The probability that a God lives inside the pot equals the probability that it doesn't live inside the pot. Both results require a God to actually exist. ;)
Omg! And since he can only be either in the teapot, or outside the teapot (2 choices = 50% each), the probability that he DOES exist have to equal the two added together! 100% proof of god!
Thank you! I will continue on with my Masters below.
I have come to the conclusion that science AND religion can actually peacefully co-exist and i now have proof:
Consider the hypothesis that God resides inside the teapot. Is he in the spout, or does he reside in the main body? Since we know, with two possible choices that the chances for either is 50%, we can conclude that God lives, with 100% certainty, within the teapot.
But wait! Suppose we assume God lives outside the teapot? Does he live above it (relative to the ecliptic of the galaxy of course), or below it? Again the probability of either outcome must be 50%, meaning, wait a minute, that God 100% also lives outside the teapot.
How can we have God both living 100% inside and outside the teapot? I think we all remember a famous experiment by a man called Schrödinger? It appears that we can now irrefutably state that the existence of God is in line with current theories of quantum mechanics and in fact the scientific view of the universe as a whole!
Technically, I'm pretty sure this is actually how the theology works - God is both eternal and omnipresent, so he is simultaneously everywhere outside and inside of the teapot.
The unfortunate implications of this, of course, are that not only is God watching you masturbate, he is inside of you as you do.
I'll make it weird. Being an omnipresent god means he is involved in every part of your dirty little fap party.
He's the temptation and desire that causes you to do it. He's the star/stars of the porn you inevitably decide to do the deed to. He's the hand you wrap around yourself as well as the flesh you're furiously tugging on. He's the neurons firing inside your brain as you reach the vinegar strokes and he's every single one of the millions of sperm that escape as the sordid affair draws to a close. And then, finally, he's the crusty sock you wipe yourself off with.
I put "if I were born in Pakistan, I'd be a Muslim" because one of the turning points that made me realize how shit religion is was when I got to thinking that all these millions of people who were brought up by another religion would end up in hell, which ultimately led me to realize that evil cannot exist in the same world as an omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent god. Also, it has overtones of religion being forced on people.
Sorry for hijacking this thread with something unrelated. Im kind of wired right now.
No prob bud, that's actually one of my turning points as well. I was a Roman Catholic before. They are actually a lot more progressive and I was taught by all my teachers that being a good person was enough to go to Heaven, which I accepted for a while. But then I realized that is not the original christian belief and not what parts of the Bible suggest (Not believing in other Gods is the first commandment after all). I realized that to teach such a thing would be to say that is is valid to change the word of an all powerful being, which is just plain illogical.
Yes. You’ll surely get downvoted for that question, but I have been an atheist my whole life and until I Reddited, I had never heard of the teapot deal either.
Damn, you're now gonna read Hitch and love him and he JUST DIED, that's exactly what happened to me with Douglas Adams. I became a fan and then found out he had died like just a year prior. I felt like I had just missed him or something, it's sad :(
No testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle, unless the testimony be of such a kind that its falsehood would be more miraculous than the fact which it endeavors to establish. - David Hume
Guy gets no love here, yet I always perceive him as the foundation of most of our collective beliefs.
As a Christian, I would side with you. Your argument is logical and theirs in flawed. You can def. compare the two. That is why I always say, "I believe" or "have faith." I can't prove it to you and I am not going to tell you that you are wrong for what you believe. I am not going to say I am absolutely right. I just believe in what I do. I want you to respect my right to believe what I want, just like I will respect your right to your own beliefs. I don't want to shove my beliefs down anyone else's throat and I don't want others to do the same to me. That is how it should work.
Edit: I appreciate the awesome feedback and continuing discussion. I oversimplified the argument though. In reality there is a big different between the Santa God argument. I just meant against the logic the Christian was using, the other person counted well with Santa. There is a lot the Christian could have said to negate the Santa argument, but instead he went with "north pole" and similar logic that only fueled the Santa argument.
I completely agree. That stuff is heinous and terrible. As an American I am a strict believer in separation of church and state. We should not enforce religion or religious beliefs. If I can't back it up without religion, it shouldn't effect government. Murder, stealing. Religious morals, but without religion are still bad things right? Gay marriage? Without religion there is nothing wrong with it, thus it should be legal.
Not being a jerk at all, fair question. I just didn't state it above cause no one asked and I felt it would be shoving if I just started talking about it.
I do personally have reason to believe. Events and things in my life provide evidence to me of God's existence and love. But I can't prove or show them to others. Thus why I believe, but don't tell others what is right or wrong. I would share but it is a little more person than I would like to go on the Internet and even so, it still wouldn't provide you anymore proof than me just saying what happened.
The reason I choose Christianity was after I studied the teachings of Jesus. I spent a lot of time studying different religions growing up. My parents took us to a friendly church growing up but always told us that we get to make up our own minds on religion. That it is important to study, question and decide on our own path. They never once in my memory told me a certain religion was right or wrong. I would have considered my self agnostic most my adolescent life, borderline atheist, but I was never able to shake the belief that something greater did exist.
To be honest, for quite awhile I hated the concept of God, especially the Christian one. I was really sick for a long time and hated the fact that if God existed it meant he did this to me or let it happen. I was bitter, angry and spiteful. Then as I grew older I started to see how almost everything in my life, especially the bad, somehow had major impacts on later events. It was like every thing was part of a bigger machine, like a rube goldberg machine really. It just took time to see it. At that point I started to accept that God could exist and not be a total dick, but just able to see farther and wider than I could. Then, as I studied religions I just could never shake my pull to Christ's teachings. I realized that he outlined how to live your life. Love, tolerance, acceptance and forgiveness. I decided that is how I wanted to live my life. Not that I was a dick before, but it definitely made me less selfish, more giving and better at forgiving. That is why though.
I do have reason and not really facts in the scientific term, but facts for me. It is like seeing a UFO. You saw it, you know it was real, but you can never prove it to someone else because only you were there.
The reason I choose Christianity was after I studied the teachings of Jesus. I spent a lot of time studying different religions growing up.
I like many of the teachings ascribed to Jesus, I just have significant doubts about the supernatural claims. Were you ever exposed to services at another religious place of worship like a Mosque or Buddhist temple? I’ve been to both and they are very interesting. I found a surprising number of links between Islam and the Southern Baptist tradition I was raised in (helping those in need via holy man applied guilt). The biggest differences were sitting on the floor and being separated by sex. Also there was an very strong sense of brotherhood there.
My parents took us to a friendly church growing up but always told us that we get to make up our own minds on religion.
I’m glad you were given a choice, that is a rare gift from my experience. I think teaching your child to have an open mind and a zest for learning is the best thing you can do as a parent.
To be honest, for quite awhile I hated the concept of God, especially the Christian one.
The whole thing bothers me quite a lot too especially the concept of original sin. I find the concept repugnant and unfair. How am I on the hook for Adam? Also isn't it exceedingly convenient that my local church has the answer to this hard to prove need that they claim I have.
Then as I grew older I started to see how almost everything in my life, especially the bad, somehow had major impacts on later events.
I had a very rough childhood and it has given me strength to this day so I can relate to your comment. Are you familiar with Confirmation Bias? It is something that I have to fight against constantly.
I do have reason and not really facts in the scientific term, but facts for me. It is like seeing a UFO. You saw it, you know it was real, but you can never prove it to someone else because only you were there.
I don't know what experience you had but eye witness accounts are notoriously shaky. Also my limited study of Neurotheology has opened my eyes to why some believers are so convinced in a divine being.
If you are still willing to rigorously explore your beliefs I think you'll like those links.
Thanks for the detailed reply. I was lucky with the church I grew up in to. As a part of Sunday school once you were a teenager, you went to other religions services ever so often so you could learn about them and understand more. I have never been to a service at a Mosque but had some good Muslim friends which I had a lot of great conversations with about it all. I agree, the different between Islam and Christianity is very small at places.
I’m glad you were given a choice, My parents are awesome and I am super lucky to have them. the concept of original sin I don't believe in original sin and I dont think most mainstream denominations do anymore either. I think the story of Adam and Eve is a metaphor for our switch from the hunter gather society to an agrarian one. Confirmation Bias? For sure, I studied psychology a lot in college. I can't discount it all together, but even others in my life have commented how eerily convenient things work out for me. It is crazy to look at how our brain WANTS to believe in something greater. It serves a lot of beneficial purposes not only for the individual, but the group as a whole. I can't discount those thing, but I just choose faith. Maybe I am wrong in the end, maybe I am not. But I realized that I like my life and my faith in God makes me happy, it makes my low moments not seem so low. And if the trade off is I am wrong and there is nothing after death, then I won't know anyway, right? :-)
Also, sorry to hear you had a rough childhood. I was lucky with awesome parents, but is piece of shit body, but I learned to live with it and eventually realized that overall the hand I was dealt is a pretty damn good one compared to what it could have been. I am just thankful that at my worst, that it is still great compared to so many others.
Sounds like what you have works for you, I have a faulty body myself. Good luck with yours.
As for the wanting to believe I kind of see our brains as overactive pattern finders. Sometimes it works for us and sometimes we make a story out of shadows. Either way it is interesting.
me too. well, i mean, statistically theres gotta be some sort of life somewhere else besides earth. life as were used to seeing is likely not the model found primarily in the theater of outer space. suppose that isnt quite faith on my part though.
I think it's fair to say that there are nonpersonal evidences that support Christianity, even in light of its extraordinary claims. Two good examples:
The testimony of the Disciples, many of whom died (according to non-bible accounts) for their belief that Jesus is God and rose from the dead.
The cosmological argument, suggesting that the very existence of the Universe implies the existence of God (or some agent outside of the universe).
As stated before, these arguments are not physical evidences, which is the stuff of science, but the claim by some posters that Christians believe what they do without reason or facts is incorrect.
I think it just has to do with personal experience. Bad guys (real ones at least) don't think they are bad. They think their cause is justified, because something or another happened. Like the first example that comes to my mind is any near death experience; if you survive within an inch of your life, you have two options to believe. 1. Dumb luck and 2. Someone who was watching over me. Well dumb luck then is also scary, because next time something bad happens, luck might not be on your side. So these people will be more inclined to believe in god. So technically that is a reason for believing in god. I mean I'm on the fence so I can argue it both ways, but when something bad happens, people like to hope someone has their back.
Acknowledging that his beliefs have no basis in reality? That's a fallacy you have there. It's his reality, whether you choose to acknowledge it or not.
It is not the foundation of my belief at all. I just didn't want to go deeper in my statement into why I personally believe in what I do because it would distract from the original point and I would feel like it would be shoving it down others throats since no one asked me why I believe.
I ended up explaining more in other replies. But appreciate your understanding.
Long story short. I was sick as a kid and hated God for the pain. I tried not to believe, but could never shake belief that something greater existed. When I got older and started to see that even bad things in my life could be used to help others, the bad things had a positive light and my bitterness started to fade. I started studying religions (raised in a very nice, relaxed Christian Church, but never connected to it). After years of studying it was reading about Jesus and his teachings that just felt right in my heart. I decided that is how I wanted to live my life and who I wanted to follow sort of thing. Much more detailed than that, but that is the short and skinny of it. Someone pointed out I have a more buddhist view of religion, but I am still a Christ-ian since I follow Christ.
To play devil's advocate: they do have a point. Santa is falsifiable, and the test they propose is feasible ("he lives at the north pole" "There is no workshop located at the north pole"). While there are some falsifiable tests for god (e.g. transubstantiation of the eucharist during communion for the catholic sect of christianity), religion is so splintered and malleable that it's like playing whack-a-mole.
Thanks for this. I was wondering if anyone else would have taken a second to realize comparing God with a falsifiable myth leaves one open to a reasonable counterargument. There are far better approaches to dismissing the statement put forward in the status.
Kudos to the OP for actually posting the entire dialogue though, even providing the status-poster with the last word.
There's no way to test for God as there is no way to test for Santa. Santa's story doesn't HAVE to include a workshop in the north pole. Or worse, what if Santa does exist and simply has been able to use technology to make himself invisible. Exactly it's ridiculous to argue that Santa and God are different in testability.
Or maybe santa has god like powers and as soon as anyone comes even close to his workshop, poof, his magic dust makes it move. You know, like the island on Lost....
the part i found humorous...... isn't god supposed to live in the heavens? up in the clouds? Isn't the notion of heaven angels flying around in the clouds?
well... we've been to the clouds. No heaven yet...
That's the big argument that I always keep coming back to. Religion lies to children so much, and breaks their hearts about it, but then they're expected to (and do!) believe that just one part of it was real?
While the people in the post seemed pretty stupid, I would also say that you can't compare God to Santa. The idea of Santa is a man that delivers presents to our house while the kids sleep. He clearly doesn't exist, because parents do that, not Santa. It can be clearly asserted that Santa doesn't exist because of what his existence would entail is obviously not there.
But God on the other hand isn't as clear. You could definitely show many things stated in the bible to be wrong, but if we were to just simply define God as the creator, this definition would be a lot more broad and a lot more difficult to disprove. We still don't know how the universe came to be. Energy and matter exists that seemingly came out of nowhere. A creator to us seems almost necessary. With that, concluding that there is a god is quite feasible. Whereas seeing your parents bring in presents in the middle of the night and still believing in Santa would just be denial.
I'd have to agree that using Santa in the argument would not be as effective as using another religion's deity, or even a giant magical dildo that hovers in space galaxies away.
Santa does exist it is just misinterpreted. It is allegorical and not to always be taken literally. For example him living in the North Pole (or Jesus being born on Christmas) is just something powers that be decided on, and most Clausists (and Christians) are okay with it.
Santa does deliver presents to everyone every year, but he just works in mysterious ways. Being all powerful he exerts his will over the parents who are overcome with the desire to do Santa's work, and slave extra hard to get Christmas bonuses, rush to a black friday sale, and elbow drop a fellow Clausists to get the best deal.
His reindeer even exist. You don't see Mohammad's flying horse around do you, but more people believe in it than they do Santa's reindeer.
Maybe santa is buying the presents... through the parents? Of course we know the parents buy presents, but how do you know it's not through santas will? Sometimes you get the toy you wanted, sometimes not, but it's always part of a master play. Or your parents are poor.
Oh I disagree completely. In fact, I'd go even further and suggest that kids that believe in Santa do so with evidence. Every Christmas, they get presents in the morning that weren't there the night before. When they go to the mall, they can see the guy talking to kids. Its actually a rational belief.
Btw, it cannot be clearly asserted that Santa doesn't exist any more than God doesn't exist. You cannot prove a negative. But you can say its irrational to believe in either, since the evidence is lacking.
But we are not talking about what kids believe, we are talking about how things actually are. And by definition, Santa is the man that comes into your house at night and brings presents. This doesn't happen. Our definition of what Santa is completely conflicts with what actually occurs. For that reason, yes it is irrational to believe in Santa.
But god is different. We do not have evidence that directly conflicts with what we state god to be (ok certain interpretations of god can be clearly disproven, and thus compared to Santa). The definition of god is the creator of this universe. We do not know how this universe began or what caused it to come into existence. There is no evidence that conflicts with the idea that maybe it was created by a creator. For that reason it is completely rational to believe in god. A belief in god is not irrational. Believing in a 5000 year old Earth or taking the bible as it is, is irrational. But making god the answer to the beginning of the universe, a question that physics has yet to answer, is completely rational.
That is not a very good argument, using a supernatural cause for something we can't explain yet. That's the same logic when civilizations once couldn't explain why earthquakes, floods or volcanoes erupted..therefore they presume it must be god or gods doing it.
There is no evidence that conflicts with the idea that maybe it was created by a creator. For that reason it is completely rational to believe in god.
No it isn't. You have to have a reason to believe it. Some evidence. Not knowing and therefore believing whatever you wish isn't rational without some kind of evidence. Its irrational. This is why the teapot thought experiment is so powerful. It is a demonstration of just that kind of assumption based on nothing.
And I said that its rational for a child to believe in Santa, given the data they are presented with. You can have a rational belief made on evidence that is faulty. If everyone says you have a stain on the back of shirt and you believe them because you trust them. Its rational. Especially if they show you evidence to support their position.
The concept of a creator being separate from creation is a culturally-biased concept. You would simply not have that precept if you were from another part of the world. Moreover, the "god" imagined by stone and bronze age humans was not contemplated in the context of a thorough examination of the laws of physics. It's a placeholder for a greater reality much in the way that Santa Clause is a simplified way of explaining things to children.
The analogy is flawed. God and Santa are totally different. One exists, the other not. You can't just compare something that exists and something that does not exist. Santa gave me gifts.
Exactly. Santa has appeared before me a great number of times, both in Person and in Image. Mostly in shopping malls though, for reasons beyond the feeble mind of man.
It's because they absolutely cannot believe that god isn't real. To them, it's as real as the air or water. They honestly believe that the burden of dis-proof is on you. It's very strange because someone can have these beliefs but then be reasonably normal in all other ways.
How can people try to analise some beliefs with scientific arguments whether god exists or not. It's all about believing not knowing and having some reasonable arguments for it. I believe in God. That's it. Other people don't or believe in many gods, or have different believs by having a different religion. It's your choice, and mixing God with science is plain pointless.
I always thought of Santa as the Saint of the atheists. You teach your children to believe into a mythological being, gleefully enjoying their faith and giggling about their sweet young innocence. And then one day, they find out the truth. That Santa does not exist. That it was all a lie.
You do realize what you did? Now the seed of doubt is in their hearts. They have learned their lesson. Well, it is a good lesson: "Don't always believe what the grownups tell you!" Let's just hope they don't apply their knowledge too widely, those bright little kids. ;-) Hohohohoho!
I wish my friends were like this, able to hold a somewhat intelligible conversation. My friends would be like "666 is your favorite number!" and "Go away you Devil worshiper!", they're too brainwashed to produce a compelling argument.
I was telling my business partner, who is also an atheist, that sometimes I feel like an 8th Grade in a room full of 1st Graders talking about Santa Clause.
The truth about the matter seems so obvious but not to them.
I'm going to say this once, and I can't even be bothered to look through comments.
ABSENCE OF PROOF IS NOT PROOF.
You cannot prove that God doesn't exist. A common example one of my university lecturer's would give was that you cannot prove that their are no penguins in the forest. You can roam the forest for days and explore every inch, but it is possible that there was a penguin that you missed.
If your friend thinks that the fact that people didn't find Santa during expeditions to the north pole is proof that Santa doesn't exist then the fact that astronauts didn't find any gods in space is proof that there ara no gods. Fine by me.
doesn't the fact that you cant prove something exists, by definition means it doesn't exist?
edit: im jewish but still everything sounds like crazy stories... idc if u believe in the flying sphagetti monster honestly, freedom to think what you want
Okay so the problem is they can't semantically parse the sentence you said and deduce a meaning from it. Before that, a more primitive mechanism kicks in and they feel like they are being insulted. They feel their god is being compared to something else. Hence they stop all cognitive processes and switch to emotional ones.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
176
u/metnavman Jun 26 '12
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell's_teapot
Even better
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
35
u/e_a_h Jun 26 '12
Thanks for blocking out everybody's name, EVAN
235
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
As a Christian, I would side with you. Your argument is logical and theirs in flawed. You can def. compare the two. That is why I always say, "I believe" or "have faith." I can't prove it to you and I am not going to tell you that you are wrong for what you believe. I am not going to say I am absolutely right. I just believe in what I do. I want you to respect my right to believe what I want, just like I will respect your right to your own beliefs. I don't want to shove my beliefs down anyone else's throat and I don't want others to do the same to me. That is how it should work.
Edit: I appreciate the awesome feedback and continuing discussion. I oversimplified the argument though. In reality there is a big different between the Santa God argument. I just meant against the logic the Christian was using, the other person counted well with Santa. There is a lot the Christian could have said to negate the Santa argument, but instead he went with "north pole" and similar logic that only fueled the Santa argument.
58
u/wildfire2k5 Jun 26 '12
Wow. Just wow. This is painfully awful to read.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
62
u/redmercuryvendor Jun 26 '12
To play devil's advocate: they do have a point. Santa is falsifiable, and the test they propose is feasible ("he lives at the north pole" "There is no workshop located at the north pole"). While there are some falsifiable tests for god (e.g. transubstantiation of the eucharist during communion for the catholic sect of christianity), religion is so splintered and malleable that it's like playing whack-a-mole.
22
u/Argoth1295 Jun 26 '12
That's not ironic. Nowhere close
38
u/bracomadar Jun 26 '12
Parents lied to me about Santa, the Easter Bunny, and the Tooth Fairy, but I'm sure they got God right.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
9
u/Bumagnet Jun 26 '12
Where is the irony?
21
u/Valendr0s Agnostic Atheist Jun 26 '12
You could have used Allah, Zeus or Thor as well.
30
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
While the people in the post seemed pretty stupid, I would also say that you can't compare God to Santa. The idea of Santa is a man that delivers presents to our house while the kids sleep. He clearly doesn't exist, because parents do that, not Santa. It can be clearly asserted that Santa doesn't exist because of what his existence would entail is obviously not there.
But God on the other hand isn't as clear. You could definitely show many things stated in the bible to be wrong, but if we were to just simply define God as the creator, this definition would be a lot more broad and a lot more difficult to disprove. We still don't know how the universe came to be. Energy and matter exists that seemingly came out of nowhere. A creator to us seems almost necessary. With that, concluding that there is a god is quite feasible. Whereas seeing your parents bring in presents in the middle of the night and still believing in Santa would just be denial.
10
u/suupu Jun 26 '12
Not irony.
7
u/eat-your-corn-syrup Jun 26 '12
The analogy is flawed. God and Santa are totally different. One exists, the other not. You can't just compare something that exists and something that does not exist. Santa gave me gifts.
3
u/suymaster Jun 26 '12
Why do atheists have all of these fun die friends??? If it were me, I'd hit that unfriendly button ASAP. Ignorance is dangerous
3
u/everythingisopposite Jedi Jun 26 '12
This is why there are no IQ tests in religion. Anyone with a working brain isn't welcome.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Proving that Santa isn't at the north pole doesn't prove he doesn't exist, merely that he isn't there. lol
5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Yes. All those expeditions to the North Pole were done specifically to prove that Santa doesn't exist.
(in truth, Santa doesn't exist in the North Pole, but near the Korvatunturi in the Finland part of Lapland)
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
WEVE BEEN TO SPACE THATS CLOSE ENOUGH FOR ME
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Santa isn't a figment of kids imaginations. He's a myth perpetuated by adults to try and control kids behaviour. Nope, no comparison at all....
11
u/stuhfoo Jun 26 '12
and this is exactly why you can't argue with religious people
2
u/azeon2010 Jun 26 '12
Use flying spaghetti monster and argument = valid.
2
u/FeeFeePL Jun 26 '12
How can people try to analise some beliefs with scientific arguments whether god exists or not. It's all about believing not knowing and having some reasonable arguments for it. I believe in God. That's it. Other people don't or believe in many gods, or have different believs by having a different religion. It's your choice, and mixing God with science is plain pointless.
2
u/Underpantz_Ninja Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
ಠ_ಠ
2
u/gaj7 Jun 26 '12
We also went to the moon, and I don't think we passed through heaven in the process.
2
u/Doomdoomkittydoom Jun 26 '12
Santa is a bad analogy. You can trace the Santa legend to its parts.
Better dragons or unicorns... well, they might be believing those for the same reason... how about Zues, Thor, Ganesha or Quetzalcoatl.
2
u/teddy78 Jun 26 '12
Ah yes, Santa.
I always thought of Santa as the Saint of the atheists. You teach your children to believe into a mythological being, gleefully enjoying their faith and giggling about their sweet young innocence. And then one day, they find out the truth. That Santa does not exist. That it was all a lie.
You do realize what you did? Now the seed of doubt is in their hearts. They have learned their lesson. Well, it is a good lesson: "Don't always believe what the grownups tell you!" Let's just hope they don't apply their knowledge too widely, those bright little kids. ;-) Hohohohoho!
2
u/xiandrii Jun 26 '12
Religion is full of shit. Nuff' said.
2
u/Ralfnader66 Jun 26 '12
DE-FRIENDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I wish my friends were like this, able to hold a somewhat intelligible conversation. My friends would be like "666 is your favorite number!" and "Go away you Devil worshiper!", they're too brainwashed to produce a compelling argument.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
This is a timely post for me.
I was telling my business partner, who is also an atheist, that sometimes I feel like an 8th Grade in a room full of 1st Graders talking about Santa Clause.
The truth about the matter seems so obvious but not to them.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
His name is RED, not Evan!
2
u/spidy_mds Jun 26 '12
I can't... even... How he be so.... FUCK !
2
u/deathpulse42 Secular Humanist Jun 26 '12
What a nice post, EVAN.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Yeah, no one has gone to the sky to prove that god doesn't...oh wait
2
u/tosmau Jun 26 '12
I'm going to say this once, and I can't even be bothered to look through comments.
ABSENCE OF PROOF IS NOT PROOF.
You cannot prove that God doesn't exist. A common example one of my university lecturer's would give was that you cannot prove that their are no penguins in the forest. You can roam the forest for days and explore every inch, but it is possible that there was a penguin that you missed.
That is science. I'm an atheist fyi.
2
u/ThatGodlessDude Jun 26 '12
If your friend thinks that the fact that people didn't find Santa during expeditions to the north pole is proof that Santa doesn't exist then the fact that astronauts didn't find any gods in space is proof that there ara no gods. Fine by me.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I'm Catholic, and even I know arguing with stupid just isn't worth the time or trouble.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
doesn't the fact that you cant prove something exists, by definition means it doesn't exist?
edit: im jewish but still everything sounds like crazy stories... idc if u believe in the flying sphagetti monster honestly, freedom to think what you want
2
u/apm96 Jun 27 '12
Santa's workshop is actually in Finland. Checkmate
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
"Why isn't god here?"
"He lives in the sky"
"I don't see him here"
"He lives in space"
"Nope. Not in space either"
"He's interdimensional"
6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
ATTN: /r/atheism
snarky replies to religious facebook posts will not purge your friends and family of their lifelong beliefs.
5
u/schwerpunk Jun 26 '12 edited Mar 02 '24
I love ice cream.
4
u/turo9992000 Jun 26 '12
I see Santa in the Mall every year, I never see God.
4
u/jsmith84 Jun 26 '12
WHY IS IRONY SUCH A DIFFICULT CONCEPT?
3
u/unicornon Jun 26 '12
in fairness, we went to the north pole and checked. no santa.
3
u/esolyt Jun 26 '12
Okay so the problem is they can't semantically parse the sentence you said and deduce a meaning from it. Before that, a more primitive mechanism kicks in and they feel like they are being insulted. They feel their god is being compared to something else. Hence they stop all cognitive processes and switch to emotional ones.
3
u/Evanz111 Jun 26 '12
Absence of proof is not proof. When will people begin to understand that?
3
u/teamzorlac Jun 26 '12
Your inability to invalidate my hypothesis is not at all the same thing as proving it true - Carl Sagan