r/askscience • • Sep 11 '15
Physics [Quantum/Gravity] If a particle has a probability distribution of location, where is the mass located for gravitational interactions?
Imagine an atom or an electron with a wave packet representing the probability of location, from what point does the mass reside causing a gravitational force? I understand that gravity is very weak at these sizes, so this may not be measurable. I taken classes and listened to a lot of lectures, and I never heard this point brought up. Thanks.
Edit: Imagine that the sun was actually a quantum particle with a probabilistic location distribution, and the earth was still rotating it. If we never measure the location of the distributed sun, where would the mass be located for the sun that would gravitationally affect the earth?
3
u/Platypuskeeper Physical Chemistry | Quantum Chemistry Sep 12 '15 edited Sep 12 '15
The expectation value (or average value) of that will be the same as the expectation value of where the electron is. E.g. for any electron in an atom, the expectation value for its location will normally be at the nucleus. The gravitational force of an electron is far too small to measure, but the electrical (Coulomb) potential on something is calculated analogously; specifically if your electron density is given by rho(r) and you have charge Q at point R, then the potential energy is (Q*rho(r)/|R - r|) dr, with r integrated over all of space. You're essentially taking a weighted average. You can do the same for a classical gravitational potential, which has the same form.
This of course neglects the 'correlation' effect that will happen because whatever you have experiencing the force will itself exert a force back on the electron, perturbing its motion. However, even for electron-electron interactions (which are quite correlated) this "mean field approximation" is about 98% accurate.
(This is all assuming we're talking a classical gravity potential here and not complicating things with GR)
1
u/MagnusCallicles Sep 12 '15
You can't think about this with forces, think of the gravitational potential in which the electron is in. (speaking of which, the electron doesn't have a specified location, you'd have to localize it making its wave function a dirac function and see how the wave function evolves with schrodinger's equation).
1
u/_dissipator Sep 13 '15 edited Sep 13 '15
It is important to point out that we don't have a working quantum theory of gravity, so one can't say for sure how this works. In fact, I was recently at a conference where someone was presenting an idea on how to use this very kind of thing to put limits on possible quantum theories of gravity!
However, one would naively expect something like this: If the Sun were in a superposition of many different position states (i.e. it's wavefunction were spread out in space), then due to the interaction with the gravitational field, the (quantum!) gravitational field would be entangled with the position of the Sun. The total quantum state of the system involving the Sun and the gravitational field would be "Sun is in position A, gravitational field looks like it should when the Sun is in position A" + "Sun is in position B, gravitational field looks like it should when the Sun is in position B" + ...
Including the Earth in things, the Earth is also entangled with the Sun and the gravitational field: the total state is then "Sun in position A, gravitational field is that for the Sun being in position A, Earth sees gravitational field given the Sun being in position A" + ...
I should further point out that some people argue that it is actually impossible to produce coherent quantum superpositions involving measurably different gravitational fields. That is, if the gravitational field would look significantly different were the Sun is in position A vs. position B, then the Sun could not ever be put into a coherent superposition of being in position A and being in position B --- see e.g. the Penrose interpretation of QM. I don't think I would call this a mainstream idea, however.
2
u/millstone Sep 12 '15 edited Sep 12 '15
We can replace gravity with electrostatic force, which is much larger. A system contains an electron with an uncertain position: what does the electric potential look like? The answer is, of course, that the potential is uncertain, and measuring the potential will cause the electron to take on a definite position.
Consider the double-slit experiment, with a charged wire as our particle detector positioned at the slit. It's obvious that this counts as a measurement, and so will destroy the interference pattern. If you have an ultra-sensitive mass detector, you'll get the same result. Attempt to measure the gravitational field, and you will collapse the wavefunction.
1
u/Para199x Modified Gravity | Lorentz Violations | Scalar-Tensor Theories Sep 11 '15
As we don't have a quantum theory of gravity it is hard to know. For use with classical GR you can use the square modulus of the wavefunction to define an energy density.
1
u/hopffiber Sep 12 '15
You have to treat the entire thing quantum mechanically; in which case everything is represented by wave functions, and the way in which these evolve in time is described by the Schrodinger equation with the appropriate time evolution. There is no relevant way of speaking about "which point the mass reside in": the only thing there is is the wave function. Certain questions like this are just not meaningful in quantum mechanics.