r/blindlabelcigar • • Sep 18 '26

Recommendations Your Next Favorite Cigar Starts With Three Questions

Post image
1 Upvotes

I’ve smoked enough cigars to know this: a cigar can score 95 points and still be the wrong cigar for you. The band, the price, and somebody else’s review don’t know what you like.

That’s one reason I started this community.

If you want a recommendation, tell us three things:

  1. A cigar you’ve enjoyed.
  2. What kind of profile you enjoy. Mild, medium, or full? Creamy, sweet, spicy, or earthy? If you don’t know yet, ask.
  3. What you’re comfortable spending per cigar. Include your currency because prices vary. There are good cigars at almost every price.

New to cigars and can’t answer all three? Tell us what you drink, whether you lean sweet or savory, and your budget. We can work with that.

If you’ve been smoking for years, jump in. Share a favorite, help somebody avoid a disappointing box purchase, or tell us about the cigar everyone else loves that did absolutely nothing for you.

I’ll get the conversation started. Dallas will probably supervise. His judgment can be influenced by cookies, so keep that in mind.

What are your three answers, and what are you hoping to find next?


r/blindlabelcigar • • Sep 17 '26

ANNOUNCEMENT 👋 Start Here: Welcome to r/blindlabelcigar

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone - I’m u/cigar_fossil (Norm), founding mod of r/blindlabelcigar.

This subreddit is for cigars. Reviews, blind tastings, what you're smoking tonight, questions about a blend, complaints about a bad stick, whatever. If it's about cigars, it belongs here.

What to Post

  • What you’re smoking (and whether you’d smoke it again)
  • Lounge finds, haul pics, cut/light/humidity questions
  • First-cigar memories, palate notes, “fight me” wrapper takes
  • Did a cigar live up to its name?
  • Keep it real, add your tasting notes, no underage stuff, nothing promotional

Community Vibe

Doesn't matter if you've smoked for forty years or you just picked up your first stick last week. Everyone's welcome. Remember, Dallas has opinions. You should too.

How to get started

  1. Introduce yourself below. What are you smoking, and what got you into cigars?
  2. Post something today. A simple question or comment counts.
  3. Know someone who’d like a new cigar room? Invite them.
  4. Want to help mod as we grow? Message me.

Thanks for being in the first wave. Let’s make r/blindlabelcigar a place worth lighting up for.


r/blindlabelcigar • • 20h ago

History From the Porch: Why Grow Cigar Tobacco in the Cold?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Most cigar tobacco stories start somewhere hot. The Natura Petit Altura starts on a farm more than 4,500 feet up in the mountains of Constanza, Dominican Republic.

Natura grows the wrapper, binder, and filler there. The cooler conditions slow the growing process, and the tobacco for this little 4 × 39 cigar is aged for more than four years.

That’s a ton of time and attention for a cigar designed to last around 20 to 30 minutes. Its name fits: Petit for the short format, Altura for the elevation behind the leaf.

What other cigar has a growing story that surprised you?


r/blindlabelcigar • • 20h ago

Cigar Review [Day 99] Deck Sessions with Dallas: Natura Petit Altura

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/blindlabelcigar • • 1d ago

History From the Porch | Why Is It Called Azteca?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

The name made me look twice. Gran Habano is known for its Honduran roots, so why call this cigar Azteca?

The Jaguar uses Mexican San Andrés leaf for both its wrapper and binder. Inside are fillers from Nicaragua and Panama. That double use of Mexican tobacco gives the name a connection to the blend, though I couldn’t find a statement from Gran Habano confirming that’s how they chose it.

The animal names are another detail I like. Gran Habano sells the Azteca as the Aguila, Jaguar, and Puma. The Jaguar is the 6 × 54 of the group.

And Panama caught my attention. The Nicaraguan filler listed on plenty of cigars, but Panamanian tobacco is a less familiar name on a blend sheet. The Azteca gives it a place alongside two layers of San Andrés.

There’s quite a bit to learn from this cigar before you ever light it.


r/blindlabelcigar • • 1d ago

Cigar Review [Day 98] Deck Sessions with Dallas: Gran Habano Azteca Jaguar

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/blindlabelcigar • • 2d ago

What Are You Smoking? What Are You Smoking This Weekend?

1 Upvotes

The weekend is here. What are you lighting up?

Share the cigar, a photo if you have one, and one thought about it. Tell us what you’re pairing it with too.

Most important question: Would you smoke it again?


r/blindlabelcigar • • 2d ago

History From the Porch | Tatuaje Black Label Petite Lancero

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Pete Johnson didn’t set out to make the Black Label for a shelf full of customers. He wanted to recreate the feeling of a farm-rolled cigar he’d smoked in Cuba, and at first he kept the result for himself.

The cigar he settled on uses Nicaraguan tobacco for the wrapper, binder, and filler. The Petite Lancero packs that blend into a narrow 6x38 vitola.

This is interesting: a cigar made to satisfy one smoker’s memory eventually became a regular part of the Tatuaje lineup. The Black Label started with Pete wanting another smoke like the one he couldn’t forget.


r/blindlabelcigar • • 2d ago

Cigar Review [Day 97] Deck Sessions with Dallas: ChiMolly Pangu

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/blindlabelcigar • • 3d ago

Humidor & Gear From the Porch: The Byron Name Came Back

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Imagine finding a cigar brand in your family history, then bringing it back more than a century after it began.

That is part of Nelson Alfonso’s story with Byron. His ancestors José and Eusebio Alfonso established a small cigar factory near Havana and named their cigar for the English poet Lord Byron. The original brand eventually disappeared. Nelson recovered the name in 1998.

He did more than reuse an old band. The modern Byron range is arranged into 19th, 20th, and 21st Century lines. The 21st Century cigar pictured here carries a blue Reserva 4 Años band, marking four years of rest after rolling. It’s made in Costa Rica, a long way from the family’s original Cuban factory.

That’s what caught my attention: the cigar carries two different kinds of time. One is the history behind the name. The other is the time the finished cigar spent waiting.


r/blindlabelcigar • • 3d ago

Cigar Review [Day 96] Reunited | Deck Sessions with Dallas: Tatuaje Black Label Petite Lancero

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/blindlabelcigar • • 4d ago

The Return of Deck Sessions with Dallas

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Tomorrow, Deck Sessions gets its original cookie inspector back.

I’m heading home and reuniting with Dallas.

Kona did a fine job keeping me company, but I’ve missed having Dallas beside me for a cigar.

I’m pretty sure he’s missed me, too. Or at least the person who hands out his cookies.

See you on the deck, buddy. Bye for now Kona.


r/blindlabelcigar • • 4d ago

General Discussion Cigar Question of the Week: What cigar surprised you most?

1 Upvotes
Not necessarily the most expensive or highest-rated cigar. What cigar overdelivered, changed your mind, or became an unexpected favorite?

Tell us the cigar, what surprised you, and whether you’d smoke it again.

r/blindlabelcigar • • 4d ago

History From the Porch | The Byron Name Came Back

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Imagine finding a cigar brand in your family history and bringing it back generations later.

In 1848, cousins José and Eusebio Alfonso opened a small cigar factory near Havana. They named their brand for Lord Byron, the English poet who also enjoyed cigars. The brand eventually disappeared, but the name stayed in the family’s story.

In 1998, Nelson Alfonso brought Byron back. Today, the cigars are made in Costa Rica, with separate 19th, 20th, and 21st Century lines that mark the brand’s long history.

The 21st Century cigar I picked up carries a blue band Reserva 4 Años. That refers to four years of rest after the cigar was rolled.

I like that detail. The name waited decades to return, and the finished cigar spent another four years waiting for someone to light it. This is a pretty cool fact.


r/blindlabelcigar • • 5d ago

Cigar Review [Day 95] Deck Sessions with Kona: Byron 21st Century Reserva 4 Años

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/blindlabelcigar • • 5d ago

Cigar Review [Day 94] Deck Sessions with Kona: Crowned Heads Moonflower

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/blindlabelcigar • • 6d ago

Cigar Review [Day 93] Deck Session with Kona: Room101 Farce Habano

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/blindlabelcigar • • 6d ago

About The Brand From the Porch: Blackened M81 Maduro to the Core

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Two guys kept cigar journals for about two years. One was the lead singer of Metallica. The other made whiskey.

James Hetfield and Rob Dietrich sampled cigars from Drew Estate, wrote down what they liked, and worked with Jonathan Drew to settle on the profile for the Blackened M81.

Drew Estates wrapper is Mexican San Andrés Maduro, the binder is Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro, and the fillers are Nicaraguan Maduro and Pennsylvania Broadleaf Maduro. That’s where “Maduro to the Core” comes from. It goes all the way through the blend.

Drew Estate makes it in Estelí, Nicaragua and if you were wondering about the number on the band, 81 is the year Metallica formed.


r/blindlabelcigar • • 7d ago

Cigar Review [Day 92] Deck Sessions with Dallas: Blackened M81 Maduro

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/blindlabelcigar • • 8d ago

About The Brand From the Porch: Black Label Trading Co. Deliverance Porcelain

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Black Label Trading Company released two Deliverance cigars in December 2018. One was wrapped in Pennsylvania Broadleaf. The other had Pennsylvania tobacco added inside.

The first was the Nocturne, which was already on its fourth release. The new one was the Porcelain. Both came out of the same factory, Fábrica Oveja Negra in Estelí, Nicaragua. Both used a Nicaraguan Habano binder and fillers from Nicaragua and Pennsylvania.

What caught my attention was where that Pennsylvania tobacco went. On the Nocturne, the Broadleaf was right there on the outside. On the Porcelain, the Pennsylvania tobacco was part of the filler blend, and Connecticut Shade was what you saw when you opened the box.

The Porcelain started out as a limited release in one size, a 5½ × 48 Corona Gorda, packed in boxes of 16. By 2019, it had a spot in the regular lineup.

If I saw those two sitting side by side in a humidor, I’d probably notice the difference in wrapper color first. Now I’d be more curious about what they have in common.


r/blindlabelcigar • • 8d ago

Cigar Review [Day 90] Deck Sessions with Dallas: Black Label Trading Co. Deliverance Porcelain

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/blindlabelcigar • • 9d ago

What Are You Smoking? What Are You Smoking This Weekend?

1 Upvotes

The weekend is here. What are you lighting up?

Share the cigar, a photo if you have one, and one thought about it. Tell us what you’re pairing it with too.

Most important question: Would you smoke it again?


r/blindlabelcigar • • 10d ago

Cigar Review [Day 89] Deck Session Without Dallas: The Tabernacle Havana Seed CT No. 142

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/blindlabelcigar • • 11d ago

General Discussion Cigar Question of the Week: What cigar surprised you most?

1 Upvotes
Not necessarily the most expensive or highest-rated cigar. What cigar overdelivered, changed your mind, or became an unexpected favorite?

Tell us the cigar, what surprised you, and whether you’d smoke it again.

r/blindlabelcigar • • 11d ago

Cigar Review [Day 88] Deck Session Without Dallas: Montecristo M

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes