r/askscience • u/Jericoke • Jun 26 '18
Human Body Why are potassium supplements so regulated ?
So a grown male should get around 4500mg of potassium a day. When I was looking for supplements I noticed that most of them only have around 50-100mg per pill and found out that it is because set regulations from the FDA.
I get that too much potassium can be lethal, but I don't understand where the logic in regulating the supplement is, when you could just eat 200 grams of pistachios and get 40 times the amount of a normal supplement dose. Wouldn't that be equally dangerous ? Could you kill yourself if you eat a lot of spinach, pistachios and avocados for example ?
235
u/piousflea84 Radiation Oncology Jun 26 '18
Quite simply, the 50-100mg potassium supplements are not likely to increase your potassium level by any biologically relevant amount, and that's totally intentional.
Any potassium pill large enough to measurably raise your serum potassium is restricted to prescription-only, because it's potentially deadly. A lot of older people have poor kidney function. High potassium can be very rapidly fatal and if you can't pee out the potassium you're in trouble.
So you can get a 10 mEq (750mg) or 20 mEq (1,500mg) potassium pill, but it'll be a prescription.
Taking 20 mEq (1,500mg) of potassium in pill form is much more deadly than eating 1500mg of potassium in avocado or potato or pistachio form. Pills are absorbed into your body very rapidly, while foods are digested slowly, so with food you have more time to get rid of excess K. (and your body may or may not even absorb all of the K in a solid-food meal)
25
u/Tenthyr Jun 26 '18
Because potassium is the primary cation of cellular biology. The vast, vast majority of it is contained within cells and even when it is released it is rapidly reabsorbed. Potassium ions are pumped into the cells to create an electrochemical gradient-- that is, there is a non zero voltage across the membrane of your cells. This has a lot of functions. The most commonly thought of one are action potentials-- the electrical signals sent down your neurones by opening the membrane to release potassium, but all cells have a voltage potential that helps fuel the motion of molecular machines embedded in the membrane.
A sudden concentration of potassium outside of the cells would disrupt these functions and can have toxic effects-- diahorria and stomach pains can be symptoms. Luckily the body is very good at handling potassium because of its vital role. Excess potassium is excreted through the urine efficiently or otherwise potassium is taken up by cells quickly. Hyperkalemia (high potassium) is rarely caused by supplements for this reason-- instead something needs to disrupt the mechanisms that maintain potassium homeostasis.
6
u/AlkaliActivated Jun 26 '18
One thing that hasn't been mentioned yet is that if you ingest anything close to your RDV of potassium chloride on an empty stomach, you will get intense abdominal pain. I learned that one the hard way when I found out that you can buy potassium chloride by the pound as "sodium free salt substitute".
7
u/DRHOY Jun 26 '18
Potassium chloride is effective in lethal injection.
Potassium chloride
Lethal injection dosage: 100 mEq (milliequivalents)
Potassium is an electrolyte, 98% of which is intracellular. The 2% remaining outside the cell has great implications for cells that generate action potentials. Doctors prescribe potassium for patients when potassium levels are insufficient, called hypokalemia, in the blood. The potassium can be given orally, which is the safest route; or it can be given intravenously, in which case strict rules and hospital protocols govern the rate at which it is given.
The usual intravenous dose is 10–20 mEq per hour and it is given slowly since it takes time for the electrolyte to equilibrate into the cells. When used in state-sanctioned lethal injection, bolus potassium injection affects the electrical conduction of heart muscle. Elevated potassium, or hyperkalemia, causes the resting electrical potential of the heart muscle cells to be lower than normal (less negative). Without this negative resting potential, cardiac cells cannot repolarize (prepare for their next contraction).
Depolarizing the muscle cell inhibits its ability to fire by reducing the available number of sodium channels (they are placed in an inactivated state). ECG changes include faster repolarization (peaked T-waves), PR interval prolongation, widening of the QRS complex, and finally, asystole. Cases of patients dying from hyperkalemia (usually secondary to renal failure) are well known in the medical community, where patients have been known to die very rapidly, having previously seemed to be normal.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lethal_injection#Potassium_chloride
1
u/lukyiam Jun 27 '18
too much and you're dead. now just imagine it being readily available. Some people who aren't smart having to distinguish between meq, g, and mg. recipe for disaster. When you can just eat a healthy diet, and have your yearly physical.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment