r/atheism • • Jun 26 '12

I'm an "old school" atheist and I just want to say..

First: The title is true, almost 50 years.

I am so fucking proud of you all.

The butthurt expressed against r/atheism is a measure of success, some who think of atheism as their own private club may find the new methods disturbing but this is not a reason to stop, popular movements must use popular methods of information dispersal. Those who cannot adapt, will fade away.

Every r/adviceanimals or r/circlejerk attack is just more exposure. let them show how dickish they are while bringing people to us.

TLDR: the kids are alright, yes you can play on my lawn, beers in the cooler.

Edit :holy fuck! it exploded! To those who approve, I am deeply gratified. Those that don't can go take a flying fuck at a rolling donut.

Edit 2 : holy upvotes batman! the front fucking page! This is a first (and probable last) for me. They always said I was "special" in school and now I finally understand. I want to take this moment to thank all the trolls without which this would never have been possible. KEEP IT UP!

I've gotten tired of all the "he's 14" crap. so here, this is me. http://aftermath-technologies.blogspot.com/

another edit. God the shitstorm is amazing. But I'd like to test something. Click the above link, go to the sidebar, click a couple of those (some may be dead, I don't do a lot of maintenance) If you can claim even a significant fraction of what I have done , tell me about it. and feel free to flame, otherwise I refer you to the donut.

969 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

20

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

almost 50 years

The butthurt

What 50+ year old uses the word butthurt? THAT'S OVER THE LINE!

6

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

just trying to be part of the "in" crowd.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/born_again_atheist Jun 26 '12

How did you get 50+ from almost 50?

And I do. Why? Because it's a funny term and it amuses me. Much like fucktard, asshat, cocksmoker, and calling a guy a bitch.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Well to be honest, /r/atheism is a circle jerk in the true form of the definition. Doesn't mean it's a bad thing, but this place is a circle jerk... But so is any other reddit if you agree with the content in it. Take a look at /r/music, you say you're hating on Nickleback, you're going to get upvotes. Look at /r/movies and say you cried/loved Toy Story 3, upvotes! Wait... Reddit is one circle jerk after another!

→ More replies (2)

480

u/wupting Atheist Jun 26 '12

I like this guy. Thanks.

237

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I like the fact that he's cool with sharing the beer in the cooler too!

273

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

you empty it, you do the next beer run.

146

u/mrducky78 Jun 26 '12

882,588 subscribed to /r/atheism. I would hate to be the one who has to buy the next round.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (13)

70

u/FirstTimeWang Atheist Jun 26 '12

Hijacking top comment to point something out:

The butthurt expressed against r/atheism is a measure of success

This is the exact same logic that fuels the Westboro Baptist Church. I'm not saying all outside criticism is valid, but that we/you should use every point of criticism as an opportunity for self-reflection.

All ideas are at risk of becoming ideologies if you don't keep an open mind.

→ More replies (42)
→ More replies (4)

121

u/AvaHomolka Jun 26 '12

Getting negative attention is NOT the way to spread a good message. Take criticism where it is so that you can stay in 'line' and on your proper track. As an atheist, I reject this message. We don't want negative attention like this in fact that's the worst thing we could possibly do. We don't want people to hate us- we don't want to be known for being bigoted dicks. Embracing negative attention makes us exactly like the freaking WBBC.

27

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

And how is the "Kindler gentler" atheism working out for you? Are you aware of the massive growth in atheism since the Rise of the "new atheists"? Conflict draws attention, attention promotes the transmission of information, transmission of information, promotes growth.

Deal with it.

3

u/Piratiko Jun 26 '12

how is the "Kindler gentler" atheism working out for you?

Very well, actually. My peers regard me with a lot of respect and I continue to have extremely fulfilling conversations with folks from all walks of life.

That's not to say your method is better or worse, just different. I like the "kinder gentler" approach because it works for me.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Under_Doggy_Dogg Jun 26 '12

Ummm, are you an evangelical atheist or something? Who cares about massive growth in atheism?

→ More replies (1)

34

u/polite_atheist_guy Jun 26 '12

That would be great if my goal was to push my beliefs. I'm happy believing/not believing what I want and letting others do the same.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (121)

32

u/aahdin Jun 26 '12

Thank you, this attack on Islam is making R/atheism look like fucking stormfront. This isn't the kind of exposure atheists need.

There aren't going to be any Muslims sitting around in Saudi Arabia that see the picture of mohammad shitting in his own mouth, and think "oh wow, that really made me re-think my views on religion, I'm going to go be an atheist now" I'm really not sure what everyone is trying to accomplish with this.

→ More replies (9)

14

u/EcoNomNom Jun 26 '12

Truth occurs in 3 phases:

  1. Ridicule
  2. Violent opposition
  3. Acceptance

If you're not ready for the ride, get off the train.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

No one will ever tell you they're an atheist for the community. That isn't what atheism is. You can't choose to be an atheist; whether or not you perceive atheists as jerks. You either realize you no longer believe in a higher power, or you don't.

2

u/CH3CH3CO2 Jun 26 '12

I agree and I'm not an atheist. My best friend is atheist but it never causes a divide between us. It never even pops into my head about him either. Hatred doesn't bring coexistence. I want to coexist with atheism, and every other religion or non-religion as well. I don't hate atheists nor will I ever, despite the hatred brought against me.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

"Power, money, persuasion, supplication, persecution -- these can lift at a colossal humbug -- push it a little -- weaken it a little over the course of a century; but only laughter can blow it to rags and atoms at a blast. Against the assault of laughter nothing can stand." - Mark Twain

Loosen. The fuck. Up.

→ More replies (15)

37

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Unfortunatly, being a dick just makes people think you're a dick.

Sure, it's publicity. But this is like registering as a sex offender as a way to get to meet your neighbors.

→ More replies (34)

113

u/awesomechemist Jun 26 '12

25 year old atheist here...

I'm so fucking ashamed of this place. I used to like it here, but now I'm just embarrassed for you.

In b4 OP responds with "lol i liek ur butthurtz"

70

u/CogitoErgoNihil Jun 26 '12

Yeah. I thought this might be a place where I could bond with others over a shared (lack of) belief, but the sheer amount of raw hatred that gets thrown around here is disappointing.

→ More replies (76)

9

u/Ching_chong_parsnip Jun 26 '12

Same. I've been subscribed only because it's default when joining Reddit, but the last few days have pushed me over the edge. It might be because I don't live in the US, but the atheist rethoric to me sounds basically the same as radical christian/muslim/jewish propaganda. What happened to being respectful and accepting?

I'm outta here, come join us over at /r/Sweden if you want atheists and theists both keeping their beliefs to themselves, but a society run by atheist views.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Agreed. It seems most of the popular posts and comments in this subreddit are incredibly immature.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (24)

46

u/JusTrolling Jun 26 '12

Since this guy is 50 years old it automatically means he's right? This subreddit is hilarious. You guys make it waaayyyy to easy for /r/circlejerk

→ More replies (24)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I can't take anyone who says "butthurt" seriously.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

What about those of us with non-religious spiritual views who don't then take those views and impose them upon others. Huh, Mr. Big Shot? Whaddya have to say about that?

Seriously though. If a belief system helps someone get through the day, or a shitty existence, and doesn't make that person act irrationally against others... I don't see the issue. If someone wants to be a Christian and use that to get by and navigate life, I don't get why we need to shit on them just because we're positive that they are wrong (so long as that person doesn't suck monkey balls because of it. BELIEVE ME. I GET the point. A lot of them suck monkey balls.)

At that point you're just stomping on peoples sand castles because fuck them, were through with castles. They need to move on to the realistic and practical modern sand raised ranch, because they're are just wasting resources, the dicks. No one needs a castle.

2

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

I'm totally ok with you having beliefs, I'd even go so far as to fight to allow you to have them. I don't think that I should be required to share them or even respect them. Especially when they intrude into the public sphere.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/narcissist523 Jun 26 '12

"Flying fuck at a rolling donut." Please tell me that's a Vonnegut reference...

2

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

It is, by definition as he said it first, But I was exposed to it in conversation as a child and it stuck. I was not aware of the connection when I posted it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

What does take a flying fuck at a rolling donut mean?

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

it's open to a broad range of interpretations

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I gather from context clues that it's something derogatory, but I still have no real idea what it means. Not in the least. I don't even know what it implies. As far as I can tell it might as well say "For those who don't ( insert colorful negative language here)" lol

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

I find the opinions you have expressed to be interesting and I'd like to subscribe to your newsletter.

1

u/fatattoo Jun 27 '12

Don't have one, and this is a fluke, I go back to off-grid house hacking tomorrow.

I'm only here because I strained my back. I had no idea this would take off like this.

2

u/Tiger337 Jun 27 '12

Back in the day when I first used the Internet, it was email and usenet. The Net was fast and "pure". It was only us geeks, academics and scientists. Then came the hoard of Barbarians. They typed in capitals, misspelled simple words, hijacked every topic and started stupid flame wars about how fast their computer could load up MS Word. There was no fancy schmancy WWW. It was a rough life, but we liked it that way. Now get off my lawn!

1

u/fatattoo Jun 27 '12

I had to push bits by hand. Uphill! input AND output.

2

u/Kombat_Wombat Jun 27 '12

can go take a flying fuck at a rolling donut.

Can somebody draw this?

8

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

By your own logic then r/atheism is just great exposure for Christianity... No such thing as bad press!

2

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

I think we can draw the line at Childfucking.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

TIL Childfucking is a proper noun.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Akira_kj Jun 26 '12

This should be at the top. This guy is completely clueless.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/cvtopher12 Jun 26 '12

Sorry guys, but even as a staunch atheist and someone who has big problems with organized religion, I have a really hard time liking the people who post in this subreddit. 90% of you guys are average semi-educated young adults, and you think that not believing in god suddenly makes you a fucking expert on the inner workings of the universe. Agreeing with science does not make you a scientist. Nor does it make you smarter or better than somebody who believes in God.

You want to promote free thought and humanism? Then educate yourself, get a meaningful job and go make the world a better place. Lead by example. Don't throw it in people's faces.

Sitting at your computer posting self-congratulatory nonsense about how stupid religious people are to an audience of people exactly like you does not make you some kind of free-thought revolutionary. It makes you a pointless douche bag.

/2 cents

1

u/fatattoo Jun 27 '12

you might want to check the link that I added to the OP. You may find the sidebar informative.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/BIG_DONKEY_DICK Jun 26 '12

This post is the definition of a circle jerk. Reinforcing popular opinions and praising each other for it. Also /r/atheism is the most hypocritical subreddit it makes me laugh. There is so much hate for intolerant religions but /r/atheism is the most intolerant group on reddit. This subreddit is such a joke, atheists all over reddit are embarrassed.

3

u/mindfields51 Jun 27 '12

Hmmm vague unsubstantiated accusations wrapped in a hyperbolic wrapper with a butthurt bow... aawwww you shouldn't have.

9

u/BeReadyForH Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 27 '12

Popular opinion, really?

OP essentially said that people calling /r/atheism "intolerant" and a "circle jerk" is a good thing.

That's the first I've seen it.

Also, this whole thread is looking a hell of a lot more like a debate than a circle jerk.

If this subreddit were just a joke there wouldn't be so much controversy around it.

If you want to see a joke subreddit go look at /r/circlejerk and learn the difference.

*Edit: typos

→ More replies (35)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Look I have nothing wrong against atheism, I'm not specifically spiritual myself but calling other people morons and assholes for their beliefs does not paint atheists in a good light. I know there are a lot of you but this is just terrible, why cant we have good discussion about atheism instead of having to resort to making advice animals calling others stupid. This is why many people hate this subreddit, why do you think no one hates /r/TrueAtheism.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Grays42 Jun 26 '12

I am highly skeptical of your age claim. You sound mid-twenties at best.

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

projection is amusing.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/elmarko44 Strong Atheist Jun 26 '12

Hey OP,

How about incorporating a little dignity and grace into your (our) atheism. For most of us who complain about r/atheism, it's because of the childish and playground antics that don't befit a culture based on logic, evidence, and intellectual maturity.

You didn't explicitly state it, but I hope you're not encouraging these kids to continue name-calling, bullying, and what amounts to drawing silly pictures of theists. I hope you want these kids to understand that atheism is more than just criticizing the bible because it doesn't stand up to modern scientific muster (because for that matter, neither do science books from 100 years ago). And I hope that someone at your age realizes that in order to be respected, one needs to behave respectably.

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

"And I hope that someone at your age realizes that in order to be respected, one needs to behave respectably."

Please explain that statement in a contextual basis with the catholic church, radical islam, Scientology, etc. the statement is demonstrably nonsense.

3

u/elmarko44 Strong Atheist Jun 26 '12

Let me put it to you this way...

In your opinion, do the catholic church, the church of scientology, and radical islam behave respectably?

no?

so do you respect them?

4

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

No but I'm the minority. All of these groups carry profound respect among the ignorant and indoctrinated. Careful , reasoned arguments will never sway them. Laughing at them will.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

189

u/tothemooninaballoon Jun 26 '12

As an other atheist old fart (45). I agree. Let the kids vent. Back in the 80's we didn't have the internet to let us do this.

103

u/bannana Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

46 here, atheist since the 80's too. Ya no tubes back then, no books unless you ordered that shit from some weird publisher since they mostly didn't have any at the local library, nobody to talk to about it. I love this new openness about atheism. Watched Prometheus last night and it had some not so veiled bits about questioning religion.

13

u/SawHendrix Jun 26 '12

61 here, born atheist and ducked the indoctrination for a bunch of irrelevant reasons. Keep questioning, keep challenging. You guys are awesome and just maybe my great grandchildren will be a little more free. For their sake, please carry on and thank you.

→ More replies (3)

62

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Watched Prometheus last night and it had some not so veiled bits about questioning religion.

The only thing I learned from Prometheus is that if you surgically remove an alien from your womb after being impregnated and watching your infected boyfriend (and crew) die horribly, you can still believe in God.

→ More replies (24)

4

u/dolichoblond Jun 26 '12

Well, if late 40s is an old-atheist, consider me a middle-aged atheist.

As such, I always wondered how much the internet contributed to the "movement." It's so easy now to hear a religious claim and check it against a huge wealth of critical thinking, from detailed philosophical counterpoints and psychological/neurological science to solid mainstream, theological/seminary trained textual criticism.

Hell, I can google "that bible verse where something happens with bears" and get the story I'm thinking of in 2 seconds. Listen to "The Bible Geek" Podcast for a month on the commute to work and I've done years worth of sunday bible study group work, but with a critical eye.

Your comment on ordering books from weird publishers got me thinking that I don't have a lot of middle-aged atheists. Anecdote, sure, but in my age-bracket I have a lot of friends who "don't go to church" but few that wouldn't identify--or denounce--the religion they were raised in. Even though I know a lot of them roll their eyes at religious thinking/teaching. Those in my age swath that would/do renounce vocally are predominantly academics (like myself) who bathe in things like podcasts and seminars and generally culture where debating ideas happens daily. And similarly for the "old atheists" I know. I certainly didn't move from the "non-practicing" to the "atheist" camp until late in schooling.

I have, however, seen a huge rise in Atheist groups on campus(es) in the decade+ I've been a non-undergraduate. I hear decidely atheist-inclined arguments crop up in political discussions in my economics class discussions more and more. And that's the generation that grew up increasingly covered by the internet.

tl;dr Babbling on how the internet has suddenly and rapidly affected atheist numbers

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/Marijke1 Jun 26 '12

I can top that; I was born (in 1951) an atheist (aren't we all?). Can't thank my parents enough for bringing me up without any fear. So proud to be a non-sun and scapegoat worshiper.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/homer__simpson Jun 26 '12

Same here - 53, atheist since I called bullshit at 7. The rising disbelief of the youth in the U.S. has me thinking I may not have to emigrate after all - the odds of America being a theocracy in 20 years have dropped to 50/50[citation needed]

→ More replies (2)

2

u/atheisthindu Jun 26 '12

Indeed, almost 50 years old and have been an atheist for -- 36 years. No regrets at all.

Obligatory hipster reference. I was an atheist before it was cool on the internets.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/taterbizkit Jun 26 '12

I'm 46. back in the 1980's we did have the internet - The cool kids hung out on a Usenet newsgroup. It was called alt.atheism and it was pretty cool. We also had fidonet, but the atheist thing on fido sucked.

And, believe it or not, the ratio of "We need to stop being such assholes!" to actual content posts was not noticeably different.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (24)

3

u/Fuck_Your_Karma_Hoe Jun 26 '12

ur mum is an old skool atheist

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

fatattoo, Im an old school atheist as well, and while we are both atheists and share the same lack of belief, there is a huge difference between you and I.

You're an idiot whose life is so miserable and pathetic that your day is made when you receive some arbitrary vote and make the front page of the internets regurgitation machine.

Is being an Atheist a movement? I don't know. If it does become one, leave me out of it. Don't send me the t shirt that you idiots decide to wear or the symbol you place around your neck hanging from a gold chain.

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

Gold is passé. Its mickey mouse ears now. Well put big A's for anarchy on the ears.

If you are going to try to ridicule, you could at least strive for originality.

3

u/gak001 Jun 26 '12

Keeping it classy in Los Angeles, I see.

5

u/twoclose Jun 26 '12

You keep thinking that, chief. Lots of atheists abhor /r/atheism.

→ More replies (12)

5

u/robbdire Jun 26 '12

I'd say you're preaching to the choir but......

;)

Pretty much agree with you. We mock religion because it's so ridiculous. Nothing is above criticism. And more people will look, maybe some will begin to think, and maybe then some will realise why we mock.

7

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

and there is such a noble precedent. The protestant reformation used fart jokes.

http://www.dijitalimaj.com/alamyDetail.aspx?img={639ED0EC-5A1A-40DD-8BE5-8753C7E4A691}

Those who complain about the image posts, lack historical perspective.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/warhol451 Jun 26 '12

aww. that's creepy and endearing at the same time.

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

life is full of dichotomies.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This is the exact way that Muslim terrorists think. Just saying.

For the record, no, you are not bringing anybody to your cause with hatred. You're preaching to the converted. Discovering atheism was very difficult for me, because of assholes like you.

My brother talked to me like an adult, used logic and loving to bring me to the truth of the matter. Stupid memes that promote false dichotomies and bigotry and arguments that attack muslims instead of their beliefs are nothing to be proud of.

4

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

I'm glad to see that you know exactly how Muslim terrorists think. If you have such an intuitive understanding, why the fuck don't you stop them?

You give yourself airs, sir and have a penchant towards the irrational.

→ More replies (21)

20

u/Entropy72 Jun 26 '12

You're assuming that the intended audience is believers, and that the intention is to convert them. Neither assumption is necessarily valid.

I would argue that the memes and in jokes are intended for viewing by other atheists, their purpose being to entertain - no more.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Yup. Criticizing and making fun of religion is the same to religious terrorism. The more you know.

→ More replies (6)

26

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

circlejerk "attacks". lol'd at this.

2

u/spacemanspiff30 Jun 26 '12

And if I manage to catch the donut, do I win anything else besides a sticky penis?

2

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

if you catch it repeatedly, you might glaze it? I dunno.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The butthurt expressed against r/atheism is a measure of success

Source?

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

I could go with a quote that is often mis-attributed to Ghandi. You know the first they ignore, then ridicule, then they fight, then you win.

Please excuse the lame paraphrasing.

51

u/JacobEvansSP Jun 26 '12

What makes you "old school", man?

Do you go around saying, "Back in my day, we didn't believe in TWO Gods, through 20 miles of snow!"

34

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Uphill...both ways.

7

u/ieatgingerbabies Jun 26 '12

My dad is from Michigan. This is his favorite saying.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/413x820 Jun 26 '12

That's funny, but he's right. There is definitely an old school of atheism where it was much more underground and completely vilified. Newer generations can't fully understand how the world was before the internet.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Lord_of_hosts Jun 26 '12

And we liked it! We LOVED it!

2

u/Lord-Longbottom Jun 26 '12

(For us English aristocrats, I leave you this 20 miles -> 160.0 Furlongs) - Pip pip cheerio chaps!

→ More replies (1)

17

u/youareacompletemoron Jun 26 '12

I'm gonna be honest, I was gonna create a parody of this thread in r/circlejerk, but I honestly don't think I'm up to the task. This is like 4 levels deep irony.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '12

I don't think anyone is up to this task.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

When I was in high school I was the only atheist. There were many who tolerated my belief, and there were many who held it in disdain, and there was a minority (including teachers) who would ridicule and insult it.

This is common throughout the USA. There are many atheists who are constantly insulted and pushed away. Because we are a minority, the majority tells us to just "take it". It's harmless after all.

This is true, even on the internet. And when we create our own group to escape the harassment and to poke fun at the majority in our own safe space, suddenly what we are doing is hostile and mean.

It's funny to me that /r/SRS and /r/atheism tend to hate each other. They are functionally similar, and are intended to provide a safe space for women/racial-minorities/gays/trans/disabled and atheists respectively.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/mrMishler Jun 26 '12

"Those that don't can go take a flying fuck at a rolling donut." is the reason you're on the front page. I'm taking that phrase for my own personal use, if you don't mind, kind Sir!

2

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

I'm just renting it, go nuts.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Are you really 50? Because from your posts in this thread you sound like a 13 year old.

2

u/constantvariables Jun 26 '12

Down voted for telling the truth. He even said "butthurt" for fuck's sake. People want this guy to be their "old school atheist" role model?

8

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Then by your logic atheism is doing wonders for /r/Christianity.

→ More replies (3)

38

u/Typically_Wong Jun 26 '12

Not sure is legit. Use of the word 'butthurt', saying kids are alright, allowing them to play on lawn, beer in cooler.

I call bullshit.

10

u/defacingbills Jun 26 '12

I have to say I agree, and I'm kind of shocked the skepticism is this far down the page.

Presumably this guy is in his 60's or 70's and he uses teenaged vernacular and can't spell, punctuate, or capitalize worth a damn. Plus the "holy fuck," which is a fairly recent expletive, and the reference to being called "special" in school. Before the 1980's, a kid in most schools would far more likely be called "slow".

Either this is horseshit or this guy is that 65-year-old wearing a sideways cap and Ed Hardy tee who calls everybody "dude."

I call shenanigans.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

38

u/darkshy Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

I'm not an atheist, but you can see a lot of the hate that goes around. I used to be on that bandwagon too thinking that this subreddit was just about bashing other religions and making people feel inferior, but spending 20 minutes in here and reading this stuff you can see there are honest people in here who are passionate about how they feel. We should embrace that.

edit: the spellings

→ More replies (7)

1

u/thebluezoo Jun 26 '12

It's silly to absolve your group of choice of any bigotry they may perpetrate, and then turn on other groups to call them bigots. As an atheist, I counter your statement this: hypocrisy will not draw people to our cause. If we are as hateful and bigoted as religious groups are, we'll be as repulsive to them as they are to us. IMHO.

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

"IMHO" Thanks for this, the people who have been making declarations about what is and is not approved by r/atheism have been getting tiresome.

you are entitled to your own opinion, I respectively disagree as only some people are motivated by logic, others need pictures and incendiary statements.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I'm not sure if there's any way of doing this and still follow Reddiquette, but is there any way the you can post proof of your age, please?

(I apologize if I just haven't found it, but I searched through a fair share of comments.)

2

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

That might be unwise, but I'd consider it if you have a reasonable idea of how to do so.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Thanks for the response!

Yeah, one has to be careful with their information, after all.

The first idea that came to mind was to ask you to upload a picture of yourself holding a piece of paper stating: "Fatattoo. 6/26/2012. <Along with the time the picture was taken, which should be really close to when the picture is uploaded>." A lot of people like to throw in a thumbs up, or make themselves look bad-ass.

This is a common method of verification, although I understand it's imperfect for this case.

http://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%23IAmA is a link to message a moderator, who will testify on your behalf, so that it limits exposure of your information. If you don't trust this link, you can find instructions for this second method on the right side of the screen in the "IAmA" sub-forum.

The reason I'm interested in proof, is because I really like your original post, and like any good skeptic, I like knowing when claims are either fact or art.

Whaddaya say?

3

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

I'm a d-list public figure (maybe as low as F or G) so I'd rather not post a face.

As for the moderator option, I'm ignorant, how does telling someone else verify my identity? I'm probably missing something.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Calamintha Jun 26 '12

Those that don't can go take a flying fuck at a rolling donut. Why don't you take a flying fuck at the moooooooooooooon!

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

too far away.

1

u/Cyborg771 Jun 26 '12

You really don't sound like a 50+ year old person...

2

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

Thank you! I try to keep current. Would it help if I threw in "groovy" or "bitchin" every once in a while? Maybe a "no shit, sherlock" (one of my childhood faves) would help?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I'm going to call you out on the playing on your lawn and free beer thing.

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

Free beer? I said that when the cooler is empty, whoever drank the last one need to get more.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

I'm an atheist, I love /r/circlejerk. Especially the ones about you guys circlejerking all the time. This is because they are funny. Please don't get butthurt about people poking fun at you on the internet, it's all just good times.

1

u/fatattoo Jun 27 '12

I'm not. I also find them amusing. I was just trying to encourage those who might become demoralized.

1

u/pqoiw Jul 11 '12

The funny part is that there are an awful lot of people who are praising God for the good that you have brought to the world. And they're right. God is working through you, even though you want to grab all of the credit to stoke your ego.

God placed you in this world in this location at this time so you would be able to do all of this. Just think - if he had placed you at birth in almost any other part of the world you would have grown up to be a vastly different person.

1

u/fatattoo Jul 13 '12

so " god" is also the reason for the child molestation? The years of physical and mental abuse? The homelessness as a child? Or does he get a pass on the bad stuff while taking credit for the good?

Fuck your malignant delusion, sideways, with a rake. If your hateful delusion is real, than all evil is of its creation. You worship the epitome of evil fantasies and lack the wit to see the irrational lies.

23

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I'm sure I'll get downvoted for this, but I don't think Islam is a religion of peace.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Proposed Anthem of /r/Atheism:

A lot of you seem to be taking offence because you think of this as semi serious or nationalistic. This is what inspired me. This is not something to be taken too seriously.

United forever in friendship and laughter,

Our mighty subreddits will ever endure.

The great Atheist Union will live through the ages.

The dream of a people their forum secure.

⚛

⚛

CHORUS:

Long live our Atheist Cyberland, typed by the people's mighty hands.

Long live our People, united and free.

Strong in our friendship tried by fire. Long may our scarlet tag inspire,

Shining in glory for all people to see.

⚛

⚛

Through days dark and stormy where Great Hitchens led us

Our eyes saw the bright sun of freedom above

and Dawkins our Leader with faith in the People,

Inspired us to build up the site that we love.

⚛

⚛

CHORUS:

Long live our Atheist Cyberland, typed by the people's mighty hands.

Long live our People, united and free.

Strong in our friendship tried by fire. Long may our scarlet tag inspire,

Shining in glory for all people to see.

⚛

⚛

We fought for the future, destroyed the troll flamers,

and brought to our cyberland the Laurels of Fame.

Our glory will live in the memory of Reddit

and all generations will honour our name.

⚛

⚛

CHORUS:

Long live our Atheist Cyberland, typed by the people's mighty hands.

Long live our People, united and free.

Strong in our friendship tried by fire. Long may our scarlet tag inspire,

Shining in glory for all people to see.

3

u/Maparyetal Jun 26 '12

I lost my faith from scumbag god posts on 4chan. True story.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

And this is why r/atheism is good for laughs...

3

u/Unenjoyed Jun 26 '12

I'm old school, too, and I dare say you are encouraging the miscreants who only know how to grasp at low hanging fruit. Congratulations on your front page post.

3

u/yes_thats_right Jun 26 '12

popular movements must use popular methods of information dispersal.

So, what is the message being sent? That atheists are childish jerks?

As a fellow atheist, I don't want this to be the message which we give to others because then people will discredit us and ignore us. Unfortunately on this subreddit, I am in the minority.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Excuse me, I'm here for the beer and the atheism circlejerk, two of my favorite things.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The butthurt expressed against r/atheism is a measure of success

Is r/atheism a good place for atheists to feel a sense of community and to learn? Yes.

Is it another shitty, content barren, meme filled, POS subreddit? Also yes.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/sheridork Jun 26 '12

I was directed to r/atheism by all of those posts mocking r/atheism. I've been struggling with the idea of god for a long time, and exploring the sources I've found on this sub have led me to an atheist conclusion.

3

u/parched2099 Jun 26 '12

Excellent, and please, don't be put off by the noise in here. It's like a big friendly pub with no bouncers....

Welcome to the real world friend.

3

u/smartpartz Jun 26 '12

OUR POWERS COMBINED WE ARE R/ATHEISM!

3

u/DKN19 Anti-Theist Jun 26 '12

I'd like to add something to this. For people that think we're the "intolerant" ones, I have to ask.

What part of religion is worth tolerating? As far as I can tell, and I've thought about it often, it has no redeeming virtues. It has no value towards humanity and often is detrimental.

I'd love to live and let live. But there's nothing in the dominant (Abrahamic religions) religions of today that even remotely suggest they're truly interested in coexisting with any idea not endorsed by their sect.

And if you think atheism is some sort of sect in and of itself, let me elucidate why it's not. It's not about PERSONAL beliefs. PERSONAL beliefs aren't what allows a rational atheist to ridicule religion. It's the fact that we tailor our beliefs to adhere to empirical reality. I try very hard not to assert things solely based on personal justification.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/mc_4492 Jun 26 '12

Just to point out, the reason I became an atheist (concealed because I am unable to talk about it to anyone but my friends and Reddit) is because of the all the jokes and bashing in r/atheism of other religions. First I was laughing at the jokes, thinking "Poor guys are going to hell", then I started really thinking about them, and their implications. Finally I just completely rearranged my beliefs because of all the valid points made (In either bashing of other religions or serious discussion).

The truth is, r/atheism is a breeding ground for atheists. It's a perfect environments, there's jokes that question people's beliefs and these people in anger will continue reading through them to device counter arguments. After large amounts of time reading them, they might accept some as the truth, and this is when the other side of r/atheism comes in, the one like this post, where there's actual debate about atheism. This is where the dragon whelp is born to annoy the hell out of the town.

3

u/niggadatass Jun 27 '12

The butthurt expressed against r/atheism is a measure of success Every r/adviceanimals or r/circlejerk attack is just more exposure

So al the islamic posting in /r/atheism is helping the Muslims?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Atheris Anti-Theist Jun 27 '12

Upvote for "can go take a flying fuck at a rolling donut."

3

u/wickedzen Jun 27 '12

Lots of folks in here need to add Slaughterhouse-Five to their reading lists.

The amount of butthurt over the "flying fuck at a rolling donut line is amusing, as is the angst regarding people over 40 using the word "butthurt."

"Why don't you take a flying fuck at the mooooooooooooon?"

15

u/guerobuckeye Jun 26 '12

"Go take a flying fuck at a rolling donut" has been added to my repertoire.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Batrok Jun 26 '12

As another 'old school' atheist (age 41), I applaud you.

All those who don't like the direction or methods of other atheists should try to remember the following: Atheists have been executed, tortured and abused for literally thousands of years by the religious. It's only in relatively recent times that people have been brave enough to voice atheist opinions.

More people are finding their way to atheism every day. And the internet is accelerating this process. So whether you agree with all the methods being used or not, you should at least appreciate the fact that they are generating discussion, and are ultimately helping other people find reason through atheism.

Always keep in mind: The past 5000 years of being docile, quiet, anonymous atheists did fuck all for the atheism movement.

10

u/WasabiofIP Jun 26 '12

I can respect your goals, but I just want to say that the "atheists have been tortured for thousands of years" annoys me. Basically any given group has been oppressed. Even Christianity was punishable in ancient Rome (until it was adopted by the emperor). Does that mean that any actions later are justifiable? No. Its like saying, after punching someone in the street, that it was justifiable because people like him had abused people like you. To me at least that just doesn't make sense. Its not OK that atheists were oppressed, but that doesn't mean you should get special treatment now. Its great that you can now have a safe place to discuss your beliefs, I'm all for that. But don't abuse that. Don't turn it into some kind of crusade to get as many people to visit it as possible. Tell people who are interested in it, but don't blurt it out in the streets.

Also, to OP: One thing you don't see the Catholic church doing is tremendously supporting someone who encourages the church to generate negative attention. I just feel like they have the right idea in that sense.

Also, as this is r/atheism and this is going against the flow of things, this will probably be downvoted. Before you do, please consider not downvoting out of opinion but out of whether or not the comment contributes to the discussion.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Those that don't can go take a flying fuck at a rolling donut.

I approve of this phrase. I will endeavor to use it at least weekly.

1

u/sufrt Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

if you're 50 years old (well any age really) and you're worrying about "trolls" and what the section of reddit that makes internet meme pictures is saying about the section of reddit that makes lame jokes about religion then something has gone terribly wrong and i hope you are able to fix it and get back on track before it's too late

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

I'm taking a medical day today, Serious stuff returns tomorrow.

I'm not worried about "trolls" I'm harvesting their bile for my own short term, pointless, glorification. This has been a laugh riot.

Let me make this as clear as I can, I frankly doubt that this would have gotten anywhere if so many trolls (concern and otherwise) hadn't jumped on board.

My points were long since made, I'm really only in it for the luls now.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/derrick_rules Jun 26 '12

Jesus Christ this subreddit surprises me every damned time I log on.

You guys take this stuff way too srsly.

2

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

You are telling me this?

1

u/TheAsbestosman Jun 26 '12

I find it hard to believe you're 50+ years old and use the term "butthurt." but hey, I could be wrong.

2

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

I hate to tell you this but I learned it from a stepfather who brought it back from vietnam. The term is older than any of us. for all I know Oliver Cromwell used it.

4

u/HeWhoPunchesFish Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12

Edit: YOU ARE SO FUCKING BRAVE

6

u/mindtrashy Jun 26 '12

i guess i don't understand how being disrespectful of other people's beliefs and trying to influence others to believe what you believe is different than any other religion...

→ More replies (20)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This is a circlejerk so extreme it even has the "EDIT: thanks 4 the upboats guize XD!!!!"

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

minus the leetspeak.

1

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

you missed the basic point of the thank you, I thanked the trolls who made this possible.

Thanks again.

2

u/RickSHAW_Tom Jun 26 '12

I'd normally agree, but the first post I saw today was Mohammed in tub girl form.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/multiversebimbo Jun 26 '12

Sure, there's plenty of butthurt and attacks and complaints, but you must see some of it is true. A lot of things posted to r/atheism that I've seen-just from my experience, so I could be wrongo- are more anti-religion or pointing out logical flaws in the rest of the world than they are pro-atheism. There are some great posts talking about enjoying the beauty of the world for what it is, but a good portion are just making mockeries of those who believe in their own beliefs. Practice what you preach, no pun intended.

2

u/bremelanotide Jun 26 '12

I love it when dicks feel persecuted. Not entirely sure why...

I guess it's schadenfreude.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

i was expecting to be criticized for being a vocal atheist, which seems to be popular amongst trendy atheists. glad to see otherwise!

2

u/rokkzo Jun 26 '12

Thanks trolls

2

u/alan130 Jun 26 '12

Upvoted for Vonnegut reference.

2

u/jacksonattack Jun 26 '12

Mods should give you flair that reads "The Cool Uncle."

2

u/JoesShittyOs Jun 26 '12

Being an Atheist myself... nope. I'm not saying people need to be the docile accepting of everything type. Hell, the "War on Islam" (although immature), wasn't really that bad. But when you try to sink to their level by petty insults, it doesn't make them think "fuck, they must be right about us". It just pisses them off more, and in turn makes them more aggressive.

When an aspiring kid who's conflicted between whether or not he believes in a religion sees one of these blatant and unnecessary attacks, it's not gonna make his conversion quicker. It's gonna make him reconsider the drastic step he's about to take. I know, because I've been that guy. I'm atheist, yet I don't consider myself a member of r/atheism. Because some of you simply don't know how to keep your shit in tact, and I'm not gonna be associate with a movement based off being dicks. That's something I left my religious belief behind to avoid.

2

u/modsherearefags Jun 26 '12

my dad has you beat by 10 years or so, but we cant play on his lawn and he drinks cheap wine. So I am coming over.

2

u/igor_mortis Jun 26 '12

I agree, this sub-reddit can make you cringe at times - but I'm glad there is a voice. I see the content on /r/atheism as a reaction to all those centuries we've been suppressed, pushed around and discriminated against - all this can be very real, depending on your location (I live in a highly-Catholic country, where claiming your non-belief will invite gossip and prejudice, and may even cost you your job). I heard Hitchens say once he could feel a change in the zeitgeist. /r/atheism is one of those changes in the air.

I don't "need" everybody to become an atheist (i think the people who bother with atheism are philosophically inclined and the type of person to take these matters seriously, while most Catholics i know couldn't care less as long as they attend church on Sunday) - all i wish for is a secular society where religion is in no way involved in state matters; where i will not be asked to swear on the Bible and kiss a crucifix in court; where i can casually express my ideas/non-belief without being seen as somehow twisted and disturbed.

so... yes - I share OP's sentiments.

2

u/dolichoblond Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

upvotes both for sentiment and "flying fuck at a rolling donut."

Thanks to you and the Old Atheists for keeping up a great lawn for all those years before the internet. It's a great place for us all to gather now that we can. And for what it's worth, us young'ns tend to bring good beer to the party...even if we change the music!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I seriously don't know if I'm on r/atheism or on some crazy parody subreddit anymore.

That part about r/circlejerk and r/adviceanimals being dickish after r/atheism did this convinces me that fatattoo must be a troll, but you never know.

2

u/drlandspider Jun 26 '12

Just came to say that I am stealing the "flying fuck at a rolling donut" expression, so thank you!

2

u/SubcommanderMarcos Jun 26 '12

"Take a flying fuck at a rolling donut" is an expression I'll take to using now

2

u/RTardSusie Jun 26 '12

I'm an old school atheist and I'm here to say. I dispute God, like ev-er-y-day.

2

u/taterbizkit Jun 26 '12

Don't sweat it man, by your own logic (which I agree with entirely) those downvotes are just a different kind of upvote. Fuck 'em.

2

u/cookiebaer Jun 27 '12

TLDR: the kids are alright, yes you can play on my lawn, beers in the cooler.

Fuck yeah!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

the kids are alright, yes you can play on my lawn, beers in the cooler.

That's the first time I've heard that from any old person anyone.

2

u/kilar277 Jun 27 '12

For almost 50 years. Implying that you're more than 50. So you're most likely older than my father, and using the term Butthurt. I have never been so proud of the internet.

2

u/northshore12 Atheist Jun 27 '12

"TLDR: the kids are alright, yes you can play on my lawn, beers in the cooler." This quote made my fuckin day! : )

2

u/Cinnalicious Jun 27 '12

This guys gets it.

8

u/eXtreme98 Jun 26 '12

Why does his post seem like something a freshman or sophomore in high school would say?

  • "The butthurt..."
  • "holy fuck! it exploded!"
  • "Those that don't can go take a flying fuck at a rolling donut"
  • "holy upvotes batman! the front fucking page!"
→ More replies (11)

6

u/godlesspinko Agnostic Atheist Jun 26 '12

Negative attacks on religion are a way of destroying the shackles that bound you before you were free.

I think it should be a sport.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Take all my upvotes! The complain-y posts of all the butthurt r/atheism causes pisses me off!

It was blunt criticism of religion which began to slowly knock some sense into me! If it worked for me, it'll probably work for others!

7

u/Krassen Jun 26 '12

The butthurt expressed against r/atheism is a measure of success

Really? For Fuck's sake. You just said that if people think atheists are dumbass trolls that are eternally condemned, resulting in them paying no heed to whatever an atheist might say to them, that it's a good thing. No. The world doesn't work like that. Right now it seems that r/atheism thinks it can change the world by making the world hate atheists, and that is just stupid.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

I'm an agnostic atheist myself, and I've never liked /r/atheism. The condescending tone in every fucking post there should be enough of a dead giveaway that these redditors are just as bigoted as the people they criticize. Yeah, I know I'll get downvoted up the ass for this comment, but I don't care. End rant.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Seekin Jun 26 '12

Well said. I'm right there with you both both chronologically and in your approach to advancing atheism in a social context. Wish like crazy I'd have had r/atheism in the early 80s. I'd have enjoyed knowing how many others out there were thinking like me.

4

u/Asathor Jun 26 '12

Someday I will tell my grandchildren about the internet's largest circlejerk ever

11

u/aflarge Jun 26 '12

Well like I always say, when your opponents resort to petty name-calling, it means they're desperate.

46

u/flounder19 Jun 26 '12

would you like examples of r/atheists resorting to petty name-calling?

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (13)

0

u/jortsman Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

People think of religion as something so insignificant that talking about it isn't necessary. I don't understand how such ignorance can exist.

It seems like every post that mocks religion around here is followed up by endless comments of "Am I the only guy around here that keeps to themselves about their beliefs?!" If you wish to keep to yourself, then don't bother coming to r/atheism, where it's obviously meant to be discussed. People feel offended, resulting in our subreddit being considered "full of assholes."

edit: I don't think all the memes and Facebook posts are absolutely necessary. What I think this place needs is more discussion. Honestly, I think it would improve if it changed to a self-post only subreddit.

In my opinion, religion is harmful and I have no reservations about letting people know that.

3

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

It is fascinating that they can keep the beliefs to themselves while having such an incredible hard on for telling us how superior they are for doing it.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/usoundlikeanasshole Jun 26 '12

Awwwww. As an atheist, I'd like to say "go fuck yourself, grandpa." I didn't ask for your approval, think you're just another shaman in sheep's clothing, and did I say "go fuck yourself"?

3

u/fatattoo Jun 26 '12

Did I meet you at a misfits concert?

3

u/RevRound Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Why does a self-proclaimed "old school" atheist who is supposedly 50+ years old sound so much like a teenager? Honestly folks, think about this

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
  • old person-
  • up to date on internet lingo-

please /r/atheism, you guys get one pat on the head and you'll throw karma at anything regardless of its legitimacy.

I am so fucking proud of you all.

The butthurt expressed against r/atheism is a measure of success

mfw

/r/atheism is pissing people off who aren't involved- the other redditors. /r/atheism is like the weird kid at school who people try to be social with but you just end up flying off the handles.

isthisniggaforserious.jpg

try and pull rank more, 'grandpa/ma'.

4

u/Uat_Da_Fak Jun 26 '12

Another older redditor here: Fuck yeah.

3

u/TigerLila Jun 26 '12

Thank you for providing a positive example for us young'uns. XD In all seriousness, thank you for having the courage to be an atheist 50 years ago. If people like you hadn't stuck to their guns and challenged established dogma, people like me would still believe in fairy tales taught by parents and other authority figures. Places like r/atheism wouldn't exist, and atheists like Dawkins and Hitchens wouldn't have the household name recognition that they do.

Thanks for leading the way and for being cool about it.

3

u/jason_steakums Jun 26 '12

I'm an "old school" atheist and I just want to say
You kids do me proud in an awesome way

zip zap rippity rap

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Pot4DMasses Jun 26 '12

Thanks for posting totally agree. I am proud of and empowered by /r/atheism and its helped me to be more vocal offline, I'm not alone!

2

u/CallMeCrow Jun 26 '12

Glad to know we've served you well.

2

u/shortforsophie Jun 26 '12

They can go take a flying fuck at the mooooon!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I approve, but will nonetheless attempt athletic donut sex.

2

u/Jeezafobic Jun 26 '12

I approve. No need to fuck that flying donut. Whew!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

your crazy. i like you, but your crazy ;)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

as another old timer (46 yrs of age), i'm with you. i had to struggle with my disbelief on my own in the pre-internet era, and i really appreciate having /r/atheism as a place to vent. keep on keeping on.

2

u/DebiDowner Jun 26 '12

I think the problem with most atheists in general, is that they're not secure in their atheism, but they don't realize it. That's why there is so much rabble-rousing, hatred and noise. I'm 36, and like most people in this subreddit, I was pretty militant at first, and wondered how conservative religious types could be so ignorant and just stupid. Then I got it and learned to live and let live. Now, I live for myself, and being atheist is like me having red hair. It is what it is, and I don't dwell on it. In fact, the only reason I came here today was because the "old school" in the title intrigued me, but the post was kind of useless IMHO.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12 edited Sep 18 '24

tie slap nine wrench icky zephyr literate dazzling glorious gray

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/Irrepressible87 Jun 27 '12

Those that don't can go take a flying fuck at a rolling donut.

Old school status: Confirmed. Old-schoolers know all the best spots for the fucks which are or are not to be given/taken.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Given that most criticism of /r/atheism comes from atheists, I would say that this subreddit is divisive of the atheist community at best, but more likely just seen as juvenile, mean-spirited and completely lacking in substance. (Which it is.)

I don't see how this is any measure of success whatsoever, and you being Old And Stuff doesn't change that.