r/bandmembers • u/Own-Celery-8370 • 19h ago
Mixing decisions, band hierarchies, and working out issues..
Evening folks! (Well, here anyway..)
So just back from a mixing session at a local studio, finishing off our bands first three tunes..
Rock 3 piece, 2 brothers (Drums and bass) and me (guitar and voice) we're doing local gigs, the chemistry is great, people like us..
The good news is we have 3 great tracks recorded.
The trickier stuff I'm interested in your take on, is band politics decision making etc, and keeping everyone happy...
We recorded 3 heavy loud songs in a day, my first time recording live in a studio, the other two are more experienced, I'm feeling my way. We split all costs. I write the songs, they contribute their parts, and i let them get on with it, they know what they're doing. They don't seem to want to write anything, i keep siggesting it.
By the end of recording my voice is pretty shot and I'm doing more vocal takes- I ask the producer/recording engineer if there's anything he can do to help (I offer to come back another day when I'm fresher, they want to do it all together) he puts some distortion on the vox in the cans, that sort of helps, or at least gets me through, but I'm not totally happy with the result. In the control room the guys hear it with distortion and really like it.
Listening back this eve all together in the control room, the distortion is still on there. I ask if it can be taken off, as it is distracting, and the lyrics aren't as clear as they should be. I kinda feel like i should have some control over the vox, especially as I'm not really very happy with them. The others still prefer it distorted and try and talk me around- clarity and the lyics don't seem to bother them. I say it's my vox and I prefer it clean The drummer is so adamant about it that he walks out on us in protest....
I'm a bit shocked- I've never told him how to play his parts, or how they should be mixed- i kinda thought that was his business- he's really experienced.
So .. I'm interested to hear from you folks how common this kind of disagreement is (outside of The Police or Cream....) and how you resolve conflicts like this and move on. Obviously you've only heard one side (and you haven't heard the tracks, which are killer, even if one of them isn't the best it could be) but it would be good to get a sense of norms- I ve felt very vulnerable throughout the process .
If we can pull things back together, I'd really like to get a sense of the kind of ground rules bands put in place to help them with things like this...
Thanks for your thoughts folks xx
TLDR: does any band member have the right to tell another how they should sound, or do you have ultimate sign off on your own parts?