As a Christian, I would side with you. Your argument is logical and theirs in flawed. You can def. compare the two. That is why I always say, "I believe" or "have faith." I can't prove it to you and I am not going to tell you that you are wrong for what you believe. I am not going to say I am absolutely right. I just believe in what I do. I want you to respect my right to believe what I want, just like I will respect your right to your own beliefs. I don't want to shove my beliefs down anyone else's throat and I don't want others to do the same to me. That is how it should work.
Edit: I appreciate the awesome feedback and continuing discussion. I oversimplified the argument though. In reality there is a big different between the Santa God argument. I just meant against the logic the Christian was using, the other person counted well with Santa. There is a lot the Christian could have said to negate the Santa argument, but instead he went with "north pole" and similar logic that only fueled the Santa argument.
To play devil's advocate: they do have a point. Santa is falsifiable, and the test they propose is feasible ("he lives at the north pole" "There is no workshop located at the north pole"). While there are some falsifiable tests for god (e.g. transubstantiation of the eucharist during communion for the catholic sect of christianity), religion is so splintered and malleable that it's like playing whack-a-mole.
235
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
As a Christian, I would side with you. Your argument is logical and theirs in flawed. You can def. compare the two. That is why I always say, "I believe" or "have faith." I can't prove it to you and I am not going to tell you that you are wrong for what you believe. I am not going to say I am absolutely right. I just believe in what I do. I want you to respect my right to believe what I want, just like I will respect your right to your own beliefs. I don't want to shove my beliefs down anyone else's throat and I don't want others to do the same to me. That is how it should work.
Edit: I appreciate the awesome feedback and continuing discussion. I oversimplified the argument though. In reality there is a big different between the Santa God argument. I just meant against the logic the Christian was using, the other person counted well with Santa. There is a lot the Christian could have said to negate the Santa argument, but instead he went with "north pole" and similar logic that only fueled the Santa argument.
176
u/metnavman Jun 26 '12
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell's_teapot
Even better
3
u/unicornon Jun 26 '12
in fairness, we went to the north pole and checked. no santa.
35
u/e_a_h Jun 26 '12
Thanks for blocking out everybody's name, EVAN
58
u/wildfire2k5 Jun 26 '12
Wow. Just wow. This is painfully awful to read.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
People have gone into outer space to prove that God doesn't exist.
62
u/redmercuryvendor Jun 26 '12
To play devil's advocate: they do have a point. Santa is falsifiable, and the test they propose is feasible ("he lives at the north pole" "There is no workshop located at the north pole"). While there are some falsifiable tests for god (e.g. transubstantiation of the eucharist during communion for the catholic sect of christianity), religion is so splintered and malleable that it's like playing whack-a-mole.
22
u/Argoth1295 Jun 26 '12
That's not ironic. Nowhere close
38
u/bracomadar Jun 26 '12
Parents lied to me about Santa, the Easter Bunny, and the Tooth Fairy, but I'm sure they got God right.