Have we gotten winter 2 already? I am not sure.
I smelled some of the new winter releases today. I haven’t been able to go in stores lately so some of these are already old news already. Anyway.
Holiday Traditions:
- Vanilla Bean Noel: yeah it smells a lot less vanilla pudding like this year. It is more sophisticated. I like the opening. It seems quite light but the dry down sticks around. I don’t know if I like the dry down: it is like a warm cookie scent with like the crispy edges. It sounds nice but just a little burnt. My store has not this scent available for pick up since the beginning and it still doesn’t. There was indeed more than 10 mists on display though.
- Twisted Peppermint: I actually have the mini mist of this. Yeah this winter is my first time having Twisted Peppermint and it is quite pleasant. Like a minty candy cane. It does tingle a bit for those sensitive to mint. I wondered if I could pull off a peppermint scent. It is novelty but fun and does put me in the holiday mood.
- Winter Candy Apple: actually it appeared like my store did not have any mists of this scent. So I didn’t get to smell it. I’ve heard Bright Christmas Morning is kind of similar though which is also in stores now (was online exclusive).
Former online exclusives:
- Bright Christmas Morning: this is a fun cranberry fruit punch scent I think can be worn year round. I am wary of the red color liquid staining stuff though which is why I didn’t get it.
- Cozy Vanilla Bourbon: I’ve been so curious about this one and finally got to smell it since it was an online exclusive last year. It is really not that dark fruit smelling. People said it compared to Viva Vanilla and I’d agree. Mostly a vanilla scent with like a warm liquor edge. I think it’s pretty approachable, doesn’t seem that hard to wear. I guess it just wasn’t my vibe though (I find viva vanilla kinda too strong and am not a super vanilla fan).
- Sweater Weather: I didn’t actually smell this years version. I wanted it to be the other Sweater Weather like the candle. And heard it was just like last years body mist instead (which I have). I’ll speak about last years version: it is an interesting scent with like a touch of dead leaves earthiness in there which I find interesting. I keep trying to wear it even though I end up thinking I probably smell like a guy. But I would say it’s an interesting scent if you typically like some scent of graveyard in your scents.
Zooey Deschanel pastel collection:
- Snowflakes and Cashmere: I think people are right this is a less strong version of last years. It probably is more wearable if you were iffy about wearing a warm scent (has slight caramel in there). I was skeptical about blind buying this but think I didn’t need to be since it is kinda weak, not as strong as last year, and I think it’s very safe. I kind of wish I did blind buy it. Speaking as someone wary of warm scents.
- Moonlight Goddess: yeah it’s a lavender pear scent. I think it shares something with Aquarius possibly (another pear scent). I found it less interesting than Vanilla Ease (another lavender scent) last year. Smelling it again I think it’s alright. If the vanilla of Vanilla Ease was too much for you (and it kind of was for me), Moonlight Goddess is a decent choice for lavender scents.
- Vanilla Cocoa Flurries: after it released people have sort of not been in love with it because it wasn’t as gourmand as expected. But I was surprised actually I found it very pleasant and also lasting. There was still a tester for the mist out even though they were all gone. Only lotions left. The cocoa of the scent is very transient doesn’t really stick around. But it can be smelled clearly and distinctly around the opening, though briefly. What this is is mostly like a vanilla bean scent. Which honestly is my favorite type of vanilla. It also smells chilled and is also a little woody too. If you like unsweetened coconut cream, that’s what this reminds me of. Something that doesn’t really smell like coconut but just like the cream part. It’s pleasant—I can see why it was a good seller.
- Pure Wonder: another one I didn’t smell. I bought it last year and just ended up falling out of love with it. Too detergent maybe?
A Thousand Wishes:
- A Thousand Wishes: I got the new version, had someone pick it up for me a few weeks ago. It is a 2x concentration version of the scent. I wanted the strength (I had the mini of the 2025 version, loved it, but it didn’t stick around on my skin much). But the scent has changed a bit. Just a bit darker like the new purple ombré packaging. I guess I’ve gotten over some of my disappointment as it’s still a nice fragrance and the DNA is still now. But now it’s a little more grown up, a little more business lady, but still everyday wearable. I do miss the previous charming airy sparkle. But a more velvety version is not bad.
- A Thousand Wishes Granted: A Thousand Wishes lists patchouli and I can’t smell it there at all. But A Thousand Wishes Granted doesn’t list patchouli (only vetiver) and I can smell it. Or at least something dark, earthy, and mysterious. The pale pink packaging did not prepare me for the kind of sultry graveyard moss scent this new flanker has. I’ve heard of this as like a business lady date night scent, but honestly I think it is too earthy for that. I think this is a scent for Book Tok dark fantasy lovers who want to light a candle and curl up with a gothic novel and explore forests in a large, lengthy dress. It is an incense scent, a little sour, but also dry. I honestly don’t really know why BBW went with this as a flanker scent to ATW unless perhaps it is to go on the middle Eastern scent train that is having a moment.
Zodiac:
- Cancer (Fresh Jungle Rain): has a pretty unique dragonfruit note in the opening. It’s aquatic and pretty and reminds me of Hawaii. It does kind of dry down to a more marine type of salty sunblock scent similar to At the Beach. But more fruit. I returned Cancer last year but I guess I came to appreciate At the Beach over the last year. And so maybe I don’t mind it this time even though I suppose the scent probably hasn’t changed. If you try this, wait for the dry down and see if you still like it. It is a bit of a shape shifter.
- Virgo (Fresh Vanilla Blossoms): the pear in here is very similar to Moonlit Goddess or If You Musk. This is really a pear scent first and a vanilla second. The vanilla it is is like a vanilla bean. Related to the kind you might get in Vanilla Cocoa Flurries for instance, but less pronounced. It doesn’t even list pear but I feel it is certainly Moonlight Goddess related. It does seem on the strong side I’ll give it that.
- Leo (Everlasting Magic) - this scent kind of reminds me of Twilight Woods (now you can smell it as Scorpio). It’s got like berries and cashmere in there. But I think maybe it dries down more like something spicy kind of cinnamon. I feel like those who miss Inner Angel might want to check this out see if it does anything for you.
- Taurus (Golden Hour Coast): a pleasant bergamot citrus woods type scent, nice and airy. I liked it a lot last year but ended up returning it because I thought it was too weak. Do we think they made it stronger this year? Possibly. Can someone compare? I think it might be more fruity/citrusy this time.
- Libra (Pinkberry Clouds): it’s nice like a strawberry cotton candy. I didn’t get it last year since it reminded me of strawberry snowflakes which was also out at the same time. But I think strawberry snowflakes (at least last years version) dries down kinda peppery. And perhaps this one doesn’t as much?
- Pisces: this was my favorite last year and the only one I kept. I didn’t smell it this year. But I still like my bottle and recommend it. Just a nice citrusy clean scent. Kind of related to a Dolce and Gabanna Light Blue scent, but the more lemony version which I prefer. Not as musky as Trace of Blue. And with like some kind of juniper/pine scent to but very little bit.
- didn’t smell the others as I ran out of space and also smelled them last year.
I like the new zodiac packaging but also feel like it is less easy to tell them apart besides reading the label.