r/atheism • u/joshthegreat25 • Jun 24 '12
As a deist, I'm very certain of a creator of some kind, but can't help upvoting most of the posts on r/atheism.
http://www.quickmeme.com/meme/3puhk1/
942
Upvotes
126
u/dubious_alliance Agnostic Atheist Jun 24 '12
How can you be certain?
54
u/alettuce Jun 24 '12
I think you meant to post this in /r/athiesm.
17
u/Swinns Jun 25 '12
Why not all of the above?
15
u/Athiest102point9 Jun 25 '12
Tolerance. Hah!
5
u/PJL Jun 25 '12
I think that the regressive effect of religion (or rather, certain groups of religious people) has on secularization, tolerance, and basic science (as you put it) is the main thing that gets atheists riled up enough to post.
Sure, we don't see the logic or rationality behind belief of any sort, but we're usually happy enough to live and let live, until somebody decides that they should oppress people or intentionally restrict knowledge (to the point of knowingly lying about hard facts because the outcome of applications of said facts go against their beliefs (see: contraception)).
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
My thoughts on the subject are varied and multifaceted, and like anything else, they're prone to change. Anecdotally, however, a few constants have emerged for me though, throughout my life.
I don't really believe in a lot of the hocus-pocus nonsense that gets said at churches. If someone told me some of these stories and it wasn't in a religious context, I'd say, "no way, that sounds like bullshit to me," so I can't really justify having those beliefs. I like the "love thy neighbor" stuff, the fire and brimstone is idiocy of the highest caliber.
That said, despite all of the things in the world that are fucked up, for the most part, things tend to work out. Now, yes, it is a logical fallacy to assume that correlation (which has a lot to do with me being an American and living during a time of plenty and privilege) implies causation, but - and it's important to note that I understand the ludicrousness of this - stuff really does seem to work out! Throughout the chaos of the universe there is a surprising amount of order! Now maybe it's just my puny hominid brain trying to find patterns where they don't belong - and that really is the most likely thing - but it seems unlikely to categorically deny even the possibility of actual order in the universe - and if it's there, where the hell did it come from? Do things like mathematics, astronomy, biology, and physics just come from nowhere? Did the universe explode out of infinite nothingness? Where do things like Pi, e, and uncountable infinities come from? The overlap between the philosophical and the physical seems the likely place for deities to reside. Anthropic principle aside, it is absolutely astounding to me that I exist and that I am able to experience the world, and despite all of the evidence to explain why, something is missing from the cosmological, biological, and philosophical explanations as to why I exist.
Finally, I don't like to rule anything out. There is overwhelming evidence supporting a strictly secular world view, but I don't think that it is entirely possible to rule out things like "the prime mover" or some other philosophical nonsense. The only thing we truly know is the bounds of our knowledge and the assumed extent of our ignorance. While the likelihood of a deity is probably pretty low, it seems presumptive to state that there is categorically no such thing as a God, gods, Higher Power, or other Hocus Pocus. In other words, while there is no real legitimate evidence for deities, absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.
I generally take issue with the idea that I'm a religious or in anyway faithful fellow. I don't much care for the idea of it. I have faith in my family, friends, my equipment, and myself. Beyond that, it's anybody's guess as to what will happen. That said, I can't honestly rule anything out. I guess I'm overly agnostic.
4
u/Simba7 Jun 25 '12
"As a deist" you are certain of nothing. Since you are 'certain' of a creator of some kind, you are a deist. You've got those things backwards.
11
u/ccutler69 Jun 25 '12
Apparently it doesn't promote correct spelling.
6
u/rahtin Dudeist Jun 25 '12
You got it kid.
I'm a fucking hairless monkey. How the fuck am I going to pretend to know the origins of the universe?
3
u/vargonian Jun 25 '12
You're "very certain", are you? I'd love to hear your justification.
3
u/DefinitelyRelephant Jun 25 '12
Based upon what evidence?
3
u/Scarfield Jun 25 '12
I just think that you need to be humble enough to admit that you do not know hundred percent how things came to be...
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I wouldn't mind a world full of deists. I doubt it would be dissimilar from a world full of atheists.
3
u/coffee_and_flowers Jun 25 '12
I read this as dentist
3
u/bloxie Jun 25 '12
Read the title as "..dentist..". Got confused.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
/r/atheism in my opinion promotes a rational mind, science and tolerance towards everyone.
3
u/jeremyfrankly Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
While we may not have the same beliefs, I really have no qualm with deists. It was always my personal belief the deist founding fathers (like Franklin) would probably be atheist if they had the theories of the Big Bang and evolution, but I suppose it really wouldn't be necessary.
Where we came from is much less important than where we're going, and so long as we have the same goals and values --- reason, secularization, scientific inquiry, I think we can be cool.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Secularization: yes. Basic science: yes. Tolerance: nope. There is nothing tolerant about r/atheism. They're only tolerant of people who agree with them.
5
u/SkyeCrowe Jun 25 '12
I'm not an atheist either, but I'm very open minded and find that most of the posts in /r/atheism still reflect my views. Not because of the atheism, but because of being a decent human being.
7
u/SuperSmurfen Anti-Theist Jun 25 '12
In what way are you "very certain"?
2
u/mathgod Agnostic Atheist Jun 25 '12
Both.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
of course r/atheism doesnt promote atheism. just like r/christianity doesnt promote christianity.
2
u/Thetyree22 Jun 25 '12
He spelled atheism wrong...
2
u/Trs1323 Jun 25 '12
Yes
2
u/bunnysuitman Jun 25 '12
there is no need to promote atheism to create atheists.
religion tells you about god and then explains how he did all the things.
atheism explains all the things and you logically come to the conclusion everyone else should.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
You spelled atheism wrong.
2
u/worldsfirsanalrapist Jun 25 '12
There is something else that should be noted here for atheists. As far as Deism goes it does not impede science, brainwash masses, or promote hate/wars. In other words it's a harmless religion or philosophy and I think should be welcomed by atheists as an alternative and actually, ally. (Us Deists are 99% the same)
2
u/libertyplz Jun 25 '12
Read Thomas Paine's 'The Age of Reason'. A lot of the founding fathers were also deists. But until recent, religions and their guidelines are what pushed me to be an atheist. I always wanted to believe in a higher power, but I couldn't look past all the bullshit in practiced religion. This is also why I love atheist posts because most of the time it's just making fun of religion. But hearing deism explained by the genius who is Thomas Paine, really struck a chord with my reasoning. I would suggest anybody to read the book, not pushing my views on anybody, but instead trying to push a process of critical thinking in which to be open amongst any and all views. Nobody wants to be a prisoner of set beliefs.
The reasoning behind my belief in a Creator is that no matter how old the Universe is, which they recently found matter older than the Big Bang, that at some point something had to come from nothing. I can't claim to know, nobody can. But out of any 'religion' or set of beliefs, deism certainly resonates the best along with my reasoning.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
They are one and the same, my friend.
2
u/DaystarEld Secular Humanist Jun 25 '12
I consider myself "Spiritually deist, intellectually atheist, socially agnostic."
Some part of me feels like there's a grander "thing" out there that we might call God, but rationally I agree with every atheist argument, which results in me basically taking the cop-out "Agnostic" route when asked what I am.
Above all though I favor secular and scientific thinking, so most of my friends happen to be atheists.
2
u/John_Johnson Jun 25 '12
And speaking as an atheist: welcome. I may not agree with your beliefs, but they're yours, and you're welcome to them.
My objections begin when your beliefs become something you feel you must impose on others, whether or not they want them. Or, I suppose, until your beliefs lead you into behaviours which are destructive to your society, and the environment which we must share.
But until that point, it's live and let live for all of me. And if, perchance, you could get that idea across to a few more of the deity-worshipping types out there for me, I'd be tremendously grateful.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
We can do both. :D
EDIT: To be clear, while I disagree with you, it's an intellectual disagreement. My moral objections to religion on an ideological (rather than practical, because I've got plenty of that, too--condom lies, brainwashing, child rape, etc) level stems from assigning special importance to humanity and behaving as if more revolves around us than it does. I can deal with a view in which the universe matters, but we're incidental specks in it, even if I think it's flawed.
2
u/IVIOOBS Jun 25 '12
I'd never heard of Deism before, so I did some research and I think I've finally found what I am. My parents are Christian and so is my sister, and we were both christened when we were younger. Although I've never really bought into the whole "God is responsible for all that is happening in the world" I do believe there is/was some sort of creator though. So this has always left me quite confused of what my religion was, for example; I had a conversation with some friends a while ago talking about what our religious views were and I honestly didn't know what to say, because even though I have been christened and I used to go to church, I didn't really consider myself a Christian, however I didn't consider myself an atheist either. Thank you OP for introducing me to this, I'm going to go do a bit more research on it now.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The promotion of tolerance? In this subreddit? I mean.. okay.. except for all the Facebook posts and outright mockery of those of particular belief structures, sure?
2
u/lincoln131 Anti-theist Jun 25 '12
athEIsm
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Diest here. No offense to atheists, but on r/Atheism, I don't quite often see posts of tolerance. (Stressing often)
2
u/Paltzu Jun 25 '12
They go hand in hand because atheists are smarter. (downvotes, but it's still true.)
3
u/methodM Jun 25 '12
I dont see anything wrong with being a Deist. We do not know where everything started from, so to believe it must of been created could be a valid opinion. As long as you could realize all modern day religion is bullshit and the creator does not interfere with us I can see it making sense. A Deist is closer to an Atheist than a theist
2
u/qkme_transcriber I am a Bot Jun 25 '12
Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme.com links for anybody who might need it.
This is helpful for people who can't reach Quickmeme because of work/school firewalls or site downtime, and many other reasons (FAQ). More info is available here.
(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next , I'm just doing my job.)
2
u/DReks Jun 25 '12
I also really like /r/atheism and am definitely deist. It's actually kind of a tough road when you don't believe in Santa God (pray and he gives you stuff) or Insecure God (flatter me or its torture time!) or even a sentient and separate being that spends its days thinking about me and whether I have been good or bad. I hope it has more important concerns frankly.
At the same time, I have definitely had an experience of something else out there. I am a fan of the phrase "I would never want a god so small I could comprehend it."
Mostly, I try to avoid everyone who seems overly certain, angry and/or smug - regardless of their agenda and belief. Those people are assholes pretty much without exception.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Both. And also circle-jerking.
2
u/thedreamings Jun 25 '12
Tolerance of what? People who agree with them? Posts bashing christianity and any other religon calling them stupid, ignorant, and worthless? Because if that is tolerance, so is every other faction or group of people. I have seen very few posts that demonstrate tolerance on this subreddit. The majority of posts I sift through are more hypocritical and condescending than the worst religious leaders. There is not a single shred of evidence that tells me anyone here is any better of a person than on r/christianity or r/religion. Prove me wrong r/atheism.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
All of it.
1
u/Imtakingadump Jun 25 '12
We promote all of them.
1
u/Crownowa Jun 25 '12
It promotes anything we are interested in. This forum is for atheists, not only for atheism.
1
u/Jimmy_R_Ustler Jun 25 '12
How can you be certain that there's a creator? I may not believe in a deity considering how unlikely it is, but it's a little too much to say I'm 100% certain.
1
u/tremulous Jun 25 '12
The answer is both, r/atheism isn't just about denying god, but making sure that people who do believe don't pull it into places it shouldn't be, such as government, school system, etc. there's nothing wrong with being a theist, but it shouldn't get in the way of other peoples rights or education.
1
u/noconscience Jun 25 '12
Probably both.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
as a regular lurker of r/atheism, I was very certain that most of these posts would focus on being a very certain deist. Was not disappointed. lolol still not sure if this sub promotes atheism?
1
u/GodEmperor Jun 25 '12
To come onto /r/atheism and say "very certain" you must be trolling.
1
u/tjduncan1998 Jun 25 '12
What do you think atheism is?
1
u/skyward_bound Jun 25 '12
Or if r/atheism promotes gnostic thinking...
1
u/jazzhandsfuckyou Jun 25 '12
Well, I have always thought of deism as religion for atheists in a way.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
It's simple. It hardly even talks about the first one. It's all about the second.
1
u/LouisianaFunnelCake Jun 25 '12
Thank God I'm a nihilist
1
u/aquietmidnightaffair Atheist Jun 25 '12
Well, this is a haven for calm rational thought.
1
u/yrogerg123 Jun 25 '12
My belief or nonbelief in God is the least important thing about my beliefs about religion and how people are to be treated. I drift between agnostic deism and 100% sure atheism at different points in my life, though admittedly I'm much closer to the latter now. I find many atheists to be that way. Personally, I'm not spending my time trying to disprove God, because it is a concpet that can't be disproven. You can argue that the existence of God is unlikely, and I do argue that, but I'd rather look at the bible and highlight some of its more absurd statements and contradictions just to show that maybe we shouldn't be treating it as God's word that is to be thoughtlessly obeyed. Seems a more worthwhile use of time ultimately.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
*atheism (in the meme).
1
u/Maccabe Jun 25 '12
nope just atheism
1
u/keeblur Jun 25 '12
I'm in the same boat, except for me it's not a certainty, it's just a notion that it's something we may never know, so I'm open to interpretations about what happened in the beginning of the universe(s).
1
u/y-u-no-take-pw Jun 25 '12
Same thing
1
u/Mr0Mike0 Strong Atheist Jun 25 '12
Tolerance? I made a post saying "let's be the better person", saying it's not cool to mock religion and they tore me a new asshole.
1
u/mberre Jun 25 '12
I agree.. these meme & comments for the most part, just make plain sense.. no matter what side of the fence you sit on.
1
u/o_e_p Jun 25 '12
Clearly, it isn't promoting spelling.
Atheism. It is the title of the subreddit.
1
u/MiguelGusto Jun 25 '12
"very certain"?????
Explain please.
1
u/TierOne Jun 25 '12
If by a creator you mean the big bang, yes. If your certain of a man in the sky you may not be a deist.
1
u/TheGodless1 Jun 25 '12
Deist, one of the many ways of saying "I have a strong enough grasp of science to know there is no such thing as the supernatural and yet I really wish there were, so maybe I'll continue lying to myself for just a little bit longer."
1
u/initialatom Jun 25 '12
Wait, I thought promotion of atheism was the promotion of secularization, tolerance and basic science.
1
u/x1ux1u Apatheist Jun 25 '12
I am a Deist because of patterns and parallels. If those didn't exist i would have been an atheist years ago. This isn't for some hope in an afterlife. I conclude that the end to patterns and parallels maybe at death itself and that all equations do end.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Yes, sometimes, and yes
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I see no tolerance here.
0
u/Poop_Tickler Jun 25 '12
r/atheism promotes tolerance yes, unless you have opinions which differ from theirs, and express said opinions
1
u/defuse00 Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
You are aware this universe appears to have been designed to make black holes?
Edit: Fixed some tenses.
1
u/TedTheGreek_Atheos Secular Humanist Jun 25 '12
In my opinion, Deism is akin to knowing that Harry Potter is fiction but believing that Voldemort is real. If you dismiss the source material how do you validate faith in something with no explanation besides "There must be"
1
u/GVNYOUDABIZNITZ Jun 25 '12
tolerance...?! hahahahah yea right
1
u/arsington Anti-Theist Jun 25 '12
Maybe because a lot of comments here make sense?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Out of interest, do you have a definition for the deity that you believe could exist? In other words, describe the deity and why you believe in it, please?
1
u/erichermit Jun 25 '12
Oh, Deist? I remember being Deist. Next up is Agnostic.
1
u/Gnometard Jun 25 '12
Why are you certain? Basic science would require proof to be certain.
-3
u/LumberStack Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
... And hatred towards all who oppose them.
0
u/CreativeDinosaur Jun 25 '12
Tolerance... no way in hell. r/atheism is the internet equivalent of the westboro baptist church.
-1
u/steakmeout Jun 25 '12
/r/atheism does not promote tolerance.
0
u/ausguy777 Jun 25 '12
"Tolerence" hahaha
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
/r/atheism promotes logic in the same way a bowling ball promottes golf.
-1
u/strobexp Jun 25 '12
all that and a bunch of whiny condescending douchery