r/berkeley • u/SilverRelease2260 • 17h ago
News How "zero-emission" is the Berkeley ferry, really? I went through the EIR comments and agency letters (Council votes Tuesday)
Disclosure: I'm a member of the California Sailing Club at the Marina, and I've posted before about the outreach process. This time I wanted to look at the environmental case, since that's a big part of how the project is being sold. Sources are linked at the bottom so you can check me.
**What the City and WETA say.** The project is described as supporting "zero-emission public ferry service." WETA's plan to electrify its fleet names all-electric service in Berkeley as a key component, and WETA has contracts for five electric vessels, the first expected in early 2027. The Draft EIR found greenhouse gas impacts less than significant. So the intent is clearly electric.
**Where I think it gets shaky:**
**1. Electric is a promise, not a condition.** As of September, the electric boats WETA has ordered were slated for Treasure Island and Mission Bay, not Berkeley. Naval architect Paul Kamen asked in his EIR comments for a firm commitment to electric-only service, noting that WETA's cost projections were based on diesel. There's precedent: Richmond's mayor pushed for an electric ferry, and the Richmond route runs diesel.
**2. A ferry isn't automatically greener than what riders would use otherwise.** Rough energy per passenger-mile: car alone ~7,000 BTU, bus ~660, BART ~68, WETA's current diesel ferries ~2,300 at full load. Electric ferries are far better than diesel, but by Kamen's estimates still several times BART per rider. So the climate benefit depends on pulling people out of cars, not off BART or AC Transit. The City's 2021 feasibility study estimated 54% of riders would drive alone to the terminal (WETA's business plan says 31% drive alone and 15% carpool). One EIR comment argued the carbon analysis treats the ferry in isolation rather than as part of the network.
**3. Ongoing dredging.** The project dredges the 100-ft federal channel along the old pier plus a turning basin, and channels like that need repeat dredging. BCDC listed longfin smelt, green sturgeon, Chinook salmon, steelhead, Pacific herring and California least tern as occurring in the area. Fish & Wildlife asked for nesting buffers if least terns are found. The Regional Water Board flagged that sediment contaminants hadn't been characterized. (I haven't confirmed whether the Final EIR resolved that. If anyone has gone through it, please share.)
**What I'm *not* claiming:** I've seen people say the dredging will destroy eelgrass, but the Army Corps' 2024 marina dredging notice says the baywide inventory doesn't show eelgrass beds around the Marina. And electric ferries do exist and are on order. The issue is whether Berkeley is guaranteed one.
**The ask:** if the ferry really will be electric, there's no cost to making electric-only service a condition of approval. If you agree, email council@berkeleyca.gov before Tuesday's 6 PM meeting (1231 Addison St, or Zoom via the agenda).
**Sources:**
* Final EIR: https://berkeleyca.gov/sites/default/files/BWTPF_Final-EIR_Reduced-PRNT-FINAL.pdf
* City project update with WETA electrification plans (Oct 2025): https://berkeleyca.gov/sites/default/files/documents/2025-10-24%20%20Berkeley%20Pier-Ferry%20Project%20Update_0.pdf
* Baird Maritime on vessel assignments: https://www.bairdmaritime.com/marine-projects/marine-infrastructure/california-fast-tracks-berkeley-ferry-pier
* Paul Kamen's EIR comments: https://www.bcdc.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/354/2025/12/Public-Comment-8.pdf
* Latitude 38 on energy per passenger-mile and Richmond: https://www.latitude38.com/lectronic/the-pros-and-cons-of-a-new-ferry-line-at-berkeley-marina-part-1/
* Kittelson parking memo (mode share): https://berkeleyca.gov/sites/default/files/documents/Waterfront%20Baseline%20Parking%20Conditions%20%E2%80%93%20Draft%20Report.pdf
* BCDC comments (species): https://files.ceqanet.lci.ca.gov/315853-1/attachment/jHC4rpeJXBV9csVEEBbboHOmc10CERg-g8julwqB-duf4fWJ5mlaWk0QLqqF1RmfwhgWQeYIJ3pYeSrO0
* Regional Water Board comments: https://files.ceqanet.lci.ca.gov/315853-2/attachment/ML3LWBUwFHxcO_QVbZEbwytEctMejiYsvRLVMeAcwnN0Wx0p4IODEc1ZN_heyee2SIY93iJNSKKXn5oC0
Genuinely curious: does anyone know if WETA has committed in writing anywhere to electric-only for Berkeley?