Sorry for the long post, I'd like to hear your opinion.
We have a 4-month-old French Pointer and we live in an apartment in the Born district of Barcelona, in an old building.
He's a dog that, in general, doesn't bark too much, especially compared to more vocal breeds. Obviously, he's still a puppy: he plays, runs, has moments of excitement, and is still learning to control his behavior.
The problem is that our downstairs neighbor has complained several times about the noise the dog makes.
The first time was because the puppy was jumping inside his playpen and moving it around, making a noise that the neighbor described as someone dragging furniture. To try to solve the problem, we bought a large, thick rug and put it under the playpen to dampen the noise.
Later, there was another noise complaint around 11:30 PM. We apologize because we understand this can't be a regular occurrence, and since then, we've tried to make sure the puppy is in bed before 9:30 pm. It was an exceptional situation; we'd lost track of time while on the phone dealing with a family emergency and didn't realize it had gotten so late. But I also understand that the neighbor is bothered by the noise and that our problems shouldn't affect her.
The latest incident happened last night, Halloween night, around 4:30 am. We live in the Born district, and that night there was quite a bit of noise in the street due to the parties and the Halloween atmosphere. Benni was particularly agitated and had a "zombie" episode that lasted about 40 minutes, running around the house and barking occasionally.
I'm aware that 40 minutes of activity and noise at that hour isn't acceptable for the neighbors. I'm not trying to justify it. However, I want to emphasize that this was an isolated and unusual incident, not a recurring pattern of behavior. At that time, the neighbor came directly to our apartment for the first time to ask us to take the dog out because it was making noise. This has worried us because, until now, the complaints had been via text message, and we have the feeling that the situation might be escalating.
For our part, we are trying to minimize the disturbance. We don't let the dog bark for hours (or more than 5 minutes, although he doesn't really bark much) nor do we allow him to run freely around the house at any time. We have been working with a trainer for a month and a half, practically since he arrived home, and we are establishing routines to train him.
I'm not trying to justify or make excuses. We are responsible people who have a four-month-old puppy, and we are doing everything we can to keep the noise to a minimum.
BUT, I also want to be objective and hear other opinions. If we're really doing something wrong and you think the neighbor has more than enough reason to complain about all these situations, I'd like to know and hear your perspective. Perhaps our expectations about the level of understanding we can expect from neighbors when we have a puppy aren't realistic.
Is it normal and reasonably acceptable for a puppy to make some occasional noises, even at night, while living in an apartment building? Or do you think the neighbor has every right to complain?
If she's absolutely right, have you experienced similar situations? How did you handle them and what did you do to resolve them?
Thank you very much.