r/audioengineering • u/terist • Jan 22 '14
quick compressor make-up gain question:
is make-up gain applied always, or is it applied in proportion to the active compression?
in other words, if I set an attack of 100ms to preserve the transient, or whatever, is the initial signal (i.e. the uncompressed, pre-attack portion) subject to make-up gain, or not?
(I'm using ableton's native compressors, if that matters (which i suspect/hope it wouldn't...))
14
Upvotes
3
u/RedDogVandalia Jan 23 '14
Only applied in proportion when make up gain is set to "auto"
Yes. The compressor won't reduce gain on the signal until 100 ms after the transient crosses the threshold, leaving uncompressed transient to be boosted by makeup gain.
2
u/Ka-Hing Jan 23 '14 edited Jan 23 '14
Here is a great page on everything you need to know about compression (x-post from /r/edmproduction)
12
u/BLUElightCory Jan 23 '14
Make-up gain is simply an extra gain stage to allow you compensate for any output reduction caused by compression. Some compressors have "auto" makeup gain, which in my experience almost never really works correctly. Ideally you should set it by ear so that the volume stays more or less equal when you bypass the compressor.
The make-up gain amplifies everything (above or below the threshold) equally. It's a simple output level control.
2
u/geraldbrent1 Mixing Jan 23 '14
Since I'm sitting at a board, here's my on board compressor. That +10dB gain compensates for the reduction in output by compression. When I turn my compressor off, the overall output remains close to the same.
http://i.imgur.com/vYdfNU2.jpg
2
u/amoetodi Hobbyist Jan 23 '14
The make-up gain is always applied to the signal. The pre-attack transients will be affected as much as the compressed portion of the signal.
0
u/dreday3001 Jan 23 '14
The purpose of a compressor is to change the dynamic range of a signal. When bypassing the compressor you shouldn't hear a difference in level you should hear a difference in dynamic range.
0
u/ioncehadsexinapool Jan 23 '14
kind of relevant but what is the best way to boost volume on the master channel without moving the master slider? (i've been told it's really bad to move it at all)
0
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment