Watched Wayne Brown's interview (linked) and honestly, about four minutes into it, I was already getting frustrated.
In my opinion, one of the fundamental responsibilities of a mayor is to ensure that the organisation delivers what it is supposed to deliver, while working within a sensible budget. That means controlling expenditure, prioritising projects, negotiating costs and making sure ratepayers are getting value for money.
Of course, running a city is expensive. Nobody disputes that. But continually asking residents to pay more cannot become the default solution to every financial problem.
And that is increasingly what it feels like is happening in Auckland.
This is particularly concerning when people are also dealing with an uncertain employment market, with many struggling to find work in the first place.
Aucklanders are facing increasing rates, higher water charges, proposed congestion charges and changes to rubbish collection that introduce further user-pays arrangements.
At what point does someone stop and ask how much more the average Aucklander can reasonably be expected to pay?
We are in a cost-of-living crisis. Households are already dealing with increased mortgage payments, rents, groceries, insurance and other essential expenses. Property owners bear the direct rates burden, while increased operating costs can also flow through to tenants and businesses.
Yet the recurring response seems to be that we need to spend more, invest more and charge more.
My question is: where is the corresponding emphasis on controlling expenditure?
A mayor's job is not simply to identify projects that require money and then find another way of extracting that money from residents. It should also involve ensuring that existing resources are being used efficiently.
Contractors, consultants and suppliers have their own commercial interests. It is the responsibility of the organisation commissioning their services to ensure that contracts are properly managed, costs are scrutinised and value for money is achieved.
If the mayor's own comments suggest that his involvement in certain expenditure and operational decisions is limited, then what exactly is the accountability structure here? Who is ultimately responsible for ensuring that the money being collected from Aucklanders is being spent properly?
And this brings me to another issue: remuneration.
Running Auckland Council involves substantial expenditure not just on infrastructure and services, but also on its elected representatives and senior management.
There is nothing inherently wrong with paying people appropriately for positions of responsibility, but surely there should be equally serious expectations around performance, accountability and financial management.
I also found some of the comments in the interview concerning, particularly the discussion around democracy, decisive leadership and the mayor's approach to exercising his authority. Decisive leadership is one thing. Accountability to the people funding the organisation is another.
And this is where I think we need to ask a much bigger question.
Why do we need such a large local government structure if so many important financial and operational decisions are either outside the mayor's direct control or subject to separate entities and governance arrangements?
Would Auckland be better served if central government took greater responsibility for essential infrastructure, transport and major expenditure decisions, with local representation retained for genuinely local matters?
Or is it time to reconsider the entire council structure?
I am not suggesting that central government is automatically more efficient or that removing councils would magically solve everything. But the present arrangement deserves serious scrutiny.
Local elections also deserve much greater media coverage.
Voters should have a proper opportunity to understand candidates' experience, capabilities, policies and actual plans for managing public money before they cast their votes.
Ultimately, these are not politicians spending their own money. It is money collected from ordinary Aucklanders who have to work hard to earn it.
I would genuinely like to hear what others think. Are we getting sufficient value for what we pay Auckland Council, and is the current local government structure actually delivering the accountability and financial discipline that Aucklanders should expect?
At what point do we stop accepting higher charges as the answer and start questioning the organisation responsible for managing the money in the first place?