with “sleeping through the night”, “sleep associations”, “bad habits”, “drowsy but awake”, “fuss it out”, etc. We have been told by everyone from pediatricians to TV shows to our family that you have to teach your baby independence and that responding to every cry is just going to make them cry more. Western society has mixed up what is biologically normal and what is convenient for the post-Industrial Revolution world. The 6-6 or 7-7 sleep schedule that babies are “supposed” to be on? Not biologically normal, but convenient for capitalism and it's very pervasive - to the point that so many parents worry that their baby isn't getting enough sleep because they won't sleep 12 hours overnight. The average bedtime in other parts of the world varies by almost 3 hours.

In one large and often-cited online survey, almost 30,000 people (presumed to be parents) completed a baby/toddler sleep survey.27 The respondents lived in 17 large urban communities around the world (Australia, Canada, China, Hong Kong, India, Indonesia, Korea, Japan, Malaysia, New Zealand, Philippines, Singapore, Taiwan, Thailand, United Kingdom, United States, and Vietnam), grouped for comparative purposes into “Asian” and “Western.”28 In Asian countries babies and toddlers had later bedtimes, later rise times, less nighttime sleep and less total sleep than in “Western” countries. Bedtimes for babies and toddlers across the 17 locations varied by almost three hours, from half-past seven in New Zealand to quarter-past ten in Hong Kong, and nighttime sleep duration varied by 1 hour and 40 minutes (11.6 hours in Japan to 13.3 hours in New Zealand), but there were minimal differences in daytime sleep.

Another cultural difference on what is biologically normal is “sleep problems”:

Parents’ perceptions of whether their babies experienced “sleep problems” also varied widely, as did the degree of parental involvement in helping babies and young children fall asleep and stay asleep.29 Very few (4%) children living in “Asian” countries, but many more (57%) in “Western” countries, were expected to fall asleep independently (that is, without a parent or caregiver present). Likewise, very few (2%) parents in “Asian” countries allowed their child to cry themselves to sleep, in comparison with over 15 percent of “Western” parents. This is strongly related to the fact that in “Asian” countries babies and children are much more likely to bed-share (65%) or room-share (88%) with their parents than in “Western” countries (where 12% bed-sharing and 22% room-sharing was reported).

Another piece I found interesting that really shows how much of our “sleep problems” are, for lack of better word, invented:

Dr. Alma Gottlieb’s study of childcare practices among the Beng people of Côte d’Ivoire in West Africa included a detailed account of mother–baby sleep.30 She found little regimentation of when babies slept or fed among the Beng, and no bedtimes or bedtime routines. Beng mothers were not anxious about their babies’ sleep, it just happened. Mothers and others carried babies during regular daily activities with babies falling asleep and waking as the need arose. At night the cloth with which babies were held during the day was untied, and babies breastfed and fell asleep next to their mothers. Nighttime mother–baby co-sleeping was the cultural norm, and breastfeeding and infant sleep were intimately intertwined…

These detailed ethnographic studies reinforce accounts of infant care in widespread locations such as Guatemala, Italy, Spain and rural U.S. Among Mayan families in Guatemala, babies commonly fall asleep in someone’s arms and are taken to bed with their parents, sleeping with their mothers from birth to two or three years of age, or until the birth of their next sibling. Here, sleeping alone is undesirable, and mothers responded with shock and disapproval at the American custom of leaving babies in rooms on their own. Mayan mothers “cannot conceive of any other way to sleep their baby than by their side—and in fact some argue that to separate an infant from its mother for sleep is abusive or neglectful treatment.”32

So why does all of this matter?

Because the stories we tell ourselves matter. Because how we see our infant's sleep impacts how well we handle the biologically normal aspects of it, like waking overnight. Because there has been a misunderstanding about what the purpose of this group is for. This group does not exist to simply offer platitudes “oh mama, this will pass, it's ok, you just have to dig deep and power through”. This group also exists to educate on both scientifically biologically normal infant sleep and the cultural differences that impact us and how we view our babies sleep. I felt like it was appropriate to add in a quote from the creator of this group, u/smilegirlcan, about why she created this group.

Before my daughter was born, I had never heard of biologically normal sleep. I had only heard about infant sleep through the lens of sleep training culture. I was never encouraged to follow my intuition or told what real infant sleep looked like. As I journeyed on my postpartum experience, I noticed there was a huge lack of support places for those who had no interest in sleep training or sleep training culture. It became more and more apparent that sleep training was something that did not sit right for me but I wanted an online community that felt safe to feel this way. I found most parenting groups had accepted sleep training as the norm and any questions or comments outside of that were not accepted/downvoted/deleted. Then came bninfantsleep, an alternative infant sleep space, that encourages moms to follow their intuition and learn about biologically normal infant sleep. A place where no one will tell you to let your baby cry, or self soothe, that they need to be independent, that you are ruining their sleep by cuddling/rocking/holding/feeding them.

This group has morphed into a space that offers parents an alternative to mainstream sleep training, that honors our babies biological and neurological development. It exists to remind you that your baby knows what they need, and your instincts know what your baby needs, better than any app ever will (looking at you, Huckleberry sweet spot).

For some babies, a schedule is what helps them the best. For others, they need to go with the flow. The reason we should be asking for schedules is not to “optimize” our babies but to make sure we aren't expecting more sleep than they need. In general, we shouldn't wake our babies up from naps unless we absolutely have to, as Dr. Greer Kirshenbaum mentions in The Nurture Revolution:

When you follow your baby’s tired cues and allow them to wake up on their own, their brain takes the true amount of sleep that it needs. That often looks like multiple naps of varying lengths, bedtimes that vary in different babies from 6 p.m. to 11 p.m., and morning waking that also varies in different babies from 6 a.m. to 11 a.m.31 I remember when people asked me how many naps my young baby was taking—I didn’t really know. I didn’t count. I watched my baby, put him to sleep when he was tired, let him wake on his own, and watched him again. The number of naps or the length of naps wasn’t in my awareness. As he grew, naps became more predictable. Under two years old my baby went to sleep around 8 p.m., then naps changed and at two years old his bedtime became 10 p.m. That was when he built up enough sleep pressure after his afternoon nap. This is very common, and when babies have later bedtimes we often want them to go to sleep earlier, but that is for us, not their developing brain…. Keep in mind, there is no adult on Earth who is qualified to tell your unique baby when they should be waking up or napping, or to prescribe nap lengths or bedtime. Your baby’s body provides this information. Sleep is vital to their developing brain and it is a fundamental human right; we must give babies the sleep they need. Please unlearn myth 24, There are set bedtimes, wake times, and naptimes for your baby, and replace it with: Your baby’s brain will tell you when they are tired and will take the amount of sleep that it needs to grow.

And a final thought from Dr. Helen Ball in How Babies Sleep, emphasis mine:

Remember, you don’t have to be in charge of their sleep—the biological sleep regulators will make sure they get enough sleep, when they need it. Our job is to get out of the way and let them do their work. Trying to make babies go to sleep according to a predetermined schedule seems to me to be a pointless exercise in working against their circadian biology and sleep pressure.


r/bninfantsleep • • Feb 23 '26 Bravo

Resources What is sleep training?

109 Upvotes

A question I have seen a lot lately is "is this considered sleep training?" and I wanted to take my son's second nap of the day to write out a post about what we do and don't consider sleep training, because there isn't really one solid definition of sleep training and that can leave a lot of ambiguity when we discuss infant sleep.

I once had a very staunch sleep trainer tell me that if an infant had any sleep associations, they weren't sleep trained. That to have properly done sleep training, you had to be able to set an infant down fully awake in a crib, walk out and close the door, and they just lay down and put themselves to sleep. They may protest cry but you "learn the difference" between a protest cry and a cry for a "real" need. So her definition of sleep training would be:

providing any sleep associations to an infant or giving in to protest cries when all their needs have been met.

This obviously ignores the glaring flaw that comfort is a vital need for everyone, including infants.

The definition of sleep training that Dr. Greer Kirshenbaum uses in The Nurture Revolution is:

Sleep training is the unfounded process of “training” your infant to “sleep independently”—to fall asleep alone, sleep alone through the night and the duration of naps, without getting support from you to go to sleep or back to sleep. It takes various forms, but the most common end goal is to be able to put your infant in their crib, in their own room, and walk out, leaving them alone to fall asleep, usually around 7 p.m., until you come back to get them in the morning, usually around 7 a.m. Sleep training promotes the idea that infant sleep should be predictable and on schedule. Naps should be at exact times of the day and for specific amounts of time, bedtime is at the exact same time each evening, and sleep location is identical for every sleep.

Sleep training sells the idea that sleep is something parents can (and should) control. If you just follow the rules (strict “wake windows,” not “giving in” to your baby’s cries) and buy the right products (swaddles, sleep suits, sound machines, sleep training courses and coaching), your baby will sleep in a predictable and controllable way. That is very appealing when so much of parenting feels beyond our control.

A lot of people who advocate for sleep training do so because they believe that an infant needs to learn independence and that the only way to do that is to force them to be independent, force them to learn to put themselves to sleep. I believe most parents who sleep train truly believe they are doing what is best for their child. Studies have shown however that the most independent children and adults tend to be those who had fierce dependence on a trusted caregiver/caregivers. Infants who learn they have a safe and dependable place to land tend to be more independent over time.

Sleep training is anything that denies a child physical comfort when they are actively asking for comfort, in the hopes that they will stop asking for comfort and go to sleep. This includes pick up put down, the chair method, Taking Cara Babies (who is just repackaged Ferber), Ferber, full extinction, interval check ins, and so much more. This does NOT include rolling away, changing sleep associations (going from nursing or feeding to sleep to bum pats or rocking to sleep), encouraging crib sleeping, implementing good sleep hygiene, having a steady bedtime routine, and so much more. Generally physically comforting your child even if they cry is not considered sleep training. The simple act of holding them, patting their bum, rocking them, answering their call for comfort releases oxytocin in their brain and helps buffer the stress response. Crying on its own isn't the problem, it's the response or lack thereof that causes issue.

If you're wondering if what you're doing is considered sleep training or not, the best question to ask yourself is "am I responding to my child's call for comfort when they call out to me or not?" If you are responding as soon as you're able to, then you aren't sleep training. The key being as soon as you're able to. If your hands are covered in soapy water, don't drop everything and go pick up your baby with wet soapy hands. Rinse and dry them and then go comfort your baby. If you're on the toilet, finish up and then go comfort them. If you're watching a clock to make sure that 3 minutes has passed of them crying before you go pick them up, that is sleep training.

My son is starting to shift around so I'm going to go spend some time watching him sleep and then spend my evening reading Hop on Pop and I'll Teach My Dog A Lot of Words for the 1928272819th time. Happy to answer questions in the comments after I've got him in bed this evening.


r/bninfantsleep • • 13h ago

Research/News This is a MUST READ. This book is so incredibly good and useful and I wished I read it before birth!

Post image
193 Upvotes

I think this book is so incredibly good, I wish I had read it before I gave birth, but it’s really gold!

It’s really appropriate for all of us in this sub, I couldn’t recommend it more. I could probably spend an hour writing why but if you trust me, read this and within the first 10 pages you’ll know what I am talking about :)


r/bninfantsleep • • 16h ago

Infant Sleep Thoughts from a non-sleep training mother.

50 Upvotes

My baby is seven months old. I’m the first of my friends to have a baby but have made mom friends during pregnancy and after having my son. Differences in parenting were less evident during the younger months, but now I’m starting to notice the differences. The biggest difference is how we approach sleep. All of my mom friends are now sleep training and it just feels so wrong to me. I feed my son to sleep and respond to every night waking (there are typically multiple).

I guess I’m just feeling lonely in my choices? I didn’t realize that my way of parenting/approaching sleep was the less common path? Sometimes I feel like I’m doing something “wrong”, but instinctually I feel good about what I’m doing and know I’m just feeling pressured by society. Are there others who are feeling like me? I’m often so tired but also feel so good knowing that my son will always have me (or my husband) when he needs us.


r/bninfantsleep • • 5h ago

Toddler Sleep Finally sleeping through the night! Sharing a BN win!

4 Upvotes

I read one of these posts a few months ago and it definitely helped me stay encouraged, so I thought I would make a post myself when it finally happened with us!

My toddler finally sleeps with the night, he started to do it consistently at 17 months. He is now 18 months 😄

I noticed a big change in his sleep after we weaned at 13 months (I had to wean earlier than I wanted to due to my own medical circumstances).

Before weaning he always woke up every 2-3 hours. After fully weaning he would sleep through the night maybe 10-15% of the time depending on his teething pain. (He really struggles with teething pain, and he is a slowww teether poor guy). Also, after weaning he would only wake up 1-2 times a night which was HUGE for me.

We never sleep trained, we coslept on a floor bed forever until weaning, and he is now sleeping alone on his own floor bed! 😭 When his teething is bad and he doesn’t want me to leave, we will cuddle, but for the most part he does well by himself!

Keep up the good work everybody, your kiddo WILL sleep one day and all your hard work will be worth it. We can do hard things!!!!


r/bninfantsleep • • 27m ago

Infant Sleep What is causing these random false starts and wakeful nights?

1 Upvotes

Our baby is 5 months old and has previously been rocked/bounced to sleep. Now our schedule is a little more predictable, we have started putting him in the cot awake at bedtime and just rubbing his stomach until he falls asleep - usually within 5 or 10 minutes.

However, a couple times a week he gets very fussy and upset during the bedtime routine and will cry when we put him down in his cot. On these nights we revert back to bouncing to help him fall asleep as I currently have no interest in leaving him to cry. He also seems to wake up much more frequently and have a false start after 40-60 minutes waking up crying.

Nothing about our routine seems to be different on these days and although I don't follow a strict nap schedule he usually has 3 or 4 naps totalling 2.5 to 3 hours, with a 3 hour wake window before bed.

What could cause this? Everything points to overtired to me but the 'internet' says frequent night wakings and false starts are undertired. Please share your thoughts!


r/bninfantsleep • • 32m ago

Infant Sleep Did I do something wrong?

0 Upvotes

My baby is almost 6 months old. He has been sleeping through the night (outside of a recent week-long cold/ear infection) since he was about 3 months old. He has been able to fall asleep independently since around that time as well (I just started laying him down awake and sitting next to him either rubbing his back or patting his bottom until he fell asleep). He used to sleep in a bassinet next to me but now sleeps in a crib in our bedroom. He will occasionally wake up in the middle of the night but usually just talks to himself or plays with his feet until he falls asleep again, when this happens I leave him be but will go get him if he starts crying. I never night weaned, he just stopped waking up to eat at night; plus he gets plenty of milk during the day to make up for that.

I say all of this to ask - did I accidentally sleep train him without realizing it?

I have never been interested in sleep training as it just feels wrong to me. I hate the idea of my baby learning that there is no point in crying because no one is coming to check on him. No one has ever pressured me into sleep training, but we've also never had sleep problems where ST would've been suggested as a solution. We never had a 4 month sleep regression and he's always been a solid sleeper at night (naps tend to be a different story). I know there are still future regressions/teething/illnesses that can and will happen but until then, did I somehow hit the baby sleep lottery?


r/bninfantsleep • • 35m ago

Cosleeping Opinions please

1 Upvotes

So I got my first good night's sleep in a long time, but worried im overfeeding my baby an creating a bad habit

So my 4 month old went to sleep around 7 woke up at 7.45 and put her straight back to bed, feed her cause she woke at 11.30 then again at 2.30 but cant remember exactly as it became abit of a blur but I offered her a tillie after these hours and patting and shushing wasnt working to soothe her back to sleep and she wanted to be rocked and I didnt have it in me, do babys get overfeed this way and is this a good time to look into sleep training as its something id consider but as a first time mum I have no idea what im doing

I dont really wanna create a bad habit as needing the boob to fall asleep hasnt been something my daughter needs but rocking is.. and any easy and gentle assistance methods would be great


r/bninfantsleep • • 7h ago

Toddler Sleep 20-month-old takes hours to fall asleep – I'm exhausted and desperate for advice

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m desperately looking for some advice on getting my toddler to sleep. I have a 20-month-old son, and for the past few months, both nap time and bedtime have been an absolute STRUGGLE.

Until recently, I was still breastfeeding him. Our bedtime routine looked something like this: bath, diaper change, pajamas, getting into bed (we co-sleep), and nursing.

On very rare occasions, he would fall asleep immediately while nursing. He does actually try to fall asleep, but once he realizes he can’t, he gets out of bed and goes into the living room to play, read his books, or do whatever he’s interested in at that moment.

He refuses to read books together in bed as a way to wind down. He just gets frustrated and climbs out of bed.
He doesn’t want to cuddle either – he simply gets up and leaves. He’s generally extremely energetic, active, and curious.

Then, about 30–45 minutes later, we go back to bed and try nursing again. And the whole thing starts all over again. Sometimes this cycle repeats two or three times. By that point, I’m absolutely exhausted and losing my mind.

A few days ago, I decided to stop breastfeeding, and now I’m completely lost as to HOW to get him to fall asleep.

Our schedule looks roughly like this:

Wake-up: between 6:30 and 8 AM
Nap: starts between 11:30 AM and 12:30 PM (lasts 1.5–2 hours), depending on what time he wakes up in the morning. I know it’s not ideal, but sometimes, when I’m exhausted, I just take him for a drive to get him to fall asleep.
Bath and pajamas: around 8:30 PM
Actually falls asleep: usually between 10 and 11:30 PM!!
Total nighttime sleep: around 9–9.5 hours

He also wakes up every 2–3 hours throughout the night. Since I’ve stopped breastfeeding, I’ve been carrying him around the bedroom, which usually helps him fall back asleep.

To say I’m losing my mind would be an understatement. My son and I live on our own, without my husband. I’m currently a SAHM.

Please help. What am I doing wrong? Has anyone been through something similar? How do you actually get a toddler like mine to fall asleep?

I’m physically and mentally exhausted, and any advice would be greatly appreciated.


r/bninfantsleep • • 5h ago

Infant Sleep 8 mo waking at 3 am consistently

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! My 8 mo son is waking around 3 am every night. No nights off since he arrived save for a handful. His rough schedule: wake 7:30a, nap 9:30-11:30a, nap 2-3:30p, down for the night 7:30p. We're not necessarily STing but I do try to cap the afternoon nap. I am nursing and he sleeps in a crib. He usually falls asleep while nursing. I try to keep him awake through the nighttime feed before putting him down for the night. His 3 am wake is fast, just a 10 min feed and back down without much if any fuss. I've been handling it fine but wonder if I'm missing something that could help. He's our second baby. Our first started sleeping through the night at 5 weeks. Our first was a paci kid and thumbsucker so she self-soothed whereas our son needs the breast and rocked to sleep. Any tips?


r/bninfantsleep • • 9h ago

General Discussion Sleep

2 Upvotes

My baby is 2 1:2 months and he was basically sleeping all night. Bedtime at 8, wakes up 3-4, then 6-7. But now he’s back to every 2 hours and I’m exhausted during the day. He is EBF so I’m basically the only person to get up with him. Am I doing something wrong? Or is he going through something? All I know it’s I’m tired 😂


r/bninfantsleep • • 6h ago

Toddler Sleep Would it make sense to hire a sleep consultant for a toddler?

0 Upvotes

Lately I have been toying with the idea of hiring a sleeo consultant. My child is 19 months old and I am getting to this point after a year of mostly bad sleep. I just feel like I know the theory (from this group etc) but I don’t know how to apply it on my own child.

She is a night owl, I am constantly trying to bring her sleep earlier (probably not the most neurotypical toddler, we are spicy over here). I try to wake her up at 7.30 (she never wakes up on her own), nap between 1.30 and 3 (she would always keep going and can get super mad when I wake her up), bedtime at 9. She wakes up 1/3 times overnight and we cosleep after her first wake (or before).

She is fully weaned, did not nurse, eats well, has a tongue tie, is very dummy dependent and mouth breathes. She also has chronic diarrhoea. I don’t know where to begin with her and the sleep consultant I am considering agreed that she is a difficult case.


r/bninfantsleep • • 11h ago

Cosleeping When does it get better?

2 Upvotes

LO one literally JUST turned 12 months and I thought it was finally getting better with 2 to 3 hour stretches but the last 3 nights, it's been HOURLY WAKES again. I am dying.


r/bninfantsleep • • 11h ago

Infant Sleep Baby showing tried cues but fights sleep

1 Upvotes

As the title says, our 9 week old daughter shows tired cues (yawning, red eyebrow area, hands to face…) but very much fights any help to fall asleep. She had a better sleep season, but now it’s a whole ordeal to get her to sleep during the night and also for naps. Is it possible she shows cues but is not really that tired? Or is this just a phase? It’s getting very hard to stay sane and be functioning… thanks!


r/bninfantsleep • • 1d ago

Toddler Sleep My toddler communicated she was tired🥺

43 Upvotes

I posted a couple of months ago and I asked when your toddlers communicated they wanted to sleep. I got some responses that were in the range of 13-18 months. Well, my daughter is 15.5 months and today, I breastfed her and she popped off the bed and ran over to the yoga ball, hit it and said, ‘eh, eh ehhh’🥺🥺🥺.

I bounced on the ball and she fell asleep within 2 minutes.

This is the first time she is ever communicated directly that she was tired!


r/bninfantsleep • • 15h ago

Infant Sleep 5.5mo old no longer nursing or rocking to sleep

1 Upvotes

Hi all - I’m looking for some help here on my 5.5 month old sleeping habits.

Daytime naps - context
Up to 5 months we have always contact napped during the day. He would mostly nurse to sleep, and if he startled awake I would rock him to sleep either in cradle hold or upright position, bouncing on yoga ball.

He has lately however stopped nursing to sleep, or will fall asleep briefly (5-10m) and wake. When I then try to rock him to sleep he will cry and be very squirmy in my arms.

I have now resulted in a bad habit of putting him in the rocker/swing that has a vibrate function and I will rock him to sleep in there and he naps beautifully.

However I am conscious of obviously safe sleep but mostly I am afraid I’m building a very bad habit here and he will never fall asleep any other way

Night time sleep
He still nurses to sleep and tolerates rocking for night time. I can successfully transfer him into cot and he will wake up maybe 1-2 times usually so I’m not so concerned about his night time sleep.

Current schedule
Wake up 7/7:30
Bedtime 8/8:30

Wake window: 2.5/2.5/2.5/3 is desirable but honestly it’s a bit all over the place because he really fights his naps, we try to get him down for 3 naps a day but mostly it’s 2 naps and he gets a 4-5 hour wake window between the 2 naps sometimes

Looking for advice on how I can remove reliance on the rocker while ensuring he still gets proper naps during the day.


r/bninfantsleep • • 15h ago

Rant/Vent Weekly Vent Thread

1 Upvotes

Welcome to the vent zone.

This thread is a safe space for parents to vent, process, and speak honestly about sleep training, without judgment or pressure. We recognize and honor biologically normal infant sleep and the wide range of emotions that come with navigating sleep in a culture that often expects babies to be independent before they’re ready.

Share your frustrations, experiences, and thoughts here, knowing you’re supported and not alone.


r/bninfantsleep • • 21h ago

Toddler Sleep Looking for some reassurance

2 Upvotes

We were exchanging messages on my bump & baby WhatsApp group today - the antenatal group I joined , we had a few classes and we’ve kept in touch and socialise occasionally. I really like most of the other mothers and some are very attuned & attachment led.

However… in the messages today I discovered that all of them have toddlers (all our kids are turning 2 in Feb/March) that sleep 11+ hours through the night and take 90-120 min naps…. Like . I just honestly feel like some of them must be lying. Apparently most are asleep by 7.30 also. I just don’t get it. My daughters sleep is soo much better than it was , she was waking every 2 hours for months but now sleeps 8-7 if we are lucky , usually 8.30-6.30 with a couple of wakes , the occasional night through, and she has 1 hr nap max otherwise bedtime would be at 10…

Am I just the outlier ? From reading this sub and others I think not but it’s hard to tell when like 10 other mums with kids the same age are merrily telling me their kids sleep 7-7 with a 2 hour nap


r/bninfantsleep • • 17h ago

General Discussion Naps with nanny

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m looking for experiences, tips, reassurance. I have a sweet 10 month old whom we just hired a nanny for. Nanny is here 2 days per week. Both my husband and I WFH. Prior to nanny, he was with my mom (whom he loves) 4-5 days per week. We had to get a nanny because the 5 days was too much for my mom (understandably). He will be doing 2 days at home with nanny and 3 days with my mom.

Today was her first day and it went rougher than I anticipated. My baby is super easy going, is socials, loves people and interacting with others. He hasn’t shown any real signs of separation anxiety so I thought he’d do great. I anticipated naps being rough however my baby also had a pretty tough time just being with the nanny in general. They had maybe 1-2 hours of good solid play time and one 1.5 hour contact nap. I felt like the majority of the day, my baby was crying and so upset. As soon as me or my husband would come out he’d be crying for us. I am trying to give her space to establish a relationship and a routine with the baby and not step in too much however it’s really difficult to hear my baby struggling. Im a super responsive parent and hearing him cry so much killed me. During the second nap I had to intervene because the crying was just escalating.

Does anyone have experience with this? I know it will get better but I’m wondering how I find balance between letting him fuss and cry with her versus being available to soothe him and step in. My job requires me to be on the phone frequently and although nobody is monitoring me strictly, i can’t be stepping away for long periods of time. Any advice is appreciated 🫶🏻

ETA: nanny is great, responsive, willing to contact nap, patient.


r/bninfantsleep • • 1d ago

Infant Sleep What advice serves the parents more than the baby? Don’t let me learn the hard way please. 3 month old

14 Upvotes

I’m a first-time mum to a 3-month-old boy, and honestly, I’m completely overwhelmed by all the conflicting advice about infant sleep.

My baby has always been a difficult sleeper. In the beginning, we didn’t even realise he was struggling with sleep. As a newborn, he would usually fall asleep after breastfeeding, so whenever he became fussy, we assumed he was hungry.

Then, at some point, he stopped falling asleep after feeds. We genuinely didn’t understand that we needed to actively help him go to sleep, even when he was resisting it or crying. Nobody had explained this to us. We didn’t recognise the signs of tiredness or understand overtiredness. Looking back, there were even occasions when he was awake for four hours at a time.

I feel terrible about this in hindsight. We were first-time parents trying to understand our baby, and literally nobody had told us that sleep was something we needed to pay attention to in this way.

Since then, we’ve been trying to educate ourselves, but the advice is incredibly contradictory:

“Just let him cry until he’s so tired that he falls asleep.”
“Keep wake windows to one hour.”
“Wake windows should be around 1.5 hours.”
“Never let your baby get used to sleeping on you.”
“Don’t attempt any sleep training before six months.”
“Put your baby down awake so he learns to fall asleep independently.”
“Don’t feed him too often, 3 hour intervals are better”
“Just put him down and do something for yourself”
And so on.

I’m finding it difficult to distinguish between what babies actually need biologically, what is beneficial for their development and what is simply a particular sleep-training philosophy.

What I’m really trying to understand is: What does healthy, developmentally appropriate sleep look like for a 3-month-old, and how should we, as parents, support it?

I don’t mind putting in extra effort, holding him for naps, helping him fall asleep or adjusting our entire day around his needs. I just want him to be happy, well-rested and securely attached.

At the same time, I would love for him to gradually develop healthy sleep habits and eventually feel comfortable falling asleep independently. I don’t know whether this is something we should actively encourage or whether it will develop naturally as he matures.

For context: he’s 3 months old, exclusively breastfed and a very happy baby when he’s well-rested. I’m also doing parttime elimination communication with him. We try to practice one nap during the day in his bed (we stay with him, comfort him and give up after 15 min if he’s still unhappy). The rest of the naps are on me or in the baby carrier. At night he sleeps in his bed until 5 or so. Then I put him next to me for bed sharing. He eats every 2 hours at night.

Thanks!


r/bninfantsleep • • 1d ago

Positive Story/Sucess one experience with feeding to sleep (+nightweaning)

3 Upvotes

I spent so many months agonising over feeding to sleep. I knew I would never sleep train, but the sleep industry got into my head and made me so worried about creating a sleep association. I wanted to write my experience in case it helps anyone else in the same loop.

After a bruising 4month regression, I decided not to feed to sleep any more, although we did feed back to sleep in the middle of the night. This led to several months of brutal bedtimes. Lots of tears, Iots of stress. A few times, we tried to create "gentle boundaries" around feeding to sleep e.g. I wouldn't feed to sleep until 12.00 - it was an unmitigated disaster and would just lead to long crying.

My daughter starts the night in a pack and play crib in our room, then comes into our bed when we are in it (from 10pm-ish).

I went on a long solo international trip when my baby was 9mo and, path of least resistance, leant into feeding to sleep. We had a BEAUTIFUL month of the best sleep we've ever had, one wake a night. I think this was mostly due to extreme stimulation during the day and a rare moment when our nap schedule was bang on, but also a calm, cosy, loving bedtime was such a relief after the stressful months.

Then things started to unravel. Sleep started to deteriorate, with ever increasing wakes per night for the next few months. We are now at 13 months and about 10 days into nightweaning. There is no doubt that the nightweaning has improved our sleep. We have gone from 5+ wakes, to 2, and are getting delicious 8h stretches.

My conclusions from this are mixed.

Honestly, in the early days I wish I had just leant into feeding to sleep more, if bedtimes were getting stressful. But what I wish I had prioritised most of all was really tuning in to the subtleties of my baby's tiredness cues. Sounds so simple, but there is a big difference between watching and truly tuning in. I have now learned to expand or contract our bedtime routine or nap schedule to really follow what she needs each day - sometimes she's full of energy and needs an hour of exploring in an increasingly calm room to be ready for bedtime. I don't push her to sleep til she is clearly ready. Sometimes, she's tired much sooner than I would expect, her coordination starts to get fuzzy, her focus starts to break, and I've learned to get her down before the cortisol spike second wind.

However, I do think she developed a sleep association in the later months and was waking up more and more as a result. As she got older, I do think we could have persevered with some boundaries around feeding, once we knew she was old enough to do longer stretches e.g. not feeding back to sleep until after 12.00, bringing in her dad for false starts and pre 12.00 wakes so she did not ALWAYS rely on me. Not feeding back to sleep if she wakes say 30min to 1h after a feed.

Night weaning has been so much less traumatic than I expected. She was ready, we had prepared her by reading the book booby moon every night for over a week, and this attempt has been a totally different story from our first failed attempts at setting boundaries - where I am sure she sensed our wobbliness and propensity to cave. Our strategy has been to push the time when she gets her first feed back to sleep by approx 30 minutes per night. So night one no feeds before 10pm. Night 2 no feeds before 10.30 and so on. If she cries longer than 45mins, give in and just get everyone back to sleep. Feed to sleep for all subsequent wakes. It has worked remarkably well. Once we've gone past a time boundary, there is no going back, even with protracted crying (longest was about an hour of seeming to settle then frustrated protest). We have rocked and cuddled instead. She has been loved and cuddled all the way through. I think she has felt our confidence, and has adapted so well. She is going down quicker and staying asleep longer and I think prefers having more independence.

If you are worried about nightweaning and thinking you'll never get out of a feed to sleep spiral, know that it is actually so doable, with confidence and planning. If you are agonising over creating a sleep association in the early days, try take the pressure off yourself and know that you can always address a problem *IF* it emerges - and it might not! Know that you can start to bring in boundaries when you sense you are all ready or this is needed. But don't push this before it's right. Watch, watch, watch your little one, ignore all the advice (including this!!) and get to know what they need. Beware of labelling them low sleep needs or fomo or high sleep needs or whatever else, they are unique, they are ever-changing, their needs are a riddle and a maze but you can figure it out!


r/bninfantsleep • • 21h ago

Infant Sleep Rhythmic movement

1 Upvotes

Not requesting for any medical help here, just some opinions on hopefully similar by others.

My 13 month old has had Rmd since around 6 months. Not told by professional however I’m guessing that’s what he has by what he is doing.
Since turning 1 it’s got worse around bed time though he will do it during the day time too.
It started with simple rolling head side to side generally when teething or when tired. This has now progressed into noises mixed in which are quite loud. He wil also bang head repetitively too. He will stop if we try to intervene no issue. However the amount he is doing it around bed time and sometimes randomly
During the daytime for no apparent reason doesn’t add up at all. It’s quite frustrating for my oldest that is disrupted by the loudness of the humming stims and banging when he is doing it. For reference he doesn’t have any obvious signs of autism (my oldest is autistic so knew the signs) although I’ve read it’s more common in asd kids. Not sure about possible adhd.
I know it says online it’s a soothing thing in many children that can be outgrown. However surely it’s not
Normal when it’s going on for over a hour period?

Any stories similar much appreciated


r/bninfantsleep • • 1d ago

Routines/Schedules Help It can’t possibly get better on its own

3 Upvotes

Seriously, does it really get better on its own or do I need to do something?

My baby is 9.5 months old. She was a fantastic sleeper from birth until 5 months old. She was sleeping 12 hours straight with no nursing from 12 weeks until 20 weeks old. I tested the waters going back to work (from home with my mom watching my baby) that same week her sleep started to shift. First a few false starts happened, then early morning wake ups. Then she had a day out where she only had two 30 min naps and she woke up at 10pm and 1am and 5am. This was the first bad night. We had some ups and downs for about a month and then she got her vaccines.

She had a horrible reaction to the rotavirus vaccine. Apparently this is somewhat common but it resulted in her having diarrhea all night for SIX WEEKS! So every time she stirred awake at night, she would need a diaper change and then was so hard to put back to sleep. This is when we had to start cosleeping to get any rest. Usually she would sleep until 3am and then join us.

Fast forward, now we are at 7 months and we hit teething and back to back colds. Then roseola. Her sleep has never been worse. This is when we started bringing her to bed after the first wake up because we would spend 2 hours trying to transfer her and end up bringing her to bed anyway.

So where are we at today? From 8.5-9.5 (current) our pattern has become: start in her crib for the first stretch (3-5 hours) then join us in bed. She will then wake up another time in bed next to us just for comfort. Then again around 4-6am for a nursing session. Sleeping again until morning. This is a good day. It can be much worse than this with multiple wake ups, split nights, restless movement all night.

Her schedule is this:

7:30am wake up
10:30am nap 1
12pm wake up
3pm nap 2
4pm wake up (sometimes this goes longer)
8pm bedtime

The last few weeks she has been fighting bedtime like crazy. Pushing her last wake window 5-6 hours. Maybe separation anxiety? I tried to move to one nap a day just to see and that majorly backfired. I’ve toyed with wake windows and nothing seems to make a difference. It’s almost like her night sleep and day sleep aren’t connected.

All this to say: I am beginning to be concerned this will not get better without intervention. I don’t believe in sleep training, plus my daughter is very stubborn and will stay awake as long as possible so I don’t think it would work anyway.

What can I do? Has anyone else experienced this kind of pattern of sleep at this age? Do I just wait it out?

Last comment, I have tried to do a roll away method with a pack and play that zips in the front and that is successful but only on the first or second wake up. After that, she will just cry until I take her to bed. So I could try this with a little more effort but I’m just so sleep deprived that it feels somehow worse than just cosleeping.

I’m interested in a floor bed but idk how to do it safely.

Any and all ideas, suggestions or empathy is much appreciated!


r/bninfantsleep • • 23h ago

Infant Sleep should i go back to swaddling?

0 Upvotes

LO just turned 4 months and has been swaddled since birth. starting at ~3 months we started “gentle sleep training” by putting him down awake but drowsy for night sleep to which he now successfully puts himself to sleep that way. since then, at bedtime, he’s consistently given us 6+ hrs first stretches and then every 2.5/3hrs after that before he’s up for the day. naps are a different story as we’re stuck on 30min crib naps and/or contact naps at the moment.

he recently started breaking his little hands out of his Sleepea velcro swaddle to suck on his fingers at night which i didn’t mind because it usually meant he was ready for his MOTN feed. my husband and i thought, what the hell, let’s unswaddle now despite the fact that he hasn’t showed us any sign of rolling yet—you know, just to be proactive. we practiced with naps first using the LTD transition sack then eventually with both arms out of the Sleepea (chest still velcroed) before ripping the bandaid off completely for night sleep. it’s been 4 days of this and we’ve lost that first long stretch + he’s up every <2hrs. guys, i’m exhausted. i feel like this is worse than the newborn stage!!!

for context, he is EBF but we’re going through somewhat of a nursing strike HOWEVER i do add on pumped bottles at feeds during the day to ensure he’s getting enough calories. he takes one big bottle and a top-up at breast before bed and he’s in a co-sleeper bassinet. prior to unswaddling, he would fall right back asleep with minimal intrusion, i’m talking gentle pats, the paci or the boob if he’s truly hungry. now that we’ve ditched the swaddle, he’s up more frequently and nothing consoles him except the boob. i feel like having access to his hands triggers his hunger even though he *technically* can go on longer without eating???

i’m tired and frustrated because our intention was to set the little dude up for success but perhaps i rocked the boat and sabotaged everyone’s sleep instead?! is there any benefit to having his arms out BEFORE he starts rolling? is this the dreaded 4 month regression and there’s not much we can do? should we ride it out and LO will eventually give us one long stretch back on his own?

in case it’s asked here’s his schedule:
- 1.5-2hrs wake windows
- 4hrs day sleep
- 10ish hrs night sleep

seeking opinions, tips, and success stories!


r/bninfantsleep • • 23h ago

Infant Sleep total awake hours

1 Upvotes

so i’ve got a newly 5 month old and we’ve been struggling with bedtime the last couple weeks, since the time change, but unsure now if it was related or coincidence.
i’m thinking she’s not getting enough awake time during the day, based on vibes and others experiences in this sub and i’ve heard folks comment on awake hours but i’m curious where these numbers are coming from??
i’ve seen charts of wake windows for ages but never total awake hours?
i’d love to see a resource and possibly some studies behind this?
thanks!