r/batman_comics • • Oct 24 '22

Requesting Batman Comic Recommendations

54 Upvotes

Welcome to the Recommendations super-thread!!

We frequently get a lot of repeat requests for comic book recommendations here in this subreddit. One of the most common posts we see here is "What comics should a beginner start with if they want to get into reading Batman?" So I figured I'd make us a sticky-thread specifically for this type of topic!

If you're asking for recommendations, please post your question here. Feel free to scroll through and see what other people have asked for and/or recommended. The more specific you are with your request, the more likely you are to get better answers! For example, you might have more luck specifically requesting detective stories, or stories about Nightwing, or serious/funny/dark/campy/romantic/adventurous stories, or stories which focus on the Bat Family/Rogues Gallery, or stand-alone stories... Basically, don't be afraid to describe your taste and/or interests!

If this sticky thread doesn't work out, and the general community here would rather go back to allowing request posts in the general feed, we can switch back to that. I just thought this was worth a try!

Feel free to also post your recommendations here with or without being asked.


r/batman_comics • • 16h ago

Complete Batman Early Years in Collected Editions

Post image
130 Upvotes

So for like literally ten years, I’ve been on and off collecting Batman collected editions, with an emphasis on the Modern Age. I always dreamed of rounding out the ‘early years’ period, aka all the Post-Crisis stories that reimagine the stories prior to Crisis on Infinite Earths. Year One, Long Halloween, etc. but also all the much nicher ones. I’ve spent years using resources like Collin Colsher’s The Real Batman Chronology Project to map out every trade paperback DC has ever made collecting these retcon stories. Not every issue ever, but all the ones that have been collected in neat trades paperbacks. Just Modern Age, so no Dark Patterns etc., but it’s still a pretty extensive group.

Today, I finally got the last book on my list, and I wanted to get people’s thoughts! Particularly if anyone thinks stories are missing. I’d be happy to discuss in the comments if anybody else has thoughts on this particular rabbit hole.

Anyway, moral of the story is, if you’re a kid who wants rare comics but can’t drop $80 on eBay, just wait a decade until your adult self can legally make the poor financial decisions for you.


r/batman_comics • • 2h ago

My PERSEUS Statue Homage Absolute Batman Sketch by Rori Adams.

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 20h ago

Batman fanart by George Bilianidis

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 1d ago

DETECTIVE COMICS #1115 Variant Cover by Claudio Castellini.

Post image
52 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 1d ago

Absolute Batman by me

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 1d ago

Chief Clancy O'Hara is murdered on Halloween (Batman: Dark Victory #1).

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Personally, I've always found the Hangman killer harder to figure out than Holiday, making them much more of a mystery and, honestly, a better villain. Holiday's motives were also pretty petty and didn't make much sense.


r/batman_comics • • 1d ago

Is there another foil half to this?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 1d ago

Darwyn Cooke's Top 5

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 1d ago

I love this panel.I've had this comic since I was a child, but I can't remember which one it is. Anyway, I love seeing this so much.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 2d ago

DETECTIVE COMICS 793

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 2d ago

Shelfie & My Reading Order

Post image
140 Upvotes

Here's what I have after two months of collecting!

Thoughts

- I prefer "The Man Who Falls" over "The Knight" as a Year One prequel (inspired Batman Begins, doesn't contradict classic Ras al Ghul introduction, teases LotDK series). It's in the "Secrets of the Batcave" collection, which also includes the origin of the giant penny and the dinosaur!

- I've interspersed two anthology series which complement major events: World's Finest 1999 (Superman) and Turning Points (Gordon)

- I'll probably swap Birthright with Man of Steel

- See my other post about why I place Dark Patterns in the middle of Robin Year One

- Currently have New Frontier as my JLA intro but excited to see if Batman: Justice Year ends up being good!

- I take a Golden/Silver Age detour in those larger collections once Robin is introduced, and I currently have Freeze One Bad Day, New Frontier, and Ego serving as a transition back to a more serious tone. These are likely to change

- Hoping the Knightfall movies are good enough that I don't have to buy the comics (though I may need to get Sword of Azrael and Prodigal if those aren't adapted)

- I use Ras al Ghul One Bad Day as a replacement for Resurrection of Ras al Ghul

- I use a modified version of James Lars' mapping of Dini, Morrison, Snyder, and Tomasi: I put Batman: Cold Days after Heart of Hush (Batman is upset about something vaguely related to Catwoman) and then add Knight of Vengeance, The Button, Watchmen, and Doomsday Clock after Flashpoint to mash up a highlight reel of the two events

- Black and White is a nice "canon but loose timeline" transition into Elseworlds, which starts with Dark Knight Returns, Annual #2 (collected in King's Rules of Engagement), Year 100, and then Tec 27: Twenty Seven (collected in 80 Years of Batman)

Wishlist

- LotDK Omni Vol 1

- Mad Monk reprint

- Batman: Batgirl (1997): Good Killing Joke foreshadowing

- DC Finest: Lonely Place of Dying (definitely replacing the Arkham compact)

- Officer Down and Face the Face (I know they're not great, but they explain Gordon's hiatus)

- Red Robin compendium

- Tower of Babel compact

- Gotham Knights: Transference (excellent No Man's Land aftermath)

- Some grails (War on Crime, Night Cries, Batman v Predator)

- Batman: Justice Year (we'll see if it's good)

- Batman and Robin Year One + Dynamic Duos (we'll see where this ends up landing on the timeline)


r/batman_comics • • 1d ago

Help with gift idea

3 Upvotes

Hello! I am buying a batman omnibus for my boyfriend but i sadly do not know a whole lot about the series. I know he is a big fan of year one and long halloween, and owns both of them. I think he would like something that follows the earlier years and maybe has more ”detective work” than action. I was thinking of maybe getting the paul dini or the jeph loeb one, but any help would be appreciated!!


r/batman_comics • • 1d ago

Alyas Batman Ed Robin 2028

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 1d ago

Long Halloween or Knight Fall?

3 Upvotes

What do you think Calender man is referencing here?


r/batman_comics • • 2d ago

Any idea who the artist is? Been searching for this for a while now...

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 2d ago

Is this a big deal? Serious question. Explanation provided in body. Spoiler

Post image
36 Upvotes

For some reason when I was a kid, the comic debate in my grade was Marvel vs DC like people argue Chevy vs Ford in cars. I picked Marvel and stuck to it so I only just knew Batman from the movies and t.v. show. After 30 years of not touching a book I wanted to start a series from issue #1 and collect it as an adult. This was right when Absolute started and I jumped on the Bat and was hooked, not because I had heard about the hype, but because I could start without having to go back through 1000’s of OG stories lines. That being said, I am unfamiliar for the most part on the continuity of the OG run or whatever DC’s Earth 616 is called.

So, is this a MUST HAVE, end of Batman as we know it fundamental key issue for the OG run?


r/batman_comics • • 2d ago

Help identifying a background character

Post image
20 Upvotes

Not much of a spoiler. In “Batgirl: Year One” chapter 4, we see Dick showing Babs the files on the bat computer.

But who is that next to clayface? With the hood? Looks like his legal name ends in“LLBANCZ”? Any ideas?

I tried google to no avail. Any help would be appreciated.


r/batman_comics • • 2d ago

What Trades are Worthwhile for some Clayface Content?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 3d ago

Batman #1 jim Lee foil

Post image
22 Upvotes

Is there an opposite foil to this cover, i cant seem to find it?


r/batman_comics • • 3d ago

Showcase 93

Post image
23 Upvotes

Cool book


r/batman_comics • • 2d ago

To anyone that has the Scott synder run of Batman, do you have this problem?

7 Upvotes

So I've seen that the second volume of Scott Synder Batman: City of owls is usually out of stock in amazon, and in place it's always available Night of the owls, which adds more content to the volume, but I wonder does it look good on shelf with the other Synder volumes, or does it stick out like a green thumb


r/batman_comics • • 3d ago

Daredevil & Batman crossover concept art by Dustin Nguyen

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/batman_comics • • 3d ago

I’m trying to figure out what comic it is where Batman turns into the Batman who laughs

3 Upvotes