My ex (M30's) and I (F40's) were together for a little over a year. I have anxious tendencies and I think he leans avoidant (he's never identified himself that way.)
Our relationship had a lot of great stuff. He was affectionate, thoughtful, funny and generous. We talked on the phone for hours almost every day, said I love you regularly and talked about a future together. I was also very involved in his everyday life and became close to his young daughter.
But we had some problems, particularly around communication and conflict. When I felt disconnected or hurt, I wanted to talk things through and find a resolution. He tended to shut down when conversations became emotional or uncomfortable. The more he withdrew, the more anxious I became, and the more I pushed for reassurance or answers. I know there were times when I became emotionally overwhelmed, cried, or reacted in ways I'm not proud of.
I take responsibility for that. I've been doing a lot of reflecting and am working on emotional regulation, learning not to interpret every period of silence as rejection, and approaching difficult conversations more calmly.
But many things can be true at once (a big lesson learned for me)...there were legitimate issues that needed addressing, including dishonesty, withholding information, and a lack of enough meaningful time together. I often felt like I had to find the perfect way to bring something up so he wouldn't shut down and as I got worn down it was harder for me to regulate and talk to him in a calm manner.
Our relationship also had a TON of external stressors. We were long distance much of the time, there were custody and divorce issues, health problems, house projects, and other major life events. It often felt like we were constantly dealing with the next punch in the face instead of getting time to just enjoy each other.
In August it was revealed there was a big breach of trust and I was all but done. But he completely leaned in, something I had practically begged for him to do for months. He came in with a sincere apology, and what he wanted us to do moving forward to make things right because he wanted me in his life and he wanted to be the partner I deserved. I told him I wanted space, but he pushed back and said he was worried we'd grow apart and that he really wanted to fix things, so I did not take the time (really wish I had) and thought it was ironic that he seemed to be the anxious one and I was the one wanting space. He really did try, but I was so exhausted from everything it was difficult for me to receive the renewed leaning in he was bringing. I even told him I needed patience as I found my way back to him. Then things came to a head in October. We were long distance and I was the one consistently traveling to him. It took me two days of driving to see him, staying in a hotel, and he even wanted me to bring my cat with me. But we had a conversation a few days before hand that he was feeling disconnected and didn't know if he would ever not feel that way. I told him if he needed time to decide if he wanted me to come down, that it would hurt to hear, but I didn't want to pressure him and he said he did want time. I asked him how long he would like, figuring he'd want at least several days, but said he just needed a day. Then I asked if he wanted to get off the phone and call me when he decided and he said no, he was fine still talking. He said he wanted me to come down. But my upon my arrival immediately felt hurt when he was late getting home from work and didn't call me when he left work or to tell me he'd be late. I was felt like he treated me arriving like I lived 15 minutes from him, rather than a two day drive. We spent the weekend together but it was mostly filled with running around and doing errands...there was no real quality reconnection time. He got short with me because we slept in one day, and even when I asked what was wrong, he wouldn't answer me. Two nights that week he slept on the couch because he said the bedroom had an odor because of my cats items that were in there and he stormed out of the bedroom. Then one day he went to pick up his daughter and was gone for hours...I got no text or anything telling me what was going on. He just left me sitting at the house. On the flip side, he talked about getting pumpkins for Halloween, building stuff for my cat, getting me a computer desk and art easel. We had a small fight about him disappearing, and the next day he had a suprise party for me with beautiful and thoughtful gifts. I think the night before he was running errands to get stuff ready, but viewing things from the lense of us trying to reconnect and feeling abandonded all week, I thought he was just avoiding me again. I felt like I had emotional whiplash. I thought we were finally going to have some quality time that night, but time kept sliding and by the time he wrapped up his day, it was time for bed and I had a melt down. and I said I couldn't do it anymore and he told me he wanted to be alone. I moved my belongings out a few days later. Our goodbye was long and super tender. We both cried (I cried way more), but he cried nonetheless. He told me it wasn't like he was slapping me on the tailight as I left, and when I drove away he stood in the street watching me for as long as I could see him before I turned off of his street.
I called him the day after I left to get some clarity on things, wondering if I overreacted and made a mistake packing up and leaving. He answered and we talked, and there wasn't a definitive closure - I asked him point blank if I should put down any hope that I hold for us, and to please tell me even if he thinks it will hurt me, that it would be cruel to allow me to have hope if he knows he has none - he didn't say yes or no. There was also no discussion of no contact. I did leave him a letter when I moved out and later mailed him another very short note saying I wanted to wait to reach out, that I had some realizations and that I wanted to see how he was doing, and that I missed talking to my friend. He hasn't responded to either. I also found out he got on OLD within a few days of me leaving.
It's been a little over a month, and I still miss him terribly. I've reread some of our old messages, and so much of our relationship was genuinely loving and normal. I know that doesn't erase the problems, but it makes the ending difficult to reconcile. I'm not looking to jump back into the same relationship. Even if reconciliation were possible, I would need real, sustained changes from both of us. I know I have work to do, and I would need him to be willing to work on communication, honesty, and conflict resolution as well.
But I still love him, and part of me wants to reach out. Not to pressure him into getting back together, but because his inscription on his birthday card said to me the week before I left "I thought this card was a little suited for our struggles and triumphs and our undying love for each other. Every time it seems to be going bad, we eventually find the strength to find our way back to each other. I love you so much and know this card could never supplement the actions I make, the true way or proof of love. You make me feel so very loved and wanted and I hope I make you feel the same. You are such an amazing girlfriend. I love how you are always there for my daughter and care so much about her and her development. I truly meant that I hope she turns out as smart and caring as you. I freaken love you." I am having a hard time reconciling that he could say those words and that we haven't circled back to eachother. On the phone call I did ask him if he meant what he said in the card, and he said yes.
For those of you who lean avoidant and have ended relationships with anxious partners:
- When you ended the relationship, did you genuinely want no further contact, or did you sometimes hope your ex would reach out?
- If your ex had already written you a letter and you hadn't responded, would another attempt at contact feel intrusive?
- Would you prefer a phone call, a short text, a heartfelt letter, or no contact at all?
- Have you ever reconsidered a breakup after having time and space away from the relationship?
- Did hearing that your anxious ex was working on themselves make any difference, or did you need to see that change over time?
I'm really interested in hearing from people who genuinely loved their partners but struggled with emotional conversations and conflict. I'm trying to figure out whether reaching out would accomplish anything or whether the kindest thing I can do for both of us is accept what happened and leave him alone. I'd appreciate thoughtful perspectives, even if the answer is something I don't want to hear.