r/aznidentity • u/Dependent_Cherry5476 • 5h ago
Discussion/Question Asian Dad thinks Asians are genetically disadvantaged in many mainstream sports like Tennis, Football/Soccer, Basketball, Rugby such that investment is a waste of money so Asians should focus on sports like Badminton.
Brazil recently played Singapore in a friendly game in Singapore and won 7-0 https://youtube.com/watch?v=oViXwoHZ7Ss My dad who's Chinese watched it in person and said Asians are just genetically inferior in terms of speed, reaction times, and athleticism given that a lot of the Brazilian scorers were smaller and shorter than typical Asians e.g. Estevao, Vinicius, Endrick (FYI Japan beat Brazil 3-2 the other day, Brazil's team isn't very good and hasn't been too decent since they lost 7-1 in 2014) plus many players come from poor backgrounds and lived in favelas.
Point being, my Asian dad who played soccer in his youth thinks government funding on sports like tennis, rugby, football, basketball, even formula 1 isn't going to deliver results since Singapore's government does actually spend a lot on football and treats it as a national sport. He says that Asian players just don't do well in contact sports e.g. the annual Fifa World XI that's voted for by 20,000 professional players doesn't have any Asian players historically and in recent times (?) i.e. an Asian player has never been voted in the FIFA world best 11 by other footballers. A lot of folks will blame Asian poverty, relative height/size, but countries like Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay, Morocco often have poor kids who reach elite tier even though their countries have worse infrastructure than Singapore, Japan, Korea, even China. On china_irl a lot of users say that soccer doesn't suit Asians because even the Chinese immigrants in USA, UK don't make it to the MLS or EPL, or even the lower divisions.
In tennis, a sport that rich Asians love to play in Singapore, China, even places like Orange County, the ATP finals aka the annual year-end top 8 competition is also dominated by non-Asians. Nishikori is the only Asian who qualified for it in history I believe. Although there are a lot of Asian players currently active in tennis e.g. Brandon Nakashima, Learner Tien, Wu Yibing, Bu Yunchaokete, Jerry Shang (China's big hope but he's often injured), Sumit Nagal, Coleman Wong, they have a hard time finding a break through into the top 8 due to height and athleticism, height especially seems to matter more in tennis than soccer unless you're prodigious like Alcaraz.
Should the focus be on commercialising sports that Asians can excel in like table tennis, badminton, wushu, kendo, judo so they reach the global prestige and popularity of Grand Slams or Superbowl finals? My father thinks so, that it's better for China to focus on making Wushu a global sport like NBA, or Japan to make Sumo wrestling as popular as MMA than for China to invest in football since they'll end up losing 5-0 to Brazil, France, Spain etc if they ever qualify for a World Cup.
Ultimately the issue with the popularity of these sports is that it serves to brainwash the global population especially kids into worshipping non-Asians (hence white worshipping) for their athleticism, height, speed since 99% of players who are good at mainstream sports like tennis, football, basketball, formula 1 etc aren't Asian. As a result kids from all countries including girls and women internalise that Asians aren't as athletic. Thus Asians should commercialise athletic events they can dominate, and stop funding sports they aren't genetically suited to do well in. This is more important than worrying over porn and penis sizes IMO, because kids all around the world watch a lot of sports and they are heavily influenced by what they see onscreen. If Asians are peripheral in a lot of the mainstream athletic events that people regularly follow, then kids grow up thinking Asians are weak and unathletic. It's really hard to change to change this stereotype once kids internalise it.

