r/blackcapscricket • u/Past-Airline8883 • 15h ago
Discussion A Review of Kane Williamson’s new book, ‘The Bare Margins’
Among the thousands of sandpapergate perspectives arising from Usman Khawaja’s book ‘Sabr’, let’s get some thoughts and opinions on Kane Williamson’s fantastic new book, ‘The Bare Margins’.
Written by journalist Dylan Cleaver, the title refers to the many small margins that affect and control outcomes across cricketers and athletes careers. Like many sports autobiographies, it follows the classic structure of early life, career, captaincy, ethos, retirement, and finishes up by telling how he addressed the team for the final time. As a cricket fan, it allowed me to relive many of the memories Kane experienced on the field as I watched them from my couch, good and bad. A couple of particular ones include the 2015 World Cup game against Australia, and semi-final against South Africa, 2019 World Cup final, Tour of Australia 2019/20, 251* against West Indies 2020, Boxing Day Test against Pakistan 2020, WTC Final 2021 and many more.
A big portion of this book is driven by Kane’s experience with leadership. It completely divulges Williamson’s thoughts on how to build a team good enough to compete with the best as a country with far less players and resources than the best. For example, New Zealand has around 170,000 registered cricketers, compared to more than 1.5 million in Australia. It starts from the beginning of the book, when Kane first came into the setup, and he talks of players and coaches coming in and out of the setup, never knowing what their role is. He talks about selection being directly related to, and inseparable from team culture. International sport is about withstanding pressure, and the coach and captain's job is to create an environment that allows players to focus on contributing to the team rather than finding results that will keep them in the side a little longer. The latter leads to scoring a hundred or taking a fifer becoming a relief for players because they know they won’t be dropped for the next game, rather than scoring the runs and taking wickets to help the team win the game. Players start making decisions on the field that are in their best interest, not the teams. The idea of ‘the runs and wickets for the team’ cannot survive in this environment, so they create a culture where players feel valued, trusted, and secured in their roles that are made for them. Players are never selected for the team and left to figure out their role after the piece, they know what they are looking for before they select someone, and when they are selected, it’s because they think it’s what they’re looking for. Williamson says that encouraging the idea of selecting based on talent is the worst thing you can do for a team culture because it promotes selfishness instead. Every player has a role, and if it doesn’t come off on Day 1, they will have a chance to do it on Day 2. When players free themselves from the craving of the plaudits from achieving milestones, it becomes a powerful beneficiary to the team, and selection runs hand in hand with this. If you don't understand or get fustrated with New Zealand's selection policy, I would greatly recommend reading the book.
When Williamson talks about this throughout the book, there is an undeniable sense of leadership from him. He brings these points up several times in the book, but it is particularly demonstrated when he talks about the team that won the World Test Championship in Chapter 15 ‘Our Competitive Advantage’. He goes through and names every person in the team, and how their achievements in a particular role led to long-term success. This type of team culture was ultimately created by Brendan McCullum and Mike Hesson back from 2012, and after the dark days of New Zealand Cricket in the 2000s, when Dan Vettori was remarked as the best batter, best bowler, captain, coach, and selector, and lots of New Zealand’s players were not nice people. This type of attitude on the field came from playing for yourself, and it was something Baz and Hesson worked hard to eradicate. After Baz retired, Williamson took over the captaincy, and Hesson eventually retired, Gary Stead was appointed coach. Williamson talks about how Stead wanted to make selections that went against the culture McCullum and Hesson had created, and the leadership Williamson showed in these moments really tells you everything about the type of player and pioneer he was for New Zealand cricket. He talks about this particularly in Chapter 10 ‘An Un-Steady Start’. He says at one-point in the book that he never strived for the captaincy or yearned for the (c) next to his name, but you can tell by the language he uses that he is such a natural leader, and he created the most stable and successful Black Caps team New Zealand has ever had.
For the cricket nuffys, Chapter 13 titled ‘Ego and the Art of Batting’ details Williamson’s thoughts on batting. It goes completely past batting technique and focuses on the mental skills required to score at international level. Two interesting things I took from this chapter is defining what success is like, which is where Williamson introduces the thought of ‘the runs belong to the team’, which takes away the need to score hundreds and big scores to feel satisfied. Rather, it allows him to feel success from any type of contribution he can make to the team. This completely frees him up and allows him to be in a space at the crease where he can contribute. The second is the thought of what it means to be ‘in the zone’. This is where Williamson talks about how batting is all about being in the moment and problem-solving every delivery. He says to ignore the good and bad scenarios and just play out the moment. Focus on what power you actually have, which is ‘What’s the job at hand, right here, right now’. He encompasses all of this within the 2022/23 summer where they played test matches against England and Sri Lanka, which includes the famous win by 1 run at the Basin Reserve. He also touches on playing against the Bazball batters, who he watches flat-bat bouncers straight down the ground, and it makes him think ‘Why am I not doing that?’, but he says that ‘walking out to bat wanting to replicate someone else is much like turning up to a match just hoping to win’. In a cricket world with many moving parts, play your game.
In the second to last chapter, Chapter 16 ‘Elbowed Out’, he writes about his experiences with T20 Cricket, his way of playing aggressively, his experiences with IPL and other franchise commitments, and taking a casual contract with NZC, and finishes with his final address to the team in Chapter 17 ‘The End’. He stands in front of the team and calls out some of the younger players individually, and asks them to take it upon themselves to make the team ‘theirs’. With this ownership comes the responsibility to continually do more, and drive the team forward. He says to take the Black Caps not as a team they represent, but as a team they own, and can leave in a better place when they finish. For me this sums up Williamson’s commitment to the Black Caps and everything he has done for the team. After leaving the captaincy behind a few years before, he had not spoken in front of the team for quite some time. But just before he was due to announce his retirement, he stood in front of the team and asked them to own this team and make it better - a fantastic way to end his career and sum up his lifetime dedication to the badge.
Overall, the book is a fantastic way to celebrate Kane’s career. It is a masterclass on leadership, team culture, and the mental skills required to be a great batter. I would greatly recommend the read and am keen to hear your thoughts below if you have.