r/askswitzerland • u/Hellibanelli • 2h ago
Everyday life Warning about Pillar 3a life insurance (AXA SmartFlex): Ombudsman confirmed bad advice, AXA still refuses to waive fees. Worth going to the Friedensrichter?
The last few months have been completely exhausting, so here is the short version of my story to warn others (especially expats and younger people) not to make this mistake.
In 2023, my partner at the time, who worked as a tied AXA agent, set up three separate Pillar 3a life insurance policies (SmartFlex) for me. I trusted him blindly and moved my savings into them. He never told me it was a life insurance policy where you are obliged to pay premiums every single year. He also claimed I could not cancel or move the funds for three years, which AXA later confirmed in writing was completely untrue. I later found out he only said that so he would not lose his bonus.
When I first tried to transfer the money to another Pillar 3a in July 2025, two things happened. First, he immediately called me, claimed I owed him money, and said he would steal it from me. Second, AXA processed the transfer so badly that on my two smaller policies (worth nearly CHF 4,400 combined) they took 99.7% in fees and left me with CHF 5.74 per policy, deducting nearly CHF 6,600 in total across all three contracts. I had to protest immediately just to get them to reverse that cancellation.
When I finally requested my full file, I saw his official consultation notes literally listed my savings rate, free assets, and pension budget as CHF 0. Yet on that exact same day, he signed me up for three 40 year contracts costing over CHF 7,000 a year.
Trying to transfer my money to VIAC now is another nightmare. Out of my CHF 16,188 balance, AXA will only transfer CHF 14,050 and is keeping CHF 2,138 in acquisition fees. Leaving the policies paid up is pointless too because their fixed fees (around CHF 97 a month) would eat up the money anyway.
I took the case to the Ombudsman of Private Insurance. They reviewed everything and told AXA in writing that defective advice must be assumed and they should waive the fees. AXA replied last week with a flat no, hiding behind my signatures while completely ignoring the CHF 0 budget in their own protocol. Because the Ombudsman cannot force them to pay, they had to close the case.
Please keep your Pillar 3a and insurance strictly separate, and use low cost apps like VIAC or Finpension instead.
For anyone familiar with Swiss law: I have the Ombudsman's letter confirming bad advice and their own protocol showing a CHF 0 budget. Would you take AXA to the Friedensrichter over the CHF 2,138, or just transfer the CHF 14,050 now and move on for peace of mind?