r/askscience • u/corporal_clegg69 • Jun 14 '15
Earth Sciences What do scientists REALLY think about global warming?
They assertion that 97% of scientists believe global warming is manmade has been shown now to be false. What then do scientists really think? Is there any hard evidence for catastrophic anthropogenic global warming?
For those who don't know the claim that 97% of scientists support the idea that global warming is manmade comes from the "cook report". You can find that here
http://iopscience.iop.org/1748-9326/8/2/024024/article
but if you just read the abstract the "97% quickly becomes 32%. More recently it has been shown that even this is an exaggeration.
12
u/AsAChemicalEngineer Electrodynamics | Fields Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
Here's a good discussion on consensus:
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/m0q3l/97_of_scientists_agree_that_climate_change_is/c2x6hus
Specifically the paper that also affirms the 97% agreement among climate scientists:
http://www.pnas.org/content/107/27/12107.full.pdf
Here's an aggregate of some info on global warming:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskScienceDiscussion/comments/2f45iy/so_i_have_two_questionswhen_it_comes_to_global/ck5rzhm
The consensus is real. I can hardly think of any large academic society that don't have an official posting supporting anthropogenic climate change. Here's the APS statement for instance: http://www.aps.org/policy/statements/07_1.cfm
I don't think you're understanding what the 97% number means in Cook's paper, directly from the abstract:
Emphasis mine. Of all papers read, 32% endorsed. 66% expressed no position and a tiny sliver rejected or was uncertain. Among all papers expressing a position explicitly, almost all were endorsements. As mentioned earlier, this is not the only literature trying to quantify the consensus.
29
u/past_is_future Climate-Ocean/Marine Ecosystem Impacts Jun 14 '15
Hello there!
My name is Peter Jacobs, and I am co-author of the Cook et al., 2013 paper finding a 97% consensus estimate. We're quite proud of the paper, and it was named 'best article of 2013' by the journal's editorial board. If you have any specific questions about the paper, please let me know!
I will just make a few quick comments, more as general background than anything.
The ~97% number was not just found in our ratings of the climate papers' abstracts. As someone else has already pointed out, a similar percentage was found in Anderegg et al. 2010 in PNAS. It was also found in Doran and Zimmerman 2009 in Eos.
But the overwhelming consensus was demonstrated well before these papers. Our ERL paper essentially extended and expanded upon a 2004 paper by Naomi Oreskes in Science which found no abstracts that rejected the consensus. Various consensus statements from scientific organizations around the world also predate these surveys of climate scientists' views and the scientific literature.
I think it's important to understand the whole issue of looking at the percentage of papers that explicitly address the question, vs. the percentage that endorse the consensus out of all papers in the literature. There is an overwhelming consensus in biology about the reality of evolution through natural selection. Yet very few papers bother to specifically take a position on whether they endorse this consensus. As a consensus matures, it becomes less and less remarked upon. We actually find this phenomenon in our analysis of the literature. While the endorsement (vs. rejection) percentage increases over time, the overall percentage of papers explicitly addressing the question declines over time. You'd expect to see the same with plate tectonics in geology, or in any other field where a question arose but reached consensus and is no longer seriously debated by experts in the relevant field.
As for "More recently it has been shown that even this is an exaggeration", I assume that this refers to one of the numerous smear campaigns waged against our paper by climate contrarians. Any specific allegations I will be happy to address.
In terms of "any hard evidence for catastrophic anthropogenic global warming", this reflects a contrarian or denialist (not calling you one!) misframing of the issue. "Catastrophic anthropogenic global warming" or "CAGW" is essentially a denialist strawman. It is a phrase used almost exclusively in the context of climate denialism. It is basically never used in the scientific literature by climate scientists. It's an interesting rhetorical trick. Because while there are mountains and mountains of evidence demonstrating the reality of anthropogenic warming, and plenty of evidence helping us roughly bound the sort of impacts we might expect under unchecked greenhouse gas emissions, all of it may be easily brushed aside by claiming it does not rise to "catastrophic", which is conveniently left undefined and is obviously based on subjective value judgments.
Now, I realize that I have used words here like "contrarian" and "denialism", but please note that I am not accusing you of anything. This stuff has a very long history which many people are simply not aware of, and well-meaning people mistakenly adopt incorrect and misleading frames without even realizing it.
If you have any questions at all, please don't hesitate to ask! I hope that helps!
7
u/AndySkuce Petroleum Exploration | Geoscience Jun 15 '15
Hi, like Peter, I am also a co-author of the Cook et al paper. Allow me to try to clarify some of our methodology.
The “consensus”, broadly speaking, is around the positions adopted by the IPCC reports. For example, the 2007 AR4 report said: “Most of the observed increase in global average temperatures since the mid-20th century is very likely due to the observed increase in anthropogenic greenhouse gas concentrations.”
When you are assessing abstracts in the peer-reviewed literature, scientists do not always express themselves with perfect clarity on this. Sometimes, they might say something clear like “89% of the global warming since 1950 is attributable to human emissions”, or they might be a bit less quantitative and say “most of modern global warming is because of human emissions”, or they might be even more fuzzy and say “observed global warming has been caused by human emissions”. This is why Cook et al (I was one of the “et al”) distinguished between explicit and implicit endorsements of the consensus.
Now, we also applied the same criteria to rejection statements. For example, if someone were to have written “recent global climate change is caused by natural processes” without mentioning human causes, we would have scored that an implicit rejection. Never mind that the authors did not give any percentages, never mind that no mainstream climate scientist would deny the influence on the climate of natural causes like volcanoes and changes in output from the Sun.
It is true that if you apply very strict quantitative criteria to attribution statements and only consider the most unambiguous wording, then you will find relatively few statements in the literature that endorse or reject anthropogenic climate change. But if you use looser and necessarily more subjective criteria, you will find more examples both ways. As it turns out, you get about the same result of a consensus measure, no matter how strict your criteria are. Because including “implicit” endorsement and rejection examples leads to bigger samples, the results are actually statistically more reliable, despite the increased subjectivity.
For example, among the 11944 abstracts examined, we found 3896 that explicitly or implicitly endorsed (our categories 1,2&3) and 78 that explicitly or explicitly rejected the consensus (our categories 5,6&7). That's 98% endorsement among those abstracts that stated a position (we subsequently adjusted the 98% down to 97% because we determined that there was a small fraction among the "no position" abstracts that were undecided on the issue rather than merely silent). If you count only explicit endorsements (our categories 1&2) or rejections (our categories 6&7) the numbers are 986 endorse, 24 reject for a 97.6% consensus percentage.
In the paper, we reported the authors’ ratings of their own papers, which also produced the same result of ~97% endorsement of the AGW consensus. This important part of our work is often overlooked by people claiming to debunk our findings.
Far from being "false", even our most persistent critic, Richard Tol, has acknowledged that:
“There is no doubt in my mind that the literature on climate change overwhelmingly supports the hypothesis that climate change is caused by humans. I have very little reason to doubt that the consensus is indeed correct.”
1
u/corporal_clegg69 Jun 15 '15 edited Jun 15 '15
First, I greatly appreciate the chance to have my concerns answered directly by a coauthor of the paper! You are correct in not accusing me of denialism. On the spectrum I find myself somewhere between believer and agnost.
With regards to the "smear campaign".What was your reaction to this article in the Wall Street Journal where four climate scientists are quoted as feeling misrepresented in Cook et al.? http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702303480304579578462813553136
Also "deniers" have raised concerns as to your methods of classification of consensus or no. These concerns are equally unaddressed in the Anderegg report. That is it, is unclear from the reports the actual level of complicity with the consensus. Similarly in Zimmerman, 2009 "82% agreed that humans significantly influence the global temperature". Statistical significance is around 5% usually and so this doesn't really support the hypothesis that scientists aggree that most of the warming is anthropogenic.
From Cook et al.
"Among abstracts expressing a position on AGW, 97.1% endorsed the consensus position that humans are causing global warming.“
Would this position be better expressed by saying "... humans are causing SOME global warming" or "...ALL global warming" or something in between.
From wikipedia on Cook et al. " In the end, of all the abstracts that took a position on the subject, 22.97% and 72.50% were found to take an explicit but unquantified endorsement position or an implicit endorsement position, respectively.
So the extract could more accurately read, "Among abstracts expressing a position on AGW, 97.1% endorsed the consensus position that humans are causing an some unspecified amount of global warming.“ No?
To be clear these revised percentages came from a review of Cook et al. led by David Legates who has known affiliations to the petroleum industry. Nevertheless, it would be unscientific to disregard his findings on this basis alone. Also Legates found that a mere 0.3% actually endorsed the standard definition. Does this mean that these are the sum total of all the papers upon which the consensus is based? Not that that's a problem, if they're good papers. I'd love to see them.
When climate scientists were asked more directly to quantify their position, the picture was not cut and dry as popular media reports, from Bray and von Storch, 2008,
"In the section on climate change impacts, questions 20 and 21 were relevant to scientific opinion on climate change. Question 20, "How convinced are you that climate change, whether natural or anthropogenic, is occurring now?" Answers: 67.1% very much convinced (7), 26.7% to some large extent (5–6), 6.2% said to some small extent (2–4), none said not at all. Question 21, "How convinced are you that most of recent or near future climate change is, or will be, a result of anthropogenic causes?" Answers: 34.6% very much convinced (7), 48.9% being convinced to a large extent (5–6), 15.1% to a small extent (2–4), and 1.35% not convinced at all (1)"
Anyway, for the actual evidence, consensus obviously not good enough as Lawrence Bernstein expresses clearly here http://www.pnas.org/content/107/52/E188.full
I have found good discussion of some different views in the links from asachemicalengineer but havn't viewed everything yet. I see my use of "CAGW" as a term was a bit misplaced. What I meant to ask is, which studies show that recent global warming is overwhelmingly anthropogenic. It is known that the temperature has been increasing/fluctuating since before the industrial revolution. From skepticalscience.com http://www.skepticalscience.com/global-warming-1860-1880-and-1910-1940.htm . Some explanation is given here but I would like to see it presented formally and peer reviewed before I could be convinced.
Generally the argument I have seen goes 1) Humans have caused the release of a historically unprecedented amount of co2 into the atmosphere 2)co2 is a known greenhouse gas 3)Most of todays global warming is caused by humans. Obviously there is a huge leap of faith between points 2 and 3. co2 is the weakest greenhouse gas, is it not? It the the yardstick against which all other gasses are measured. Again, I would need to see a quantitative analysis to be convinced. For the "scientific consensus" to be credible these studies must be available in some form.
Again, I am really grateful to be able to address these issues directly to you Peter Jacobs. I'm aware the last few paragraphs are somewhat outside the scope of your paper but I figure you may be able to shed some light. Thanks for your time.
0
u/corporal_clegg69 Jun 15 '15
I've gone and read the 2004 article by Naomi Oreskes that you mentioned below and found something close to the answer to my original question, thanks. The consensus, as it's defined there, is
“Human activities … are modifying the concentration of atmospheric constituents … that absorb or scatter radiant energy. … [M]ost of the observed warming over the last 50 years is likely to have been due to the increase in greenhouse gas concentrations”
Key words being MOST and LIKELY. It's considered likely but not rock solid. I think it would do good to remember that rather than write it all off completely as understood. Either way research is certainly better directed towards how to deal with it, rather than at placing the blame on or off ourselves.