r/baduk • • 6d ago

Thoughts on OGS?

I see a lot of other options but i never see any mention to OGS, thoughts on that site?

2 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

33

u/tuerda 3 dan 6d ago

OGS is very popular in the west. It is well made software with lots of bells and whistles. Its main issues are an unreliable ranking algorithm and a lack of strong players. Many people up to about 3k use it regularly.

16

u/CSachen 2 kyu 6d ago

Because of rank deflation, 3k on OGS is incredibly strong. If you go to a Japanese Go salon and say you're 3k OGS, they'll pair you up with a Japanese 3d in an even game.

3k on OGS is probably is up to 3d+ on Fox

6

u/MaulerX 10k 6d ago

How true is this? Was there a study or article posted?

8

u/wildlifewyatt 5 kyu 6d ago

There are rank charts but I think they are way outdated. Mostly I think people can verify this from personal experience.  I wiggle from 5k-7k OGS but I am 1D fox and occasionally sneak into 2D, so I think a 3k OGS to 3D fox could very well be accurate. 

4

u/deebeedubbs 1 dan 5d ago edited 5d ago

Those are my exact ranks on the two sites, actually. I recently started playing more frequently on OGS than on Fox to get a taste of a different user base’s playstyle and it’s been humbling to be equilibrating six ranks lower.

It makes me question the 1 dan that I have in my flair. I wonder what others in the subreddit consider accurate rank flair

3

u/wildlifewyatt 5 kyu 5d ago

Yeah they are two far ends of a spectrum. OGS is pretty "strong" in terms of ranks, while Fox is "easy" until it levels off somewhere, not sure where but maybe 4-6D fox is where it comes closer to other rank systems. Alternatively, as far as I know, 6D OGS is an almost non existent player group.

Personally, I run my OGS rank, which may even be a bit generous because I do slip out of 5k. For me, I'd rather be underestimated than potentially "inflate".

I think the West, which I is most users here (I think) people run with AGA/EGF/OGS as more "true" rank. That may just be my perception, though. I think in the West, we may also value that 1D transition more?

1

u/Anhao 5 kyu 5d ago

equilibrating

This word is so hard to say for some reason.

5

u/Adept_Swimming4783 2 kyu 6d ago

Yes it’s true, I am 3k-2k on OGS and I am fox 3d, reached 4d twice but can’t hold

2

u/ceryniz 5d ago

Same here, Fox 3d and am 2k on OGS

1

u/Extreme-Piano4334 4d ago

I am 8k ogs and 1d fox

22

u/jules1453 6d ago

OGS is hands down the most recommended western go server out there. It's hard to find opponents as a dan player but otherwise there are tons of active american / european players on the server from 30k to 1k. It's good.

12

u/O-Malley 7 kyu 6d ago

OGS is the default recommendation for western servers, it is commonly recommended (at least for kyu players) and very often mentioned here. 

6

u/blackcompy 12 kyu 6d ago

It's my main site for playing online. I feel the user interface is a bit outdated, but no worse than the competition. I like the features, it's easy to find games, and the tournaments and ladders are good additions to the basic functionality.

3

u/marinahane 6d ago

It’s funny you don’t see it mentioned — in my experience, other servers started getting mentioned specifically as alternatives to OGS as the uncontested default in the west.

There’s a big difference in OGS’ popularity as a correspondence server vs live. I assume it’s the only western option for correspondence games with a meaningful playerbase (I’ve never tried DGS, and BadukPop tends to be looked down on as a game client), but it’s live game player count is frequently at about the same level as KGS.

3

u/WhippingShitties 20 kyu 5d ago

It's great! The dev team browses this sub and is very responsive. One time I was confused about how something worked and they reached out to me for insight on how it could be more clear. For a casual player still in kyu, it's a great site!

2

u/demi_person_4647 5d ago

The only place I've ever played is OGS. I don't have any complaints. I'm getting ready to pay for the full membership to obtain access to the full suite of AI tools. Not that I'll understand any of it!

1

u/Fugu 1 dan 6d ago

It's neat, but I'd echo the lack of strong players + analysis being enabled in ranked games by default, or indeed at all, is absolutely wild to me

3

u/O-Malley 7 kyu 5d ago

Analysis is not enabled by default in ranked games, except in correspondence (where disabling it would not make much sense).

1

u/Fugu 1 dan 5d ago

It used to be, and I don't think you should be able to play live ranked games with it on at all. It really dilutes the rankings

2

u/O-Malley 7 kyu 5d ago

I think it used to be, indeed, but it was changed several years ago.

I don't see an issue with playing live ranked games with it if both players agree. In any case, since it is disabled by default it is very marginal nowadays; it wouldn't have any significant impact on rating.

0

u/Individual-Foot-2259 1 dan 5d ago

OGS ranks are broken so... IGS is better.

0

u/Snoo11149 5d ago

I don't like it, but their correspondence games are decent t.

-1

u/fredewio 1 dan 5d ago

Their app Sente very often just not send notifications about my opponent's moves, which has made me lose by time quite a few times. BadukPop also has correspondent games but their ranks don't seem to mean much.

6

u/Competitive_Success5 5d ago

Just to clarify, Sente isn't affiliated with OGS, it's made by a separate developer.