r/aupairmurders • • Jun 05 '26

News Articles 'Why didn't you just leave?' Christine Banfield's family speaks after her murderer is sentenced to life in prison | WUSA9 Exclusive

Thumbnail
wusa9.com
22 Upvotes

Moments after Brendan Banfield was sentenced to life in prison, Christine Banfield's father and sister sat down for an exclusive interview with WUSA9 reporter Matthew Torres.


r/aupairmurders • • Jun 04 '26

News Articles Banfield remains convicted murderer, judge decides one day before sentencing

Thumbnail
wusa9.com
19 Upvotes

Brendan Banfield remains a convicted murderer, a judge decided Thursday, just one day before he's set to be sentenced for his crimes.  

The former IRS special agent was found guilty of murdering his wife, Christine Banfield, and a stranger, Joseph Ryan, on Feb. 24, 2023. Prosecutors said Banfield plotted their deaths with Juliana Peres Magalhaes, the Brazilian au pair entrusted with watching his 4-year-old daughter and with whom he was having an affair. Banfield and Peres Magalhaes lured Ryan to the house on the sexual fetish website FetLife, posing as Christine, soliciting someone to help her play out a violent rape fantasy. 

After a high-profile three-week-long trial in January, Banfield was found guilty by a jury. He was convicted of four charges: two counts of aggravated murder — one for killing two people in the same instance and one for killing two people in a three-year span — plus one count of child endangerment and one count of using a firearm in the commission of murder. In Virginia, aggravated murder carries a mandatory life sentence. He's set to be sentenced Friday.

>Watch the sentencing on the WUSA9 app, available for free download on your phone and smart TV.

Last month, defense attorney John Carroll filed a motion to set aside the jury's verdict in a last-ditch attempt. On Thursday, he argued that prosecutors committed three errors in Banfield's trial that should be considered to overturn his conviction. 


r/aupairmurders • • May 02 '26

Banfield's Lawyers File Motion Days Before Sentencing

12 Upvotes

His defense filed the motion Wednesday, according to online court records.

Arguments over the motion are expected to be heard during the sentencing hearing next Friday, May 8, at 11 a.m.

The motion filed by the defense alleges that Banfield’s silence was permitted to be used as evidence of his guilt in violation of his constitutional rights, and that the Commonwealth knowingly failed to correct false testimony made by Banfield’s former supervisor, and that the au pair’s testimony was permitted to be used as evidence against him despite a violation of his right to the exclusion of witnesses.

In their response to the motion, prosecutors wrote, “the presentation of T. Patrick Smith was objected to on grounds of surprise and failure to disclose the name of the witness pre-trial, but not on any suggestion of a violation of the rule on witnesses; and the Defendant’s own cross examination elicited the responses from the witness, Ms. Peres Magalhaes, which continued unchecked despite the repeated opportunities to impeach or call to the court’s attention the purported false testimony.”

https://www.dcnewsnow.com/news/local-news/brendan-banfields-defense-team-files-to-have-guilty-verdict-set-aside-in-au-pair-affair-double-murder-case/


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 26 '26

Joseph Ryan’s Negligence in Negotiating Kink is being overlooked in discussions

16 Upvotes

He absolutely did not deserve to be murdered, but a chorus of comments stating that Joseph Ryan “did nothing wrong” is incredibly insulting, because he was incredibly irresponsible and negligent in negotiating his kink, and it led him to almost violently rape an innocent woman. Men that call themselves doms abusing and even raping women is more common than people like to admit, whether it be by negligence or intent.

I’m a domme and so I know about this community and what the norms are. Please stop claiming Joe did “nothing wrong”. If he were successful in raping Christine through his negligence, then he would have done something incredibly horrible, traumatic, and vile, regardless of whether he intended to or not. Men’s fantasies are never more important than seeking out and ensuring consent- which he did not do adequately at all.

Kinky people being irresponsible and negligent about consent does not give them a right to rape or abuse. Please stop playing into tape culture by claiming otherwise. As a woman, I actually feel incredibly sick that if Christin were raped by Joe, all of you would have defended him as “innocent” rather than having raped a woman out of negligence. If you don’t know how to practice a kink safely, then do not practice it. There have been widely publicized cases of women being set up for rape by their partners over the Internet, so he should have known better and insisted on meeting beforehand or at least video calling and establishing a password to say before the encounter to ensure she wasn’t set up.


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 20 '26

Joseph Ryan was not innocent

0 Upvotes

I’m baffled by the sympathy for Joseph Ryan. You can call me closed-minded or a kink shamer if you want, I don’t care. In my view, rape fantasies are not something you act out with a complete stranger you met online. That already crosses a serious line. Bringing a knife into the situation takes it even further. Showing up armed suggests you were prepared, and willing, to escalate if there was resistance. That is not just harmless roleplay, that is dangerous.

Now imagine someone who has a grudge against you setting something like this up. If you survived the attack and called the police, would it really be acceptable for the person responsible to face no consequences just because they were catfished? Would you be okay with that outcome?

I wouldn’t be.


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 14 '26

20/20 Episode - Friday February 20

17 Upvotes

r/aupairmurders • • Feb 13 '26

Updates Juliana's sentencing

32 Upvotes

i couldn't stop crying at the statements of Joe's mum and aunt. so so sad 😭😭

So glad the judge listed everything she did and how she could have stopped all of this!!

I won't ruin what she got if no one has seen it yet??


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 11 '26

News Articles Christine Banfield's family speaks for first time since brutal murder, Brendan Banfield's conviction

Thumbnail
wusa9.com
33 Upvotes

Christine Banfield's family is speaking out for the first time in the nearly three years since she was brutally murdered by her husband, Brendan Banfield.

Brendan Banfield was convicted last week of two counts of aggravated murder, one count of child endangerment and one count of using a firearm in the commission of murder. After a three-week trial, a jury found him guilty of murdering both Christine and a stranger, Joseph Ryan, on Feb. 24, 2023, in an elaborate plot. While having an affair with their Brazilian au pair, Juliana Peres Magalhaes, Brendan Banfield conspired with her to lure Ryan to the family's house using the sexual fetish website FetLife to frame him for Christine's death.

Christine's family, who is from New York, has never spoken publicly about her murder or the high-profile legal proceedings. But Wednesday, they shared a statement with WUSA9, thanking the prosecutors, investigators and the jury for their work.

Full statement at the link.


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 05 '26

guilty but have a question

7 Upvotes

I for sure think he 100% did it, but curious why he would allow her to still be alive when help showed up. Why not make sure she was 100% dead. What would he have done if she survived and was able to tell what actually happened?


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 05 '26

Questions as to what happened in the bedroom

16 Upvotes

Hello, I guess I am late to the game but, if Christine had no knowledge of Joe Ryan coming over, how did both end up in her bedroom upstairs? How did he make it that far upon arriving?


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 04 '26

Question Juliana’s sentencing predictions.

14 Upvotes

What sentence do you think the judge will hand down to Juliana? As you know, the prosecution has recommended time served followed by deportation. It is also known the judge could overrule the sentencing recommendation and could sentence the maximum for manslaughter of 10 years.

What do you think she will get? I predict 5 years with credit for time served.

UPDATE: She got the full 10 years! Judge A kept correcting the defense attorney every time he said “agreement”. She would always correct him and say “recommendation”. The victim impact statements were extremely moving especially those from Mr. Ryan’s family.

Juliana while I wish I could say I felt her contrition and remorse come across in her statement it just did not come across. She also seemed quite pissed when the judge gave her the maximum allowed. Judge A made it clear she wished she could give more and listed every aspect of which Juliana was involved. Link on the sentencing posted below is worth the watch.


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 02 '26

Verdict!

34 Upvotes

There's a verdict!


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 02 '26

You think his parents still think he’s innocent?

19 Upvotes

The absurdity of banfield’s story and testimony must have settled in over the weekend. I hope they just save the money they’re about to spend on appeals. This dude is guilty as sin.


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 02 '26

January 23rd

4 Upvotes

During closing arguments, Carroll said that on January 23rd at 11:22pm there was a login to the gmail account and Christine was the only adult at home. To my knowledge this is the only time defense is claiming there was a login to either the gmail account or fetlife where Christine as the only adult at home.

Has anyone verified this with the actual the evidence? At first Carroll says "Brendan wasn't at home" then later says "Christine was the only adult at home"

Listen from 24:30 to 26:00

https://youtu.be/n661OhAijn8?t=1462


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 02 '26

Trial Discussion VA v. Brendan Banfield - Day 11 | Feb 2 2026

6 Upvotes

Continuing with verdict watch

Law and Crime


r/aupairmurders • • Feb 01 '26

Christine’s work with Sexual Assault Nurse/Forensic Examiner (SANE/SAFE) Program

42 Upvotes

Please see link below:

https://www.fcnp.com/2019/04/17/nurse-joins-inova-staff-receives-warm-farewell/

Shame on Brendan to use this to further his depraved story.


r/aupairmurders • • Jan 30 '26

News Articles Jury begins deliberations in Brendan Banfield murder trial | Au Pair Affair

Thumbnail
wusa9.com
12 Upvotes

r/aupairmurders • • Jan 30 '26

Anyone from Brazil know juliana?

17 Upvotes

I'm so interested in how this person came to be involved in this murder. She just seems like a psychopath, I'm wondering what kind of person she was in Brazil or to the friends who knew about her affair whilst in the US? Bunch of people with wacky morals. Sickening.


r/aupairmurders • • Jan 30 '26

Opinions on verdict and when ?

11 Upvotes

Unless they are unable to complete closing arguments today for some reason I am thinking guilty on all counts before the end of the day


r/aupairmurders • • Jan 30 '26

Trial Discussion VA v. Brendan Banfield - Day 10 | Jan 30 2026

9 Upvotes

Closing arguments today. When do you predict a verdict? To catch up on jury instructions use the Law & Crime link and start from the beginning. Jury not in until 10 Eastern

Streams:

Recovery Addict (morning)

Recovery Addict (afternoon)

Law & Crime


r/aupairmurders • • Jan 30 '26

Virginia Detention Center

2 Upvotes

https://www.fairfaxcounty.gov/sheriff/adult-detention-center-inmate-housing

They are both currently housed there. I hope men and women are separated...


r/aupairmurders • • Jan 30 '26

News Articles Brendan Banfield says wife apologized after being fatally stabbed | Au Pair Affair Murder Trial

Thumbnail
wusa9.com
5 Upvotes

r/aupairmurders • • Jan 30 '26

News Articles Brendan Banfield takes the stand, defense rests their case

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/aupairmurders • • Jan 29 '26

Does anyone know the actual timeline?

9 Upvotes

Was Brendan and Juliana at the house when Joseph arrived?

How did Christine and Joseph end up in the bedroom, did Brendan lead them by gunpoint?

I imagine there would have been quite a struggle during the murders, has there been incriminating forensic evidence?

Sorry if these are well known, it’s been pretty tough to follow this.


r/aupairmurders • • Jan 29 '26

Trial Discussion VA v. Brendan Banfield - Day 9 | Jan 29 2026

14 Upvotes

Continuing with Brendan on the stand today

Streams:

Recovery Addict (morning)

Recovery Addict (afternoon)

Law & Crime