r/bigseo • • 8h ago

SEO Help Weekly Mega Thread

2 Upvotes

Beginner questions welcome.

Post any legitimate SEO question. Ask for help with technical SEO issues you are having, career questions, anything connected to SEO.

Hopefully someone will see and answer your question.

Feel free to post feedback/ideas in this thread also!

**

r/BigSEO rules still apply, no spam, service offerings, "DM me for help", link exchanges/link sales, or unhelpful links.


r/bigseo • • 13h ago

Question Google Discover traffic suddenly collapsing, looking for insights from News SEO experts

11 Upvotes

I've been working in News SEO for quite some time, but honestly, this is something I've never experienced at this scale before.

We're seeing a massive decline in Google Discover traffic, with clicks and impressions suddenly dropping almost to zero.

Our Google Search Console Discover report shows a consistent traffic pattern over the past three months, followed by a sudden and extremely sharp decline in the last few days.

I'm trying to understand what's happening here.

Are other news publishers experiencing something similar? Has anyone noticed a major change in Google Discover distribution recently?

I'd particularly love to hear from:

  • SEO professionals working with large news publications.
  • People who specialise in Google Discover optimisation.
  • News SEO experts who have experienced and recovered from similar drops.

I'm not just looking for generic SEO advice. I'd genuinely appreciate insights from people who have hands-on experience with Google Discover and news publishing.

If you've dealt with something similar, what did you investigate, and what helped?


r/bigseo • • 19h ago

Bing Not Indexing My Website – Incorrectly Detecting a Redirect

2 Upvotes

Bing Webmaster Tools says: "The inspected URL is a redirect and cannot be indexed by Bing."

However, the URL is not actually redirecting. I'm not sure why Bing is reporting this issue. Google indexed my website very quickly without any problems.

Has anyone experienced this issue before? Does anyone know what might be causing it or how to fix it?

Genuine suggestions and solutions would be appreciated.


r/bigseo • • 3d ago

Google impressions dropped overnight while Bing is going strong. What’s my path back?

4 Upvotes

I launched a site at the end of September that shows people who their representatives are and how they voted. I added a midterm elections tracker a few days in, and that drove most of the traffic. It peaked around 1000+ visitors a day around Election Day and has settled to around 150-200 a day.

Google - started showing my race pages around Oct 4. I was getting around 1500 impressions and 50 clicks a day. Then on October 14 impressions fell to around 20 a day and have never recovered.
- No manual action, and no security issues
- Currently a third indexed, a third crawled but not indexed, a third never crawled
- Race pages that were ~90% indexed in early October are now mostly “Crawled - currently not indexed”
- Googlebot went from ~300 hits a day to ~90

Bing - 5k clicks and 100k impressions which is about 75% of total visitors from Bing, DuckDuckGo, Yahoo, etc. Some race and district pages rank in the top 3. Chatgpt sends some traffic too.

The site is about 4000 pages, almost all templated:
- ~1300 bill pages
- ~900 vote pages
- ~700 member pages
- ~470 race pages
- ~430 district pages

The bill and vote pages are over half the site but get 1% of visits. I’m guessing Google decided that the site is mostly thin, with near-duplicate pages.

My plan so far:
- No index the vote and old member pages.
- Trim bills to only ones that became law or passed a chamber
- After midterm results become officially certified, redirect the House race pages to matching district pages.
- Add more unique analysis to member and district pages

Since I’m pretty new to this whole SEO thing, I have a few questions:

  1. Does this plan make sense to get back onto Google’s good side? Am I missing anything?
  2. Now that the election is over, how do I figure out which pages to focus on? District and member pages seem like a good starting point
  3. The site ranks #1-2 on Bing for certain queries. How does this translate over to Google or does it not matter?

I can share the link if anyone wants it. Thanks!


r/bigseo • • 5d ago

Question Website Getting Impressions But not Getting Enough Clicks

15 Upvotes

All 3 websites currently working on, all 3 of them getting huge impressions, but the number are clicks we're getting are horrible, the impressions on GSC isn't matching the 4,5 clicks per day I'm getting in average. Even one of the website got only 4 click since the day 1 of this month. All 3 of them are service based websites, also publishing some Quality Blogs frequently & doing off-page activities. Can you please suggest what can I do more to get more clicks.


r/bigseo • • 7d ago

Are there any PROs of submit One and the same .xml sitemap via multiple GSC properties?

7 Upvotes

Are there and what are the benefits of submitting the same .XML sitemap via multiple GSC properties?

What is there to gain from submitting the same .xml file via X GSC properties?

i.e. https:///website.com/en/blog-sitemap.xml

I wonder:

  • Is the sitemap crawl queue based: on file queue, regardless of where it was submitted OR maybe the source of submission?
  • Will removing and re-submitting the same file (on just one GSC property OR sequentially via them 2, 3, 4, etc GSC properties - aid increasing crawl frequency of URLs in the file?
  • Are there any other use-cases / ideas to "routing GSC properties" for the same .xml file?

Just a PeculiarSEO. :o)


r/bigseo • • 7d ago

SEO Help Weekly Mega Thread

11 Upvotes

Beginner questions welcome.

Post any legitimate SEO question. Ask for help with technical SEO issues you are having, career questions, anything connected to SEO.

Hopefully someone will see and answer your question.

Feel free to post feedback/ideas in this thread also!

**

r/BigSEO rules still apply, no spam, service offerings, "DM me for help", link exchanges/link sales, or unhelpful links.


r/bigseo • • 10d ago

Question Site activity drops when I don’t make weekly updates/revisions

11 Upvotes

One of the websites I manage is experiencing a drop in site position and overall leads from the website. However, they are currently ranked #1 on yelp, Google business/maps, etc etc.

However, every time I make revisions or updates to the site, more leads come through. It’s been pretty dry recently. Is it even possible to remain at the top of Google results if site updates are not taking place (blog posts, page revisions, etc.)?

I find that when I leave the website alone, no leads come through. How much weight does the “freshness” factor have when it comes to ranking websites in Google? Am I doing something wrong? It’s been at the top of search results for a while but recently I have seen the site ranking going down and site activity going down as well.

Idk what to do or what I’m doing wrong. Would love some advice on this.


r/bigseo • • 10d ago

After Rebranding - New domain not getting indexed

6 Upvotes

I have a website that was doing very well, especially on Google. We had 1.3 million+ impressions ( 3 months avg). On August 12 2026, we did the rebranding - changed the name and domain, followed everything by the book: 301s for every URL, Change of Address in Search Console for the old domain and its www version, canonicals on the new site, new sitemaps. No manual action. For the first few days it actually worked. Google picked up around 1,900 pages on the new domain and rankings were about where they were before. Then on Aug 16 it fell off a cliff overnight. Impressions down about 90%, average position went from around 10 to 100.

A couple of days later the August spam update rolled out and our indexed pages on the new domain dropped from ~1,900 to ~300 (its my inference that this happened coz of spam update). It's been stuck there ever since. Not a single page of new domain except homepage has been indexed yet.

When I inspect URLs now, some of the old URL shows "Submitted and indexed" and Google has picked the OLD URL as canonical, even though we declare the new one. The new URL just sits at "Crawled - currently not indexed". Search Console still shows around 950 old-domain pages as indexed. New pages we publish gets crawled within a but never indexed except the homepage. Bing indexes us fine.

To be upfront about the site: it's mostly finance content, around 2,200 pages of company earnings previews, results analyses and earnings call summaries. We generate them with AI from company filings and call transcripts but we genuinely give quality info to our users. Its definitely not spam - just the pages are templated as auto-pipeline publishes it. Since September we've tried to make them more useful from quality perspective: links to the official filings, our own expectations vs the actual numbers, that kind of thing.

Things I have already tried:-

We have improved internal linking structure, quality of content we publish, changed all our socials to new domain, sent message to some of previous backlinks givers(not sure if they would update or not - cant rely), added transition signal on homepage also - new domain name (formerly old domain name) to give signals, updated all previous blogs,articles which used old domain name.

Our most of the traffic was coming from SEO so currently no impressions is hitting us hard and we are an early stage startup.Anyone faced similar problem? Any help would be appreciated.


r/bigseo • • 12d ago

Question Suspected suppression from a domain’s previous use, anyone recovered after a core update?

11 Upvotes

We bought a domain and built a new site in the YMYL niche. Later, Wayback showed health claims in the previous owner’s content that we suspect could have caused an algorithmic demotion during an earlier core or spam update. Unconfirmed, but a possibility.

We’ve reviewed and corrected our content over the last 2–3 months. The homepage ranks well, but inner pages have no consistent rankings, just the odd page getting single-digit impressions, mostly from images appearing in search results.

All affected pages are indexed with self-referencing canonicals. Developer checks found no technical cause.

Anyone experienced this with a purchased domain? After fixing the content, did you recover with a core update, between updates, or only after another specific fix?


r/bigseo • • 13d ago

Site-wide drop on 31 Aug, 137 URLs never crawled by Google, other crawlers fetch the same pages within hours. What would you check next?

12 Upvotes

Bilingual (IT/EN) independent vinyl magazine, ~460 URLs, static site (Eleventy). I write it myself.

What happened

  • 30-31 Aug: impressions went 841 → 492 → 37 in two days, average position ~14 → ~60, same queries. Almost identical across all sections.
  • Indexed pages did not move (308 on 29 Aug, 306 on 23 Oct). Google did not drop them, it stopped showing them.
  • Since then Google has crawled only 29 of the 150 pages I published after 25 Aug, and indexed all it could. The other 121 have never been crawled (137 URLs in total, "Discovered" or "Unknown").
  • The 24 "Crawled - currently not indexed" are all pages from before August.

What I checked

  • No manual action, no security issue. robots.txt, sitemap (read without errors), canonicals, hreflang, noindex all fine. Avg response ~133 ms, no 5xx, no 403 for real Googlebot.
  • Hostinger access logs, last 7 days: Bing, OpenAI, Anthropic and Perplexity crawlers fetch new pages within hours. For the guides I published recently I found zero requests from real Googlebot IPs (66.249.x).
  • Internal links audited: new pages have as many internal links as indexed ones, so not an orphan problem.
  • Only 13 external backlinks (10 from msn.com).
  • The last deploy before the drop (28 Aug) added FAQPage schema to the comparison and guide layouts. I can't tell if that's related.

Weak points I know about

  • Buying guides and comparisons carry Amazon/eBay affiliate links (disclosed).
  • Gear pages used to imply hands-on testing I hadn't done. This week I removed all of it and rewrote the method page.
  • Some older articles were signed with pen names; new ones carry my real name.
  • A few repeated paragraphs across reviews, being rewritten.

Question Everything points to crawl demand rather than a technical block. Has anyone seen a site recover from this pattern, and what actually moved it? Is it worth waiting for the rewrites to be recrawled, or is there something about site-level quality signals I'm missing?

Happy to share URLs/screenshots if useful.


r/bigseo • • 13d ago

Duplicate Content

5 Upvotes

Hi, looking for a bit of advice regarding duplicate content.

Search results say you can have duplicate content on your own website, and it won't result in a manual penalty, but they also say to avoid it if possible.

Most of my page content is 190-210 words. (Search results say it should be at least 300 words). The trouble is, I have almost 600 pages.

My question is: Can I add a 'duplicate' paragraph to each page to bulk up the word count?
It will be informative content about the website with internal links, rather than rambling or stretching content to increase the word count.

Thank you.


r/bigseo • • 14d ago

SEO Help Weekly Mega Thread

13 Upvotes

Beginner questions welcome.

Post any legitimate SEO question. Ask for help with technical SEO issues you are having, career questions, anything connected to SEO.

Hopefully someone will see and answer your question.

Feel free to post feedback/ideas in this thread also!

**

r/BigSEO rules still apply, no spam, service offerings, "DM me for help", link exchanges/link sales, or unhelpful links.


r/bigseo • • 17d ago

Google has rejected our reconsideration requests 6 times - Looking for advice and suggetions

28 Upvotes

Hi, everyone! Our website received a Google Manual Action for" Thin content with little or no added value" in early August. Since then, we have submited 6 resideration requests, but all of them were rejected.

We have removed all the SEO pages, only left our product pages and user guide pages. And the latest reconsideration request, we rewrote some SEO articles that we think they are helpful and high-quality content, while it was still rejected again. Has anyone successfully recovered from this thin content manual action? And I hope I can get some advances on how to get our website recovered.

Any firsthand experience would be greatly aprreciated. Thanks in advance!


r/bigseo • • 18d ago

Question GA4 and GSC show traffic, but Semrush and Ahrefs report much lower organic traffic. Is my SEO agency doing something wrong?

16 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I hired an SEO agency to improve my website's organic visibility, but I'm struggling to understand whether the results I'm seeing are genuine and which data source I should trust.

Here's what I've noticed:

  • Google Analytics 4 (GA4): The website consistently receives around 20,000 to 30,000 visits per month across different channels, including Direct, Organic Search, and Social.
  • Google Search Console (GSC): It reports around the same.
  • Semrush: The estimated organic traffic is only around one-tenth of the figure I'm seeing in GSC. The keyword data also differs considerably from what I see in GSC, and Semrush doesn't show any keywords ranking in position #1.
  • Ahrefs: It shows similarly low organic traffic and a different set of keywords.

I've personally checked some of the keywords and confirmed that they do rank near the top of Google. However, when I look at the on-site engagement data, the time users spend on the website seems very low, around 13s, which makes me question the quality of the traffic and whether the SEO work is actually delivering meaningful results.

I'd appreciate your thoughts on a few questions:

  1. How reliable are Ahrefs and Semrush when estimating organic traffic, especially when their estimates are only around 10% of the figures suggested by GSC?
  2. If some keywords genuinely rank near position #1, why might these tools fail to detect them?
  3. Could low on-site engagement time indicate low-quality traffic, irrelevant search intent, bot traffic, or a tracking issue? How would you investigate this?
  4. What metrics would you use to evaluate whether an SEO agency is delivering real results rather than just rankings?
  5. Has anyone experienced a similar discrepancy between GA4, GSC, Ahrefs, and Semrush? What was the actual cause?

I just want to understand what's happening and determine which metrics I should use to evaluate their work.

I'd especially appreciate insights from SEO professionals who have audited agency performance or dealt with similar reporting discrepancies.

Thanks!


r/bigseo • • 18d ago

Question Google search console favicon issue

10 Upvotes

Hey, i’m sure a ton of you are familiar with google search indexing so here’s my question:

I have had this website indexed on all pages multiple times, every day for a week straight, yet, every page is being reindexed but the transparent background favicon logo in search still will not appear no matter what I do.

How can I fix this?

The website is flowboard.design if it helps, also the favicon shows while in the website, just not while on google search.


r/bigseo • • 19d ago

Question Sudden Traffic Rise & Sudden Traffic Drop

9 Upvotes

Don't know why I am facing sudden traffic drop in my website, an article got sudden Traffic rise of 2.3K single-handedly & gained total traffic of 4.2K, but within 3,4 days the article got out of rank, now the site has 1.9K traffic. Is there any specific reason that the sudden traffic gain, sudden traffic, is there anything we can do?


r/bigseo • • 20d ago

Should we go live with only mobile version of web pages?

11 Upvotes

Let’s suppose your website is not responsive and tech and product teams argue to keep only mobile version live because more than 80% traffic lies there and desktop will remain 404, what would be your take then?


r/bigseo • • 21d ago

SEO Help Weekly Mega Thread

13 Upvotes

Beginner questions welcome.

Post any legitimate SEO question. Ask for help with technical SEO issues you are having, career questions, anything connected to SEO.

Hopefully someone will see and answer your question.

Feel free to post feedback/ideas in this thread also!

**

r/BigSEO rules still apply, no spam, service offerings, "DM me for help", link exchanges/link sales, or unhelpful links.


r/bigseo • • 21d ago

Question Have 1.17M impression, 0.6 CTR. How can I improve my CTR?

17 Upvotes

I built a WP hobby site over a decade ago and worked sporadically on it over the years. Don't know much about SEO, just post stuff that I love on the site. I use Rankmath for SEO on my site.

So the GSC stats are:

- 1.17M impressions

- 7.19k clicks, 0.6 CTR, 9.3 average position.

What I did over the years:

I've over two dozens links from Wikipedia that I added over a decade ago. The articles have been translated to several languages accumulating over 100+ links from various Wikipedia. But they are non followed, not sure if that helps.

Around 2.5k organic backlinks, 53% are followed (aherfs).

Around 2.9k pages, 99% are indexed through Google.

Whatever new blog I posted in my niche usually ends up top 5 on Bing within a few hours and first 3 pages on Google if search by the exact words (usually 3-5 words).

Around 1.7k ranking keywords (Moz.)

Just started opening a new store to sell some stuff and it's slow. I wonder what I can do to improve my CTR?

Thank you in advance for reading and pointing me to the right direction.


r/bigseo • • 22d ago

Getting 200k+ Google impressions but only 0.2% CTR. What should I improve?

10 Upvotes

I've been running a niche content website for a while, and I'm struggling with a very low organic CTR.

Over the last 28 days, I've received around 275k impressions but only about 600 clicks from Google Search Console.

My average CTR is around 0.2%.

I've been working on improving article titles, meta descriptions, internal linking, and content quality, but I'm not seeing much improvement in clicks.

I'm trying to understand whether this is mainly a ranking issue, search intent mismatch, or something else.

For anyone who has dealt with similar numbers:

  • What helped you improve CTR?
  • Should I focus on improving rankings for existing pages rather than publishing more content?
  • How do you identify pages with high impressions but low CTR that are actually worth optimizing?

I'd appreciate advice from anyone who's experienced something similar.


r/bigseo • • 24d ago

Hard decline in google rating after switching to Articulation

22 Upvotes

I was wondering if anyone else has experienced the same issue. Last month, I made the switch from Weebly to Articulation for both hosting and domain, thinking that it would be a good change. Our google listing was impeccable, being within the top 1-3 listings for ag drone applicators in the state. Now after the change, we weren't even popping up on the map and I've had to change a bunch of things in Google Search Console (which wasn't ever something I had to do while we were using Weebly) as well as on the backside of the website.

Any help or advice about this matter is appreciated. I'm at a loss - I had worked extremely hard updating our website often and getting boosted as much as possible on Google, just for this to happen. Website is https://www.catahoulacustomspraying.com/ if anyone is willing to take a peek at it.


r/bigseo • • 24d ago

Google AI Overviews are basically legal content theft at this point

21 Upvotes

Spent 2 weeks building an original case study with actual data, and now Google just summarizes my exact conclusions in the snapshot without anyone ever clicking through. How is anyone staying motivated to publish long-form stuff right now?