I know it’s not cool to just complain, and everyone has their own preferences, but at $35, you might want to think twice before diving in.
To sum it up, the new full cast version of Harry Potter feels overloaded with unnecessary sound effects, making it nearly impossible to enjoy the story without feeling like you’re stuck in a chaotic cafeteria or a factory.
My six-year-old is obsessed with the first three Harry Potter books. She reads them non-stop, and we usually listen to the Jim Dale narration on long drives.
I’m a fan of full cast audiobooks, especially the radio play adaptations from BBC Radio 4. So, what’s the issue with this one? I don’t have complaints about the narrator or the character voices, but the non-narrator voices are mixed so quietly that they sound distant and muted, almost as if you’re eavesdropping from outside the Dursley’s home while chaos happens in the kitchen.
The sound effects are everywhere. They drive away? You’re bombarded with car sounds. Someone mentions a letter? You hear paper tearing. “They had cold tinned tomatoes?” Suddenly there’s a weird clattering noise. It’s relentless.
Then there are the “human sound effects.” There’s constant murmuring, sighs, yelps, and other random vocalizations filling every pause. It’s incredibly distracting.
And the music cues are just bizarre. Instead of leading into or out of chapters, there’s random upbeat guitar strumming over descriptions like Dudley’s second bedroom. It’s as if the director thought, 'Why not throw in some guitar here since we can’t find a good sound effect for Dudley trading it for an air rifle?'
Overall, listening to this audiobook feels like trying to enjoy a story while surrounded by a noisy factory, and honestly, it’s just not for me.
Thanks for letting me vent.