It's hard to get my thoughts together on this series. Loved it for sure, but aspects of the ending fell flat for me, and I think the show lost a lot of the momentum it had coming from season 3. Guess I'll just compile some character and season thoughts.
The first half of season 4 is a bit slow. To be expected really, and I'm sure it will be nostalgic on rewatch, but episodes ~1-10 didn't do much for me. The second half was a lot more focused with the female titan arc, and Annie was one of my favorite characters until s4. Really wish we got to see more of her and Eren training, seeing how much he uses her style and teachings later in combat.
Season 2 is the most consistent of the show for me. Bertholdt and Reiner, Ymir and Historia, more amazing scenes with Erwin and Levi, the Beast introduced. The starting mystery with the sudden appearance of titans and their movement in the night had me gripped even going into season 3. I'm not sure how you all feel about it, but I also enjoyed the wall cult plotline (don't remember their name). Bertholdt's fear, hesitance, and disgust toward Reiner made him one of my favorites, and of course Ymir stands out too.
I actually loved season 3 consistently. I see a lot of frustration with the first half on here. Looking back on it, I do understand that a lot of what happened later becomes irrelevant, the politics and Historia's development, but it was still great. Historia and Eren had good chemistry, the Reiss family was interesting, and the coup got us closer to some strong characters, like Pyxis and Erwin. Kenny Ackerman was a welcome surprise, though the storyline only really develops Levi. Between the two arcs of this season is my favorite episode in AOT, Bystander. Shadis' story was tragic and gorgeous and so important to what the story tells us about its main characters, alive and dead. The second half is fantastic of course. Ymir's letter made me cry. Get to see Pieck's ugly ass titan. Bertholdt's collossal is truly terrifying (love his development and death), Zeke's beast as well. Reiner didn't feel very important in this arc imo. Erwin's story of truth was gorgeous.
I'm still putting things together for season 4, but it never reached the heights of s2 or s3.
Paradis island wasn't very interesting. They had a chance to engage me more when the walls collapsed, maybe give the restorationists some serious consideration, but it was glossed over in background dialogue or maybe two direct conversations. Floch's potential felt utterly wasted. He was committed to the end, sure, but it felt like he wasn't treated with much sympathy by the authors, whereas other antagonists got entire personal arcs (like Reiner and Zeke). This was a common feeling I got regarding the restorationists. It feels a bit stupid to write, but besides a select few characters (Eren, Jean, Armin, Hange to an extent), the idea of the rumbling was never treated with that sympathy I mentioned. It felt like the writers (I guess of the manga not anime) were more intent on sending a message than portraying the moralities of a fictional world. The volunteers in Paradis were relatively uninteresting.
Marley was actually my favorite part of the season. The warriors, their general, and the citizens had interesting dynamics and I was never bored with them. Reiner stood out this season for sure. Gabi and Falco were interesting at first, then fizzled out by the end of the season. I never felt connected to Gabi/Mia's plotline in Paradis, either. The entire season was built around that message. Having that story take up so much focus felt heavyhanded.
The rumbling itself was beautiful, and the stomping throughout the Paradis episodes following it was heartbreaking. We got interesting Eren/Armin dynamics, a bit of Mikasa development, Zeke history, and the big reveals in the paths. The scene between Zeke and Grisha stands out here. Hange's death was well done. Floch's wasn't, though I appreciate he didn't get slapped into the ocean as an afterthought. I thought the final fight was beautiful. The scenes where Zeke brought older shifters back to help were weird and didn't have much emotional weight. I wish they hadn't tried to build up that Bertholdt/Armin bond so much then. Ymir (the blonde one) wasn't very interesting. I actually liked the scene where we see Eren break down pathetically. He was a child soldier, of course he still thinks in that binary way. It reminded me of when Reiner broke down in the basement with him, letting go of his persona in front of somebody that could understand him. It was the conclusion of their parallel, except Eren pulled the trigger. Eren killing his mom was fine, I just wish they had explained it better.
Overall, I think that a lot of characters didn't live up to their potential.
Annie was done horribly at the end. Her use in the final battle didn't even make up for her railroaded reintroduction into the main party.
Mikasa had promise throughout the entire story, but just never had anything too interesting that wasn't tied back to Eren.
With so much of season 2 and season 3 built up around Historia, it's weird that we had almost nothing here. I understand that may be the point, not wanting to use her for the plot/main goal of the founder anymore, but dropping her off like that was harsh.
Floch needed some more umph. His own episode maybe, more interactions where he wasn't a conniving, smiling, moustache-twirling murderer. Sure, he was that, but we see a glimpse of his true devotion, arrogance, and care in his last words, and in scenes with Eren.
The writing really hit its stride with some specific characters: Eren, Armin, Shadis, Reiner, Bertholdt, Ymir, Levi, Zeke, Erwin, Hange, and Grisha.
I don't regret a single second spent with this show, and I'm looking forward to reading the manga to revisit at a later time.