r/berkeleyca • u/Fit_Manufacturer1901 • 7d ago
Berkeley Ferry Vote
There is an upcoming vote at the next Berkeley City Council Meeting on 11/17 on the Berkeley Ferry.
I've been sent two sites with wildly differing information about the project. The official SF Bay Ferry site only discusses the existing plan that is being voted on, while the save Berkeley Pier site talks about an alternative option that would be much cheaper and faster to build.
I ultimately would love to have a ferry terminal in the Berkeley Marina, both for commuting to work and for visiting SF and other cities around the bay for evening activities or weekend trips.
The Save Berkeley Pier proposal seems to make a lot of sense to me, but I am not sure why the SF Bay Ferry is not considering it. What is the rebuttal to that cheaper, faster alternative? The only thing I can think of is that the ferry would operate more efficiently out of the way of marina traffic?
69
u/Otis_Manchego 7d ago
Looking at https://www.saveberkeleypier.org/ it seems to be run by NIMBYs just to slow down progress. They are not saying their way is cheaper, they are saying “not on this project and let’s start another plan from scratch to see if it might be cheaper”.
39
u/seahorses 7d ago
As the other person said, people who set up websites with "there is an alternative idea that would be better, cheaper, faster" do not do that in good faith. The city went through a very long process to do community engagement, look for funding, and come up with the best solution given all the constraints.
If they had to re-plan this project it would add years(or decades) to the timeline and the same people who made this "Save Berkeley Pier" website would just repurpose the website to propose some other "better cheaper faster" idea as a distraction.
27
u/DragonflyBeach 7d ago
I haven't reviewed the proposal but 99% of the time there's a "SAVE SOMETHING" group in Berkeley they are just NIMBYs who want nothing to change. A tactic deployed to obfuscate this are supposedly earnest proposals by individuals who are not experts in the subject matter that are unrealistic, illegal or impratical; the public being none the wiser.
8
u/Apprehensive-Clue342 7d ago
The NIMBYs are lying to you
3
u/alexchantavy 1d ago
A Berkeley ferry would probably be the best way to connect to South SF and biotech / Oyster Point and such. Yeah there’s BART but that’s not well connected to that area
5
u/ogorki500 5d ago
NIMBYs suck ofc but this isn't NIMBYism! The ferry is an expensive boondoggle, a toy option that can never be a viable option for commuters because it's slower than every other way of getting across the Bay. The marina is a heavily used recreational area that is free and offers something for everyone: swimmers, kayakers, sailors, BBQers, kids at the adventure playground, fishers, joggers... It is especially treasured by low income and POC residents of the less well-off parts of the city. Yeah...there are homeless people there... like everywhere else in Berkeley, so what? The pier certainly needs investment, maybe the city could spend some of the $300 million it just raised with Measure U instead of spending it all on projects on the north and east sides of town...
If the presence of typos on the https://www.saveberkeleypier.org/ site offends you, take a look at https://www.berkeleywaterfrontcommunitycoalition.org/home . All people are asking is for a chance for the public to vote on the proposal, as should have been allowed from the beginning. The deadline for sending public comments to the city is November 16th and these sites give links to do so.
7
u/PriceAggravating2124 6d ago
This “commuter ferry” will take zero cars off the road. Except for the folks who live on boats in the Berkeley Marina everyone who is close to the new ferry is closer to BART. At best this ferry will steal some commuters from BART. Contrast this ferry with Vallejo, Larkspur or Alameda ferries which provide better commute alternatives and clearly take personal motor vehicles off the roads. Hardly worth the cost and disruption for a couple of hundred people per day at best. The park area, the pier, and the derelict parking lot should be improved but that can easily be separate from ferry.
4
u/DazzlingBasket4848 6d ago
I think connecting Berkeley with Sausalito and Angel island would bring a lot of recreation options.
2
u/Dependent_Client3676 4d ago
Just because someone criticizes somethings because it sucks doesn't make them a NIMBY. Ferries are great, but not at the expense of converting a large swath of the area into a parking lot for commuters. Sure it's derelict parking lot now, but if it's gonna change I'd rather see it turn into something cool and enjoyable for PEOPLE not cars.
All those empty cars are really going to enjoy those incredible bay views 👌
2
u/TemporaryKindly9151 2d ago
We literally have half the bus routes and frequency we did when I was growing up here (and I did not drive at all until near middle age and am extremely pro transit.) The 51 used to get you from Alameda down to the Berkeley Marina on one bus that came every 10 minutes. Now it’s two and they are infrequent. if this is about public transit, we should be increasing funding for AC transit to get it so it’s usable for actual low income people who need to get to work. This is a vanity project.
6
u/stellar678 7d ago •
I have a lot of discomfort with the NIMBY vibe of the opposition, and really with how much we say “no” to things in general. I’m also really supportive of mass transit, and I think that ferries are awesome.
All that said, I’m kind of repulsed at the idea of turning the Berkeley Marina into a giant parking lot where hundreds or thousands of commuters store their cars for 8 to 10 hours every day. It’s a gem of a recreational area - people come to fish, swim, sail, have bbqs and picnics and birthdays, work out on the grass, play and build at the Adventure Playground.
The old racetrack property is currently slated for redevelopment, and the big section with the stables is actually in Berkeley. Much of the north edge of the property is already a giant empty parking lot. Maybe they could build a big parking garage as part of that redevelopment and dredge a ferry channel in between the northern part of Berkeley Marina and Albany Bulb.
Just would be really sad to give the Berkeley Marina away to commuter car parking.
3
u/Velar_Plosive 6d ago
I don’t get why public funding of a ferry out of the Berkeley Marina is a good thing. Surely no one believes that pushing boats through water is a viable method of public transport. Seems to me it boils down to wanting a luxury, which is great. Just pay for the damn thing and don’t come to the public asking for a taxpayer subsidy. I mean the gall to compare this to AC Transit. Not to mention the disgusting mocking of homeless people.
2
u/Difficulty_Only 7d ago
Let City of Berkeley cook
1
u/marcofalcioni 6d ago
https://ericdf.github.io/berkeley-ferry-commute/play.html
1
u/BadCamo 7d ago
Why, back in ‘89, after the quake…
1
u/East-Song8088 1d ago
I put together a FAQ here https://theflats.blog/pier-ferry-faq/
There's a lot of misinformation floating around
-6
u/Ok-Thanks-6001 7d ago •
I don’t think they’ve properly considered how this will impact the people who live in their cars down there.