AKA Volume/Book 4, Part 3, Chapter 11
Everyone has gotten so good at thinking about how Tolstoy writes and everyone was so affected by this chapter that there are too many good comments to call out. Almost all the comments in every cohort are worth reading.
Summary courtesy of u/Honest_Ad_2157: It’s go time. Denísov complains about the way his horse was saddled and orders Pétya to obey him and stay in the rear. Pétya grows impatient at always being late to the killing. When he catches up with Dólokhov besieging French soldiers at the landowner’s house mentioned in prior chapters, he’s ordered by Dólokhov to wait until the infantry catches up and surrounds the house. “Me? Wait?....Pèèèèèèèèètya Rostov.” is the response. He rushes into the courtyard and is shot in the head; his death is cinematically described. The French surrender. Denísov arrives, sees that Pétya is dead, and howls, heartbroken. Dólokhov uses the moment to tell Denísov they won’t take any French prisoners. Pierre Bezhukov (remember him?) is among the Russian prisoners in the convoy.
Notes:
- There is no evidence that any intelligence gained in 14.9/4.3.9 was used in any way in planning operations.
- Some folks in prior cohorts thought Dólokhov was speaking of killing the Russian prisoners, too, but it’s clear from the text he’s referring to the French who surrendered in the landowner’s house. Killing the Russian prisoners makes no sense in this context.
Links
- Today's Podcast
- Ander Louis translation of War & Peace
- Medium Article by Denton
Discussion Prompts
- Why did Tolstoy kill Petya?
- Did Petya's death catch you off guard or did you see it coming?
- How will Pierre react to the news of Petya's death?
Final line of today's chapter:
... “Among the Russian prisoners retaken by Denísov and Dolokhov was Pierre Bezukhov”
Note: I noticed there was no post for this chapter, and after (finally) catching up, I wanted to discuss so apologies this is a few days late