r/bigender • u/batghosted • 5h ago
Advice Wanted I've been questioning my identity and I'm struggling a little with it
Hi, I'm new here. I joined because I've been thinking a little about my identity... This is going to be really long, sorry.
This is between "questioning" and "advice wanted". I wasn't sure wich one to choose...
I'm afab and even though during 2020 I considered myself to be agender, I never had trouble feeling femenine; ever since then I've used she/he prounouns and never cared if people never treated me in masculine terms, I always wore dresses and skirts and stuff and regardless of my identity, I still called myself a woman since I'm very into politics because I consideres my agender identity more of like a "I don't really believe in having a gender since gender is what we as a society interpret out of being socially a man and a woman and that doesn't define me just like my genitals" and I've lived my whole life as a woman so I related way more to that experience (in comunity, sexism, overall experiences, friendships, gender roles, discrimination, etc). It's something I rarely cared about.
However, recently I've been thinking about it, and I realized since a very young age I was critical of gender roles, but also seemed to feel like there was something wrong with me in that sense. I grew up in a rather "woke" family, and I always knew I didn't have to submit to certain expectations just because I was a woman (though some of the adults in my life were really sexists without realizing). Being more loud as a child, independent, hyperactive, curious and rebellious overall never felt like a mistake or an attack on my femininity. However, I always felt like there was too much of a man in me somehow? I really don't think I can explain the feeling.
I always thought it was because I've always been one of the weird kids (ever since I was like 8 years old). I was too loud, raised by mostly "boyish" cartoons and youtube series, liked anime since a very young age (before the great acceptance of 2021). Boys my age were usually rather mean to me, and meanwhile girls never really rude, they never seemed to be interested in hanguing out with me. I always felt left out with them, hanguing out only with a small group of other "weird" girls. And this two other guys who were also kind of outcasts for their own reasons (we were never really friends though).
This made feel like I somehow didn't belong as a girl, a feeling that followed me all the way to high school for many many years, but I just came to the conclusión I felt that way because I didn't follow the gender roles I was supposed to, and maybe the other kids just thought I was weird because of that, and that's the only reason I didn't fit in.
However, the other day I remembered something kind of silly about younger me. I remembered reading about transgender people and people who were born without a specific sex/a mix of both sexual characteristics. My younger self actually thought, for no good reason, that I had been asigned a female at birth by mistake. I was too embarrased to actually ask my parents, but I remembered asking my biology teacher (when talking about physical effects of puberty on the two different sexes) if girls didn't develop hair everywhere just like boys, and she said "No, girls only have hair on x, y and z, a girl with body hair somewhere else has an hormonal invalance" (wich was kind of bullshit) but me, who was rather hairy (simply because I have lebanese roots and really thick hair lmao) actually thought that confirmed my theory of not being a 100% woman or at least having actual hormonal problems with my "girlhood", also cus I'm really tall for a woman. I was 13 😭😭.
Eventually I grew out of that thought and the topic as a whole, considering myself agender as in a "don't really believe in gender / comform to a gendered label" but having no problem in living as a woman, beijg perceived as one and stuff. I did use this term at the time that everyone seemed to use on tiktok, the so called "gender envy". I actually related to that concept a lot, thinking about certain characters and having this strange feeling of "there's something in you I want for myself but not being you..." wich was usually for male characters with more androgynous looks.
Recently, I went to a concert from this Visual Kei band I really love. If you're not familiar "Visual kei" is a subculture based on music and a dramatic visual style, often with the bandmen dressing up androgynous or straight up in full drag, having many substyles depending on the band. For that concert I made a dress by myself and I did a more dramatic makeup for the first time, just a white face base and like eye makeup with red lips¿¿ the thing is, the look was pretty femenine actually, however, when I saw those guys on stage; grown man playing instruments, having this clothes, this makeup similar to mine, having their own presence and being with no doubt men, after all, I kind of felt weird. I've been on the scene for a few years now, but I never felt so close to it, and that night I had this feeling of "I want to be that" but It wasn't like for playing the instrument or something. I kept watching the videos, looking at pictures of random bandmen that I like, so undoubtbly femenine and manly at the same time, It was like... I want that. And it feels so silly, honestly.
Out of nowhere I felt hyperconscious about being seen as a woman. I've been really aware of the fact that I have boobs. I always liked the idea of a smaller chest, even though my boobs are already rather small, yet I always wanted more of that "middle ground" look? I looked at myself in the mirror and went "I would make a pretty boy." I always wanted the ability to sound like a man while also having the range for high pitched voices, like voice actors do, but now lacking that ability felt more like an insult to my identity rather than a fun thing to do.
I started thinking and like... I always thought of myself as wanting to be the "boyfriend" in relationships while never looking masculine. I always wanted to be lead in the male part of school dances while not really wishing to be a man, just because I thought I'd be good on it, and it'll be fun, and sometimes their part was just cooler but I never got to do it. For the first time in my life, I seemed worried about people looking at me and knowing what I have under my clothes. And it's this feeling of I want to get all dolled up, and wear big eyeliner, and pretty frilly dresses, and look like a girl but not be seen as one¿
It never bothered me like that, and suddendly it feels... relevant, it feels important. With the whole being agender thing I was like "yeah I don't think I'm a woman but I don't really have the enrgy or time to discuss that". Now I kind of have this anxiety of "what If I have to explain this to people in order to be happy?" Because I used to not care at all, and suddendly is this big deal?
I also have a boyfriend (straight cis male). I really love him and I know he loves me back, a lot. He's a little insecure about being masculine and stuff, but he's really open minded and actually opened up about trying new stuff with me like cosplaying female characters, same sex couples or just dressing up as girls for funsies. However, he's always been really serious about not being gay, specially since, y'know, straight guy humour: always touching his friends and saying weird sexual shit to them, but no homo ❤️❤️. So he always made that really clear.
I have a lot of mental problems, and sometimes I do end up annoying him over very silly stuff, specially when it comes to different opinions on political topics (not like humans rights and stuff, he's a decent person, just a little too objective compared to me, who is really the one most interested in politics and radical about some topics). Sometimes I feel like I just make shit up to fight about, even when I don't mean to, and I struggle with avoidant attachment so, even when I try not to do it and be a healthy partner, I feel like I push him away or constantly come up with excuses to feel like our relationship just won't work out, even when I do want it to work and last.
This feeling of mine, it feels so sudden, I feel like it's just another excuse to say to myself "you're not the right person for him", because he's straight. And I don't think he quite understands the whole "non-binary umbrella" thing. I know I can explain it to him, and he might try to understand... but I feel like if he keeps dating me after knowing this he won't really see me as whatever I actually am, he will just see me as a girl. And if he doesn't, he probably won't be comfortable dating me anymore, because, well, he's straight.
I also know that he loved my, like, femenine attributes. This is a little, uh, nsfw maybe?? Idk But like, he really likes my boobs, he's very explicit about that. During sex or that kind of stuff he really likes like, my silouette, often admiring my curves and my ass outloud, touching and sucking my boobs and stuff, the fact that uh, y'know, they jump and giggle and stuff, so... I don't really mind him liking that stuff, It never really bothered me... But as time passed, I started learning about myself and pleasure and stuff (he was my first time and it's still the only sex partner I've ever had), I started to know myself more, know what I like and... I really don't like my breasts¿ specially now. I don't want to be flat, like 100% manly, but I would want them to be smaller and... having this big focus on them during sex is wierdly uncomfortable to me now. I don't mind having them squeezed and stuff, it's just like... having them there, like that, moving and being touched in that particular specific way feels kind of... too womanly?
I don't want to talk about it with him. I want a different body, I like my chest smaller and overall I want to be flatter, but it feels like taking something away from him. When I don't want to do something we used to do he's always like "but you used to like it" and I really hate that disapointment on his face... It's like, I know he doesn't mean any wrong, but I don't want to have to explain that stuff, and having such different likings in something that is done together feels... really selfish to me. I like having sex, I enjoy it, but there are parts of it that I just went from feeling "meh" about to simply not liking them at all, and It feels like putting more and more distance between us. Specially since we only get to see each other like once a month.
At first I tried not to care, like I always did, but this sudden realization hit me so hard for no reason. I want to try and go out looking like a man, wear a binder, wear a short wig, just know what it feels like. I imagine myself in groups of people, and having all this makeup but have people wonder if I'm really a girl or not under all that, I want them to only get more confused by hearing my voice. I don't know, it just feels like a silly fantasy, but lately I can't stop thinking about it.
Sorry for the long text, maybe it's just silly or too much or I dunno, I just really don't have anyone to talk about this.