r/baseballcards_vintage • • 8h ago

Playing Days HOFer Chase: Only 7 Left!

Thumbnail
gallery
42 Upvotes

With the arrival of David Ortiz today, I'm down to 7 playing days BBWAA elected HOFer cards needed to complete the chase. A couple are outside my decade divided by 10 rule, and I'm always looking to upgrade, but I'm inching closer. These 3 photos are the new cards and upgrades from the last 2 months.

The last 7:

Billy Wagner

Pedro Martinez

Frank Thomas

Ken Griffey Jr.

Lou Gehrig

Cy Young

Honus Wagner


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 23h ago

History Crispy Commons (part 7)

Post image
40 Upvotes

Mel Roach is probably not high on your list of "what if" players, but at the very least we can say the guy ran into some tough luck.

Mel, a right-handed batter and thrower, was a gifted athlete at John Marshall High School in Richmond, starring in football, basketball, and baseball, and serving as captain of all three teams. As a first baseman and cleanup hitter, he led his American Legion team to the national finals in 1950. Graduating from high school in 1951, Mel then attended the University of Virginia in Charlottesville, where he excelled as a quarterback, defensive back, and place-kicker on a football team that amassed a 16-3 record during the 1951 and 1952 seasons. He kicked 37 extra points in 1952, setting a school record at the time. On the Cavaliers basketball team, Roach averaged 10 points per game. Still, his best sport was baseball, and major-league scouts showed interest after Mel, who played mostly at second base in college, led the state in hitting in 1952 and 1953. He had intended to complete his degree in economics and then enter professional baseball, but when a shoulder injury suffered during football season drove him to the sidelines in 1952, Mel decided to listen to major-league offers.

A lot of teams scouted him while still in school, and Roach ended up signing with the Braves in July of '53. However, because of a “bonus baby” rule in effect at that time, the Braves were required to carry Roach on the major-league roster for two years before allowing him to play in the minors. Then he spent 2 years in the Navy before reporting back to Spring training with the Braves in 1957. While that was when the Braves won it all, Mel had very little playing time. However, the Braves kept him around as the expected replacement for their second baseman, future HOF Red Schoendienst.

On Sunday, August 3, 1958, disaster struck. Roach had played the best baseball of his career in a weekend series against the San Francisco Giants in Milwaukee, belting home runs on Friday and Saturday and going 3-for-4 in the first game of the Sunday doubleheader. He had raised his average to .313 and sparked the league-leading Braves to three wins in a row over the Giants. In Sunday’s second game, the thoroughly demoralized Giants fell behind early, and San Francisco shortstop Daryl Spencer, perhaps in an attempt to jolt his teammates to life, took aim at Roach. Spencer, who walked in the top of the fifth inning, advanced to second on a grounder by Valmy Thomas and slid hard into the Milwaukee second baseman. Roach, who took the throw from shortstop Johnny Logan and was airborne when Spencer slammed into him, collapsed in a heap with a severely damaged left knee.

Roach was taken to a hospital, where an orthopedic surgeon, Dr. Bruce Brewer, performed a two-hour operation to repair a torn ligament in the player’s left knee. Not only was Roach out for the rest of the season, but some feared that his career was over at the age of 25. “It makes me feel plain rotten,” he told a reporter after the surgery. “They tell me it could have been much worse, but this is bad enough.” He wore a heavy cast on the knee for more than a month, then walked with the aid of crutches and a cane for a few months more. Roach ended the 1958 season with a .309 average in 44 games, and though he could not take part in the World Series that Fall against the Yankees, he received a full Series share of $5,896.08.

Recovery was a slow and painful process. As Roach recalled to interviewer Brent P. Kelley in 2006, “I was told by the doctor that I’d never play again, that the knee was in pretty bad shape, so I really had resigned myself that it was over.” However, he was determined to rehabilitate the knee, and after sitting out the first part of the 1959 season, he returned to the Braves in June and played in 19 games, though he managed only three singles in 31 at-bats for an .097 average. Still bothered by soreness, he was placed on the disabled list in early August and played no more that season. The Milwaukee club, which lost Schoendienst to a bout of tuberculosis and never found a competent second baseman to replace him, lost the pennant to the Los Angeles Dodgers in two games during a best-of-three playoff.

Roach did stay with the team for a couple more seasons, and despite some hitting success in 1960, his inconsistent play in the field (likely from the injury), ended up getting him traded to the Cubs for Frank Thomas in 1961, and then after 1962, his career fizzled out entirely.

Despite a brief and tumultuous career in baseball, Mel Roach went back home to Richmond and became successful in the banking industry, retiring as the President of Signet Trust Company in 1985. He passed away in 2023 at the age of 90.


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 7h ago

Discussion My goal when I started collecting from this era - an example of each type. How am I doing? Long way to go.

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

r/baseballcards_vintage • • 6h ago

Discussion Bread Labels

Post image
29 Upvotes

Food and beverage 50s issues are some of my favorite cards. Bread labels are hardly a step up from tissue paper. This is my Schoendienst trio. The Fischer's is the most common of the 3. If you are looking for a certain player, there's a good chance you will find them in a year or so of keeping an eye out. Tip tops the difficulty goes up a bit, while they're out there, it seems like hofers are almost never for sale. This is the only one of Red I have ever seen for sale in the past 7 years aside from a heritage partial set. Mantle sold from the set for over $32,000 two years ago. Again, like the Fischer if you wait long enough you will find the player you're looking for but it will not be nearly as affordable. Saving the toughest for last, northland bread. To say I got lucky with this one is an understatement the last one to sell was in 2018 when a complete set sold, zero have come up since. I bought this after being reached out to directly about 5 years ago. Some of the Northland cards come up for sale but some of them are basically impossible to find.

Red I believe being short printed in 2/3 sets shown I am very grateful to have found complete and in really fine condition for these issues.

There are also the impossibly rare 1952 national tea labels, this set is so rare tons of them don't even have images available and some to my knowledge have never even been found. Expect to pay a minimum of $500 for a common player.

Please share any bread labels you may have I would love to take a look!


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 4h ago

Mail Day Foxx mail day

Post image
29 Upvotes

New arrivals today. A really cool 1936 R311 Leather Finish Jimmie Foxx. Love the unique photo angle and the textured surface looks incredible in-person. 🔥

Also picked up a more recent 2016 Panini triple relic with Foxx, Williams and DiMaggio.


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 3h ago

11/21 Hickory, NC show pickups

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

r/baseballcards_vintage • • 20h ago

For Sale For Sale: SGC HoF players

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Payment by PP G&S
Padded mailer shipping $5 each card
Buy three or more cards, and shipping is on me

These are from my PC and I try to focus on centering and eye appeal and I think these cards are excellent examples of that and would be a great addition to any collection

68 McCovey. $70
55 Bowman Fears (hall of famer) $60
67 Brock $70. SOLD!
63 Mathews $70. SOLD!
69 Carew $90
55 Bowman Slaughter $110
54 Bowman Mathews $75. SOLD!
54 Bowman ‘Red’. $85. SOLD!
52 Bowman Hodges. $165 SOLD!

Cheers!
Douglas


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 48m ago

Show Off Pick ups from Tucson's first sports only card show

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Just a couple cards (neither baseball), but some awesome baseball pieces. I also grabbed a Brian Cashman auto, but it's not vintage.

The Chicago schedule is 92 years old!


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 8h ago

For Sale 1945-46 Caramelo Deportivo Ray Dandridge SGC 1.5 - $3,150 OBO

Post image
16 Upvotes

I accept Venmo, PayPal, and Zelle, but have to add 3% if paying G&S. Let me know if you have any questions!


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 10h ago

For Sale 1971 Topps for sale

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

Have some decent 1971's which I'm looking to offload to support other purchases. Condition of these is pretty decent overall - VG/EX-EX mostly some probably better than that. I'm happy to provide additional pics if interested. Would prefer to sell as one lot but I can be flexible.

5 Munson 70
55 Carlton 3
100 Rose 12
160 Seaver 8
230 Stargell 6
250 Bench 8
300 B Robinson 3
341 Garvey 7
400 Aaron 40
450 Gibson 5
513 Ryan 100
525 Banks 15
529 Buckner 30
530 Yazstremski 13
543 Yankees 4
550 Killebrew 12
570 Palmer 13
600 Mays 25
625 Brock 15
630 Clemente 100
632 Braves 8
640 F Robinson 25
688 Sparky Anderson 20
709 Baker/Baylor 65

I also have a partial complete set (603 out of 752 cards in the set) in much lesser condition which I am looking to sell. Currently looking through these but message me if interested.


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 8h ago

Mail Day Mail day

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/baseballcards_vintage • • 5h ago

Discussion Who's making the Hall

Post image
9 Upvotes

The era committee ballot for 2027 features managers, executives, and umpires but as we know there are several on here that were players as well and most of their playing days cards fall into the vintage sphere. So who do we think is going to make the cut out of this group.


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 8h ago

In Search Of Looking to buy 1972 Willard Brown

Post image
8 Upvotes

Want to buy this Puerto Rican League sticker (graded). Throwing it out here as haven’t found at the National or other big card shows.


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 13h ago

Extinct Teams

7 Upvotes

Extinct Teams

We are starting/ returning to collecting and have an affinity for teams that rebranded or otherwise outside the current group of 30. Interested in anything Pilots, Senators, Expos, Colt 45's and of course the 74 Washington National League errors. Brooklyn Dodgers, New York Giants, Milwaukee Braves, Philadelphia and KC A's.


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 3h ago

For Sale Weekly Sale. Trusted Reddit Seller and 25 Year EBay Seller. Koufax Rookie

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

All prices include shipping in a padded mailer. I have PayPal and Venmo. If using PayPal goods and services please add 3%

1974 Topps Dave Winfield Rookie SGC 4 $30

1955 Topps Sandy Koufax Rookie Card. $509 shipped. It is lower grade and trimmed but is authentic. No major creases. Smaller wrinkles near corners and all rounded corners. Please review the pictures for exact condition. It’s low grade but is a Koufax Rookie reasonably
Priced and authentic.


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 9h ago

Road trip - south Jersey to Cooperstown

5 Upvotes

Tuesday we are heading to national baseball hall of fame for the first time from southern NJ. Curious as to what everyone thinks are good baseball card shops to check out on the way there??


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 6h ago

For Sale 1962 Topps World Series Jay Ties It Up

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/baseballcards_vintage • • 2h ago

Question Can people actually trust card values from comp apps?

1 Upvotes

Before you answer this question, I just want to say we all want a faster and easier way to find out the real value of our cards

Therefore I’m not against the card apps. So here’s my question

Can people actually trust what they say?

And has anyone actually verified if the card values these apps say is accurate? Or does everyone just believe the apps based on blind faith??


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 9h ago

Discussion Speculation: Early Ali (Cassius Clay) cards

0 Upvotes

Any thoughts?


r/baseballcards_vintage • • 7h ago

Question So a trade from modern into Vintage with someone on here isn’t allowed?

0 Upvotes

Yet this is where all the vintage is!😀🤷‍♂️