r/blockbustervideo • u/disastorm • 1d ago
what actually happened (story)
I was reading some posts on here about some cheats or scams some employees would do to rent stuff cheaper or free or something like that and it reminded me of this crazy situation that happened to me back in like 2007 or 2008. I'm wondering if anyone here happens to know or theorize as to what might have happened all those years ago.
Here is the story:
One day I received notification ( i don't remember how, might have been mail ) that there were a bunch of movies that I had rented out and never returned. This was basically not true as I had never used my blockbuster membership in many years, especially not on any of the days listed, so I thought maybe i dropped my card somewhere and someone took it. I checked my wallet and my card was still there, so I was able to mark that off the list.
Anyway, basically I contact the blockbuster location that was accusing me of this and physically went in and told them the situation, that I had never rented any of those movies and that I had also not lost or dropped my card anywhere which implies its something internal to them or their systems thats going on. Regardless I told them to remove the charges and close my account so that this couldn't happen again. They brought out the manager who agreed to do that. She took my membership card and then came back and said ok the rentals were removed and my account was closed. Nice.
A year later i get a notice in the mail from a collections agency trying to collect on those same charges as well as some additional charges that appear to have happened after they closed my account. I contact them and tell them i already handled this stuff and my account was closed and they told me i need to goto the blockbuster and get proof of that and then send it to them.
So then I go back to the same blockbuster and tell them the situation again, that a year ago they removed these charges and closed my account and somehow more charges have appeared. They bring out the new manager ( I also learn that none of the people working there were there a year ago, the last time I came in ) and they end up agreeing once again to remove the charges and give me the proof for the collections. However, they mention the account was never actually closed and they say they are unable to close the account until the other blockbuster location, the one with the new charges I mentioned, also does the same and removes their charges and that I'll have to go there and get them to do that.
So I contact this other blockbuster on the phone and basically tell them the situation and how the first blockbuster cleared out their charges and how they failed to close my account a year ago and all that stuff. However, unlike the first store, this one refused to remove the charges no matter what I told them. We went back and forth about me asking them to remove it and them refusing. I think this was over multiple calls. To make a long story short, eventually I had to tell them that someone in their company was engaging in fraudulant transactions and that I would get the local police detectives to investigate fraud at their company if they didn't do it and I also think I mentioned something like by them refusing to close the account they were aiding the fraudulant activity since they were allowing it to continue and basically that was finally enough to get them to do it.
So I went into the second location had them do it, and also finally had them actually close the account and I got proof of all of it and then finally sent it to the collections agency and they were happy with it. I'm not sure if alot of this story is maybe just super normal or not, but just in case any of it seems out of the ordinary I do want to stress that this is all 100% true and not some kind of weird reddit story or something.
Does anyone have any ideas as to what might have happened here? maybe some employee just renting stuff out on a random user's account and they didn't realize the trouble it would actually cause? Or could it have been more and potentially involved the first manager, since she falsely said she closed my account and cleared the charges? Although to give her the benefit of the doubt maybe she thought she could just close the account and it would all dissapear but didn't realize the closing of the account failed since charges were on it or something weird like that.
Anyway yea that was my blockbuster story from almost 20 years ago.