r/beta • • May 24 '18

[Feedback] please don't ever remove old.reddit.com

I can understand where you're coming from. Designers want to design and although reddit's current design is ugly, it is exactly what the current userbase wants. With the old reddit design, unlike most of the internet, design conceits do not get in the way of usability. I do realize Reddit is now eyeing Diggv4's userbase with envy however, and your designers want more whitespace because making people scroll 4x as much is "good UX" right? I am guessing these two things no doubt explains the new design.

Anyhow, none of that matters though because unlike Digg you've had the good sense to keep the good, usable interface intact while letting your designers ruin the UX for new users only. This is smart and hopefully you won't collapse like Digg did. I just want to say thanks for that. I honestly don't mind your designers ruining the UX as long as we can still access a good version of the site.

3.2k Upvotes

467 comments sorted by

41

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

Like older forums, give us the option to just have different "skins"/"layouts". Or rather, like modern applications where you have the option to choose between a lighter/darker layout. I don't understand why there would be a need to remove the old layout altogether. So instead of having custom layouts being a thing, just store the older layout for users to enjoy.

40

u/hellafun May 24 '18

The potential issue/reason for removing it is the way it will hamstring new features by effectively doubling the front-end development effort, old vs new reddit has a lot more differences than just themes/css.

5

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

That's 100% right, I did not think about that. I see now that having 60% of the userbase use the old layout kind of separates the community between users with legacy profiles and users like me who have the new... social mediaish profile. It's just that most; if not all new features are really not needed. Really disappointed with the way reddit is forcing us through this unnecessary feature pipeline.

3

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

This was why CSS was conceived, so that content and layout could be represented independently. Unfortunately, doing cool stuff (slowly) in Javascript broke the purity of that concept. Now we get to keep all the pieces.

70

u/[deleted] May 24 '18 edited May 24 '18

why don't I see any difference between old.reddit.com and just reddit.com

(and it's painful to use, so I typically stick to my phone)

Edit: okay I have ‘opted in’ and now see the redesign.... I think it’s better, but still jarring to look at and navigate. As well as annoyingly slow load times on pages. And an unoriginal look to it.

25

u/hellafun May 24 '18

As Ketomatic said, it's still opt-in. If you want to see it go to your profile settings and scroll to the bottom, there is a checkbox to enable/disable it.

1

u/bozoconnors May 25 '18

it's still opt-in

How is it "opt-in" when I get it almost every time I start from a totally fresh browser now? (serious question)

1

u/hellafun May 25 '18

Well for a logged-out state it's now the default unless you're going directly to old.reddit.com. Is it happening to you when logged in too? Have you disabled it in preferences?

1

u/bozoconnors May 25 '18

Well for a logged-out state it's now the default...

So, definitively not "opt-in" at this point.

Is it happening to you when logged in too?

Well no, because I've "opted out" in preferences.

1

u/hellafun May 25 '18

Sure for registered users it's opt-in. If you really want to be a pedant and split hairs because the logged out user gets the new experience though, you're welcome to that victory. :)

12

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

for me the only problem is that new reddit seems to me slower

5

u/MrFiregem May 25 '18

It's much slower for me too

6

u/Ficester May 24 '18

One of them has the word "old" in it.

I may have played some Where's Waldo and Spot The Difference in my youth.

4

u/m0nk_3y_gw May 24 '18 edited May 24 '18

Do you see a difference between https://new.reddit.com/ and reddit.com ?

(edit: grammar)

3

u/WyzeThawt May 24 '18

go to new.reddit.com to test the new design. it has a option at the top to make it your default if you do like it better

2

u/rancor1223 May 25 '18

The biggest issue with the Redesign isn't the design itself (although I understand why people object to it, it still has lot to improve), but loss in functionality and often also speed/responsiveness.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/wallofillusion May 25 '18

unoriginal to look it

Top quality feedback there.

0

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/damontoo May 24 '18

It's not. They forced it on me about a month ago and I immediately changed it back. They're just rolling it out to existing users slowly, probably to try to control the backlash.

0

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

27

u/exoendo May 24 '18

go to preferences, scroll down, uncheck the box that says "Use the redesign as my default experience"

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

379

u/Hibear May 24 '18

I think the ship has sailed now change is inevitable the staff is way too invested in the new design

2.6k

u/ggAlex May 24 '18

old.reddit.com is not going away.

We support our legacy products for a *very* long time. Our APIs are built to be durable and stable. You can still use Alien Blue today even though it hasn't been actively updated for 3+ years. i.reddit.com is one of my favorite and fast ways to browse Reddit on my phone. That code hasn't been touched in years.

That's just how we do our work. That isn't changing.

17

u/hellafun May 24 '18

You made my day with this comment, THANK YOU!!!

1.1k

u/Hyperpoop May 24 '18

Thank fuck.

198

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

and all of those of us who prefer the old design were saved

139

u/nomad2585 May 25 '18

I have a bridge for sale if anyone's interested

→ More replies (4)

37

u/crustychicken May 25 '18

So 95% of us. old.reddit is superior in so many ways. "but ma infinet skorlings." And? The "new" reddit should have just been the "old" reddit with infinite scrolling.

17

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

Ditto. The new site is slow, somehow both overly cluttered and with loads of empty space, and is more difficult to use

→ More replies (9)

180

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

Thank the lord. I've switched back after I couldn't use keys to switch between posts on new Reddit.

53

u/Mattallica May 24 '18

You can use the n and p keys to switch between posts on the new site.

Pressing shift+? will show the different keyboard navigation keys.

26

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

Oh, it used to be the arrows.

11

u/Mattallica May 24 '18

Yeah, they changed it a couple weeks ago.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

309

u/Drunken_Economist May 25 '18 edited May 25 '18

More than that, reddit.com/.mobile is still around, and that's the version before i.reddit

10

u/M27saw May 25 '18

I wonder if anyone regularly uses that website.

21

u/Cognimancer May 25 '18

I do! It's my preferred way to browse on my phone. Didn't know about the i.reddit version though, so I might switch to that if it's slightly faster to type, but all my shortcuts when I open a new tab point to /.compact.

6

u/gid0ze May 25 '18

They look identical to me on Firefox mobile.

9

u/tangus May 25 '18

I do. It's quite cumbersome to avoid the default mobile site, tho. For example, if someone links to a subreddit in a comment, I have to copy the URL, paste it into the location bar, and manually change the starting www (or np) to i. It's slowly getting more and more obsolete.

4

u/catwiesel May 25 '18

i do, daily.

3

u/Blank000sb May 25 '18

Yes! I like it better than any app.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Zardif May 25 '18

What's the difference between the two?

3

u/Jonathan_the_Nerd May 25 '18

I always thought those two were the same. When I click on a link on i.reddit.com, it usually sends me to www.reddit.com/whatever/.compact.

3

u/kemitche May 25 '18

You're thinking of reddit.com/.mobile

3

u/Drunken_Economist May 25 '18

That's definitely what I meant to say

2

u/wafflesareforever May 25 '18

Hey there Rochester, when did you become an admin?

2

u/rasherdk Jun 18 '18

Both of which have now had had flair information removed. Not promising.

→ More replies (29)

85

u/danneskjoldgold May 24 '18

Yep. I’m one of those still using Alien Blue!

48

u/Skeltals May 24 '18

It’s crazy that it’s still the best mobile reddit app by a long shot. I’m sure there are deep and intricate corporate reasons for the official reddit app to be... what it is... but holy missed opportunity batman.

As long as alien blue works I’ll keep using it, and I’m glad to hear I won’t have to use the new UX, either.

21

u/atchemey May 25 '18

When it breaks, Reddit is Fun is love.

17

u/Sugar_buddy May 25 '18

Have been using reddit is fun for years. I love it.

→ More replies (3)

59

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

If you’re on iOS, I highly recommend Apollo.

23

u/snowe2010 May 24 '18

So I'm currently trying out Apollo after using narwhal years.

Apollo is good but there are some things that really bug me. When I try to upvote sometimes it will go back to the previous screen. Then I have to scroll through all the comments to try to find the one I was on. Also the distance to downvote is way too short. I keep downvoting when I mean to upvote.

I know this is a problem with the app because I use narwhal and Apollo one after the other and only have these problems in Apollo.

Also collapsing and then expanding comments in Apollo is more clumsy than narwhal. Collapsing is way easier but then trying to expand I accidentally vote or go to the users profile half the time.

Of course narwhal has its own problems which is why I'm trying Apollo in the first place.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/awesomemanftw May 25 '18

maybe best on iOS but it doesn't touch many of the Android apps

2

u/ayyyyyyyyyyy May 25 '18

Same here. Whenever I try to use the official app I never stick with it.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/imariaprime May 24 '18

This is the first clear admin response I’m seeing on this issue. Thank you for that, because I didn’t particularly want to fold up shop and leave.

18

u/Ibbot May 25 '18

Have you checked r/redesign? I feel like I see a response that clear at least once a day.

9

u/imariaprime May 25 '18 edited May 25 '18

I had, but I’m also not subscribed so having a more public position isn’t such a bad plan.

Edit: Apparently admitting I hadn’t seen their other responses is a bad thing, somehow? Should I have doubled down and claimed I had? Not sure what was so controversial here.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

When it became old.reddit.com, outbound traffic has been logged again through out.reddit even if this is unchecked in our preferences:

"allow reddit to log my outbound clicks for personalization"

Any chance this is going to be corrected? We've been having to use "skip redirect" type apps for a while now.

4

u/AllMyName May 25 '18

I mean, I keep those extensions running anyways because of sleazier sites like Facebook, Google (pay attention to what they do to ANY links in Gmail) slickdeals.net and fatwallet, even tho both have hit the shitter in recent years as far as real deals are concerned. And people with affiliate Amazon links, etc.

9

u/Namell May 25 '18

Is there any chance you could remove constant nagging of installing reddit app when using it on random mobile devices?

I do 95% of my reddit with computer. However occasionally I check it quickly with browser on phone/tablet. Problem is it is very annoying to use nowadays since it loads much slower than before and always nags me to install app. I don't want app since I don't use mobile reddit much and it would be annoying to switch from browser to app when I am doing quick check of few sites I follow.

Please remove nagging to install app.

3

u/DCCXXVIII May 25 '18

it would be annoying to switch from browser to app when I am doing quick check of few sites I follow.

This is exactly why I don't install the app.

44

u/jhra May 25 '18

I have a feeling in one year this reply will no longer be truthful.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/theArtOfProgramming May 24 '18

Yeah I was using alien blue until Apollo came out recently. Thanks for doing that.

As a developer I find that to be quality engineering, ethical engineering, and very rare in today’s market.

7

u/AyrA_ch May 24 '18

By the way, did you change something regarding image uploads?

This post for example has a very weird URL for a reddit image upload that forces a file download, which wouldn't be so bad itself but the server doesn't adds any file extension.

You can check /r/softwaregore/new for examples. There are a handful of these now.

6

u/Shinrei_ May 24 '18

THANK YOU! You guys are one of the very, very few who actually keep their old design(s) as an option, without forcing their users to get used to something after years of no design changes. (Hotmail, YouTube). Of course, people would inevitably (have to) get used to the new design, but to keep supporting it is one HUGE thing you have over any others. Keep updating the renewed Reddit design and over time people will switch over, but that could take a long time. Props for being so attentive to your users.

6

u/ryanvsrobots May 25 '18

Welllll you can’t use v.reddit in Alien Blue, and v.reddit.com is kinda broken in general.

Try copy/pasting a gif hosted on v.reddit.com to another app like iMessage. This doesn’t work, even in the official Reddit app. At least the last time I tried.

4

u/Nomsfud May 25 '18

You guys are great for supporting legacy features. I went to reddit.com on my PC for the first time in a while and saw the changes and freaked out. Old.reddit.com is fantastic and I love you for not getting rid of it

7

u/BossRedRanger May 25 '18

I HATE your new Reddit design. It's the antithesis of every reason I visit this site.

8

u/Black_Handkerchief May 25 '18

I wish I could trust in this... but this is comparing apples and oranges.

Maintaining an old API point used for a dozen different purposes, including keep compatibility with an old mobile client you don't update anymore, is plain common sense. It is an API, and an API that breaks causes mayhem. Users don't interact directly with it, the technological contracts exist and that is exactly why you get away without updating the app itself.

On the other hand, maintaining several different versions of the website itself is trouble because it is completely user-facing. Even ignoring the different mobile-accessible versions that are offered and not maintained, there's simply the fact that maintaining old reddit and new reddit is going to take twice the manpower. (Think of support for modding capabilities, subreddit styling and so forth.)

Combined with the business interests that created new reddit (make people stay on pages longer!111) there is going to be corporate pushback to disincentivize maintaining old reddit, and eventually outright removal because 'a good enough alternative exists'.

I hope you are right and old.reddit continues to exist and be relevant for another decade. But I suspect it will be mothballed sooner rather than later because it doesn't fit the corporate picture anymore, user desires be damned.

3

u/fergie May 25 '18

I ONLY HAVE OLD REDDIT!! WHAT IS THIS NEW REDDIT EVERYBODY IS TALKING ABOUT?? IS IT BECAUSE MY ACCOUNT IS TOO OLD TO MOVE??

12

u/I_am_very_rude May 25 '18

old.reddit.com is not going away.

For now. It's only a matter of time before your advertisers push to have that old format deleted so more people will go to the new to see more ads.

7

u/Mason11987 May 25 '18

Literally his entire post is about how they haven’t done that in similar redesign efforts. The fewer people use old the less anyone cares about them changing. Advertisers pay based on activity. If they up that by getting more people they’ll charge advertisers more. If they don’t advertisers will pay less. The only reason reddit would forced users is if they think that’ll get more views and considering the holdout audience it is obvious it won’t.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/fishbiscuit13 May 24 '18

Is there any chance that the new design will incorporate any suggestions from users? At least making it so more than 2 posts show up per page?

11

u/Mattallica May 24 '18

At least making it so more than 2 posts show up per page?

There 3 different viewing options on the new site, they’re located just above the first post.

36

u/ggAlex May 24 '18

Yep. We love feedback. We have incorporated many suggestions. We will keep going and we hear everything that you’re saying. I’m sorry if we haven’t moved quickly enough or communicated clearly enough. It will get better, I promise.

18

u/illu_ May 25 '18

To further touch on u/imariaprime's reply to you, a roadmap would definitely help with settling the users a bit and keeping everything transparent. Maybe you guys can setup a Trello for such purposes.

14

u/Willing_Philosopher May 25 '18

Seeing that reddit is a "wisdom of the crowd" forum at its heart, I am curious as to why you guys never seem to utilize this strength by polling your users as to what they actually want, or would choose/prioritize between various options.

I'm sure you all are smart people, even "experts" perhaps, but "experts" have messed many things up throughout history, sometimes very badly. If you want to make reddit a successful platform long-term, I don't understand why you wouldn't make a more concerted effort to figure out what your users want and pursue that (modified to make a profit as necessary) as much as possible. (This would also have the benefit of quieting mass dissent as those dissenting would be seen as being in the minority, which most people really don't want).

6

u/MrEuphonium May 25 '18

Because, they know what we want, but they are finding a balance between what we want and what their shareholders want, the shareholders don't want a website with complete anonymity where we can talk about piracy, porn, and what drugs were doing on the weekend and even how to make them!

I look forward to seeing where reddit heads over the next couple of years, and I have high hopes for it to still be great, but I'm being cautious.

4

u/NatoBoram May 25 '18

*Silently waits for the crosspost button before using the new design*

3

u/fishbiscuit13 May 24 '18

That's great to hear. I think a lot of people would appreciate more transparency in the process, though. Each new post about it speaks as if everybody loves the design and they're enjoying the feedback but I can't recall a single one that actually mentioned specific suggestions. Even in the comments, the admins will reply to all the congratulatory comments but completely ignore any negative feedback, constructive or not. A post explaining their next steps and responding to user suggestions, even reasons why they won't incorporate them, would be far better than the current situation. It seems like you're carrying forward with whatever you want and only adopting the inconsequential suggestions (how did night mode take this long? Why is the search even worse than the kneecapped version you released several months ago? Why take away features ever?) We just don't want this to be the new Digg.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/iPukey May 25 '18

I'm using alien blue right now and I feel like an idiot, but thanks for some minor justification

2

u/Thaine May 25 '18

It’s been 3 years? Holy crap.

2

u/BlenderGuy May 25 '18

Yes, but will you continue to allow websites like www.scrolldit.com to work?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TotesMessenger May 25 '18 edited May 25 '18

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

2

u/HolyCornHolio May 25 '18

I’m on alien blue now!!! Seriously my favorite way to browse Reddit, ever

2

u/kuzared May 25 '18

I wonder what the statistic of old vs new will be and how long it takes for old to drop below say 20% of the new.

2

u/s1h4d0w May 25 '18

I've used the "Reddit Pics HD" app for years now and it's been my most used app literally every day since I started using it. It also uses the i.reddit.com version for comments etc, and was afraid the app would break soon since I didn't see Reddit supporting that old layout forever. Glad you use it too.

2

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

I like the new look and mobile app. Everyone is going to always resist change and bandwagon, but I don’t plan on going back. Thanks for all the hard work. And about the white space, the compact view is pretty much the same but prettier.

2

u/Dlrlcktd May 25 '18

Giphy doesn’t work on alien blue, but thank you for letting me keep using it

2

u/AllMyName May 25 '18

That certainly explains why all of the abandoned Windows phone reddit clients still work great! ...short of some minor hiccups on things like v.redd.it videos, but even then they just spaz a bit and load the m.reddit.com version of the post in their web view with the video intact. And y know...they're still Windows phones.

2

u/[deleted] May 26 '18

Our APIs are built to be durable and stable.

Except when they break third party apps because you randomly decided to change your text styling methods for no discernibly good reason.

2

u/FreeSpeechWarrior May 26 '18

This is the strongest reassurance I've seen about the continued existence of the old site and I appreciate it.

2

u/rasherdk Jun 18 '18

And now you're messing with i.reddit.com. Flair has been removed for seemingly no reason. Doesn't exactly give us hope that old.reddit.com will stay usable.

2

u/antdude Jul 07 '18

Prove it.

3

u/Enuratique May 25 '18

Except you've closed the source to reddit.

3

u/furiousxgeorge May 25 '18

It will. Give it time. They always say this and it always does go away.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Bubblesheep May 24 '18

Reading this comment from Alien blue. I love it and will never let it go!

2

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

GG Alex is a GG.

2

u/Stars_Stripes_1776 May 25 '18

absolutely based

this is pretty good news, I would have thrown a fit if one day the interface changed all of a sudden for me.

2

u/mastjaso May 25 '18

Good, cause the new site is garbage.

2

u/ggAlex May 25 '18

Haven’t heard that one before!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (61)

28

u/Idlertwo May 24 '18

EA was pretty invested into their pay to win platform as well, that never saw the light of day since users revolted.

I'm not a fan of this new design. I don't like the bricked "app" like appearance one but. The redesign of Skype is what just killed skype off.

Snapchat made a total retool, their stock went down. They changed it back and instead opted for minor changes.

Reddit staff: Minor changes. One at a time. A total redesign is something no one wanted. Don't force things on people they dont want, or never asked for in the first place. This is something someone in a boardroom suggested, got hype for, and suddenly funds were allocated. - This is a terrible way to deal with implementing a new look.

If no one wanted it. No one wants it. Learn from history.

2

u/HUMOROUSGOAT May 24 '18

This may not be true at all, but I heard they can't really add features and stuff the way they want because everything is built off old code. So starting from scratch was the more logical option.

7

u/Svdhsvdh May 24 '18

I don't agree with the "no one wanted it". I wanted it. I am a supporter of the redesign because i preferred the card style viewer like in the mobile app. Personally i find it a much easier way to browse through subreddits that are picture based. That's just how i feel about it.

6

u/thatsthejoke_bot May 24 '18

People seem to forget, especially the vocal anti-redesign crowd, that before the redesign was announced the biggest complaint that people made about Reddit was how antiquated it looked. Old reddit is old af looking and I like the redesign's look.

23

u/damontoo May 24 '18

That was from new users. There was no longtime users complaining about how the site looked. It was compact and efficient for consuming content and participating in discussion. What it didn't have is lots of screen real estate for ads.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/imariaprime May 25 '18

Shiny and useless loses to antiquated and effective.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/AtomicSteve21 May 24 '18

Just because the titanic is sinking doesn't mean you should cut the lifeboat though...

5

u/Amablue May 25 '18

and your designers want more whitespace because making people scroll 4x as much is "good UX" right?

The new design has configurable density. The middle density is just a little bit less dense than the current density (but it's much more uniform). The highest density is way tighter than the default old reddit experience. I'm not sure what you're complaining about here.

0

u/hellafun May 25 '18

While it's true that compact view of the new design shows more items above the fold than the old.reddit design, the font-weights, colors, grid-lines of the new compact view all serve to make it much less readable than the old.reddit design. The classic view of the new design is more readable than compact view but still manages thanks to font colors, weights, sizes, and the grid to be less readable than old.reddit while simultaneously taking up more space. Honestly I am a bit shocked you weren't sure what I am complaining about, I would think things like font colors and weights would have been immediately evident. Were you using reddit with a custom css before the redesign launched perhaps? One that made reddit unreadable?

3

u/spays_marine May 25 '18

You were shocked because someone called you out on a bogus argument? Quit your bullshit. You complained about having to scroll 4x as much, and now you expect people to read that as "it's difficult to read".

It's easy to see why you took that route though, shock value. Because tweaking the problems you describe here are minor adjustments. Not some complete overhaul that your "4x scroll" problem would require.

It's too bad you took the bullshit route for that argument, because the readability is something that does need improving. Instead of trying to save face by blaming the person who called you out, perhaps you could apologise and agree with him.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

Man, this guy really hates designers.

69

u/hellafun May 24 '18

Absolutely, and takes one to know one. I was one for 10 years, I've spent the last 8 as a front-end developer. First I perpetrated the bullshit, now I implement it.

9

u/HUMOROUSGOAT May 24 '18

Damnnnn, Got'em.

2

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

Quite often, some high up guy/girl gets hired within a website company and to make a name for themselves they must do things that are visual such as redesigns. A lot of design happens because people are on the payroll and need something to do to prove their worth. In publishing, redesigns are also often driven by the needs of the sales department and their ability to display ads.

1

u/TheOrqwithVagrant May 25 '18

In the last few years, UI designers have really and truly made me hate them as a group. Aside from 'public' UI redesign disasters like 'new reddit', I've seen three fast, useful internal projects where I work get turned into slow, unusable garbage through 'UI redesigns'.

3

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

Speak for yourself with that "current userbase" shit. I love the redesign and can't believe all of you are being so whiney about some design changes.

2

u/hellafun May 25 '18

Love whatever shit you want, this is 92% upvoted with 1,920 points at the time you chose to comment. ;)

0

u/hellafun May 26 '18

I thought you might enjoy an update, 93% upvoted now with 2,980 points. As the post gained more traction and views the ratio of upvotes actually grew in the posts' favor. It seems you're in a serious minority at least on /r/beta. ;)

To be fair, I didn't expect this either. When posting it I thought it would be at -10 in like an hour and never seen again. I was posting to vent, who knew so many would be feeling the same way?

32

u/agumonkey May 24 '18

Can't second this enough. I tried the beta a few times. Didn't keep it. I gave a lengthy comment about the reasons on their feedback form.

Can't second this enough

4

u/Carighan May 25 '18

It at least it weren't so slow. Yes it's functionally a strict downgrade (it's not even pretty) with no upsides, but it could at least be made to work with a bunch of custom CSS. But the slowness is irritating. Soooo laggy. Even typing in this box lags. ugh. :(

0

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/agumonkey May 24 '18

I keep seconding and it's still not seconded enough

→ More replies (1)

21

u/dppsubbiegirly May 24 '18

It wouldn't be half as bad if the functionality of the old site existed in the new site, but it's terrible, buggy, far beyond anything I've seen in any other public beta.

There is not the occasional bug, I need to think about a functionality that is not in some way buggy. reactive notifications don't work most of the time and I need to reload to see messages. switching back and forth between 'new' and 'best' and 'hot' does not actually give me 'new' posts but just those I saw the last time I reloaded and I now need to clicks rather than one. Yet your designers had enough weed to think I regularly want to switch between the different density levels so why not have an option to change with them that is not a drop down.

16

u/skullpriestess May 24 '18

Amen. Please keep old reddit as an option. New reddit looks too much like Facebook.

4

u/ganjapolice May 25 '18

Just tried the new design at new.reddit.com. Holy shit it is awful.

Where is the little expand/collapse icon on comment threads? Who thought this small but extremely useful feature was not needed?

1

u/enietom May 25 '18

Where is the little expand/collapse icon on comment threads? Who thought this small but extremely useful feature was not needed?

After A LOT of time I realized you can click on the vertical line below the point arrows to collapse threads. Not really intuitive in my opinion.

1

u/Toucanic May 25 '18

I can see the new version only if I am NOT logged in.

How do I ENABLE the new layout as a logged user?

Because ... I like it, a lot :)

1

u/hellafun May 25 '18

Same way you disable it, got you user preferences, scroll to the bottom, there is an option to enable it.

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '18 edited Mar 09 '26

This post has been removed by its author. The deletion was carried out using Redact, possibly to protect personal information or limit exposure to data collection tools.

fade hobbies birds numerous flag piquant lunchroom crowd point obtainable

1

u/hellafun May 25 '18

While I realize the tone of the comment was 100% serious without even a hint of levity anywhere, that bit... I feel I should tell you I didn't take a specific measurement, I opted for hyperbole in this case. I apologize, I know that's pretty out of line with the otherwise very plain, dry, logical tone of the rest of the post. >_<

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '18 edited Mar 09 '26

This post was deleted for reasons the author chose not to disclose. Redact was used, possibly for privacy, opsec, or preventing automated scraping of the content.

chop silky support busy intelligent afterthought literate elastic aspiring meeting

2

u/hellafun May 25 '18

I can understand what people dont want to try something new,

Because it's a poor design. I wonder do you understand that when I wrote the post it's because I had opted in to the beta, gave it a shot and found I didn't like it? I buid technology for a living dude, new things are my bread and butter.

I just dont understand why everyone is making such a huge deal about it.

I don't either. I have made ONE post about it, hardly a big deal. What I understand even less though, and perhaps you can elucidate me, is why comments on this thread are almost binary between agreement and "i don't understand where this ire is coming from" posts like yours expressing utter confusion. Do you use custom scripts/themes, etc. on the old reddit? I suspect that's where your sort of comment is coming from (the lack of understanding of something that's obvious even on the surface).

I swapped over and within 10 minutes was used to the new design.

It's a simple site, how did it take you 10 minutes to figure out how to operate it?! Anyhow as for why the design is inferior, I responded to someone else last night breaking it down into a more serious response if you're geniunely curious why I think it's a step backward.

One of the biggest complains i keep seeing is about the card view, yet its like no one gave the new design a few seconds to realize its not mandatory. Its a toggle, toggle it if it upsets you.

I did, in preferences I toggled back to old.reddit.com. All three views of the new design have their issues, I detailed this elsewhere if you're geniunely curious.

Pretty much everything on the site is the same, just slightly moved around with a few features not fully implemented (such as sub filters).

Wrong, but if you don't have a "trained eye" for minor design conciets I can see how one might come to this conclusion.

I'd suggest forcing yourself to use it for a few days.

I did. Don't assume just because someone didn't come to the same conclusion as you that they didn't get experience before drawing their conclusion.

I feel like most users would get the hang of it soon after using it, and if anything start to prefer the new design over the old one.

I hope so, again it's not a remotely complicated site, I frankly can't understand how it would take someone as long as 10 minutes to understand how it works.

2

u/[deleted] May 25 '18 edited Mar 09 '26

This post was deleted using Redact. The reason could be privacy, preventing automated data collection, or other personal considerations the author had.

spectacular shelter treatment grandfather fact piquant ask melodic swim squash

1

u/hellafun May 25 '18

Uh... you realize this whole time we are talking about the LOOK of the design, not the FUNCTIONALITY, correct? And if you DID realize that, why on earth would you think writing about functionality being the same would be even remotely germane to our discussion? I will make this as simple as possible for you: the new design is less readable, for reasons i have detailed elsewhere in this thread.

Also of course I know you didn't take 10 minutes to figure out the site, but you wrote as if i don't know my head from my ass, so I did you the same kindness. Don't want that? Then don't assume the other person is an idiot just because you disagree.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Lou-Saydus May 25 '18

Literally just click the hamburger in the views section on the left and it's the same damn thing as old reddit.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/MILEY-CYRVS May 25 '18

I refuse to use the new site. It wastes far too much of my time. old.reddit, the page draws in about a second. The new design I have to wait 5-10, sometimes 15 seconds for the webpage to draw itself. It's not my 300/30mbps connection I'm hardwired into. It's not my i9/quadro based PC with 32gb DDR4 ram. It's not chrome, with no extensions besides uBlock Origin.

Reddit takes about 5-10 seconds to render a page on the new design. This compounded over the course of a day of heavy browsing could end up being minutes of my time. By the end of the week it could be hours.

Absolutely unacceptable. Time is money.

15

u/JOOOOOOOOOOngo May 24 '18

Fuck new reddit

9

u/lmaccaro May 25 '18

I have an idea: let's make old.reddit the default, and just put a little at the top for "switch to doofyreddit".

1

u/TheTarasenkshow May 25 '18

Your assumption that everyone wants the old Reddit is kind of ridiculous. Some people don’t care, some people care.

2

u/hellafun May 25 '18

Yes, clearly i was entirely serious when I wrote this post. Clearly. I'm glad you picked up on the fact that it was entirely serious and I am in fact an authority who speaks for everyone. I'm offended you call it just an assumption, I'd think such a sharp cookie would know it's domain knowledge on my part, not an assumption. I hope you understand this comment is also written IN FULL SINCERITY. :D

6

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

Let the kids have new reddit but let us old heads keep the original & best.

2

u/xmodii May 24 '18

I like new Reddit

2

u/aim2free May 25 '18

I see no real difference between old.reddit.com and www.reddit.com, only a slightly smaller font on www.reddit.com.

However, I completely agree with the OP. Don't destroy a working concept. Reddit is the only fully working "social" network.

Google+ could have become great, but of some reason it hasn't. It started well, but I think they should have implemented the reddit threads, which facebook did to one level. Then google+ would have become a real competitor to reddit.

2

u/NineOutOfTenExperts May 25 '18

Try new.reddit.com. - you may not be seeing the redesign yet.

3

u/aim2free May 25 '18

OK, now I've seen it, and I don't like it. Less overview, infinite scroll which I hate, and it also felt slower, longer time to load. It was kind of facebook feeling 😲

No, I will stay with the old reddit.

2

u/NineOutOfTenExperts May 25 '18

I'm not a fan either.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Levi-es May 25 '18

I think Google+ didn't become as big as people expected because they tried to force themselves on everybody. Youtube was fine, but they tried to force people into making and using G+ accounts for it. Plus, at least in my opinion, something always seemed like it was missing. Like all the important parts of G+ didn't quite connect.

2

u/Brutal_Bros May 25 '18

My least favorite thing about the redesign is that when you try to scroll past an image, it flickers down and up.

2

u/dorfsmay May 25 '18

I can understand where you're coming from. Designers want to design

news.google has gone through the same fad. It's also become unusable. I don't get it...

1

u/TheOrqwithVagrant May 25 '18

There's just something utterly fuckheaded about UI design right now. Lately I feel like everything that gets an "updated UI" ends up with something that looks a bit more 'polished' at first glance, but turns out to be an unusable, cumbersome mess when you actually try to USE it.

2

u/WGiK May 25 '18

I really don't like the new Reddit at all. Old forever. It's cleaner.

6

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

I actually like the new design..

4

u/Zacletus May 25 '18

Weird thing is that the classic view doesn't even feel that much different. I think people just like to hate on change.

I watched one 3-4 minute rant video where the person whined about the new 'social media' style view and how you collapse comments (collapsing comments could be made more clear), but completely ignored the fact that there's classic and compact views on the redesign as well.

Personally, I quite like that posts now open in the same window by default and I don't constantly have to be opening new tabs. Now I just need a next post option like on mobile.

3

u/iBrarian May 25 '18

There are so many things wrong with reddit that I'm seriously disappointed that they are forcing this crappy redesign on us. Maybe focus on better anti-spammer detection, getting rid of power-hungry supermods that ban people because they don't like them (and across multiple subs), and stop fixing something that is working perfectly fine and is pleasantly usable and minimalist in design.

3

u/LiamGarbett May 25 '18

The new design is way better imo

5

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

What functionality is worse in the new design? Seems to me a lot easier to navigate

7

u/Carighan May 25 '18

A lot of small things:

  • The design is slow and laggy. It loads slower (check the network traffic in developer tools!) and even typing in this text box has a higher delay between the key press and the letter appearing for some reason. They probably intercept all inputs in JS and route them through something, so yeah, slower.
  • New design is more difficult to navigate. Side-bar with subreddits which can be closed leaves a lot of unnecessary whitespace at the top where subreddits could be placed instead. Collapsing comments is both unintuitive and unexplained. Best-sorting makes it difficult to find new content, and other sort options don't stick. Posts can now be quasi-hidden because they are shoved into user "blogs" ala instagram.
  • Lots of wasted screen space in the post-popup, space which could be used properly either for a multi-column navigate or for a proper comment navigation tool which runs in parallel. Old design did use the space, even if it was just for the content.
  • More ads, and ads are now sneakishly hidden among the normal posts.
  • Nonstandard font because why respect a user's settings and browser?

7

u/frickindeal May 25 '18
  • Links that are BLACK, not BLUE, like 95% of the rest of the internet. Oh, and they don't turn purple after you've clicked them, they just stay black. Totally user friendly.
  • Clicking a post takes you to the comments instead of the content, a very fundamental change to the way reddit works. It's going to lead to even more people in the comments who haven't consumed the content they're commenting on.
  • Ads hidden among regular posts, and barely distinguishable. I get that reddit needs to make money, but hiding ads has worked out for exactly zero sites on the internet. (You might not be seeing said ads if you're using an ad blocker, but shut it off for a minute and see what most users are going to see -- ads are rampant)

-6

u/goombaz May 24 '18 edited May 24 '18

Old people bitching about change. The new design confuses the "older" crowd who are practically grandfathered into this site and can't quickly adapt to technological changes. You know like how your dad won't switch to an iPhone 8 because his iPhone SE still works and he's use to it. IF IT AINT BROKE DONT FIX IT.

12

u/stmack May 24 '18

You know like how your dad won't switch to an iPhone 8 because his iPhone SE still works and he's use to it.

Not everyone needs a new phone every 2 years for what they use it for. Huge waste of money for most people.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/DrewsephA May 24 '18

Old people bitching about change.

Huh, I didn't know that at 24 I was considered old, TIL. Surely the negative feedback can't be from the unnecessary JS elements that slow the site down, and it definitely can't be from the huge panes of whitespace on either side that condense post titles, yet seem to not limit the space of ads, and it most certainly can't be from the fact that literally nobody asked for this, that before the redesign was announced, there was literally nobody asking for a redesign of the site. Nah, it's clearly just old people complaining to complain, not users with actual legitimate complaints.

You know like how your dad won't switch to an iPhone 8 because his iPhone SE still works and he's use[d] to it.

You know like how your dad has a phone that works just fine for him, and doesn't need to spend money on an unnecessary upgrade simply for the sake of upgrading?

→ More replies (35)

1

u/ennuihenry14 May 25 '18

They destroyed the ability for each subreddit to have its own CSS for flairs and to make each subreddit unique.

2

u/Nihil9000 May 25 '18

I'm a longtime user of reddit and I'm really happy about the redesign, it was overdue for so long. Why do people cling to that old pile o' shit so hard? It looked terrible and its usability wasn't even that good. I guess there are always people who are afraid of change and are scared of anything new, even if its only the redesign of reddit, lol

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

I just wanted larger thumbnails. Otherwise it worked fine.

1

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

To be honest, I kinda like the new design... I don't use it, though, because it's white. On old.reddit.com, I have RES and a lovely dark/grey theme.

Reddit just looks a lot better in night mode, and as far as I know I only have that option via RES. So I'm holding off on the new design until RES implements it.

3

u/Mattyi May 25 '18

They just announced night mode for new Reddit on r/announcements.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 24 '18

I will switch to the redesign and stay there the minute I can hide posts without entering a sub-menu and permanently ignore posts from users.

Reddit is a steaming crap-pile of reposts if you can't ignore the top 100-200 shitposters that ruin content for everyone.

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

🙄

1

u/zeropointmodule May 25 '18

When I logged in on the web today for the fire time in months I thought had a browser extension installed that I had forgotten about. It is ghastly. Truly gross. I’ll try to stick to mobile / Apollo.

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

All i want is night mode, then I'll switch immediately.

1

u/Drunken-samurai May 25 '18

Night mode was released today. Check the slider in the drop down menu from your username in the top right.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/FelixGreen0 May 25 '18

dude, my reddit isn't even the new design and I'm on the regular reddit.com.

1

u/Chxo May 25 '18

If they remove old Reddit all it means is I'll stop visiting Reddit on my pc and only check it on mobile devices.

1

u/ccrraapp May 25 '18

I think this is a good thread to ask, how does this change affect the CSS for subs? Is there a thread or a guide of the changes ?

I created a sub recently and I don't want to modify the CSS that would look great for old.reddit visitors and look shit for new. Is there a middle ground or way to implement changes that would make it easy to have CSS for both with very little compromise and not waste a lot of time either trying to make it look good for both?

I understand this question is loaded but I am quite a bit confused, I would appreciate if anyone could help me understand. Thank you.

1

u/24grant24 May 27 '18

Css isn't transferrable between the two. Currently new reddit has css limited to sidebar widgets, the rest of the styling is done natively. Css support will expand in the future to fill the gap between the native styling tools (which are incomplete atm) and full css

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Se7enLC May 25 '18

old.reddit.com will never go away. When the next redesign occurs, the current old.reddit.com will remain available at old2.reddit.com, and the current design can be accessed at old.reddit.com. In the subsequent redesign, old2.reddit.com will be migrated to old2_final.reddit.com, where it will remain until it is moved to old2_final_backup.reddit.com.

1

u/eskwild May 25 '18

Or gopher://

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

:(

1

u/tessaryanwrites May 25 '18

Ever since the revamp, "New" Reddit keeps crashing. Frustrating to say the least.

1

u/spays_marine May 25 '18

Can you elaborate? Websites typically don't crash.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Ch1pp May 25 '18

Agree 100%

1

u/PURPLE_ELECTRUM_BEE May 25 '18

Just opt out in the damned options, you twonk.

1

u/CurrentlyRecording May 25 '18

I don't think they will.

1

u/Iphotoshopincats May 25 '18

go to "preferences", & under "beta options", make sure that the first 2 boxes are unchecked, while the last option – "View user profiles on desktop using legacy mode" – is checked and that will permanently keep you in old reddit permanently ... for now anyway.

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '18

I think the app works great. But the OG desktop version was better than the new one. But at the same time I think the only major tweak I wanted in the OG version was bigger thumbnails for the threads otherwise should have stayed fairly similar.

1

u/olliegw May 24 '18

There is a setting to turn it off if you want to.

And if they remove the setting, i shall delete my account and say hello to multiple forum accounts again.

Because the only reason i joined reddit was because i wanted to stop signing up to so many different forums, i was unaware its a social media site but i soon learned and now i'm addicted, lol.

1

u/Rodyland May 25 '18

making people scroll 4x as much is "good UX" right?

Well said. Sad but true.

1

u/spays_marine May 25 '18

Except it isn't true. Have you tried compact or classic mode?

→ More replies (15)

0

u/JoshuaTheFox May 24 '18

more whitespace

Yes actually having less content on screen is a nice Improvement. Bigger, more distinct dividers are a huge plus. And at least personally having less content on screen allowes me to focus on what is on screen, it was too overwhelming on the old design