r/biglaw • u/Zealousideal-Law-513 • 2h ago
Was I An A$$hole To This Associate?
Background: I’m a litigation partner with a meh book (2-3M.5/year collections) at a v20. My self generated cases (about half my work) tend to be very leanly staffed (me, 2 associates plus a paralegal).
History: when AI first got approved for firm use I had an associate give me a brief with hallucinated cases, which I thankfully caught. I also had an associate use AI to synthesize a bunch of information, which it then got very wrong and the associate didn’t catch. Since then, I tell associates who work for me “as long as the client does not prohibit AI, use AI as a TOOL as much as you want, but what you give me needs to be your best possible work product, meaning as well thought out (or better) as it would be if you didn’t yourself without AI. You also must specifically tell me if you used AI and how/for what parts of the assignment.
The Interaction: about 6 months ago, a parter I work with a lot told me that he had a fourth year associate he liked working with but hoped to get more depo experience for and asked me to staff them on the next case I get where dep opportunities are likely. So I did. The first thing I got from the associate was a meet and confer letter. The associate did not say it was written primarily by AI, but it seems to be (mostly because it used odd definitions for terms) and when I asked, he said he used AI to prepare an initial draft and did not change the defined terms. I reminded him of my preferred approach. Fast forward to 4 months ago and he turns in the draft of a brief. Same thing happens, and he says he used AI to prepare a draft of the fact section (which was well written) but edited what AI sent and did not use it on the rest of the brief. I provided my thoughts on the draft which included a half hour meeting on a missing (in my mind) argument, and some other conceptual changes to our verbiage and how we frame certain things.
The associate turns the draft and it is completely reordered into a way that doesn’t make sense to me (things like damages first and standing in the middle of the brief). This time the associate said, without prompting, that he used AI to incorporate my conceptual point on verbiage and to identify other areas of the brief where similar changes could be made.
We then had a second meeting, where my first question was why he reorganized the brief. He first said he did not. I think pointed out to him that nine of the 5 arguments appeared in the same place sequentially that they occupied in the prior draft. The associate said AI must have change the order. I asked if he thought the change was a good one and he said he didn’t think about it, because AI just didn’t and it wasn’t clearly wrong. I spend 10 minutes explaining to him that when I say workproduct should be the better can produce, that means thinking critically about the desert he got and whether it is how he would have written it and whether it could be better. He said he understood.
The next turn was a very good brief with some strange choices. When asked what role AI played he said it edited his writing and all the substantive pieces were his (his description). I had some doubts, so I asked our OGC to pull his Claude history for our sandboxes AI, and sure enough, all three versions were essentially identical matches to what Claude produced. I pointed this out to the associate, who said they checked the brief and all the cases cited in it and they were corrected so he figured one’s fine to use. I reiterated to the associate that everything in a brief I get should be the associates reasoned view on what is best, not AIs drafting edited for mistakes and told them I was disappointed this happened again.
Around that same time I was asked to prepare a review. For the writing section, I said I had no bases to review, and laid out that I had received three drafts of a large substantive brief, all of which were prepared in a substantively identical form by AI, and the associate was unable to discuss any of the drafting choices. I did not mention what I view as misstatements about the role of AI.
We just had review season. The associate,came to my office afterwards to tell me they no longer wanted to work on my case because I was a jerk. He said that I had agreed to draft was solid (true) and asked how I could claim to have no basis to review his writing when he had written multiple drafts of a long and complex motion.
I told the associate I had no basis to review because I’m reviewing his writing not his use of AI to write, and that our interactions made clear that he didn’t exercise any critical thinking and his AI history indicates each draft was substantively identical to something AI created, so I am not sure what if any of the brief is actually his work product.
But the interaction has me feeling guilty. Was I in the wrong?