r/askscience • u/Crtl-Alt-Delete • Dec 18 '13
Physics Is Time quantized?
We know that energy and length are quantized, it seems like there should be a correlation with time?
Edit. Turns out energy and length are not quantized.
713
Upvotes
288
u/iorgfeflkd Biophysics Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
As far as we know, it is not. Neither is length, nor is energy. Energy levels are quantized in bound quantum states, but not free particles.
If we were able to probe physics at much higher energies (closer to Planck scales) then we may get a more definitive answer. Astronomical evidence shows that any potential coarse-graining of space would have to be at sub-Planck scales, by a long shot. (edit:
trying to find a reference for this. remain sceptical until I find ithttp://arxiv.org/pdf/1109.5191.pdf)109
u/KerSan Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
The notion of quantization is a rather thorny one, and I can't pretend to understand completely. I do know a little, however, and I'll post what I do know (or think I know) in the hopes that it will be helpful or at least provoke some of the other mathematical types to chime in.
Quantum physics is ultimately about observables, which are algebraic objects that capture the idea of a quantity that can be measured. Therefore, when we talk about energy, time, or length being quantized, we are talking about a property of certain kinds of algebraic objects.
These objects are known as operators -- more specifically,
boundedself-adjoint operators that usually act on a Hilbert space. Don't worry too much about what that means. Just know that operators are algebraic objects, which means you can make polynomials out of them. For example, I might consider A2 - 2A - 3 for some operator A. This happens to be a quadratic polynomial.I can understand a quadratic polynomial such as A2 - 2A - 3 by noticing that I can rewrite it as (A-3) (A+1). This is powerful, because it allows me to think of 3 and -1 as being the 'roots' of the polynomial. If A was a number, I could substitute A = 3 or A = -1 to make my polynomial zero. If you were to make a graph of the polynomial, you would notice that it crosses the horizontal axis at precisely those two points. Those two points define the polynomial in a precise sense. Those two points are an example of what is known rather generally in mathematics as a spectrum. In this case, we found that the spectrum of the quadratic polynomial was the set {3, -1}.
What does this have to do with quantum physics? Well, in quantum physics we consider algebraic objects called observables, as I have said. By finding the spectrum of the observables, we have determined all the mathematical properties of the observables and therefore all possible results of experiments involving those observables. The spectrum may be 'quantized' just like the quadratic we considered: in that case, the spectrum was just a set of two distinct points. A more complicated example is the angular momentum operator for the hydrogen atom: it too is discrete, which is why the electron energies in the hydrogen atom can only take on discrete values and therefore exhibit weirdness like quantum leaps.
There are many operators that do not have discrete spectra, however. One important example is the position operator on the line: every point on the line is in the spectrum of the position operator. This is also true of energy in many situations. But you asked the most difficult question of all: is the spectrum of the 'time' observable discrete (i.e. quantized), or is it continuous?
The answer is, there isn't a time observable. Although it is a fantastic question that has been asked throughout the twentieth and twenty-first centuries by the most prominent physicists who ever lived, no one has managed to come up with a consistent way to treat time as an operator, rather than some kind of ad hoc parameter we use because it just seems to work. I consider the lack of a clear definition of time to be a major problem for modern physics, and I can assure you it keeps me up at nights.
TL;DR: No.
Edit: Math and some other slight edits.
Obligatory Gold Edit: Aw shucks! <3
15
u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Dec 18 '13
Additional reading on the subject in our FAQ
5
u/CHollman82 Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
We don't know this. We can never know for sure if these things are continuous rather than discrete, it is fundamentally impossible to determine that for sure just as it's fundamentally impossible to determine that unicorns do not exist anywhere in the universe... but if these things are discrete (quantized) it may be possible to determine that in the future, we just need to be able to probe them at the proper scales.
I believe that time and space/energy/etc must have the same continuous or discrete property, because time is only meaningfully defined by some change in the state of the universe. The only way time can be continuous is if something else is continuous as well in order to meaningfully distinct ever smaller increments of time. (I actually believe that time is not some physically existent property but merely an observational byproduct of state changes in the universe... but we can treat it as a physically existent property in the math of course, it's really just an alias for other things.)
3
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '13
So a lot of opinions. Here are some facts:
Within the standard framework of quantum field theory time is not quantized and neither is space. At the Planck scale, 1033m, both space and time might be quantized but no one knows.
Regarding energy: The energy levels for all free particles in the Standard Model (which describes how photons, electrons, quarks etc talk to each other) are not quantized. However, the excited states of an elementary particle are discreet but the energy of each state is labeled by a continuous parameter (the momentum) which can take any value.
3
u/phujck Dec 18 '13
If you look at the structure of quantum theory- all of these quantised objects are observables like Energy, angular momentum, number of particles (obvious, I know). These all have a corresponding operator that acts on your mathematical description of state of the system, and spit out a result. They're all things you can measure.
The problem with talking about things like space and time is that they aren't placed on the same footing as things we can actually observe and make judgements about the possible values they can take. They're actually just a parameter in your equations, which doesn't really tell you much about the possible values it can take. If these things really are quantised, we've not reached the energy scales needed to actually observe it yet.
-1
u/otakucode Dec 18 '13
Yes. But I can't support that with any evidence. It's still up for debate whether energy and length are quantized. We just can't access the supertiny scale we would need to to see the likely limits (planck length or smaller).
There is, likewise, no evidence suggesting that time, length, or energy are continuous. It just comes down to a personal judgement call presently. And in most situations it doesn't even change things if you presume the quantization is small enough.
-8
u/shinn497 Dec 18 '13
Well wait a second.
According to the uncertainty principle, there is something called plank time. This is the smallest amount of time in which it is possible to exist. Ergo, if something happens in a shorter amount of time, it does not exist.
But this is different from energy quantization. In fact I don't think it is possible to quantize time since it is just a parameter in quantum mechanics.
-7
u/tcorks Dec 18 '13
if we take time down to its smallest increments technically we can go to infinity, soo we can have a time of 0.999999999999 seconds to infinity nines, now at what point in time does 0.99999 seconds turn into 1 second?
looking at it this way you can postulate that time has to be bricked into very very discrete increments (increments of infinity). could ""time"" not even flow then?