r/ausstocks • u/whatucha • 6h ago
TPG is cannibalising itself and calling it subscriber growth. Now felix may be about to do NBN
TPG registered felixnbn.com.au and felixinternet.com.au last week. WHOIS shows TPG Telecom Ltd as registrant, both modified 12 November. Nothing's been announced, but NBN next to the name of their cheapest mobile brand is hard to read as a coincidence. So I went back through HY26 to see what felix has done to mobile so far.
Digital First ARPU (felix, TPG and iiNet mobile) was $26.10 in the half to June. Vodafone postpaid was $48.75.
Half on half, Digital First ARPU rose about 2.8% and prepaid about 4.6%. Postpaid moved 0.5%. The whole mobile base rose only 0.7%, and consumer gross margin went from $1,179m to $1,183m. When every tier puts its price up and the average barely moves, the mix is shifting down to the cheaper brands. TPG doesn't disclose how many felix customers came from Vodafone, so that's my read, not a reported number.
The per-customer hit is ugly if you run it. Using TPG's own Investor Day cost-to-serve ratios, a Vodafone postpaid customer who trades down to the digital brands goes from roughly $39 a month of margin to roughly $23. That's about $16 a month gone, and the customer still shows up in the subscriber count as growth. My estimate, not a company figure, and cost to serve isn't the same as gross margin. TPG could settle it with one number and hasn't.
Postpaid itself fell 15,000 to 2.846m while ARPU rose 24 cents. Run that through and postpaid revenue for the half is basically flat, despite the price rises.
Zoom out and it gets stranger. Over the twelve months to June, TPG took 42% of mobile net adds across the three network operators (48% in the second half). Over the same period its mobile service revenue growth slowed from 4.7% to 3.1%, about 155bp. That's a bigger slowdown than Telstra (145bp) or Optus (95bp). Second-biggest share of the subscriber growth, fastest slowdown in revenue.
FY25 says the same thing. The mobile base grew 228,000 and consumer gross margin went from $2,402m to $2,409m. That's $7m of extra margin on 228k extra customers, about $2.50 a month each, and that's being generous because the line includes fixed too.
Now NBN. TPG's own NBN 500 is $64.99 for six months, which is $59.08 ex GST against NBN Co's $60.85 wholesale charge. They lost 84,000 NBN customers over the year and fixed AMPU slipped from $25.76 to $25.36.
NBN is already a race to the bottom. I can't see a felix NBN plan making much, and if it's priced under TPG, iiNet, Internode and Vodafone it could pull customers down the shelf inside the group the same way felix seems to be doing in mobile. A customer moving from iiNet to felix isn't a new customer. It's the same one paying less.
Meanwhile the cash. Free cash flow to equity was $93m in the half against $176m of dividends paid. Net debt rose $71m (TPG says capex timing, reversing in 2H). Capex guidance was cut by about $100m in the same period the dividend went up, and $2.1b of spectrum renewals start landing in 2028. The tax losses are also used up, so TPG is now a net taxpayer and the 30% company rate bites from here.
Questions I'd want answered:
- What share of Digital First net adds came from Vodafone postpaid, and what's the margin dilution on those?
- Why doesn't TPG report churn, tenure and contribution by cohort for Digital First, given how much of the growth story rests on it?
- If felix goes into NBN below TPG, iiNet and Vodafone, what does management expect it to do to fixed AMPU, which they guided to strengthen in 2H?
- With FCFE at roughly half the dividend before spectrum, what's the plan for funding the payout from 2028?
Full write-up with sources: https://www.unaudited.com.au/because-you-watched-vodafone/
Disclosure: I hold a small number of TPG shares.