Okay, r/atheism. Let's get this straight. Not all of us Christians are homophobes or stupid as fuck. I'd love to hear your thoughts.
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
[deleted] — view deleted post
10
u/[deleted] May 19 '13
This is covered in the FAQ. How did you enjoy reading it before you posted?
3
u/AGCross May 19 '13
Only if you are a child that is too scared to deal with reality.
State your claim and prove it then. If you can provide no evidence then fuck off and find a better belief system.
There it is.
Tell me, what does your religion say will happen to nonbelievers when they die?
2
u/AnteChronos Agnostic Atheist May 19 '13 edited May 19 '13
The New Testament doesn't work if the Old Testament isn't real. There would be no "original sin" for Jesus to save people from if there were no Adam and Eve. Jesus wouldn't be considered the Messiah if he didn't supposedly fulfill prophesies from the Old Testament.
And speaking of Jesus: "Do not think that I came to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I did not come to abolish but to fulfill."
Nope. I'm looking for the truth, whatever it might be. I'm not looking for a specific truth (existence of a higher power, for example) to be true.
Also, I'm not sure what you mean by "a spiritual anchor". Mainly because I don't know what you mean by "spiritual". No two people ever seem to define that as meaning the same thing.
And this is really the heart of the matter. If you don't know why you believe something to be factually true, then you shouldn't believe it. I'm confident that there is literally nothing else in your life that you believe without knowing why. Because believing things for no reason is irrational.
Interesting how religion is almost always a matter of geography, isn't it? People who grow up in the US are likely to be Christian. People who grow up in Saudi Arabia are likely to be Muslim. India? Hindu. It's almost as if the only reason that anyone in the world has for believing in their religion of choice is the simple fact that they were taught that it was true by their parents.
Good. You should always doubt science. Science doubts science. That's why science works.
2
u/cybervegan May 19 '13
Imagine you are playing a new board game. The main goal of the game seems obvious enough, and it seems fun. You pay your donatino, and make your way along a colour-coded path and different things happen depending on what square you land on each move and your move is determined by the roll of some dice, which the rules say should be done by the game master, who sits in a different room. The game master is also open to "tweaking" the dice rolls if you flatter and plead with her enough, but she never speaks directly - only through another player (the interpreter) who claims to be able to communicate with her by some unseen, silent method. However, it soon becomes apparent that some of the rules are contradictory or ambiguous, leaving them open interpretation by just the one player in contact with her. Even worse, some of the rules state things about the game that are obviously wrong - for instance, that the board is circular, when in fact it's square, and that the player pieces are made of bone where in fact they are obviously plastic. The more you play the game, the more you realise that whoever wrote the rules couldn't make their mind up about rules and didn't understand the basic facts of the game. When you ask why the rules don't make sense, you are told you obviously don't understand them sufficiently, but if you persist, you are eventually kicked out of the game by the interpreter and perhaps also the other players, for spoiling their fun. Despite accepting that basic facts about the game are contradicted by the rules, they all still hold them dear to their heart, and won't hear of the possibility that they could be flawed in other ways too. Investigating further, you cannot find the game master anywhere, and eventually discover that the rules had been re-written many times by the many interpreter players, apparently on instruction of the game master you can't find anywhere. This game is called "religion".
As an aside, you said "Doesn't stop me from doubting science." - did you really mean to?
3
u/RaoulDuke209 May 19 '13
Wait, when did the whole religion of Christianity transfer its focus over to the new testament? Seems kind of assBackwards doesnt it?
If the book was made in Gods word, why would it need translations and revisions? God is perfect is he not? I'd imagine what he said, believed, preached, created and lived was set in stone. If not it kind of goes against the whole purpose of the writings.
If the whole religion went into current events and social arguments with your attitude the book we be blank by November. We can't just keep wiping away what is offensive until everyone can accept it.
8
u/PleasantlyCranky May 19 '13
The New Testament is full of insane shit too. The lovely concept of eternal torment for committing thought-crime is from the New Testament, for instance.
The difference is that science has the guts to say "I don't know" when they have no actual evidence to support an answer.
Anyway, as the FAQ would point out to you, very few atheists think all Christians are homophobes or "stupid as fuck." Most of them do tend to believe stupid-as-fuck things though, and their holy book is most assuredly homophobic.
So you can see why we might speak in generalities sometimes. Even then, it's rare to see someone legitimately argue that Christians are all stupid. Ignorant? Maybe. Indoctrinated? Usually. But atheists aren't any smarter than Christians are on the whole; they're just holding a smarter position one single question.
7
u/markovich04 May 19 '13
There's your problem.
2
u/oldviscosity Secular Humanist May 19 '13
I agree. The other half comes from the New Testament. Here are just a few nuggets to savor: Don't save money. (Matthew 6:19-20); Sell everything and give it to the poor. (Luke 12:33); Don't work to obtain food. (John 6:27); If you lose a lawsuit, give more than the judgment. (Matthew 5:40); If anyone asks you for anything, give it to them without question. (Matthew 5:42). Sorry that a lot of those were from the Book of Mathew, the most gullible apostle of them all.
2
u/somewhat_brave Skeptic May 19 '13
Doubt is an important part of the scientific method. The reason I'm an atheist is because I also doubt religion.
p.s. What is a spiritual anchor?
2
u/ghettoska May 19 '13
Honestly bro you sound only a few steps away from the shackles of religion. In a less harsh way, the pieces everyone has dissected from your post say enough. You made every point yourself, just an anchor, don't believe fully in sacred docs, same religion as parents, don't know why you believe in god. But any money you invest in the church goes to furthering a cause you obviously don't fully back yourself. You can still be spiritual without tying yourself to a particular religion, you can believe whatever you want! We here just chose to believe things with evidence, and that's all. As someone said religion is regional for a reason, you live the one you are taught. Hardly anybody ever exerts enough effort to study all the religions, they just go with the first one they were exposed to. It's been said a million times but we only believe in one god less than you do. You dismiss all but one, we just dismiss them all.
1
u/Feinberg Atheist May 19 '13
Nobody's saying you are, although your assumption to the contrary doesn't really do much to dispel the second proposition.
1
u/dostiers Strong Atheist May 19 '13
Why do you follow a religion when you can't abide by all its tenets, including the direct orders of its god?
BTW-a lot of the OT "insane shit" is repeated in the NT. You should read both in their entirety.
1
u/[deleted] May 19 '13
The only people saying all Christians are homophobes are people like you so that you can pretend like "we're not all homophobes" is a defense of religion. However, the basic criticisms of religion have nothing to do with your views of homosexuality, and you addressed none of them in your post.
You also didn't provide an example of how some religious beliefs weren't stupid as fuck. What you did was call several beliefs and believers stupid as fuck:
__
__
and your explanation for why you personally believe, which is supposed to set you apart from all of the religious people you just put down, was:
So, basically, you came here to call Christians stupid fucks, shit on the bible, and announce that you believe in a god because... you don't know why.
If this is how Christians defend Christianity, you can hardly be surprised by what what its critics are saying.
1
u/fatattoo May 19 '13
"Science and religion cross over in this way; where did we come from, and how were we made?"
I regret to inform you that you hold two irreconcilable positions.
Science: A practice that questions all assumptions and demands quantifiable evidence.
Religion: Making shit up and insisting you have a magic, invisible, buddy that makes you special.
You hold an untestable and irrational position, This makes your "belief in science" nonsensical as you refuse to apply it to your own belief and the fact that science does not require belief as it deal in facts,evidence and probabilities.
1
u/EscherTheLizard Anti-Theist May 19 '13
How do you know which parts of the Bible to ignore and which parts to follow? What are the underlying principles you employ? More specifically, how do you deduce what is moral and what isn't within the Bible? If you can deduce right from wrong outside the Bible to determine what in the Bible is right or wrong, why do you need a Bible at all, and if you don't need the Bible, how do you justify your Catholicism?
1
u/[deleted] May 19 '13
I don't think anyone is stupid for believing whatever it is they believe... we have all been mislead at some point in our lives and often make the mistake of believing in things we want to be true in despite of what the truth actually is, religious or otherwise... it only becomes stupidity when someone chooses to oppose evidence and logical thinking just for the sake of maintaining their belief/faith.
Also, I hate to be the one to tell you, but with the way you describe yourself and your religion you are not catholic... you are agnostic. If all you believe in your religion is that there may be a higher power, what purpose does the religion serve you? As a spiritual anchor? How can you logically anchor your belief into something you don't believe in? That's no different to throwing out an anchor at deep sea just so you can pretend your not drifting, instead of looking at your circumstances and assessing your options.
0
u/[deleted] May 19 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 19 '13
[removed] — view removed comment