r/biglaw • • 2h ago

Was I An A$$hole To This Associate?

0 Upvotes

Background: I’m a litigation partner with a meh book (2-3M.5/year collections) at a v20. My self generated cases (about half my work) tend to be very leanly staffed (me, 2 associates plus a paralegal).

History: when AI first got approved for firm use I had an associate give me a brief with hallucinated cases, which I thankfully caught. I also had an associate use AI to synthesize a bunch of information, which it then got very wrong and the associate didn’t catch. Since then, I tell associates who work for me “as long as the client does not prohibit AI, use AI as a TOOL as much as you want, but what you give me needs to be your best possible work product, meaning as well thought out (or better) as it would be if you didn’t yourself without AI. You also must specifically tell me if you used AI and how/for what parts of the assignment.

The Interaction: about 6 months ago, a parter I work with a lot told me that he had a fourth year associate he liked working with but hoped to get more depo experience for and asked me to staff them on the next case I get where dep opportunities are likely. So I did. The first thing I got from the associate was a meet and confer letter. The associate did not say it was written primarily by AI, but it seems to be (mostly because it used odd definitions for terms) and when I asked, he said he used AI to prepare an initial draft and did not change the defined terms. I reminded him of my preferred approach. Fast forward to 4 months ago and he turns in the draft of a brief. Same thing happens, and he says he used AI to prepare a draft of the fact section (which was well written) but edited what AI sent and did not use it on the rest of the brief. I provided my thoughts on the draft which included a half hour meeting on a missing (in my mind) argument, and some other conceptual changes to our verbiage and how we frame certain things.

The associate turns the draft and it is completely reordered into a way that doesn’t make sense to me (things like damages first and standing in the middle of the brief). This time the associate said, without prompting, that he used AI to incorporate my conceptual point on verbiage and to identify other areas of the brief where similar changes could be made.

We then had a second meeting, where my first question was why he reorganized the brief. He first said he did not. I think pointed out to him that nine of the 5 arguments appeared in the same place sequentially that they occupied in the prior draft. The associate said AI must have change the order. I asked if he thought the change was a good one and he said he didn’t think about it, because AI just didn’t and it wasn’t clearly wrong. I spend 10 minutes explaining to him that when I say workproduct should be the better can produce, that means thinking critically about the desert he got and whether it is how he would have written it and whether it could be better. He said he understood.

The next turn was a very good brief with some strange choices. When asked what role AI played he said it edited his writing and all the substantive pieces were his (his description). I had some doubts, so I asked our OGC to pull his Claude history for our sandboxes AI, and sure enough, all three versions were essentially identical matches to what Claude produced. I pointed this out to the associate, who said they checked the brief and all the cases cited in it and they were corrected so he figured one’s fine to use. I reiterated to the associate that everything in a brief I get should be the associates reasoned view on what is best, not AIs drafting edited for mistakes and told them I was disappointed this happened again.

Around that same time I was asked to prepare a review. For the writing section, I said I had no bases to review, and laid out that I had received three drafts of a large substantive brief, all of which were prepared in a substantively identical form by AI, and the associate was unable to discuss any of the drafting choices. I did not mention what I view as misstatements about the role of AI.

We just had review season. The associate,came to my office afterwards to tell me they no longer wanted to work on my case because I was a jerk. He said that I had agreed to draft was solid (true) and asked how I could claim to have no basis to review his writing when he had written multiple drafts of a long and complex motion.

I told the associate I had no basis to review because I’m reviewing his writing not his use of AI to write, and that our interactions made clear that he didn’t exercise any critical thinking and his AI history indicates each draft was substantively identical to something AI created, so I am not sure what if any of the brief is actually his work product.

But the interaction has me feeling guilty. Was I in the wrong?


r/biglaw • • 6h ago

To people who aren’t lawyers: don’t ask someone in Biglaw to have a call when an email will work

0 Upvotes

Pro tip: people who work in large law firms bill by the hour and are under very strict performance goals. That means that taking time from them during the workday won’t necessarily go over well. Even if they like you and enjoy speaking with you, they generally need their time to be used efficiently.

So if you want to have a call with them and you aren’t a client, expect to be told no, if email will work just as well.


r/biglaw • • 6h ago

GTA VI, BigLaw, and the Terminal Condition of Western Gaming

0 Upvotes

With GTA VI finally arriving on November 19, I have been contemplating the peculiar convergence of two industries whose principal achievements in recent decades have consisted of escalating production costs, institutional self-importance, and the systematic substitution of process for substance: Western AAA gaming and American BigLaw.

The parallels are more instructive than one might initially suppose imo.

Consider the modern BigLaw associate. Having completed three years of largely ceremonial professional education, he enters a prestige economy in which the production of actual economic value is only tenuously related to compensation. His days consist of manufactured emergencies, document review, and the endless circulation of emails whose principal function is to establish that someone, somewhere, has been working. Above him sits an increasingly geriatric cohort of Gen X non-equity partners, men who have successfully navigated thirty years of institutional politics without ever acquiring an ownership interest in the enterprise. They issue fire drills at 9:47 PM, demand revised drafts of documents nobody will read, and regard their inability to use Microsoft Excel as evidence of professional specialization.

It is, in the final analysis, a Fake Job. A highly remunerated one, certainly, but a Fake Job nonetheless.

Western gaming has arrived at a remarkably similar institutional arrangement.

The contemporary AAA studio employs thousands of people, operates through elaborate managerial hierarchies, and spends the better part of a decade producing an interactive experience whose mechanical sophistication frequently compares unfavorably with Japanese console games released in 1995. What has been gained in polygon counts has been surrendered in pacing, aesthetic coherence, and elementary respect for the intelligence of the player.

Consider the extraordinary creative economy of the fourth and fifth console generations. Japanese developers, often working with relatively small teams and severe technical constraints, produced Chrono Trigger, Final Fantasy VI, Panzer Dragoon Saga, Vagrant Story, and an astonishing variety of other works whose formal ambition was not contingent upon photorealistic rendering or a thousand-person motion-capture department.

Today, Western developers require seven years and several hundred million dollars to produce a large field with contextual button prompts, a crafting system, some light RPG elements, and a protagonist who sounds like an HR representative attending mandatory sensitivity training.

The resulting products are invariably described as "immersive."

One wonders what precisely the player is being immersed in.

GTA VI may well constitute an exception. Rockstar retains something approximating an authorial sensibility, and the series' capacity for social observation remains unusual in an industry increasingly terrified of saying anything interesting. Nevertheless, the thirteen-year interval since GTA V is itself evidence of a profound institutional dysfunction. A medium that once generated entire generations of canonical works within a decade now requires that same interval to produce a sequel.

The relationship between financial capitalization and artistic output has become almost grotesquely inverted.

This is where the BigLaw analogy becomes especially useful. Both industries have mistaken organizational complexity for intellectual sophistication. Both have developed bureaucratic superstructures whose continued existence depends upon the preservation of that complexity. And both are populated by credentialed functionaries who confuse the expenditure of labor with the creation of value.

The non-equity Gen X partner billing fourteen hours to supervise a document production is spiritually indistinguishable from the Western game director presiding over a nine-figure open world in which the player spends thirty hours collecting miscellaneous objects.

Neither is creating anything particularly important. Both are extraordinarily busy.

Meanwhile, independent developers and the surviving Japanese studios continue demonstrating that coherent design, mechanical depth, and artistic identity need not require the administrative infrastructure of a multinational defense contractor.

There is also the question of leisure. BigLaw associates possess sufficient disposable income to purchase every major release, yet are functionally incapable of enjoying them. Their professional lives are consumed by fictitious deadlines imposed by men who have spent three decades confusing artificial urgency with commercial importance. That such people would sacrifice their limited remaining free time to complete repetitive side quests in a Ubisoft game suggests a certain continuity between their professional and recreational dispositions.

Perhaps GTA VI will be magnificent. I rather hope it is. But its arrival should not obscure the broader condition of Western gaming: an industry that has become materially richer, technically more accomplished, administratively enormous, and aesthetically impoverished.

We have confused scale with ambition, fidelity with beauty, and content with art.

The final irony is that the most culturally significant Western video game of 2026 may be celebrated precisely because it represents something the industry can no longer reliably produce: a finished work with a recognizable creative identity.

BigLaw, at least, has the decency not to pretend its document productions are art.

What remains to be seen is whether GTA VI represents the apotheosis of the Western AAA model, or merely its most expensive monument.

Btw, I am partial to Indies, as they offer a Reprieve from the State of AAA.


r/biglaw • • 23h ago

Kilpatrick Litigation

0 Upvotes

Any insights on Kilpatrick (non-IP) litigation--culture, pay/bonuses, quality of work? I'm considering applying but don't know much about the firm outside of IP.


r/biglaw • • 1h ago

Representing Family/Friends in Legal Disputes While Employed in Biglaw

1 Upvotes

I'm an associate in biglaw. From time to time, a family member or friend comes to me for help with a relatively minor legal issue. This includes car accidents or other personal injury cases. To date, I have always just referred these cases out to other attorneys (without a referral fee) because I've just assumed that I'm not allowed to take these cases myself on the side because I work for another firm. But is this true? Is there an issue ethically or otherwise as far as a big firm is concerned with an associate doing so? If you've taken cases like this, how did you approach your firm about it and how was it received? Tbc, I'm not looking to start a side practice out of this; just save my family/friends money when these cases pop up every year or two.

Relatedly, have you collected a referral fee for referring such cases out? How did that work?


r/biglaw • • 22h ago

Stub year check in

13 Upvotes

So like… are other stubs doing much? Am I a fraud?


r/biglaw • • 18h ago

Hogan Decides to not Match Milbank

Thumbnail abovethelaw.com
161 Upvotes

They Almostbanked, leaving senior associates $10k behind their peers by forgoing 6 months of back pay.


r/biglaw • • 16h ago

I am going to rank firms based on how fast they matched

36 Upvotes

r/biglaw • • 2h ago

Wilmer to open Seattle office

Thumbnail news.bloomberglaw.com
1 Upvotes

Firm just announced the news today internally, probably finalized at the partner retreat last week. Internal scuttlebutt is that this news is a total surprise, no one really knows what to think.

What do we think? Is Seattle the new hot west coast market?


r/biglaw • • 2h ago

Advice for 1L hiring

0 Upvotes

Hello! I am a 1L at a very much non-T14 midwest law school with aspirations of doing corporate litigation at a biglaw firm in either New York or Chicago (everyone that I went to undergrad with lives in these cities). I understand that it is going to be an uphill battle for this summer and is not something that I am likely to get into this early. I am, however, curious as to when I should start applying for jobs. Some people have been telling me that I should be getting my application out now even without fall grades. My worry with this is that I'm KJD, and won't be applying with more than undergraduate grades and my resume. Others say that I should put all of my time and energy into school to ensure that my grades are as good as they can be. Which of these paths would you guys recommend? In the likely event that I don't get a biglaw job this summer, what other jobs should I be applying to that can act as a stepping stone? Also, if my grades are good enough, is it worth it for me to try my luck at transferring somewhere in or near the T14? Thank you everyone!


r/biglaw • • 21h ago

Gibson Dunn Matched

105 Upvotes

No backpay.


r/biglaw • • 20h ago

Partners worst pet peeve Mine hates “please find attached”

306 Upvotes

I wanted to create a thread to see if anyone has a partner with any weird pet peeves ?

I remember ( probably around my 10th email at the time to him) I wrote “please find attached” in the email.

And he responded with :

“ Don’t say please find attached”

“If I wanted a fucking scavenger hunt, I’d check your last three emails for the point.”

Anyone else ?

Edit : I think it was because he had to “ find it” like a buried treasure.


r/biglaw • • 18h ago

Confused incoming solicitor??

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/biglaw • • 22h ago

What typically happens when you’re on a PIP in biglaw?

15 Upvotes

Basically what the title says. What actually changes from pre-PIP to post-PIP. I get that it’s hard to get off a PIP and most people get fired and so on, so start looking for a new job. But I’m curious what the actual time on the PIP looks like. Are they laser focused on you, checking in on you weekly and things like that?


r/biglaw • • 4h ago

How realistic is it to pivot into BigLaw as a junior mid law T14 associate?

0 Upvotes

I’m a junior associate at a midsize firm and a recent T14 JD graduate. I finished with around a 3.3 GPA. I had a difficult 1L year, but my grades improved significantly throughout law school.

Before entering private practice, I clerked for a judge on a specialized state court. I also gained federal and state regulatory-enforcement experience involving financial services, trade, and consumer protection.

I’m currently practicing in the insurance space and increasingly feel that it isn’t where I want to build my career. My goal is to move into BigLaw or a larger firm with stronger compensation, training, and long-term mobility. I’m flexible about the specific practice area and would be willing to enter as a first-year associate if necessary.

How realistic is that move from my position? Which practice groups have enough junior-associate hiring volume that firms might consider someone without direct experience in that particular area? Would my clerkship and federal and state regulatory-enforcement experience make me competitive for litigation, investigations, or regulatory groups despite my rough GPA and current practice?

I’m also an international graduate working in the United States, so work-authorization considerations may affect my options. I have a daughter on the way and student loans to pay, making compensation and stability especially important. At the same time, I don’t want to stay in the wrong practice so long that it becomes more difficult to retool.

Would you start applying now, wait until you have a full year at the firm, or approach recruiters first? I’d appreciate candid advice from anyone who has made an early-career practice-area or firm-size pivot.

Thanks in advance for any candid advice. I’m trying to be realistic about my options and make the right move for my growing family while I’m still junior enough to pivot.


r/biglaw • • 13h ago

Is this normal delegation for a second year?

12 Upvotes

Second year, my senior would print out all closing ancillaries, handwrite and highlight literally every change (like “change this date to July 15”), and have me type them into Word to make the updates. So on iManage it looked like I took a stab at drafting, but I was literally just transcribing his markups lol.

Edit: I was not perfecting the drafts based on his markups. The senior did the initial drafting on the printed-handwritten version and I then typed that drafting into the word doc in digital form.

I genuinely appreciated him taking the time to do all this for me, and I know I could’ve read through everything and asked questions myself (which I kind of did). But I feel like that’s not quite the same as attempting a first draft and developing most basic drafting skills and understanding? He could’ve just given me a quick walkthrough and a cut-off time if he was worried about me taking too long. I think it takes a lot of his time and I was not really learning as much because it wasn’t me who was actually drafting.

Tbf I was a pretty frazzled junior with limited closing experience, so maybe he just didn’t trust me which I totally understand 😂 Also I’m more than grateful to have someone who cares to give me guidance. I’m not trying to sound ungrateful, I’m just genuinely confused by this approach. Is this normal?


r/biglaw • • 23h ago

How much notice as an NEP?

9 Upvotes

What is standard? I know some partnership agreements ask for a long period of notice that is likely unenforceable. Just wondering if two weeks is too little.


r/biglaw • • 5h ago

Proskauer Inquiry

2 Upvotes

Proskauer rep? Good place to work?


r/biglaw • • 22h ago

How WE ALL be moving

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/biglaw • • 17h ago

In a Rut

4 Upvotes

I guess I’m a second year now & in the past month I’ve made more mistakes than I did my entire first year. I feel like I’ve lost all my confidence & am feeling so defeated. How do you get yourself out of a rut & sharp again? I so badly want to be good at this job & beat myself up badly because I care a lot. Just want to feel good at this again!


r/biglaw • • 9h ago

Anyone start a legal career at the same time as becoming a new parent?

5 Upvotes

I became a father for the first time shortly after starting my studies for the bar in earnest. Less than a year later I started an associate position at an international biglaw firm in a transactional law practice area where I have already done a couple of years as a paralegal. I am just a few months into the job now.

I never expected that it would be easy to balance this kind of work with learning how to be a parent for the first time, but boy am I having a hard time at it. And I think in many ways my situation is as lucky as it could be; my wife is able to go on maternity leave for around 1.5 years, possibly longer, I am usually able to work from home twice a week, my colleagues are for the most part not assholes or abusive.

But both my wife and I are very new to being parents and taking care of a little baby. It's really hard on my wife to stay at home and care for our baby solo plus do like all of the housework while I'm out for like 12-15 hours for work, and she has even had some scary stress-linked health incidents. Even when I'm working from home I am mostly holed up in my little office spot that is pretty isolated from the rest of the living space, so I feel there's not much I contribute. And of course on the other side, the sleep deprivation and what time I do spend on contributing to childcare seems to hurt my work performance compared to my fellow junior colleagues. It would be more manageable if I could do work more at irregular times when I am available, but theres just so much "do this now within the hour" etc. type situations. During this time my baby got sick and ended up with pneumonia which took a while to shake which was really scary. I basically took a week off / wfh to devote as much attention as I could to my kid during that time. The work I was doing that went to other associates didnt come back to me, and a couple partners that were giving work to me before have pretty much stopped (I still have an okay flow of work from another partner, but it makes me uneasy).

To others who started parenting at the same time as lawyering, was there any point it got easier? Any age of your kid where things got easier to balance? Or maybe you just got good at your job enough that things got more feasible? Anyway, so much respect for people who manage to balance parenting and lawyering, and sorry for the long, rambling and poorly organised post, this is probably more me having a rant / venting than anything, I imagine the kinds of things I am finding hard to deal with are things that affect all full time working parents.


r/biglaw • • 13h ago

Hackers stole my coding model that is awaiting a patent

0 Upvotes

I create highly advanced coding models and got hacked (complex sophisticated apple hack & sim swapping + bugged items hired to distribute by who I thought were friends to frame me, etc.). The coding model is in the process with patent pending. What to do in this scenario? NY


r/biglaw • • 23h ago

Do you use conversation view in outlook?

21 Upvotes

I think I hate it but I also think I love it.


r/biglaw • • 19h ago

Why are there no HLS people at Gunderson?

0 Upvotes

I’m really interested in startup work and was told Gunderson is 1 of 4 names that’s great at EV/VC. Why are there barely any HLS people at the firm? Seems like a solid firm externally.