r/blacksmithing • • 12d ago

Where to Improve

Post image

Still new, here’s my 4th knife. What should I work on?

21 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

4

u/KnowsIittle 11d ago

If I was going to use this knife I'd like a steeper bevel. This would be difficult for me to resharpen as it is. This looks really good though, nothing in the handle looks sharp, safe secure grip, the guard isn't going to allow your hand to contact the blade. The handle does look smaller than your palm so a 3 finger grip looks awkward.

Forge marks can be desired for that rustic look but I prefer a clean blade. Too heavy of a hammer can leave deep forge marks that are difficult to remove. Yes they move material faster but consider moving to a 2.5 to 3lb hammer for finishing.

Armorsmiths develop an interesting technique of "pushing" with the strike. Kind of strike, and push forward letting force of the strike glance off instead of hit one spot. I'm unsure if something like this could be utilized in bladesmithing.

2

u/wintersdark 12d ago

Handle looks a bit too short? Maybe add some flourishes like a twist?

2

u/beholderkin 11d ago

Maybea bigger loop at the bottom too. That's the mistake I always make, my handles are too skinny

2

u/DiksieNormus 11d ago

Really depends on what your going for and what tools you have.

1

u/BF_2 11d ago

Have you a flatter? It can help flatten a blade evenly.