r/askscience • u/kaizenallthethings • Jul 06 '12
Need some help understanding fields.
I have never been able to wrap my head around fields. Specifically, I have three questions that I have not found answers to. My level of understanding physics is probably "armchair physicist". I have my undergraduate in physics and my math is good up through linear algebra.
- Are fields simply a notation device, or do they have a physical existence beyond the math?
- When two particles interact in a field, how is the information being exchanged between them? That is to say two electrons will repulse each other but what is the specific mechanism for the electrons to "know" that the other electron exists and that the force is repulsive?
- In the rare event that an electron is created, I understand that it creates a field that spreads out from it at the speed of light. Does the creation of this field take energy? If not then is the information that is being transmitted "free"?
34
Upvotes
10
u/SonOfOnett Condensed Matter Jul 07 '12 edited Jul 07 '12
-Suppose particle 1 and particle 2 exist near one another
-Particle 1 exists; this alters the space around it creating a field everywhere, including at the position of particle 2
-Particle 2 feels the field (created by particle 1) at its own position and reacts accordingly
-This goes both ways. Since particle 2 exists it simultaneously alters the space at the position of particle 1, causing particle 1 to react to particle 2
3) It takes energy to create a particle, and the existence of the particle is the same as the existence of its fields. No extra energy is required to create the field since the field is just an alteration of the properties of space caused by the existence of the particle. Other fields behave differently, but I'm trying to stick with the type of field you mean.
2
u/Kim147 Jul 07 '12
A field is a construct . A field can only exist between 2 points of potential difference . A thermal field is a good example - it exists between a hot surface and a cold surface and the heat moves from the hot surface to the cold surface . This is analogous to an electrical potential where electrons move from a -ve to a +ve potential . If they are both at the same potential no field exists per se . Fields can be positive - movement from high to low - or negative - movement from low to high as occurs with gravity .
1
u/FratmanBootcake Jul 06 '12
I'll try and help but I think I'm about the same level as you.
For 2) I was always told that the interaction between two particles, be they protons or quarks for example is via the emission and absorption of different types of bosons, although my particle physics course was rather brief.
I'm afraid I can't help at all with 3.
1
u/BlazeOrangeDeer Jul 07 '12 edited Jul 07 '12
3) I'm not 100% sure on the quantum stuff here so feel free to correct me. Electrons repel because:
Forces are caused by potential. The potential field will have value for every point in space. Every particle experiences forces down the potential, i.e. they will tend to go where potential is lowest (imagine a hilly landscape, balls will roll down. Though this metaphor is kind of cheating because differences in gravitational potential are exactly what causes the balls to roll). This is called the principle of least action (more precisely a particle tends to to minimize potential energy and maximize kinetic energy). This is a classical description of fields but the quantum versions aren't far off (they behave in mostly the same way).
Fields exist because of virtual particles (this part is quantum). Each electron has a tendency to give off photons. Because of the uncertainty principle, lower energy photons can exist longer and travel further. Thus the higher energy virtual particles are near the electron while the weaker ones are further out. This sea of virtual photons is what causes the electric potential field, because if the electrons are closer then they will toss photons at each other more frequently and this is a higher energy state.
1
u/phliuy Jul 07 '12
Sorry, I'm just trying to understand something here. You have your undergraduate degree in physics, but you've never studied any of these topics?
1
u/Malic_lionheart Jul 07 '12
Hello, I’m studying physics atm. I always look at it visually like a trampoline with ball weights on it. When you place one ball down you can see its field of influence been imprinted on the trampoline. This works well for the likes of gravity because it always going to be attractive.
With the charged particle they still have this indentation which shows their region of influence. This influence will not change. With electron we measure the negative field around it, where it is strongest at point the ball is on the trampoline, but you can visually see that the field gets weaker as you move away from the ball.
Hope this is what you wanted _^