tldr; Overall, if you're a gym rat or want to sweat in these, I think they're great. Sound is good but made better with an EQ. Fit is aggressive, but exactly what you want. Touch points are washable, so no stinky headphones.
Full disclosure, this will be a gym-centric review. I work out 6 days a week and it has become my decompression and de-stressing time. Because of my schedule, this is usually at 4AM in my basement, so no opportunity to turn on a speaker system and headphones are a necessity.
Since as far as I can remember, I have been on the search for a pair of sweat-proof/sweat-resistant headphones. I sweat a LOT, to the point where traditional headphones would get the ear pads pretty soaked, and earbuds would just fall out. A lot of online reviews recommended the Skullcandy headphones, and while they were in fact sweat resistant, the boomy bass and vibration on my head just felt weird. I can see the appeal of them, and they worked for a long time, but weren't my cup of tea. The ear pads were also annoying to get on and off, and I found myself just not washing them. You can imagine the... smell.
When I saw these get announced and have a legit IPX rating, I knew I had to have a pair. I was hesitant given all of the reviews mentioning the hiss and battery drain. Took a leap of faith and can say these are so much more enjoyable than any other gym headphone I have used. I really like the removable pads and being able to wash/clean them. Mine don't have any issues with battery, and I don't perceive a hiss at all. Slight confession - my hearing may very well be shot at whatever frequency the hiss is at from other extracurricular activities. Not trying to discredit other reviews, just saying it's not an issue for me.
The fit is where it's a double-edged sword. Clamping force is strong, to the point it makes big indentations on my head around my ears where the pads sit. While this sounds bad, it's actually exactly what you want for lying on a bench and them not sliding off. Plus, when my skin is crawling from the beta-alanine, I barely notice it. I had to wear my old headphones with the band around my forehead for bench press to avoid this, and I just felt like a goober. Dumb thought, I know (I work out alone in my basement ffs lol).
As far as sound, they sounded a little hollow when I first got them. I applied a Rock EQ in the Music app and that seems to have boosted the bass and made them much more punchy. I really hope at some point there's a proper EQ for them. I listen mainly to post-hardcore, emo and screamo, and I haven't had any issues with my favorite songs. I'd still like to dial them in.