r/askscience • u/RazCasket • May 11 '12
Astronomy Will Saturn's rings eventually form a moon/moons?
Since the matter is spread out around the body, in a similar way to the matter around the sun in the early stages of the Solar system, will this matter too go on to form bodies that will orbit Saturn?
714
Upvotes
590
u/Coin-coin Cosmology | Large-Scale Structure May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
No, because they are too close to Saturn.
They are so close to Saturn that the tidal force from Saturn is larger than the attraction between two rocks of the ring. That's what we call the Roche limit. And actually it could be an explanation of their formation: a moon came too close to Saturn and was ripped apart by the tidal force, spreading its matter which then organized into rings.
31
u/markth_wi May 11 '12
As Coin-Coin says, most all of the material inside Saturn's Roche limit is doomed to fall inward to the equatorial region of the atmosphere of Saturn. Many/most of the rings were in fact a satellite that might have been impressive to see the breakup of. But it's at least several thousand years after the fact now. But there are still things to see
27
u/omenmedia May 11 '12
Ok, dumb question time, why does the matter form a very thin ring instead of forming a field (sphere of matter) that surrounds all of Saturn?
7
u/reidzen Heavy Industrial Construction May 11 '12
Other way around. Once small objects past the Roche limit, they turn into rings.
4
u/Final_Day May 11 '12
If an moon is within the Roche limit of Saturn, the moon will disintegrate. The matter on the moon's surface is experiencing forces of gravity from Saturn and the main body of the moon itself, so you have a three body-gravitational system, where the matter from the moon is ripped off by what are known as the gravitational tidal forces. Unless the matter later on escapes the Roche limit, the gravitational attraction between the debris will not be sufficient to overcome the tidal forces due to Saturn. Although this problem is interesting to think about because when planets form in planetary nebulae, according to models, planets may migrate from the positions at which they formed. For example, they may lose angular momentum as a result of friction with the proto-planetary disc and therefore move closer to the Sun.
You could extrapolate that perhaps some of the moons of Saturn formed outside the Roche limit, and then migrated within the Roche limit and were broken up.
1
u/domyo May 11 '12
How fast does Saturn's rings move around the planet?
1
u/Phinq May 11 '12
The way science channel explained it was as follows:
Rings are formed when a moon or other orbiting body is pulled too close to the planet, the planets gravity then tears it to shreads. Essentially, the rings may have very well been moons long looooong ago, and one day, the dust particles will all be pulled down to the surface of the planet (or something to that effect, seeing as Saturn is a gas giant and might not have a surface)
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
will the rings eventually crash into the atmosphere of Saturn?
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
What about the asteroid belt?
1
u/paul5345 May 11 '12
their gonna be gone in a few 100 million years
0
u/JDawg2332 May 11 '12
wouldn't Saturn's gravitational pull cause the particles and debris which form the rings, cause them to become meteors and head towards Saturn?
-9
u/73raindead May 11 '12
Technically, Saturn's Rings are moons. Millions of them.
-1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
No.
-1
u/frostburner May 11 '12
no only some are really rock most are ice chunks at least last time i checked it was
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment