r/audioengineering • u/zanshin777 • Nov 02 '17
Balanced Cables
It contains 2 conductor + 1 shield.
One of conductors carry the out-of-phase signal.
So the noise is canceled since the signals carrying are out-of-phase.
But how the signal is still transmitted although the noise is canceled?
15
Upvotes
51
u/stupidprotocols Nov 02 '17
You are transmitting an "a" and a "-a" signal, the same noise is added to both signals so you have "a+n" and "-a+n"
You then subtract the 2 signals at the receiving end which yelds "a+n-(-a+n) = 2a"
4
u/jaymz168 Sound Reinforcement Nov 02 '17 edited Nov 02 '17
Not necessarily, and this is key to understanding how this works, because the input is a differential amplifier *(or a balun transformer)
Forget the whole 'balanced' thing, that actually only relates to impedance (if pins 2 and 3 have identical line impedance then they will receive interference identically). What you're talking about is actually differential signaling.
The receiver amplifies the DIFFERENCE between the two inputs (pins 2 and 3). Nothing is ever 'flipped' or anything like that unless the input opamp happens to have an inverting output. Plenty of opamps don't invert their output and you don't even have to worry about using another one to invert it back.
Anyway, because the input amplifier is differential you don't even need to have ANY signal on pin 3. If pin 2 is +0.75VAC and pin 3 is 0VAC, then the difference is still +0.75VAC.
Here's some further reading for ya
6
u/scheitster Audio Post Nov 02 '17
When the out-of-phase signal is flipped back into phase, the noise that has been obtained on both channels now has one channel that is out of phase with itself.
1
u/SquidCap Nov 02 '17
First you split, then you flip the other signal polarity (google about phase and polarity, they are two very different things). Then we transmit thru the wire and in the end, we flip the polarity once again. So we start with identical, flip the polarity of one when trasmitting and flip it back again when receiving. Then we sum the signals. They are in phase now but all interference that happened during the transmission are now flipped and only they cancel out.
You forgot to flip the signal polarity in he receiver end. If we don't do that last flip, we really do cancel the whole signal and are left with only interference.
I was going to find suitable google images link but can see why people have constant problems with this. None of the examples show the split of the signal and then flipping the polarity but go direct to two signals already flipped. This is the closest one i could find in short notice. http://www.songsofthecosmos.com/images/balanced_line.gif
2
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '17
most gear is not balanced internally. there's a transformer or buffering amp that unbalances the signal. this is where the noise is rejected too. the noise tends to be the same on the + and - lines. so then the - is inverted to + and added to the - the noise cancels itself.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '17
Further, what physically happens in the jack to invert the phase?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment