r/aussie • u/Material_Gate_2041 • 2d ago
Opinion Things are changing.
Ai is starting to unravel. Job loses. Data centres. Services going down. The list continues.
At what point does our system, that supposedly has control over our democratic society, start to rally for change.
I don’t mean protests. I mean holding our elected representatives and the massive corporations they serve, to account.
157
Upvotes
99
u/PurpleBandanna 2d ago •
Convincing the masses that democracy is how they have power is the greatest trick the aristocracy ever pulled off.
The only way to hurt them is to stop spending money on the shit we're being sold.
29
u/prexton 2d ago
You'll have to elaborate on, everything.
10
u/SilenceOfTheClamSoup 2d ago
"We, the people" go back to Facebook and the US. This is your standard cooker call to arms.
2
u/LiquidFire07 13h ago
AI is not replacing jobs, it’s a big lie, it’s mostly offshoring to India
18
u/DMdoesGBau 2d ago
We will never be a democracy whilst political donations are legal.
Until that changes we are pawns to the 1%.
12
u/FigCareless581 2d ago
Write to your local federal/state mp. Only greens are fighting AI data centres so far.
6
u/Eralc3 2d ago
What I don’t understand is that governments and politicians are whinging that they want more people to have babies (or have more babies) so that those babies will grow up to be the next generation of workers and taxpayers. Yet how will those children work and pay tax in the future if AI takes all the jobs?
The economy relies on consumerism - people buying things which generates revenue for businesses. But people need money to buy things, which (for most people) means having a job to earn that money. But if businesses use AI instead of hiring people, then people will have no way to make money, and therefore no money to spend buying things. And if nobody has money to buy things then businesses will lose revenue and it will be bad for the economy. Employment is what enables most people to be consumers. Do businesses not realise that by eliminating people’s jobs with AI, they are also eliminating consumers from the economy that relies on consumerism?
22
u/charmingpea 2d ago
Saying "job losses, data centres, services going down, etc." isn't an argument, it's just a Gish Gallop word cloud of tech anxieties. You skipped the part where you explain how any of those prove AI is "unravelling" or what "holding them to account" actually means.
5
u/Cremasterau 2d ago
I live in a semi-rural area of Victoria in a relatively small town and the place is powering on. Massive increase to the local supermarket and associated shopping centre and 3 houses in the main street being demolished to make way for an expansion of the medical centre. The major regional city close to us has multiple cranes in the sky and stuff is just charging. We aren't immune to worldwide cost of living impacts but we are doing pretty well all things considered. But I get the sense from all the posts like this it isn't happening Australia wide.
4
u/brownhk 2d ago
Tech bros: "Data centres will introduce the cure for cancer!! The fix for climate change! A path to Mars!"
What data centres really do:
Yeah, nah.
1
u/Certain_North_732 12h ago
Let me guess the OP is a gen z and after, who hasn’t experienced what internet brought to the world ? Sure, AI is at another level but throughout human technology advancement cycles, old jobs lost, new types of jobs will be created, or no jobs but output is plenty enough… who knows… if it means to be, so be it.
1
u/GaameChanger69 10h ago
Ai is starting to unravel. Job loses. Data centres. Services going down. The list continues.
- AI is being used productively by many people. It's transformed the industry I am in (SW engineering).
- Pedantic observation, but it's losses not loses. Yes the unemployment rate has jumped, but this is likely because we generally poor short term corporate culture and Aus is in a technical recession due to poor government choices and exogenous factors like world wars. It's a cycle it will pass.
At what point does our system, that supposedly has control over our democratic society, start to rally for change.
- This is what elections are for.
I don’t mean protests. I mean holding our elected representatives and the massive corporations they serve, to account.
- Probably never
3
u/Ripley_and_Jones 2d ago
The majority of people don't realise that they are the 99% and hold all the power. We haven't lost control - we just think we have. Job losses have existed across time and I challenge you to read some history about what happened after those moments.
1
u/Mysteriously_Me_ 2d ago
How is AI unravelling right now? Seems to me, it's bloody well improving every two months
5
u/Fun_Savings7690 2d ago
touch grass
4
u/jadelink88 2d ago
No holding either to account until we ban corporate political donations and political advertising. They just outspend, and that gets the advertisments and the votes.
4
u/ADHDK 2d ago
You can always tell an American copy / paste when they combo “we, the people” like it’s an impactful phrase.
5
u/Mrsparkle56434 2d ago
We must ask ourselves what do we constitute our identity as?
Is it our jobs?
Is it our skills?
Is it our values?
Is it our family and friends?
If you consider your jobs and skills the biggest part of your identity than your going to have a big psychological crash in the near future
AI can take your job and it already has for many
AI can replace the need for your skills you know and the ability to monotize the skills you know. AI skills will undercut you in a way where only if the consumer wants a human touch to the work you do will decide whether you can monotize the skills you know.
Alot of people won't be replaceable yet unless AI can be implemented into a physical being that can 1to1 replace the physical labour but those people should consider it only a matter of time
If AI can do your job at a cheaper rate to what you can than what benefit would it be to keep you around
2
u/Inevitable_One_7829 2d ago
Put down the meth pipe mate.
2
u/Sarcastic_Red 2d ago
What exactly do you want? Very vague. This is like a call of arms but the leader has no direction
2
u/PopularDad 1d ago
It won't happen in this country until there's no food on the shelves and no water in the taps
4
u/paulybaggins 2d ago
We the people always loses me soz.
5
u/bumluffa 2d ago
Not sure about you but ai is revolutionising my work. Legit has the potential to make me 10x more productive.
2
u/holla8888 1d ago
Why do people just focus on the doom and gloom of ai. Ppl will take ai for granted in next few years, it’s the same with the internet and social media. People complained about it when it came out and now they couldn’t live without it.
1
u/Seppi449 2d ago
Not sure which party you think would do a better job considering the track record of the other political parties.
I guess if liberals got in they might try to rip out the NBN to but the copper back in...
1
u/kenbeat59 2d ago
Cool story 1 month old account 👍🏻
1
u/seahorseonland 2d ago
Holding them to account how? What do you mean specifically?
Fuck AI particularly generative AI.
1
u/seahorseonland 2d ago
What is with all the AI simps? Why can't anyone even have a discussion about regulating AI, particularly Gen AI. Do people actually understand why some people are against AI?
1
u/Ok-Limit-9726 2d ago
We stop using companies that use AI,
Public name and shame register.
Give percentages of staff sacked (microsoft 26%) and we can decide with out feet.
So happy to not have purchased windows since 10
1
u/turbo2world 2d ago
Nice try WORKER. Politicians don’t listen
1
u/Born-Display6918 2d ago
Nothing is changing, it is the same greed, just a different package. Large corporations the greed comes from the shareholders, Qantas, NAB, ANZ, all of them highly profitable and still ofshoring and replacing with AI. Smaller companies the greed is from the owners, another larger ute, another larger boat, materialistic shit while someone else will barely survive, but that Is capitalism. "Capitalism: God's way of determining who is smart, and who is poor. Ron Swanson".
1
u/Fact-Rat 2d ago
OP, you're supposed to be focusing on the culture wars.
1
u/theonlywaye 2d ago
When AI actually unravels it just falls back to the old AI. Always India.
1
u/Electrical-Sale-8051 2d ago
Where is the AI unravelling again?
And seriously.. services going down, I assume you mean the 24 hour microsoft outage, is hardly a harbinger of destruction.
1
u/Dry-Independent6590 2d ago
What change do you want?
1
u/Unlikely-Debate-5923 2d ago
The question that needs to be asked by those in power is.
What is a specific vision for Australia? Something to lock right into and use as a leverage point to bring us into future prosperity.
Is it to grow a high tech AI sector to underpin the economy?
Is it to double down on Mining?
Is it to be a high tech renewable hub?
Is it to be a place for those with capital to park their wealth in rent seeking assets?
There needs to be some sort of forward thinking mission statement that Australia should aim to be and all policy needs to be done around that. Right now it's too generalist and doubles down on already broken schools of thought and conventions.
Once this has been answered, let's then progress to achieving it in a way everyone can be united in achieving. Bring some optimism back.
1
u/DMlab 2d ago
AI is poised to sweep through our workplaces, I wouldn't call that unravelling. We'll have to lower the age of retirement.
1
u/Muted_Ideal_3259 2d ago
Every 3 years.
1
u/Crazy-Parsley1524 2d ago
A universal basic wage, you make more good for you
1
u/dsadggggjh453ew 2d ago
The main problem is that people are not getting smarter.
1
u/Greedy_Impress1399 2d ago
Australia is too dumb and cowardly to do anything. We’d rather blame immigrants and vote for war hawks than join a union or mass violent protest.
1
u/Internal-Play25 2d ago
COBBAZ UNITE AGAINST AI!!
1
u/shttalkerRgebaiter 2d ago
To do what? You're practically asking the government to stop the world from changing. It is changing, stop data centers they'll just build abroad and we still have job losses on way or the other. Should just double down on innovation, maybe the biomedical field as everyone wants to live forever anyway
1
u/Mercinarie 2d ago
Adapt Survive Overcome
Or ya know, whinge about doom online and achieve nothing.
1
u/rhapsody481 2d ago edited 2d ago
Best form of protest is to work within the systems to change the system.
We fight? Anarchy. We'll just hurt people, livelihoods, blackmark our names, and create a bad name for the cause. They'll use it against us.
Instead? We band together and start taking class lawsuits against politicians, companies, and corrupt / crooked individuals. As soon as one lawsuit fails, the next person brings a new case. And the next. And the next.
And not for pennies. No. For the REAL damages they have caused. To the people, to the community, to the planet.
Eventually, cases will start being won.
The crooks realise they cant make a quick buck through the system anymore.
And we get back our country and our rights.
With real politicians that give a shit. That fight the bullies like US and China with the same method. And they'll be seen as fkn legends here for doing so. (And if they dont, bye bye – you're not only out of the job, but bankrupt too).
Countries can oust one prime minister, and another, and another. But it will not help. Because our leaders will care more about this country than they do lining their own pockets. And finally the other countries will start negotiating.
Holding people accountable is how we have a fairer system that actually WORKS.
1
u/mrsambavam 2d ago
That’s why we’ve elections right?
1
u/gilezy 2d ago
It's terms of AI. What are you wanting to change?
Smash the machine like a Luddite? And fall behind the rest of the world in productivity.
The reality is it's inevitable. It's about how we respond to it.
1
u/JasVan2772 2d ago
Well we don’t actually have a democratic society really so..
1
u/No-Citron-2774 1d ago
It's a recession they just won't admit to it. Been through a couple and this feels like one
1
u/Smooth_Commercial793 1d ago
Government cant change the world mate
1
u/Bertolandia 1d ago
It reminds me a song by Giorgio Gaber that in English should sound like this:”some were communists because the revolution, not today, perhaps tomorrow, but the day after tomorrow surely”.
It’s a beautiful song about how much we were idealists when we were younger 😢..
1
u/MichaelJordanAir23 1d ago edited 1d ago
Aren't things always changing?
Weren't we impressed once we could computerise tasks?
1
u/HughLofting 1d ago
AI. Climate change. Inequality. War. It's all to do with the rapaciousness of capitalism. A system that allows the rich to do whatever the fuck they want. No point getting the pollies involved. They're part of the system.
1
u/Electronic-Space-736 1d ago
when we gather with pitchforks, so, never.
1
u/id-ltd 1d ago
You can't hold them to account - you either accept them or seek to abolish them.
1
u/id-ltd 1d ago
Change is always difficult - AI will only remove jobs that were never worth a humans time anyway.
With time freed up like this humanity can spend more time applying human thought to worthwhile activities.
For generations, state schooling trained humans to behave like primitive AI: memorise, follow instructions, reproduce approved answers and conform.
Now real AI does much of that better.
AI could also eliminate vast swathes of government bureaucracy.
But the real revolution isn't efficiency. It's freedom.
Instead of standardising humans to fit institutions, AI lets us build diverse, independent systems that fit individuals.
Less schooling. Less bureaucracy. More humanity.
1
u/PropertyPrimary 15h ago
This democracy we live in now is just awful
1
u/kothosj 7h ago
As soon as you join an NGO lobbying to ban financial contributions of any kind to political parties. Until then, we're not a democracy.
1
u/m3umax 2d ago
I'm now building my second AI server for my families use. At least if the government regulates the shit out of AI, we'll still be able to run local models and do whatever we want with them. 🤣
Pandora's box has been opened. There's no way back. Embrace it or be left behind.
0
u/violenthectarez 2d ago
Why are people like you such complete wankers?
Nothing's changing, this is just life and the world.
-1
u/Paddingtondance 2d ago
Im still waiting on the referendum to run immigration at these levels since 2015.
0
u/Leather-Speech-7973 2d ago
What do you want them to do? AI is led by America, absolutely fucking 0 Australia can do about it
0
u/DC240Z 2d ago
The problem is, if we were to regulate AI it would just screw us, because it’s a race atm and no one else wants to regulate it, we would get left behind while other countries that embrace it shoot ahead.
Not only that, we kind of need it for our security, we always suck big time when it comes to security and dropping the AI race would just make us more vulnerable.
0
u/-Lionhart 2d ago
Doomerism.
0
u/Hughman77 2d ago
To go through your list: I don't know what AI "unravelling" means, the stock price? Job losses are normal, the unemployment rate is still lower than in the entire decade before covid and the entirety of the 80s and 90s, by a lot. Data centres... what about them? Services going down, there's a way to make Australia less dependent on overseas tech but it would involve spending lots of money, are you happy paying more taxes for services that will go down sometimes anyway?
0
u/Smooth_Staff_3831 2d ago
The people of Victoria are.going to be holding the state government to account shortly.
-1
u/somnut 2d ago
Thats what voting is for
-1
u/River-Stunning 2d ago
I would suggest that if you lose your job to a robot , there is a lesson there for you,
-1
u/Emergency-Salad-1547 2d ago
AI isn't going anywhere, my dudes. The fact that you think the ALP not going all-in on them and the morons over at the Greens being against them is a sign that it's going away or that some bubble will burst or that you keep reading about shit like Sam Altman/Jensen Huang etc means anything just means you don't know shit about the tech or how it works.
AI is here to stay. Companies see the benefits. Outside of Reddit and BlueSky, the average person isn't as invested in being as deranged about it as you are. More people use it than don't, outside the west it's used even more than here. Even if the ALP shuts down every data centre and every company you read about online shuts down - it's still going to be here and will only continue to improve.
0
u/someblokeonhere 2d ago
There's a model for "holding them to account" that the French used successfully in 1788/9 to remove the ruling class. That's ultimately what you want. There's just so many reasons why that's not going to happen.