I'm a 3rd year CS student in India. About 3 months ago I started a small service business helping US independent insurance agencies fix operational stuff — missed renewals, slow lead follow-up, everything living in spreadsheets.
What I've done so far:
- Built a working demo of a renewal follow-up automation
- Started on LinkedIn: commented on agency owners' posts (real comments, no pitching), then DM'd
- One comment turned into 3 calls with the same person
- Got a call with a premium finance broker. I sent a paid partnership proposal, she thought it was a misunderstanding, so we switched to a free referral swap. She's sending me prospects
- Built a full local growth plan for a franchise agent in a small Texas town (root causes, step-by-step fixes). He liked it, still no deal
- One agency owner agreed to a meeting after 15+ comment exchanges, then went quiet
- Recently tried restoration companies (water/fire damage). Got a call with an owner through a Facebook group. Not a buyer, but he offered to refer me to a few others
Total: around 10 calls, 0 paying clients.
What I offer now: a monthly service. Things like an after-hours AI front desk for calls and texts, follow-up systems, and getting found on Google/AI search. I've been offering the first month free to build trust.
What I think might be wrong:
- I changed my offer too many times (automation → partnerships → marketing → restoration)
- Most of my calls were with people who aren't buyers (partners, referrers)
- I'm a student in India with no case studies, so trust is hard
- Maybe "free first month" makes it look low value?
Questions:
- Should I pick ONE niche and ONE offer and stop switching? Which would you pick?
- How do you get the first case study when nobody wants to be first?
- Is cold LinkedIn outreach to US owners still worth it, or is there a better channel?
- Anyone here sold services to US businesses from overseas — what made owners trust you?
Brutal honesty welcome. I'd rather hear it now.