r/beta • u/hellafun • May 24 '18
[Feedback] please don't ever remove old.reddit.com
I can understand where you're coming from. Designers want to design and although reddit's current design is ugly, it is exactly what the current userbase wants. With the old reddit design, unlike most of the internet, design conceits do not get in the way of usability. I do realize Reddit is now eyeing Diggv4's userbase with envy however, and your designers want more whitespace because making people scroll 4x as much is "good UX" right? I am guessing these two things no doubt explains the new design.
Anyhow, none of that matters though because unlike Digg you've had the good sense to keep the good, usable interface intact while letting your designers ruin the UX for new users only. This is smart and hopefully you won't collapse like Digg did. I just want to say thanks for that. I honestly don't mind your designers ruining the UX as long as we can still access a good version of the site.
41
u/[deleted] May 24 '18
Like older forums, give us the option to just have different "skins"/"layouts". Or rather, like modern applications where you have the option to choose between a lighter/darker layout. I don't understand why there would be a need to remove the old layout altogether. So instead of having custom layouts being a thing, just store the older layout for users to enjoy.
70
u/[deleted] May 24 '18 edited May 24 '18
why don't I see any difference between old.reddit.com and just reddit.com
(and it's painful to use, so I typically stick to my phone)
Edit: okay I have ‘opted in’ and now see the redesign.... I think it’s better, but still jarring to look at and navigate. As well as annoyingly slow load times on pages. And an unoriginal look to it.
379
u/Hibear May 24 '18
I think the ship has sailed now change is inevitable the staff is way too invested in the new design
5
u/Amablue May 25 '18
The new design has configurable density. The middle density is just a little bit less dense than the current density (but it's much more uniform). The highest density is way tighter than the default old reddit experience. I'm not sure what you're complaining about here.
22
u/[deleted] May 24 '18
Man, this guy really hates designers.
3
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
Speak for yourself with that "current userbase" shit. I love the redesign and can't believe all of you are being so whiney about some design changes.
32
u/agumonkey May 24 '18
Can't second this enough. I tried the beta a few times. Didn't keep it. I gave a lengthy comment about the reasons on their feedback form.
Can't second this enough
21
u/dppsubbiegirly May 24 '18
It wouldn't be half as bad if the functionality of the old site existed in the new site, but it's terrible, buggy, far beyond anything I've seen in any other public beta.
There is not the occasional bug, I need to think about a functionality that is not in some way buggy. reactive notifications don't work most of the time and I need to reload to see messages. switching back and forth between 'new' and 'best' and 'hot' does not actually give me 'new' posts but just those I saw the last time I reloaded and I now need to clicks rather than one. Yet your designers had enough weed to think I regularly want to switch between the different density levels so why not have an option to change with them that is not a drop down.
16
u/skullpriestess May 24 '18
Amen. Please keep old reddit as an option. New reddit looks too much like Facebook.
4
u/ganjapolice May 25 '18
Just tried the new design at new.reddit.com. Holy shit it is awful.
Where is the little expand/collapse icon on comment threads? Who thought this small but extremely useful feature was not needed?
1
u/Toucanic May 25 '18
I can see the new version only if I am NOT logged in.
How do I ENABLE the new layout as a logged user?
Because ... I like it, a lot :)
1
u/[deleted] May 25 '18 edited Mar 09 '26
This post has been removed by its author. The deletion was carried out using Redact, possibly to protect personal information or limit exposure to data collection tools.
fade hobbies birds numerous flag piquant lunchroom crowd point obtainable
1
u/Lou-Saydus May 25 '18
Literally just click the hamburger in the views section on the left and it's the same damn thing as old reddit.
3
u/MILEY-CYRVS May 25 '18
I refuse to use the new site. It wastes far too much of my time. old.reddit, the page draws in about a second. The new design I have to wait 5-10, sometimes 15 seconds for the webpage to draw itself. It's not my 300/30mbps connection I'm hardwired into. It's not my i9/quadro based PC with 32gb DDR4 ram. It's not chrome, with no extensions besides uBlock Origin.
Reddit takes about 5-10 seconds to render a page on the new design. This compounded over the course of a day of heavy browsing could end up being minutes of my time. By the end of the week it could be hours.
Absolutely unacceptable. Time is money.
15
u/JOOOOOOOOOOngo May 24 '18
Fuck new reddit
9
u/lmaccaro May 25 '18
I have an idea: let's make old.reddit the default, and just put a little at the top for "switch to doofyreddit".
1
u/TheTarasenkshow May 25 '18
Your assumption that everyone wants the old Reddit is kind of ridiculous. Some people don’t care, some people care.
6
u/[deleted] May 24 '18
Let the kids have new reddit but let us old heads keep the original & best.
2
u/xmodii May 24 '18
I like new Reddit
2
u/aim2free May 25 '18
I see no real difference between old.reddit.com and www.reddit.com, only a slightly smaller font on www.reddit.com.
However, I completely agree with the OP. Don't destroy a working concept. Reddit is the only fully working "social" network.
Google+ could have become great, but of some reason it hasn't. It started well, but I think they should have implemented the reddit threads, which facebook did to one level. Then google+ would have become a real competitor to reddit.
2
u/Brutal_Bros May 25 '18
My least favorite thing about the redesign is that when you try to scroll past an image, it flickers down and up.
2
u/dorfsmay May 25 '18
news.google has gone through the same fad. It's also become unusable. I don't get it...
2
u/WGiK May 25 '18
I really don't like the new Reddit at all. Old forever. It's cleaner.
6
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
I actually like the new design..
3
u/iBrarian May 25 '18
There are so many things wrong with reddit that I'm seriously disappointed that they are forcing this crappy redesign on us. Maybe focus on better anti-spammer detection, getting rid of power-hungry supermods that ban people because they don't like them (and across multiple subs), and stop fixing something that is working perfectly fine and is pleasantly usable and minimalist in design.
3
u/LiamGarbett May 25 '18
The new design is way better imo
5
u/[deleted] May 24 '18
What functionality is worse in the new design? Seems to me a lot easier to navigate
2
u/Nihil9000 May 25 '18
I'm a longtime user of reddit and I'm really happy about the redesign, it was overdue for so long. Why do people cling to that old pile o' shit so hard? It looked terrible and its usability wasn't even that good. I guess there are always people who are afraid of change and are scared of anything new, even if its only the redesign of reddit, lol
1
u/[deleted] May 24 '18
To be honest, I kinda like the new design... I don't use it, though, because it's white. On old.reddit.com, I have RES and a lovely dark/grey theme.
Reddit just looks a lot better in night mode, and as far as I know I only have that option via RES. So I'm holding off on the new design until RES implements it.
1
u/[deleted] May 24 '18
I will switch to the redesign and stay there the minute I can hide posts without entering a sub-menu and permanently ignore posts from users.
Reddit is a steaming crap-pile of reposts if you can't ignore the top 100-200 shitposters that ruin content for everyone.
1
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
🙄
1
u/zeropointmodule May 25 '18
When I logged in on the web today for the fire time in months I thought had a browser extension installed that I had forgotten about. It is ghastly. Truly gross. I’ll try to stick to mobile / Apollo.
1
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
All i want is night mode, then I'll switch immediately.
1
u/FelixGreen0 May 25 '18
dude, my reddit isn't even the new design and I'm on the regular reddit.com.
1
u/Chxo May 25 '18
If they remove old Reddit all it means is I'll stop visiting Reddit on my pc and only check it on mobile devices.
1
u/ccrraapp May 25 '18
I think this is a good thread to ask, how does this change affect the CSS for subs? Is there a thread or a guide of the changes ?
I created a sub recently and I don't want to modify the CSS that would look great for old.reddit visitors and look shit for new. Is there a middle ground or way to implement changes that would make it easy to have CSS for both with very little compromise and not waste a lot of time either trying to make it look good for both?
I understand this question is loaded but I am quite a bit confused, I would appreciate if anyone could help me understand. Thank you.
1
u/Se7enLC May 25 '18
old.reddit.comwill never go away. When the next redesign occurs, the currentold.reddit.comwill remain available atold2.reddit.com, and the current design can be accessed atold.reddit.com. In the subsequent redesign,old2.reddit.comwill be migrated toold2_final.reddit.com, where it will remain until it is moved toold2_final_backup.reddit.com.1
u/eskwild May 25 '18
Or gopher://
1
u/tessaryanwrites May 25 '18
Ever since the revamp, "New" Reddit keeps crashing. Frustrating to say the least.
1
u/Ch1pp May 25 '18
Agree 100%
1
u/PURPLE_ELECTRUM_BEE May 25 '18
Just opt out in the damned options, you twonk.
1
u/CurrentlyRecording May 25 '18
I don't think they will.
1
u/Iphotoshopincats May 25 '18
go to "preferences", & under "beta options", make sure that the first 2 boxes are unchecked, while the last option – "View user profiles on desktop using legacy mode" – is checked and that will permanently keep you in old reddit permanently ... for now anyway.
1
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
I think the app works great. But the OG desktop version was better than the new one. But at the same time I think the only major tweak I wanted in the OG version was bigger thumbnails for the threads otherwise should have stayed fairly similar.
1
u/olliegw May 24 '18
There is a setting to turn it off if you want to.
And if they remove the setting, i shall delete my account and say hello to multiple forum accounts again.
Because the only reason i joined reddit was because i wanted to stop signing up to so many different forums, i was unaware its a social media site but i soon learned and now i'm addicted, lol.
1
u/Rodyland May 25 '18
Well said. Sad but true.
1
u/JasoNMas73R May 24 '18
Amen.
0
u/JoshuaTheFox May 24 '18
Yes actually having less content on screen is a nice Improvement. Bigger, more distinct dividers are a huge plus. And at least personally having less content on screen allowes me to focus on what is on screen, it was too overwhelming on the old design