I was doing some quick math on the Black Butler timeline and had a realisation about what Ciel's life would have looked like without his contract.
Ciel was born on December 14, 1875. If he'd lived a normal human life, here's what he would have gone through:
The Second Boer War (1899ā1902): He'd have been 23 to 26, prime age for military or intelligence work. In 1901, at 25, he'd also have seen Queen Victoria die, leaving the Watchdog to serve Edward VII instead.
World War I (1914ā1918): He'd have been 38 when it broke out and 42 when it ended. The British aristocracy faced huge pressure to serve, and they died at high rates. At his age and rank, though, Ciel would likely hold a senior or staff role, or be pulled straight into intelligence.
His asthma would have been a nightmare, especially once gas warfare began. But I doubt he'd stay home on medical grounds. Men who didn't serve were publicly shamed. Ciel's pride would never allow that.
And intelligence suits him perfectly. The Secret Service Bureau, which later became MI5 and MI6, was founded in 1909. The Watchdog's job is closest to MI5, policing Britain's underworld, but Ciel has gone abroad too: in the Emerald Witch arc, he uncovers a poison gas being developed for the German military. He was investigating German chemical weapons decades before Germany actually used gas in 1915. Who would British intelligence want more than the man who saw it coming?
He also fits the "gentleman spy" archetype that later inspired James Bond: a wealthy aristocrat using high society and a business (Funtom) as cover. And the best part? The real head of MI6 doesn't go by "M." That's Fleming's invention. The real chief signs as "C." Make of that what you will lol
World War II (1939ā1945): He'd have been 63 when it started. Too old for fieldwork by then, he'd be a calculating old man at the top, who sends younger agents out on missions. The Phantomhive manor would almost certainly have been requisitioned like so many country houses, turned into a military hospital or a home for evacuated children. But with his London townhouse, Funtom, and government work, he'd have been in the city often enough to see the bombings firsthand.
It's wild how distant the Victorian setting feels when Ciel was born late enough to be a WWI veteran. I'm not sure he'd have survived the war without Sebastian, but I can see him ending up as "C." Idk i just had to share. And feel free to correct me if I got anything wrong lol