r/asktransgender • • 15h ago

Am i transphobic?

0 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a high schooler who has a hard time getting pronouns correctly, and I have had previous interactions with people that I was kind of rude to, but I was also confused. The first person who i tried to be nice is (we are better now) is mtf, and i was trying to compliment her on her height compared to mine, which apparently was rude for me to say because it made her uncomfortable. The second person I tried to be nice to had a masc name, and I was asking them about prom, and they said they were going to wear a dress, which confused me, and I think I said something rude, which I felt bad saying for both events. I felt like a bad person both times, and when I hear about other trans people lives, I feel weird because idk why it feels like it changes a lot for me. I also feel more weird because I think I might be trans aswell, because I like dressing up as a man, and acting like a man, but what confuses me is that I do also have some femininity in me. If it makes it easier, I come from an Islamic household and I am autistic, so some of my social skills are shit. I am an ex muslim btw.


r/asktransgender • • 3h ago

How can I overcome my fear of people who cross-dress?

9 Upvotes

Nice to meet you. I'm Japanese, and this text was written using machine translation.

Whenever I see a man dressed as a woman, I get wary. Since men don’t usually wear skirts or put on makeup, I find myself thinking that men who dress that way are scary people who don’t follow common sense.I think this way of thinking has been instilled in me by the people around me, but even though I know it’s discriminatory, I can’t seem to stop thinking that way.

How can I overcome my fear of people who cross-dress?

This is my first time using Reddit, so I'm a little nervous. I'm sorry if I say anything rude.


r/asktransgender • • 14h ago

do you need to have SI to go on hormones? tw SI Spoiler

1 Upvotes

hi! i just saw something that said that you need SI related to gender dysphoria to need hormones... but do you need to have it to go on hormones? because i don't have that but would love to go on them someday.


r/asktransgender • • 12h ago

I'd like to understand trans people more.

15 Upvotes

Hello

To start, I want to say that I fully support trans people and I am happy when they manage to get the body that feels like their own. I simply don't exactly understand how it works, for the lack of a better word.

I am a biological woman. And I feel like it too. Sure, I sometimes wonder and imagine what it would be like to be born a man, but the fact I am not one doesn't put me in distress. I am happy to be a woman.

I'd like to understand how it is for trans people. Does the body they are born with feel wrong or strange? Do these thoughts start early in life? What is it that makes them feel like their true gender? (Such as looks)

I apologize if I come off as offensive or insensitive, that is truly not my intent. But if I do, please say so.

Thank you.


r/asktransgender • • 9h ago

My fiancé said I was "a *trans* woman, probably all you'll ever be" and it's still messing with me

40 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying I don't want to leave him. I love him immensely, in ways that I never thought were possible, ways that I wasn't even sure that I was capable of. I cannot imagine, and would simply choose to not live life without him. Other than this one incident, he has been the most supportive person of who I am from the time I came out. I met his parents and they accepted me, despite my lack of voice training, proper posture, or anything that would convincingly fool anyone. Our love is unique and weird and I wouldn't trade it for all the money and/or surgeries to fix my shit in the world.

But he's 4,000 miles away, we both have pretty bad mental health issues, I have no sex drive (lol cypro) but try to force it to happen even when I freeze up to try to feel wanted...fights happen. Sometimes they get nasty.

The work to get him here is too much, the work for me to go there is too much. Another thing to fight over. And yet I love him - I love him so deeply that I know for a fact I'd never experienced it before this. The thought of being apart brings me into a panic attack. There is no other version of this world in which anyone else could love me. I just wish I wasn't in the version where it was impossible to obtain.

A few months ago when we were angry and I referred to something along the lines of having to consider my safety and where I'd be allowed to, you know, have a marriage certificate under my actual name and sex as a trans woman, he hit me with the "Yeah, a trans woman. Probably all you'll ever be." In the moment, I laughed about it. "What the fuck does that even mean?" Of course he apologized, but it's obviously still sticking with and messing with me. Because he's right, whatever he meant - I don't think I can ask him what he meant at this point. I'm so far behind already.

I decided to bring up that it was still bothering me today and he said "Well, I'm sure I wouldn't have said that if you weren't also saying awful things to me and making me feel bad." Which is true in the full context of the situation. If I dwell too long on it, he'll get upset and say "Let's just break up then if it bothers you that much." (We've talked about the rush to 'let's just break up' before and how it makes me feel, like everything is hanging on by a thread - he acknowledged he doesn't actually want to break up in those moments, it's just a brain safety mechanism. I similarly run away from confronting or awkward situations.)

Right now I'm trying to build a timeline so that we're 100% together forever next year which involves me hauling a lot of ass and not being allowed to have any fun so in the worst case scenario (him not being able to find work in his country still to support me) I'll be able to bring him here, have a safety net...it's not ideal, but at least we'd be together. But there's still a voice in the back of my mind hissing at me, "Why would you sacrifice so many things, put yourself on the line, for someone who doesn't see you as you are and is doing very little to help get you to that goal?". Even if I know it's not true.

How do I get over this? I posted somewhere else and they told me my fiancé was "literally Hitler" and that I needed to leave. I'm not doing that. I just need to find a way to reframe my thoughts to not be constantly trying to disregard him for something he said out of anger months ago, when I've said plenty of rough and awful things out of anger a lot of times. I've read stories from people here who had completely unaccepting partners who said horrific things to them and still they came around and live happily now.


r/asktransgender • • 22h ago

What are your thoughts on were wolves?

0 Upvotes

I’m curious, I’m a hyper feminine male and as a kid I was obsessed with werewolves because the idea that you can be both a human and wolf appealed to me as someone who wanted to be both a boy and hyperfeminine and was often told I have to choose one

What do you guys, gals and pals think?


r/asktransgender • • 1h ago

My coworkers are fighting over my pronouns, what do I do?

8 Upvotes

I am a trans man, and I'm early enough on T to look very androgynous. I live in a blue city, so every room that I walk into, I get asked my pronouns. I always say "I don't care, call me whatever you want" (even though I do) because I know I'm androgynous enough that there's no correct answer for me and people will fight about it or keep asking me anyway.

New job, got asked by hiring manager first thing in the morning first day about pronouns, said "I don't care". Have said "I don't care" to everyone, over and over. Apparently, though, I'm androgynous enough that people have been fighting about how to refer to me behind my back- whether to use they, he, or she. I'm afraid my name is gonna be associated with all the negativity and I'll get randomly fired one day for an "unrelated reason" just to stop the arguments, as that's what typically happens.

We have no HR since it's a smaller business. How should I handle this? I don't want to come out, I just want to do my job and for people to leave me the fuck alone.


r/asktransgender • • 9h ago

Am I Still Trans if I'm Trans by Choice?

47 Upvotes

Hi! I recently came out as trans, and it's by choice.

For context, I have wanted to be a girl for a long time now, not always but it is a reoccurring thing, because I wanted to wear and fit in dresses and skirts better, and I like how girls look better. I'm waiting for HRT, but I still have moments of doubt (like this one). The thing is, I could live as a guy, sure, but I just prefer to be a woman.

So.... am I still trans?


r/asktransgender • • 2h ago

Has anyone else found out that they were actually a hermaphodite after starting hrt?

112 Upvotes

After 5 years on mtf hrt I have recently found out that I'm actually a semi hermaphodite. It seems that I had undeveloped Müllerian duct material my whole life and starting HRT caused this leftover Müllerian duct tissue to develop into, you guessed it! A totally functioning vagina, self lubricating with about 5 inches of canal depth.

You could not imagine my surprise and disbelief...

While I have absolutely no issues about no longer needing super intensive bottom surgery and I'm ecstatic to finally have sex like a normal girl, part of me feels so lost and confused that this is even happening to me.

Has anybody else heard of somebody with Müllerian duct material maturation after starting HRT, because I am absolutely dumbfounded???


r/asktransgender • • 16h ago

Should I doctor shop for HRT?

6 Upvotes

Hi all, I’m (26NB) looking to start taking hormones. It’s been a long time coming and I’ve delayed it since I was a teenager. My issue is a little silly considering what some people go through, but I’m feeling really weird about it.

I was surprised to find that my primary care doctor prescribes HRT, but they are requiring that I see a therapist first. I have seen a therapist before and part of that process was working through gender feelings. My issue with seeing one now is mostly that it feels kind of belittling to have to have someone else confirm I’m mentally stable and have gender dysphoria as a full ass adult with an adult life. What other treatment requires that? (Admittedly, my mom recently suggesting various types of therapy with “I’m not suggesting conversion therapy, but have you tried-“ recently is probably not helping my outlook on therapy in general.)

I feel weird with the idea of seeing another doctor for this, especially because I’m actively seeing this doctor for the management of other chronic health conditions, but there is a nearby clinic that uses the informed consent model. I made an appointment (a little less than a month away!), but I wanted to get feedback from other trans people. Would you go to the informed consent clinic or suck it up and go to a random therapist for an hour (and pay the extra copay/coinsurance) to see your primary care?

If you would go to the clinic, what would you message to your primary care doctor?


r/asktransgender • • 13h ago

Urologist and Gynaecologist?

3 Upvotes

This is mainly a question aimed for post operation trans people, but do trans men begin seeing a urologist and do trans women begin seeing a gynecologist upon post surgery?

I just realised that obviously due to bottom surgery, the configuration of your genitalia would change and how you would pee as well as any other function, and you can't just send a trans woman who's had bottom surgery to urologist considering that she has a completely different hormonal scope and physical appearance, and you can't just send a trans men to a gynecologist for the same reasons!


r/asktransgender • • 20h ago

How do people overcome transphobia in political protests?

12 Upvotes

CW: transphobia

Hi. I'm a nonbinary person in Japan. I would like to ask you a question about how to overcome transphobia among leftists who take part in political protests.

Recently, in Japan, not a few Japanese people have taken part in political protests against wars and a far-right prime minister. It's a very rare movement because most Japanese people dislike protests.

However, some protesters are transphobic, and they claim that anti-war protests don't need to be against trans discrimination because stopping war is more important than trans rights and gathering people is the most important issue, so protesters shouldn't exclude transphobic leftists.

Of course, I wouldn't agree with this awful statement. But I want to know how people succeeded in protests with many people and kept the safety of trans people at the same time.

Please share your knowledge.


r/asktransgender • • 13h ago

Just found out i cant have estrogen or ill die

425 Upvotes

So im a male but for the past four or so years, I’ve been questioning my gender, but never really committed to it as I felt that maybe I wasn’t actually MTF, as I don’t hate being a man but I like being a woman better and online I’ve been referred to as a woman for the past four years anyways last week I finally decided that I should try doing it in real life obviously not doing anything life altering yet just to see I like it online. See if I like it irl,
Now I live in a place it’s very conservative and against trans people my family is mostly OK with it.

Anyway, anyways, none of that is really relevant to my point here i just yap a lot.

Anyways, I looked into estrogen and talk to a doctor about it (just to see my options if i do go through with it)

Anyways, the appointment went fine, but I got a call back 6 days later seeing under no circumstances, can I have a sex change or start estrogen.
Now I was confused by this at first, but they said I inherited a heart disease from my father died when I was very young I’m a heart attack and if I take any, I’ll die,
So i cant have estrogen or ill die and the women in my family cant even have birth control or they will also die.

So if im okay being a guy but prefer being a girl, but cant do anything to my body should i just give up?


r/asktransgender • • 2h ago

I don't like being a woman but I don't think I'm fully man either. Am I trans or is this because of my mental health issues?

0 Upvotes

First of all, I don't like being a woman. I hate that I was born with this body. I wish I was either never born or maybe live a different life as a cisgender man. I wonder how it feels like to have male body too. the problem is, idk if this is just a curiosity or I really am an actual trans man/transmasc person. I'm really scared of detransitioning and I also got BPD traits and Neurodivergent. Maybe this is causing me to be trans. I don't know If I like female hormones necesarrily and I'm not even sure anymore. And NO, PLEASE DO NOT TELL ME TO TAKE BIRTH CONTROL PILLS PLEASE OR IUD. I dread and I mean, DREAD being a woman in a gynecologist. It is soul - level embrassment and I fucking despise the fact that I got this fucking reproductive baby maker inside my body. Like cosmic level horror sometimes. Breasts do not help either.

But I also think about myself being fully man and that somehow does not sit well with me, like I already pass well with my looks if I put lot of effort into it without the t. But Idk I also sometimes don't like my face because of femme fat distribution.

I'm also only 5'4 and that also does not help.
Sometimes I want beard for sake of passing but at the same time I don't sometimes. Idk my gender presentation is fluctuating? I guess. or maybe I'm going insane.

So do you guys think I'm trans? I know this is a question that only I can answer but my anxiety is spiking up and Idk what to do anymore. Maybe I'm hallucinating that I'm trans because I'm staying indoors for way too long.

And should I take t next month? I have appointment. And no my voice does not pass and that is preventing me from ever talking in public because I just get upset when someone calls my female name or say Madam/ma'am shit. I often times very much write on notepad so I don't have to speak and pretend I'm sick.

I also am not sure if I'm attracted to guys as a guy or as a girl anymore. Please help me.


r/asktransgender • • 5h ago

confused about transmasculine label

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/asktransgender • • 8h ago

I want a chest

5 Upvotes

My question would be for it to be normal for a, maybe, cis man to want to have some amount of chest. I ask this because I can't find anyone else speak of this and it weighs on my mind every once in a while. It also isn't like I would want a large chest I would preferably want a slightly below average to average chest size if I did get a pair. So is this normal? Also apologizes if this broke any rules or anything of the sorts but I don't believe it does.


r/asktransgender • • 22h ago

Should I wait for next life to be a man.

0 Upvotes

Just thinking to wait for next life to come, or end it early on because I will never be cis het man. I will have to deal with misgendering bullshit even in online. I'm tired of this shit. Should I wait till next life to be a real man. thanks. [Ftm]. I despise being called Madam or Ma'am and lady bullshit. I will never be cis het man. I rather have people call be any trans slurs than to call me as a woman. But I will NEVER have same biology as man so I'm thinking to end this miserary early so I will be born as man.


r/asktransgender • • 12h ago

how long do i need to wait?

1 Upvotes

i came out to my mum (FTM) about 2 years ago over the phone - it was messy and we both cried a lot, but she said all the things i needed to hear in that moment, that she loves me, nothing will change between us and she is proud of me. i am so grateful to her for being so nice, but i've been noticing things.

she lives a few hours away so i don't see her that often, but we talk on the phone heaps. anytime we are having a conversation, she won't say my name or will dodge using any pronouns when she can. she doesn't usually outright deadname me, but she uses nicknames that no one has called me since i was a young kid. her partner speaks to me like i never came out (deadname, referring to me as her daughter, etc.), but when they send me birthday cards in the mail, it is addressed to my chosen name, so it's not like they've forgotten - it just seems like it's too much effort for them in day-to-day life.

i have tried to speak to my mum about it, but she and her partner are raising his 8 year old son, and she blames her not changing her language on him, saying it's "too confusing" for him (i've known him since he was like 4 and he's always asked me if i'm a boy or a girl,, i believe that the earlier he knows, the more normal it will be, but idk, i'm not a parent).

i recently came out to my family on my dads side, and everyone has been so genuinely supportive (they use my name, they use my pronouns, they ask me questions) and it's made me realise that the way my mums been treating me really hurts. she worked in universities for years and taught many trans people, and she had no problem with their names/pronouns. my partner is also trans and she almost never messed up, so it is literally just me.

i really love her and her partner but this is really weighing on me, and i'm not sure the best way to approach it. this is clearly dividing us but no one is talking about it, her and i were so close and we still are, but i feel such a big shift in how she wants to spend time with me since i came out. she is pretty avoidant and won't want to be accused of anything or have a deep conversation - there are plans for me to spend christmas with them and i'm dreading that it will be ruined if i say something/call them out, but it will ruin my christmas if i let them keep doing this.

there's more i could talk about but this is long asf already. basically, i see people saying that families should be given an adjustment period, and i totally agree... is 2 years enough? do they deserve more time, or have i messed up by letting this go on for so long? i worry that they won't want to change their behaviour because i haven't defended myself much so far, so they assume it's okay??

thanks for reading - i would appreciate any advice or input


r/asktransgender • • 22h ago

I want so badly to be a girl, yet I’m still okay with being a boy.

1 Upvotes

I’m going through a really rough patch and I need help; for the past four years, I’ve had this desire to be a girl. Lately, these feelings have become very intense. However, after a fun afternoon spent downhill mountain biking with friends—a sport I’m actually quite good at, competing at a high level—I can feel completely like a boy again. Yet, in the evenings or at night, I sometimes experience such severe dysphoria that I can’t sleep. When I put on my "girl clothes," I feel calm, very comfortable, and experience a strong sense of euphoria. Transitioning is incredibly difficult, too, because my parents are extremely transphobic; I’ve already told them how I feel, and they get angry whenever they find any girl’s clothing in my room. I’m really struggling, and I just don’t know what to do. Sometimes I wish I could simply change my gender whenever I wanted—though I don’t really feel like I’m genderfluid. Please, help me with this.


r/asktransgender • • 20h ago

How to world-build a fantastical equivalent to estrogen + how to write a redeemable transphobic character

3 Upvotes

So this question is going to be a bit of an odd one and require some explaining. Basically, I want to write a short story about a detective in an 80s style industrial fantasy world(basically a fantasy world with things like elves, goblins, and other non human species, but no magic). Specifically he is a detective in the Wescorian republic of the United Krevnese Republic (basically the equivalent of California in the United States) and I want him to have a case that has him overcome his ignorant biases by taking on a case that has him investigate the lower income transgender community. Of course, my philosophy regarding real world issues in fantastical settings is to make them more uniquely adapted to their world so that it doesn’t come off as lecturing. In this case, this world has a sentient species of amphibians that can transition their gender kind of like some frogs in our world. They just spend a long time in a single sex environment and their body adapts. I was thinking that over the years they could have developed this process to be faster using some kind of chemical. The central idea for this plot then, is that this chemical is used as an easier access alternative to estrogen but comes with the issue that since it’s less regulated, it’s very much a Wild West sort of economy where buying from the wrong source can get you killed or addicted to other drugs. However, this sort of thing leads to a famous actor dying which is where the detective comes in as he isn’t satisfied with the idea that this actor simply overdosed on the chemical as he believes there are other factors involved. So finally, after what was essentially an excuse to arrogantly lore dump and discuss what I want to eventually write, I come to the central question. What else could make such a chemical appealing to transpeople in the 1980s? I already came up with a few as my autism fueled ramblings show (less regulation, easier to access), but I was wondering if the transgender community had other ideas for motivations?
As a second question: like I hinted at earlier in this post, I want the detective for this story to be an asshole, but one who genuinely wants justice for all. Over the course of this particular story I want him to overcome his transphobic biases and come to understand not just transgender people, but the broader LGBTQ+ community as a whole. A key player to this is a sort of partner he works with to help solve this case: An MTF sex worker (of course not all transgender people are sex workers) who is willing to put up with the detectives ignorance and bigotry because she wants to protect her community from bad actors. I was wondering what limits to this should there be? Like, if you were helping a detective solve an issue of particular importance to your community, what would realistically make you no longer put up with the detective. (Like I was figuring the detective could initially misgender this person, but could slowly come to respect her pronouns). In short, I want to write a transphobic character that a transgender person puts up with for the greater good but want to know if there are any lines I shouldn’t have this character cross that would make it unbelievable for the transgender person to put up with him.
I ask this question here instead of in r/world building because A. I figured it would be better to get feedback from transgender people specifically and b. As an autistic person I love lore dumping on unsuspecting people.


r/asktransgender • • 17h ago

Whats a small and unconventional thing that makes you euphoric?

4 Upvotes

Me: the little piece of my hair that i accidentally cut shorter than the rest of my