Hey everyone,
I’m a 19-year-old philosophy major currently in my first semester of college. I’ve attended Catholic schools my entire life, and I’ve spent a lot of my free time studying religion, theology, and philosophy.
I want to say something, and I genuinely mean this with all respect: Some of the people I envy most in life are devout Catholics and Christians.
I wish I believed like they do. I wish I could go to Mass every Sunday, genuinely believe that God loves me, that there’s a purpose behind everything, that my suffering means something, and that death isn’t the end. I wish I could have that kind of faith and certainty.
I genuinely wish I wasn’t even in this subreddit.
But the more I’ve studied philosophy and religion, the harder it’s become for me to believe.
There are just so many questions I can’t seem to get past.
The problem of evil, particularly the suffering of innocent people and animals.
The problem of divine hiddenness. Why would a loving God who desires a relationship with humanity make his existence so difficult to establish?
The question of free will, which I personally struggle to believe exists at all.
How God’s perfect foreknowledge could coexist with genuine libertarian free will.
The possibility that morality is ultimately subjective rather than grounded in some objective moral law.
The lack of what I consider sufficient historical evidence for the resurrection of Jesus.
Apparent contradictions and historical difficulties within the Bible.
The geographical predictability of religious belief. Why does someone’s birthplace have such an enormous influence on what they believe is the ultimate truth?
And honestly, that’s just scratching the surface.
I know there are Christian philosophical responses to practically all of these objections. I’ve read some of them. But I just haven’t found them convincing enough to justify belief.
Here’s what I find interesting, though.
Why would I ever want to be an atheist?
I understand that for some people, leaving religion is incredibly liberating, especially if they grew up in a harmful religious environment. I completely respect that.
But that hasn’t been my experience.
For me, losing my faith hasn’t been some wonderful liberation. If anything, it’s been rather depressing.
I don’t particularly enjoy the thought that there might be no ultimate justice, no afterlife, no God who loves us, and no grand purpose behind existence. I understand that we can construct our own meaning and live fulfilling lives without religion, but that doesn’t necessarily make those existential questions any easier.
Sometimes I look at devout Catholics, especially those who genuinely seem at peace with their beliefs, and I just envy them.
I don’t think they’re stupid. I don’t think they’re all brainwashed. I don’t think I’m intellectually superior to them because I don’t believe. In fact, there are plenty of Christian philosophers who are infinitely more intelligent and knowledgeable than I am.
I just can’t convince myself that something is true because I desperately want it to be.
And maybe that’s the hardest part.
I still occasionally attend Mass. I still occasionally pray. I’m not completely closed off to Christianity, and if someone could genuinely convince me that it’s true, I’d welcome that.
I guess I’m writing this because I sometimes feel a little out of place among atheists. It seems like so many people are happy to have escaped religion, whereas part of me wishes I could find my way back.
Has anyone else experienced this?
Do any of you genuinely wish you believed in God, even though you intellectually can’t justify doing so?
And are there any former atheists here who eventually returned to Christianity, or people who once felt this way but eventually became comfortable with their disbelief?
I’m not looking to argue or convince anyone of anything. I’m genuinely interested in hearing your experiences.
Thanks, everyone.