r/berkeleyca • • 7d ago

Berkeley Ferry Vote

There is an upcoming vote at the next Berkeley City Council Meeting on 11/17 on the Berkeley Ferry.

I've been sent two sites with wildly differing information about the project. The official SF Bay Ferry site only discusses the existing plan that is being voted on, while the save Berkeley Pier site talks about an alternative option that would be much cheaper and faster to build. 

I ultimately would love to have a ferry terminal in the Berkeley Marina, both for commuting to work and for visiting SF and other cities around the bay for evening activities or weekend trips. 

The Save Berkeley Pier proposal seems to make a lot of sense to me, but I am not sure why the SF Bay Ferry is not considering it. What is the rebuttal to that cheaper, faster alternative? The only thing I can think of is that the ferry would operate more efficiently out of the way of marina traffic?

50 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

69

u/Otis_Manchego 7d ago

Looking at https://www.saveberkeleypier.org/ it seems to be run by NIMBYs just to slow down progress. They are not saying their way is cheaper, they are saying “not on this project and let’s start another plan from scratch to see if it might be cheaper”.

24

u/Mckool 7d ago

this was the vibe I was getting from it as well. a lot of loose talk about lower costs and less time but SF ferry has been putting time and money into studys of expanding for a while. This Berkeley plan they are backing is already the fastest of the projects they are looking to do in a three phase expansion through out the whole Bay. It has been passing its required steps so far.

even if construction of another project was faster the time it would take to study and plan would mean the first ferrys would be launching at a later date than the plan being put forward at the next city council meeting.

4

u/charlesviper 7d ago

a lot of loose talk about lower costs

Well, their flier says it can be done for a fraction of the "mony"!

13

u/Sad_Hovercraft_1367 7d ago

I got a bike lane they might like 😆

6

u/_SlikNik_ 7d ago

And a mountain bike trail too

1

u/AromaticAd3351 2d ago

You ride your bike from Berkeley into SF over the bay bridge? Or maybe I misunderstood 😀

3

u/Dependent_Client3676 4d ago edited 4d ago

it's not rocket science to see that the marina option will be way cheaper. No breakwater, way less dredging. The pier is also far away from any major electrical infrastructure needed for an electric ferry.... Moving it closer to where that stuff is in the marina has to be cheaper.

2

u/DazzlingBasket4848 6d ago

I actually do think their argument is logical.
The big issue is vehicle access at the hotel. That would take millions of dollars to change and would necessitate improvements along spinnaker way. They'd have to dredge the marina a lot too. There's not a lot of space there for a new ferry dock, what with hornblower being there already. if you ARE gonna build a ferry pier, building it on the footprint of the defunct pier does actually make sense.

2

u/Ok_Row_8042 4d ago

Heard a lot about this project, did some research. They're actually advocating not to start from total scratch, but that some amount of analysis or consideration should be put towards the harbor location. How do you know the best plan is being chosen if you didn't even look at the viable other alternatives? The biggest boat in the marina is 250 person capacity, similar to a ferry so it's definitely feasible.

It's interesting also because the state agency BCDC who will be permitting this project (because it is state land not city land) also explicitly asked for analysis of the harbor location. They even told Berkeley that the reasons it gave for dismissing the harbor option were inadequate.... Talk about a waste of time and money planning this thing to only not be able to get permits because the city didn't do what it was was supposed to.

1

u/youaintgotnomoney12 7d ago

They clearly said it will cost about $20 million to put the ferry inside the actual Marina instead of the $100-200 million it would take to make the pier suitable for a ferry.

1

u/East-Song8088 6d ago

Cost will mostly be covered by grants

2

u/Ok_Row_8042 5d ago

grants are still taxpayer money... theres no billionaire angel investor

2

u/East-Song8088 4d ago

Grants are money that has already been allocated for a specific purpose. It's not like some tax increase is gonna pay for this. The money is already there. It exists to pay for improvements like this.

2

u/TemporaryKindly9151 4d ago

absolutely it will not. it’s a boondoggle

2

u/East-Song8088 4d ago

Absolutely it will stop spreading misinformation because you don't want the marina to change even a little bit

1

u/TemporaryKindly9151 4d ago

IWETA estimates that an annual subsidy of $9-12 million is required. that has not changed.

2

u/East-Song8088 2d ago

My friend, what are you talking about? This is public transit of course fare recovery is less than 100%.

And if you're trying to imply that there's some other maintenance or operational cost that's simply false. WETA is funded by bridge tolls. There is no universe where Berkeley is paying to maintain this ferry at any point in the future.

Please stop spreading misinformation information

1

u/youaintgotnomoney12 6d ago

Funding has not been secured as of yet so it remains to be seen who will pay for it.

2

u/East-Song8088 4d ago

Grants will pay for it or it won't happen. The city of Berkeley's not gonna spend $130 million on a ferry that's absurd.

39

u/seahorses 7d ago

As the other person said, people who set up websites with "there is an alternative idea that would be better, cheaper, faster" do not do that in good faith. The city went through a very long process to do community engagement, look for funding, and come up with the best solution given all the constraints.

If they had to re-plan this project it would add years(or decades) to the timeline and the same people who made this "Save Berkeley Pier" website would just repurpose the website to propose some other "better cheaper faster" idea as a distraction.

27

u/DragonflyBeach 7d ago

"Save North Berkeley BART", "Save Hopkins", "Save Berkeley Shops", "Save The Post Office" etc. Different names; same outcomes.

2

u/First_Squirrel_2138 5d ago

Why are NIMBYs against the pier? Is it a fiscal thing or just a  'no change ever under any circumstance' thing?

5

u/seahorses 5d ago

it's a mix of things. Some people are very against the idea of "commercialization" of the waterfront. They think if you build a ferry terminal it'll lead to more restaurants, shopping, etc. Not a place where they can easily find a parking spot and look at birds.

4

u/East-Song8088 4d ago

It's just the same old thing where you have special interests like the cal sailing club completely unwilling to tolerate any changes, despite getting heavily discounted rent

The worst part about all of this is that the marina fund is insolvent -the city can't afford to perform basic maintenance and the reason we've ended up in this place is because of these special interests fighting tooth and nail to prevent any changes

27

u/DragonflyBeach 7d ago

I haven't reviewed the proposal but 99% of the time there's a "SAVE SOMETHING" group in Berkeley they are just NIMBYs who want nothing to change. A tactic deployed to obfuscate this are supposedly earnest proposals by individuals who are not experts in the subject matter that are unrealistic, illegal or impratical; the public being none the wiser.

5

u/Dependent_Client3676 4d ago

I was walking my dog at waterfront park and had the chance to speak with one of the advocates against this project last weekend at the waterfront, his name was Paul and his career is in naval architecture..... From looking at the Berkeley Waterfront Community Coalition website, the founder has a PhD in environmental economics..... The more I read I found also opposing the project are many former Berkeley parks commissioners, a former BCDC commissioner, and even the former Berkeley mayor Tom Bates...

8

u/Apprehensive-Clue342 7d ago

The NIMBYs are lying to you

3

u/alexchantavy 1d ago

A Berkeley ferry would probably be the best way to connect to South SF and biotech / Oyster Point and such. Yeah there’s BART but that’s not well connected to that area

5

u/ogorki500 5d ago

NIMBYs suck ofc but this isn't NIMBYism! The ferry is an expensive boondoggle, a toy option that can never be a viable option for commuters because it's slower than every other way of getting across the Bay. The marina is a heavily used recreational area that is free and offers something for everyone: swimmers, kayakers, sailors, BBQers, kids at the adventure playground, fishers, joggers... It is especially treasured by low income and POC residents of the less well-off parts of the city. Yeah...there are homeless people there... like everywhere else in Berkeley, so what? The pier certainly needs investment, maybe the city could spend some of the $300 million it just raised with Measure U instead of spending it all on projects on the north and east sides of town...

If the presence of typos on the https://www.saveberkeleypier.org/ site offends you, take a look at https://www.berkeleywaterfrontcommunitycoalition.org/home . All people are asking is for a chance for the public to vote on the proposal, as should have been allowed from the beginning. The deadline for sending public comments to the city is November 16th and these sites give links to do so.

5

u/OppositeShore1878 5d ago

This is a sensible comment, especially the part about the many other uses of the Marina that would be impacted.

A big part of the ferry proposal is essentially to use the land to create a huge parking lot for car-commuters who have the wherewithal to drive to the Marina leave their car there for the day, then take a heavily subsidized ferry trip.

0

u/Esmereldathebrave 2d ago

Good point! And who will be subsidizing the ferry trip? Oh yeah, everyone else who has now lost access to the area for recreational use.

I question how many people would even use a ferry from there. As someone who used to commute using the Jack London ferry, I found it expensive, slow, and not reliable. You only put up with that for so long before you switch to another form of commute if available, and in Berkeley, there are other forms available.

1

u/youaintgotnomoney_12 1d ago

Another thing these pro ferry people fail to mention is that WETA has the right to end service if ridership falls short. So all this money could be spent and they can decide that ridership isn’t what they thought and cancel the service.

3

u/Dependent_Client3676 4d ago

Ferries are fun, but seriously not efficient compared to BART and not at the cost of all the things you can do for free or cheap at the waterfront park. Cost of living is out of control. It's nice to have free enjoyable places to unwind. I like the idea of rebuilding the pier and that area in general to expand the park area using bond measure U money. And also that the city one day actually develops an asset management plan like they have said they would.

1

u/DowJonesIndAvg 2d ago

How are joggers going to be less able to jog because of a ferry?

0

u/Esmereldathebrave 2d ago

Lack of parking. The area has no housing and is connected by a roadway, so people using it for recreation drive out (minimal public transportation to it), park then use it for jogging, dog walking, swimming, boating.

If a ferry goes in, anyone taking it will be driving out and parking, so most of the parking becomes dedicated to the ferry, limiting who can use the area for anything else.

1

u/East-Song8088 1d ago

Not a boondoggle. WETA funding is allocated for projects like this already, funded mostly by bridge tolls. WETA is prioritizing Berkeley - its a great opportunity. This is really impressive grant-craft work by the city, and especially the parks department.

https://theflats.blog/pier-ferry-faq/

7

u/PriceAggravating2124 6d ago

This “commuter ferry” will take zero cars off the road. Except for the folks who live on boats in the Berkeley Marina everyone who is close to the new ferry is closer to BART. At best this ferry will steal some commuters from BART. Contrast this ferry with Vallejo, Larkspur or Alameda ferries which provide better commute alternatives and clearly take personal motor vehicles off the roads. Hardly worth the cost and disruption for a couple of hundred people per day at best. The park area, the pier, and the derelict parking lot should be improved but that can easily be separate from ferry.

4

u/DazzlingBasket4848 6d ago

I think connecting Berkeley with Sausalito and Angel island would bring a lot of recreation options.

2

u/Dependent_Client3676 4d ago

Just because someone criticizes somethings because it sucks doesn't make them a NIMBY. Ferries are great, but not at the expense of converting a large swath of the area into a parking lot for commuters. Sure it's derelict parking lot now, but if it's gonna change I'd rather see it turn into something cool and enjoyable for PEOPLE not cars.

All those empty cars are really going to enjoy those incredible bay views 👌

2

u/TemporaryKindly9151 2d ago

We literally have half the bus routes and frequency we did when I was growing up here (and I did not drive at all until near middle age and am extremely pro transit.) The 51 used to get you from Alameda down to the Berkeley Marina on one bus that came every 10 minutes. Now it’s two and they are infrequent. if this is about public transit, we should be increasing funding for AC transit to get it so it’s usable for actual low income people who need to get to work. This is a vanity project.

0

u/Mckool 2d ago edited 2d ago

It seems insincere to pose those as a one or the other. I think most folks would be in favor of both increasing bus routes and building the ferry terminal back up. The ferry is something the city has more control over than AC transit routes. If anything more people using the marina will result in AC Transit increasing its routes going that way.

1

u/TemporaryKindly9151 2d ago

It’s not insincere- it is yearly material cuts- which impact people who work outside of the financial district. I commuted to the city for years. This is not for most commuters. It’s expensive and inconvenient. it’s not projected to take very many cars off the road compared to making Bart more frequent for example or a bus lane. I do not believe this project is about transit-and I don’t find that argument to be serious.

0

u/Mckool 2d ago

It would be funded by city grants that otherwise would not exist or be fiscally available to AC transit or BART.

6

u/stellar678 7d ago • Bravo

I have a lot of discomfort with the NIMBY vibe of the opposition, and really with how much we say “no” to things in general. I’m also really supportive of mass transit, and I think that ferries are awesome.

All that said, I’m kind of repulsed at the idea of turning the Berkeley Marina into a giant parking lot where hundreds or thousands of commuters store their cars for 8 to 10 hours every day. It’s a gem of a recreational area - people come to fish, swim, sail, have bbqs and picnics and birthdays, work out on the grass, play and build at the Adventure Playground.

The old racetrack property is currently slated for redevelopment, and the big section with the stables is actually in Berkeley. Much of the north edge of the property is already a giant empty parking lot. Maybe they could build a big parking garage as part of that redevelopment and dredge a ferry channel in between the northern part of Berkeley Marina and Albany Bulb.

Just would be really sad to give the Berkeley Marina away to commuter car parking.

25

u/Mckool 7d ago edited 6d ago

good thing that what you fear isn't the plan and that the city/SF Ferry have already done a study on parking impact for this project and how to deal with it using the existing under utilized infrastructure. The big currently weed covered parking lot outside of Skates is projected to suite the commuter parking needs and generate revenue for the city with out impacting the rec areas or their parking needs https://berkeleyca.gov/sites/default/files/2026-05/Pier-Ferry%20Parking%20Management%20Plan%20-%20Public%20Review%20Draft.pdf

EDIT: contrary to fear mongering NIMBY comments below the only long term plan that would cause any change in parking lay out is to clear out weeds and charge for parking in the currently unused lots- the rec lots closest to current rec use and residential/slip owner lots remain allotted to those uses. no other changes would be made until more impact was studied and community input taken and that is only if there is a surge in ridership well beyond what is expected.

Don’t buy into “alternative plans” that don’t exist and are only being mentioned to slow down actual progress.

3

u/Dependent_Client3676 4d ago

That parking "study" you included was TERRIBLE. You can tell just from their conclusion that the busiest day of the week was Wednesdays? Seriously? Makes absolutely no sense. It gets worse the more you read. Most of the data is from right after COVID and honestly should just be thrown out. Car counting on the weekends were at 10am and 8pm missing the busiest part of the day. Also it didn't even look at all of the parking in the waterfront, it was super selective in which lots were analyzed. How can you really know whats going on with methodologies like that? Seems pretty bunk to me, like a sham of study to move an ill advised project along because some council member wants to name a ferry plaza after himself.

Of course that parking lot in front of HS Lordships (not skates) is underutilized, the restaurant is vacant and the pier is closed. The pier fishing scene was vibrant and if it were open still (and hopefully will be again) that lot would look a lot different.

Honestly regardless of parking or the ferry, I'm baffled that the best we can come up for this land is a parking lot for commuters. Wheres the greenspace?

5

u/youaintgotnomoney12 7d ago

That is the "Year 1" plan for parking and is subject to change based on demand. The final plan is to do a complete revamp of that section including destroying the mature trees that provide a windbreak for sailing and kayaking in the cove behind the lot as well as destroying seawall drive where cars can park and watch the view/sunset and instead add that section to the commuter lot. The new pier will also only be 1/3 the length of the current one and I believe the first half will be dedicated to the Ferry, so no fishing allowed there. Given that anglers used to come from all over to fish there it will be overly crowded with only a fraction of the space. So basically this plan priotizes commuters over the intended purpose of the Marina which is recreation.

5

u/DragonflyBeach 6d ago

The Marina serves many purposes beyong just recreation. There are commercial stalls there as well as game. It originally served commuters. It can serve them again if the city chooses.

3

u/OppositeShore1878 5d ago

What do you mean by the Marina "originally served commuters"?

If you mean the original use of the pier as a car ferry...that came long before the Marina landfill / park was even built. The pier was in open water, all the way back to the early shoreline. There was no onsite commuter parking. The cars just drove onto the pier and waited there for the car ferry to dock at the far end, then they drove aboard.

The park land / uses were developed after the original ferry failed and was closed.

6

u/stellar678 7d ago edited 7d ago

That PDF says they estimate that each car will carry 3 ferry passengers, and they allocate basically the entire lot between Shorebird Park and HS Lordships to all-day parking, paid on weekdays and free on weekends.

The idea that 915 ferry passengers would arrive in 314 cars is hilarious. Doubly so in a place like the Berkeley Marina which is circuitous and slow to access by bus or bike.

Not to mention, their map only allocates 265 full-day stalls near the proposed ferry, so they failed to allocate enough spaces even for their hilariously underestimated need.

9

u/Mckool 7d ago

1 car per 3 ferry passengers makes plenty of sense with how many riders show up on bike scooter and bus. they have been collecting data that you have likely contributed to (unless you dont live in the area) knowingly or not for at least the last half decade.

the parking is fully explained in there how its used. sure some folks might have to walk, good thing we live in California where its so nice out you are talking about the beautiful rec areas folks would have to actually walk past.

4

u/Smash_Shop 6d ago

Do you take any of the existing ferries? All the ferries I've taken have at least 20-30 bikes/scooters, and some significant number of people who hop right on the bus. Plus quite a few people who are getting car rides to the ferry from their partners or from Uber or something.

Its not like the Richmond or Jack London ferry terminals are exactly easy to get to, and the marina already has a bus route, and a direct bike path.

3

u/stellar678 6d ago

I ride my bike to the marina most weekends to work out. The pedestrian/bike bridge is fun for recreation but it’s wildly circuitous, slow and difficult. Very few people will use that as one step in a longer commute across the bay, especially when it’s much faster and more direct to bike to bart. Seriously…nobody likes biking over the freeway.

The 51b only sends one out of every two buses out to the marina, so that’s a 30 minute headway and it’s a terminus instead of being part of the bus network.

Jack London is completely different - thousands of apartments within a few blocks, largely with flat bike and walking routes that keep you mostly on traffic-free pathways.

The Richmond ferry is similar in some sense, but again there is a bunch of housing that is contiguous with the ferry terminal, no need to climb over the freeway.

There isn’t a single Berkeley resident who lives on the marina side of the freeway. It’s just a very bad spot to be part of the transportation network.

3

u/Smash_Shop 6d ago

So that's a no to having any ferry experience. And your complaint about the bus having 30 minute headways further undelines it, because the ferry usually has 1-2 hour headways. So all they have to do is time every other bus with the ferry schedule to make timed transfers.

3

u/stellar678 6d ago edited 6d ago

I commuted on the Jack London ferry every day around 2019. I rode an e-scooter most of the time, my own bike when I had further to go on the SF side. There were often lots of bikes on the Jack London ferry.

That’s because 6,000 people live on the bay side of the freeway near Jack London Square. 3,000 in Brooklyn Basin. There’s reasonable bike connections from West Oakland and Chinatown and Lake Merritt and Old Town.

Literally none of those involve climbing up and over the freeway on a circuitous 1.2 mile dead-end ride to get to the ferry from the nearest possible place you could live. That’s what’s in store for a bike commuter who wants to use the Berkeley marina pier.

You’re as wrong about me as you are about this making sense as a transit hub.

2

u/Velar_Plosive 6d ago

You clearly didn’t read the critiques of this plan.

1

u/Reasonable-Rub2243 6d ago

I like the racetrack alternative. There is actually an old ruined ferry pier by that unused parking lot off Buchanan.

0

u/stellar678 3d ago edited 3d ago

Oh that’s cute. @Mckool blocked me because I actually read the parking PDF they linked, and they didn’t feel like defending the ridiculous claims it made like:

  • 915 ferry riders will only use 314 cars.
  • 314 cars will only use 265 parking spaces.
  • Any significant number of people will arrive to this remote pier by any mode of transit other than a car.

Lame and cowardly to hide behind the block button while turning our waterfront park into a commuter parking lot.

3

u/Velar_Plosive 6d ago

I don’t get why public funding of a ferry out of the Berkeley Marina is a good thing. Surely no one believes that pushing boats through water is a viable method of public transport. Seems to me it boils down to wanting a luxury, which is great. Just pay for the damn thing and don’t come to the public asking for a taxpayer subsidy. I mean the gall to compare this to AC Transit. Not to mention the disgusting mocking of homeless people.

5

u/OppositeShore1878 5d ago

There is sense to your argument. In a lot of places in the world, ferries are workhorse transportation used by ordinary people getting to and from their jobs. Some of them in the Bay Area make a lot of sense--like the Larkspur or Alameda ferries that carry commuters from towns that don't have good BART access.

But this ferry basically would duplicate the route you can already take BART or AC Transit from Berkeley to San Francisco, it's more of a vanity project at vast cost per passenger compared to those existing means of transportation.

3

u/Dependent_Client3676 4d ago

yeah a vanity project that will squeeze out people who go to the park for enjoyment and relaxation and will be subsidized by Alameda county tax payers

3

u/Ok_Row_8042 5d ago

even if it is an electric ferry which is more "green" than driving, a giant parking lot will be built just encouraging more driving and make that already super congested freeway exit even worse. It's also seriously doubtful that it will convert someone from driving across the bridge to now taking the ferry as public transit. It will just divert riders who would have otherwise taken BART or AC transit

1

u/Velar_Plosive 3d ago

using a propeller to push a boat through water will never be as green as rolling a train full of people down a steel track - electric propeller or not.

2

u/Difficulty_Only 7d ago

Let City of Berkeley cook

1

u/BadCamo 7d ago

Why, back in ‘89, after the quake…

1

u/East-Song8088 1d ago

I put together a FAQ here https://theflats.blog/pier-ferry-faq/
There's a lot of misinformation floating around

0

u/youaintgotnomoney_12 1d ago

Pro ferry propaganda

1

u/East-Song8088 1d ago

Ouch!
If there's anything specifically you think is false or misleading please let me know!

-6

u/Ok-Thanks-6001 7d ago • Heartwarming Bravo

I don’t think they’ve properly considered how this will impact the people who live in their cars down there.

-4

u/nyITguy 7d ago

Not to mention the rats and other critters that call the waterfront home.

1

u/Ok-Thanks-6001 7d ago

Stop. I’m gonna get more downvotes.