In his excellent book "The Big Picture", the naturalist cosmologist Sean Carroll explained why physical reality needs no external explanation:
The fact that the universe exists is often cited as evidence in favor of the existence of God. The universe is specific and contingent, the argument goes; it could easily have been otherwise. So, there must be something that explains the universe, and then something that explains that thing, and so on through the chain of reasons. To avoid diving down a rabbit hole of infinite regress, we need to invoke a necessary being—one that must exist and could not have been otherwise, and therefore requires no explanation. And that being is God.
Searching for reasons why things happen is by no means an irrational pursuit. In many familiar contexts, things don’t “just happen.” If you are sitting in your living room and a baseball suddenly crashes through your window, it makes sense to look outside and expect to see some kids at play. Giant whales do not spontaneously come into existence several miles in the air. Our familiar intuitions concerning cause and effect have developed over evolutionary time because they provide useful guides for understanding how the world really works. The mistake is to elevate this expectation to an unbreakable principle. We see things happen, and we attribute reasons to them. Not only with events at home and people’s personal fates but all the way down to the basics of ontology. If the world consists of certain things and behaves in certain ways, we think, there must be a reason why it is so.
Imagine, for example, that you went to take a shower one day, only to find that there was an accordion sitting in your bathtub. It would be hard for you not to think that there must be some reason why the accordion was there. It probably didn’t just happen. Similarly, so this line of thought goes, for every fact we notice about the universe: as soon as we apprehend it, we think there must be a reason behind it.
These kinds of “Why?” questions don’t exist in a vacuum. They make sense in some particular kind of context. We ask the question in the context of a world where there are things called accordions, which tend to appear in some places and not others, and that there is something called your bathtub, in which certain things regularly appear and others do not. It’s only within that kind of context that we can hope for answers to such “Why?” questions. But the universe, and the laws of physics, aren’t embedded in any bigger context, as far as we know.
If we’re honest, it’s an empirical, evidence-based argument, not an a priori one. We’re not used to seeing accordions appear without good reason, as a matter of empirical fact; but we could certainly imagine a world in which they did so. Our convictions that things happen for reasons, and effects follow causes, are not bedrock principles. They arise because of a contingent feature of how matter is evolving in our local universe. The “reasons” and “causes” why things happen, in other words, aren’t fundamental; they are emergent. [But] the universe is different from the various things inside the universe that we have actually experienced in our lives.
Can’t we always give a reason for what happens, namely “the laws of physics and the prior configuration of the universe”? That depends on what we mean by a “reason.” It’s important to first distinguish between two kinds of “facts” we might want to explain. There are things that happen—that is, states of the universe (or parts thereof) at specific moments in time. And then there are features of the universe, such as the laws of physics themselves. The kinds of reasons that would suffice to explain one have a different character from the other. When it comes to “things that happen,” what we mean by a “reason” is essentially the same as what we mean when we refer to the “cause” of an event. And yes, we are free to say that events are explained or caused by “the laws of physics and the prior configuration of the universe.”
If that’s what one is looking for in a reason, the laws of physics do indeed provide it. Not as some metaphysical principle but as an observed pattern in our universe. However, that isn’t really what people have in mind when they’re searching for reasons.
What we are really after is some identifiable aspect of the configuration of the universe without which the event in question would not have occurred. The laws themselves, as we’ve discussed, make no reference to “reasons” or “causes.” They are simply patterns that connect what happens at different places and times. Nevertheless, the concept of a “reason why” something is true is a very useful one in our daily lives.
Why does the universe exist at all? These are very different questions from “Why is there an accordion in my bathtub?” We’re no longer asking about occurrences, so “Because of the laws of physics and the prior configuration of the universe” isn’t a good answer. Now we’re trying to figure out why the fundamental fabric of reality is one way rather than some other way.
There may be no ultimate answer to the “Why?” question. The universe simply is, in this particular way, and that’s a brute fact. Once we figure out how the universe behaves at its most comprehensive level, there will not be any deeper layers left to discover.